I feel like Yoohyeon's voice is the most pleasant to hear (Dreamcatcher)

TOO POPULAR

To preface, I am a big fan of dreamcatcher and have listened to all of the tracks, disliking maybe 2 or 3. I have been a metalhead most of my childhood/adolescence so it made sense for me to be drawn to them.

​

After listening to their songs for the third time of the day, i have come to realized that 3 of my favorite songs from them all have something similar : Yoohyeon has the most lines (You and I, Black or White, Odd Eye). Also, in songs like In the Frozen or Break the Wall or Wind Blows, i feel like she has a stronger showing then Siyeon, even with less lines. Finally, in their ballads, i simply seek out her voice because their is comforting in it.

While Siyeon has an amazing voice, it just doesn't give me the same feelings Yoohyeon's does. I think this is unpopular because I don't see this opinion often and Siyeon's voice is mostly the one talked about.

View Poll

Posted May 19, 2021, 6:41 PM UTC · locked

3915
angelcake1a•

Yoohyeon’s voice is clearer and has a soft but pure beauty to me. Siyeon fits more dramatic moments and is more powerful and versatile overall. I love them both. However, I think Yoohyeon is actually one of those 2nd vocalists who could be a main vocal in other groups. I know people throw that around a lot but I really think so in this case.

17

Yoohyeon is actually the strongest vocalist in DC.

8
angelcake1a•

Hmm I suppose I could see why many think that but I’ve heard them sing a lot and still struggle to agree. I haven’t heard her do anything Siyeon can’t do and I’ve heard Siyeon do a lot of things Yoohyeon hasn’t shown yet. I won’t argue it though lol I get where you’re coming from

2
SparklesKreutz•

I think it's definitely a case of 'just because it sounds good, it doesn't mean she's doing it right' with Siyeon. She strains her 5th octave belts, but I do still think she sounds okay and definitely fits their concept.

It's definitely technique vs style when talking about them (tho I actually don't think Yoo is particularly amazing either, but she shines in places she's comfortable in).

2
angelcake1a•

I do see what you mean there. I actually think Yoohyeon sounds better lol so for me it’s not the sounds good = is good for me. However, what you said about style vs technique is probably more accurate to what I was thinking. But Siyeon is still able to do things Yoohyeon hasn’t shown yet in a technical sense too

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
AutoModeratorMOD•

Hello, your comment was removed because you do not meet the minimum account age or do not have the required karma. This measure was put in place to reduce troll and spam comments, and for the benefit of the subreddit community.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
SparklesKreutz•

Siyeon's technique is pretty bad, and while Yoohyeon isn't as big of a risk taker and belts nowhere as high as Siyeon does, I do think she has her fundamentals more on-lock than Siyeon. HOWEVER, sometimes, you just have to sacrifice technique to fully embody a particular sound. Think Christina Aguilera who basically put her vocals on the line for YEARS so she can sound unique and stand out. This is Siyeon's thing. No one in KPOP sounds like her, thus giving Dreamcatcher a unique sound.

​

To fully commit to technique and vocal health, you do have to sacrifice some edge. Look at the vocalists (particularly the light lyric sopranos that KPOP loves) who have good technique like Taeyeon, Wendy, Yeonjung, Yuju (post whatever fucked her voice up), Luna, etc. While they have different colors and levels of artistry, and tone, you can find similarities in their voices because they approach singing in a very similar way. Meanwhile we have people like Rose, Bom, Siyeon whose voices are extremely distinguishable because they do whatever it takes to get to the sound they want (aka not using the proper technique in order to achieve a particular sound, whether intentional or not).

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
wandsk1kes•

Yoohyeon's voice is absolutely heavenly, god really has his favorites. I never understood why Siyeon was made the main vocalist because she can't even sing soprano middle notes without straining sounding unrelaxed as hell.

3
leeknowstoomuch•

Siyeon is a very powerful vocalist and has a very strong belt (I think that’s the right term... I’m not really an expert).

Yoohyeon’s voice isn’t quite as strong as Siyeon’s (at least in terms of “presence”), however, what makes Yoohyeon stand out among the members is she’s able to sing with the most feeling. To me, it’s one thing to be able to hit the notes, but another to be able to really SING the song and convey emotion with your voice.

I have to say though that my favorite vocal moment in the whole “Road to Utopia” album has to go to JiU. When she really GOES for that second chorus of Wind Blows**, there’s such a different color to her voice than the usual whispy/airy tone she has normally and I LOVE it. You can also hear that same color during this particular “panic in the city.”

3
Famous_Ad_4542•

i like yoohyeons voice the most .. esp singing R&B type songs.. even Jiu is a big fan of her singing voice

2
AutoModeratorMOD•

Interesting opinion...don't forget to add a statement where or how your opinion is unpopular. If you've already done so, great job!

Unpopular opinion: an opinion that is rare. It may be rare because most people disagree with the stance OR because the opinion is not discussed often.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
nova-loses-it•

i honestly can’t agree or disagree because i get her voice mixed up with siyeon often 💀

1
unpopularkpop_modMODtoxic twitter stan•

Your post has been locked because it is not an unpopular opinion. The poll was voted overwhelmingly popular. To appeal this action, please message the mods with a statement why you believe your post should be unlocked.

^(I am a bot and this action was performed automatically.)

1