TheWyldMan•

The scale of this strike is so small and at this point it just feels like twitter pushing for low skilled employees to get fired

63
xudoxis•

"McDonalds" faces strikes like this all the time. It's a lot easier to hurt a single franchisee than and make them make change.

If it also opens up a pr story pushing the larger company along all the better.

Non-franchisee locations are on track to hit an average wage of $15/hr in 2024.

13
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
agentpandaOPEndangered Black RINO•

I figured I'd post about something a little outside the norm since things are a little stagnant lately.

Tomorrow (or 'later' I guess) a few of the leftists are joining McDonald's workers in striking for a wage increase. It's interesting to me that Sanders' recent tweet (I'm using Twitter for the first time so bear with me) alleging that because McDonalds paid out $10m in executive compensation last year they can afford a wage hike to their 210,000 employees particularly... hilarious. It reeks of that sort of 'progressive math' that all but ignores... well... some business realities. For starters, $10M divided up by the 210K people that work for McDonald's worldwide is a grand total of $47... a year. I don't think that covers the gap Sanders and his ilk want it to. On top of that, it really does fail to grasp the situation that executives lead a business org and are due comensurate compensation or you just straight-up won't attract that talent.

The article goes into further detail though which I find even more interesting— McDonalds' corporate-owned stores are already paying out at $11/hr for entry-level workers and $15/hr for team leads/shift leaders, but corporate-owned stores only account for 5% of their store holdings; the remainder are franchises (so... y'know... small businesses paying license fees to Mc'Ds.) But it seems like the broader corporation is moving in that direction already. This also ignores of course... y'know... flipping burgers doesn't necessarily qualify as a high-skill job nor a demand position that should earn more than a few bucks an hour.

This is all a long way for me to come around to the fact that the progressives are finally doing something I can support— instead of trying to raise wages artificially by putting pressure on the federal legal apparatus, they're attempting to hit businesses where it hurts— the pocketbook. Historically (and practically) this has a way stronger impact on any given business org; but they also make me wonder why they think this measure will be remotely successful in doing what they really want it to do. Aren't SMBs (not necessarily international corp McDonald's, but franchises) struggling already, and if so, why do some people think more money spent on employee compensation (any business's largest line-item expense already) isn't going to lead to a depressed job market during a challenging time already?

I'm not conflicted on the mechanism of action here, finally; since the far-left seems to have quieted down on their push for federally mandated, COL ignoring inflationary wage growth— I'm just a little lost on why we don't ever play the tape through to its conclusion when having these discussions instead of focusing on big-ticket numbers like "$10 million in executive compensation". Is it potentially because the realities aren't necessarily as easy to sell to their populace? After all, "McDonalds corp can't really raise your wages, the franchises can't afford to, a lot of you will probably get fired if they did, and you shouldn't be making a lifelong career out of flipping burgers for entry-level wages anyway", isn't what their base wants to hear.

Is it intentionally dishonest of politicians like Biden and activists like AOC/Sanders to not give people the full story, or just ignorance?

38
[deleted]•

You don't pass a great bill like HR5245 To designate the facility of the United States Postal Service located at 1 Marble Street in Fair Haven, Vermont, as the `Matthew Lyon Post Office Building' by doing things the easy way.

Seriously though, I truly believe he thinks this will make a difference in spite of the fact that the decisions on wages are made by the franchise owners 95% of the time. On one hand, good for him and his spirit. On the other hand it reminds me of the evangelicals that hold up signs outside of Planned Parenthood. Certainly they all must know the effort will produce no results, right?!

25
agentpandaOPEndangered Black RINO•

See that's sorta my opposite viewpoint; and it's why I make note of the fact that Sanders and AOC and their ilk are fantastic activists, even if they are quite literally bottom-rung as legislators. But in contrast they seem to absolutely produce results in that they generate strong brands for themselves and (maybe stronger?) opposition among folks like me.

As a pretty good example is this issue— if it hadn't spawned from the fringe left (and hadn't been rooted on this weird $15/hr metric) you probably could've gotten moderates like me onboard with a minimum wage hike. After all, as folks so often love to parrot, the minimum wage federally hasn't adjusted for ages and absolutely hasn't kept up with inflation— not to say it should, or that it should; in that order.

But when the conversation starts at $15 and the discussion is national programs and rooted in their oft-repeated socialism (another thing I would probably not be so ardently opposed to, just minorly so, were it not a new talking point) and their discussion of CEO compensation and other silly notions— it doesn't just turn me off from the idea, it makes me actively lobby against their efforts to the point where... y'know... I'm no longer a 'moderate' on the issue.

They're great at steering conversations, less great about 'getting things done' unless the 'things' are, well, as you note— "renaming post offices" and "creating opposition where very little previously existed".

27
_reficio_•

Sanders and AOC and their ilk are fantastic activists, even if they are quite literally bottom-rung as legislators. But in contrast they seem to absolutely produce results in that they generate strong brands for themselves

Can't help but think of Barney Stinson from HIMYM: "That's what corporate America wants: people who seem like bold risk takers, but never actually do anything."

7
agentpandaOPEndangered Black RINO•

That's pretty funny; I should really watch that again. I got about 3 seasons deep and realized it was 'Friends' without being funny— but I also was in my 20s for Friends so it was kinda 'my' era thing...

I'll give it another shot because if Doogie Howser drew that comparison to the left being led by another brand of self-indulgent make-believe-land socialist while in reality just being Pied Piper'd off the edge of the cliff it'll definitely be more insightful than I gave it credit for.

I think I've dated myself a few times in this comment.

2
[deleted]•

I think you've hit the nail on the head! I know that sentiment is expressed in an upvote, but I had to comment that your point is well said.

Edit: And, I'd like to apologize because I once said you had an axe to grind with the left and I insinuated it painted some of your points. That wasn't fair or in the spirit of this sub, so my apologies.

6
shoonseiki1•

I'm pretty sure since it's inception, minimum wage has kept up and even far exceeded inflation. Whenever people say it hasn't kept up they're specifically comparing it to when minimum wage was at its peak which doesn't make sense for obvious reasons. Its possible using the year minimum wage was created might not be the best year to compare to either, I'm not sure.

https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/01/04/5-facts-about-the-minimum-wage/ft_17-01-03_minwage_1938_2016/

3†
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
[deleted]•

You somewhat missed the point. Holding up signs is about the least efficient way to get your message out. It targets everyone that drives past instead of being targeted. It's labor intensive. Its novelty has a short lifespan (after the third time I see them I totally tune them out). The messaging has no depth at all. And on and on. They're out there convincing themselves that they're saving the world. If they really wanted to change sentiment or talk someone out of an abortion, there are other way more effective, efficient ways to do that. This isn't an indictment on anyone's personal ideology, it's an indictment on their marketing methods.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
jyper•

Sanders negotiated a compromise bill reforming the VA with McCain. https://www.politico.com/story/2014/06/bernie-sanders-john-mccain-va-deal-107491

I'd put his lack of other major legislation more to congress being broken by things like the Fillubuster then individual faults. Passing significant legislation in this day and age is nearly impossible and I a think lot of Senators have similar or worse records

1
[deleted]•

You should look at his scorecard relative to other Senators. https://www.govtrack.us/congress/members/bernard_sanders/400357/report-card/2020

3
agentpandaOPEndangered Black RINO•

lol it's kinda hilarious we have to reach back to 2014 and late Senator McCain to find something notable about Sanders.

And, y'know, the VA. We all love veterans but like c'mon dude, it's not like he's known for being the champion of veterans' rights. Bernie Sanders spends a lifetime bitching about everything related to the economy and his big legislative success is VA reform almost 10 years ago.

2
BlazzedTroll•

I'm all for pressure on companies that gross millions to pay workers fairly. What I don't like is when those companies like Amazon, who could pay them, simply don't but the back efforts to raise the federal minimum wage. There are small businesses and entry level jobs like stocking shelves at rural gas station that is really is worth the federal minimum wage to a kid with nothing better to do who ends up chilling and talk to people 50% of the time or more anyway. The work Amazon puts on their warehouse workers is a constant on your feet moving high pressure job. It's difficult and it's necessary for the business to succeed and they pay them crap and treat them worse. Fuck them. Pay your workers. Don't put it on the government to make you do it. They know exactly what they're doing. They succeed by pushing their workers to do more for less and shut out small businesses and rake in the profits.

I am fully against a federal wage hike. But I am fully behind the people boycotting and protesting big businesses with low wages. People deserve FAIR wages, and there's an argument that some jobs are worth the minimum wage to the business. Clearly the people who get the packages to your door the next day that make Amazon's Next Day Delivery ™ possible are the ones getting the company the business they are getting.

4
davidw1098•

The fun thing is, there are all the warnings in the world of this being a bad idea for entry level workers to push for, and its all being dismissed as propoganda. Talk all you want about kiosks, apps, door dash taking their jobs, but it is actively happening. I work for a company that did the change to $15 starting pay after the covid shutdowns and here is where we are a year later - in February, we slashed tens of thousands of jobs. Our sales floor at one time had been staffed by, on a typical Friday for instance, 7-9 employees (with 2 dedicated customer service and 2 dedicated warehouse). We currently run a skeleton crew of 3 sales, 1 CS, 1 warehouse even on our busiest night (as a "test model" wink wink). The vast majority of our team is facing burnout, even after coming back from PTO, and there is a growing an excessive problem with call outs and tardiness (due in part at least to the call outs). With those call outs, because we slashed our roster so much, we don't have the same number of people we used to that can be called in for emergencies (so that 5ish employees often becomes 3 employees plus an extremely stretched leadership team, often of 1). Those employees we do have, have a standing of no overtime, no exceptions (we had been able to get permission for overtime previously, now that is a non-starter) and full timers are scheduled a max of 34 hours, part timers somewhere around 15.

We use the NPS survey system, a couple of notes that are ebign gleaned from our tanking results there - unfriendly associates (burnout), product not in stock (team members stretched too thin and thus not able to stock shelves), cleanliness is dropping (ditto), can not find anybody to help (because, you know, there aren't any employees to begin with).

At least the employees are satisfied with the $15 wage right? Eh, not really. In reality, our previous starting wage was officially $10, but we would usually start around $11-12. Our more seasoned employees had worked their way up to 15ish, leadership (supervisors) would be in the high teens (salary mangers obviously higher). They were pissed. It completely devalued the years they had put in to earning a higher wage and now a 17 year old cashing out would make the same as an associate who was one of our top performers. Couple that with the burnout and lack of help and morale is trending down.

I have no doubt that eventually the McDs of the world will give in and set a hard minimum of $15 (and eventually higher), that ship has sailed and market forces are moving the needle in the direction of a higher than government mandated minimum wage (as with most progressive policy, the real goal is government intervention and mandates, not private sector, action). Those self checkout kiosks will become all the more norm (anecdotally, walmart and home depot/Lowes are almost exclusively self checkout), and the real way the $15 minimum wage will be paid for is a slashing of benefits. Things like lowered tuition reimbursement (gee I wonder if that could be helpful for young, low income earners), 401k (my company suspended matching in June of last year, didn't officially announce if they turned it back on but judging by my Voya, maybe), employee discounts, PTO, all could be greatly modified.

1
Aside_Dish•

To play devil's advocate, is it possible that your company didn't have to lay off workers, and were just being greedy?

That's what I don't like about this whole conversation, because that is often times the case (not always, of course). Kinda like with the raising of the corporate tax.

"Oh, if they increase the corporate tax, businesses will have to fire a bunch of people!"

Will they really have to, or are they just being jerks and using government policy as an excuse? When I look at their financial statements, I see companies that are very profitable and have a ton of retained earnings.

2
davidw1098•

COVID and $15 were the excuse to be certain (the $15 change had already been in the works for a while, COVID just moved that time table up by about 3 years) and I’m not of the opinion that “oh poor corporation, they’ll never be able to open their doors”. But at the end of the day, profit and profit growth are major influences on a business. IMO, by opening the can of worms that is “we demand everyone make $15/hr” you then get CFO’s to be very creative in how they make things work out. It’s redundant to “need” fewer hours, fewer benefits, less headcount, etc, but if they’re already doing one under the guise of “safety!” and “we are raising your pay”, then the door is already open to “why not all of the above?”.

There was one change they made that coincided really well. Our hours were adjusted to closing 2 hours earlier (it had been 3, but the rushes were just insane in the last hour), which when I ran the math it worked out to saving enough labor to pay 2 full timers a week. It also helped employee morale (hell yeah I want to leave when the sun is still up) and fit better with our business trends (in 7 years with this company, those 7-9pm hours have always been extremely unproductive outside of q4). So naturally, when the mask mandate was adjusted, we also went back to closing at 8 (with the inevitable 9pm coming soon at this point) thereby stretching the labor even more.

3
Aside_Dish•

Fair enough. And I agree. Excuse or not, businesses will still do it. I guess what I don't like is a certain side of the political spectrum often acting like it's the workers being greedy. Especially since that's the side of the political spectrum I happen to be on. But instead of complaining about the workers living in poverty, I wish more would get angry at the companies that can very much afford to pay their workers more, but choose not to so they can do nothing with the retained earnings or give out dividends (which disproportionately help people that don't rely on that money anyways).

Basically, I hate how there's a huge portion of people that have been convinced it's the workers being assholes, and not the actual assholes.

1
DrGlorious•

The franchises exist to extract all but about 6% of profits to the McDonald's corporation. They are not really the negotiating partner in any national push for higher wages.

The corporate entity operates with about 50% profit margin, and is probably investing a good bit of the rest. That is up from 40% in 2010, and 30% in 2006. This fantastic increase in profit margins is the result of stagnated labor costs.

So the real negotiating space is there, provided that pressure can be applied where it needs to be.

-2†
RegardTheFrost•

"This fantastic increase in profit margins is the result of stagnated labor costs."

That objectively cant be true - how could a cost not changing lead to improved margins? Somewhere, revenue went up or a cost went down, and wages just didnt happen to offset it.

(Good for mcd's workers on the strike though)

7
DrGlorious•

It can, because revenue has not remained flat compared to inflation like labor cost has. McDonald's has increased it's prices since 2006, it has just kept the gains of that increase.

2†
RegardTheFrost•

You could make the same argument for any cost that didnt rise with revenue.

2
Ihaveaboot•

Bernie never worked at McD's. I did as a teen in the 80s for 3.25 an hour.

But I wasn't paying off a mortgage at the time - it was spending money as a kid.

14
JaxTheGuitarNoob•

I mean Bernie never really worked ever besides odd jobs, he has been living off the government being a professional useless person for decades. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bernie\_Sanders#Early\_career

41
qazedctgbujmplmEpistocrat•

That's not fair. He did steal electricity from a neighbor, so he's lived off more than just the government.

34
jyper•

so you're complaining that he's an experienced public servant?

-1†
JaxTheGuitarNoob•

No I'm complaining a socialist doesn't practice what he preaches and he has no real world experience. He has never really been a worker and has made millions pushing for socialism. Why doesn't he share that wealth with the proletariat?

8
StewartTurkeylinkBull Moose Party•

Ah yes the classic "Oh you're a socialist then why do you have money" method of attack. Just because you participate in a system does not mean you are unable to criticize a system. One rich socialist giving away their wealth doesn't equal systemic change, plus Bernie isn't even a socialist. He is a democratic socialist, he advocates for reform, not the destruction of capitalism.

Furthermore Bernie's net worth is around 2 million and most of that is recently acquired from his book sales due to his surge in popularity in 2016. Before that he was one of the poorest senators. In fact he still is one of the poorest senators with a net worth around 2 million, he's not even among the top 100 richest people in congress. He has been working in government for decades now and his wife is a college administrator. It's really not that crazy that a husband and wife in their 80s who have been gainfully employed for 40 years at position that are well paying (both college administrators and Senators make sixish figures) have a net worth of around 2 million.

In fact I would be much more concerned if after 40+ years of decent even well paying employment he wasn't worth a million or two. It would show he is REALLY bad with his money.

https://www.townandcountrymag.com/society/politics/a31437248/bernie-sanders-net-worth/

4
TheWyldMan•

Which was not a managerial job at a McDonald’s should be. The question politicians should be asking is how not to make these jobs sustainable as careers but instead how to give people the skills to move onto better jobs.

15
EllisHughTiger•

That, and promoting the creation of jobs that pay more based on the value they produce. Manufacturing and other labor jobs actually create solid objects with real value.

We keep trying to pull up crappy jobs to support a family, instead of jobs that create enough value that they naturally pay good wages.

2†
NativeMasshole•

McDonald's doesn't create value? They're almost literally everywhere! This is one of the biggest chains on the planet, I don't think it's fair to call them worthless.

10
EllisHughTiger•

After all the costs involved, not really, at least on the store level.

McDs ONLY real created value is that they are a real estate and manufacturing company. Selling burgers is not the main corporate function.

1
jyper•

and forcing buisnesses to pay a larger percent of revenue as wages

their will always be low skill jobs but those people still need to live

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

1

Labor is a commodity, worth whatever you can get for it.

Bosses and labor are always in an adversarial relationship — bosses want more money going to profits and into their pockets, labor want more money going into their pockets.

It’s a struggle. There’s no inherently fair wage — bosses always have to pay labor less than the value they produce or they won’t have any profits.

The current McDonalds CEO is making less than his predecessor. McDonalds had also stopped lobbying against state and local minimum wage increases. Theyve connected executive pay to raising diversity benchmarks (I’m sure we don’t all agree here, let’s not get sidetracked). They’re doing a lot to combat the rampant sexual harassment going on in corporate — over 70% of women saying they’ve experienced it in one form or other (lot of work still to be done there).

So McDonalds is taking a lot of good steps, making a lot of progress. But labor would be stupid to just be satisfied with that and not try to sell their work to the company at a higher price.

These comparisons of CEO compensation vs median wages are just good for sound bites. I don’t really care what the ratio is. Id side with labor no matter what the ratio is or how decent or evil the bosses are — wages have stagnated in the US for decades and it’s causing a lot of political instability.

There are a lot more laboring people than there are bosses, and after decades and decades of skyrocketing GDP and flatlining wages, a lot people are starting to think the system isn’t working for them, neither party will help them, and maybe it’d be better to rip it up and start again. That scares me and that’s the main thing I care about.

13
hagy•

I will applaud their effort for taking concrete action to drive beneficial change as opposed to just “raising awareness” on twitter. Further, I agree that these unskilled roles are relatively low paying and are focused around menial work.

Yet, I believe the best solution is to get people out of these roles entirely. We need to get humans out of these menial and labor intensive roles through massive investments in kitchen automation. Thankfully, there has already been significant R&D investments in this area and we're just starting to see the amazing results.

As covered in Dec 2020 article, Future Restaurants Will Fit In A Shipping Container And Have No Humans In The Kitchen

“Starting in the next two years, you’re going to see an explosion of really high quality, small footprint delivery kiosks — think high quality vending machines, kind of express menus,” Miso Robotics co-founder Buck Jordan told me recently on the TechFirst podcast.

“But then I think around year five or seven, you’re going to start seeing a lot of … all new-build kitchens being completely reinvented, fully autonomous, no humans in the back of house, 25% the square footage, probably fits in a shipping container, completely changing the entire industry and potentially disrupting the franchise model.”

“The future’s already here,” he says. “We have standalone machines that can cook a pizza in less than three minutes from scratch. We have automated Boba tea bars hitting the scene. And all these things just make it easier for customers to get low-touch food options faster and close to home.”

White Castle has been experimenting with this tech and in October 2020, announced that they would roll out the robotic fry cook to 10 new locations. Here’s a short video, showing the robot in action. There is also the Creator restaurant in San Francisco, which has a fully automated burger chef.

Getting people out of this menial work will drop costs to consumers, while improving consistency, quality, and cleanliness. I can hardly wait for what this sector will look like in just a decade.

7
B1G_Fan•

I was about to say how these folks clamoring for minimum wage increases are about to get wiped out by automation, but you beat me to it.

Well done

3
jyper•

there's nothing wrong with automation

the problem is with negotiating power(especially with the suppression of unions and not raising the minimum wage). corporations already are gobbling up a majority of the increase of productivity. automation is good but we need a way to force a good share of the cost decrease to go to workers

1
BassFishingMasterGen Z Conservative•

There are plenty of better jobs that pay better than McDonalds, seems like it should be a temp job for people

4
agentpandaOPEndangered Black RINO•

This is similar to my viewpoint, and highlights the problems I'm having with getting my arms around the far left's views on the minimum wage.

I don't know why it should be considered a 'living wage' in the modern American economy— maybe it hasn't always been a 'stepping stone' in our history, but it really should be now, shouldn't it? Incentivizing stagnancy at the entry-level seems to be... well exactly that, disincentivizing growth and self-improvement. And then also if that growth or improvement isn't in your wheelhouse... maybe minimum wage is just what your value is?

Don't get me wrong, if Costco wants to pay its floor team $15/hr (and they do, I believe) more power to them.

5
Abstract__NonsenseMarxist-Bidenist•

Part of the issue is that in our current economy there’s many more of these minimum wage type jobs than there are workers just looking for a stepping stone. Less than half of federal minimum wage workers are under 25.. In the UK they try to get around this “stepping stone” aspect by having multiple minimum wages based on age, I’m not sure that’s a perfect approach but at least it gets around the “teenagers flipping burgers” argument.

The fact is that back in the Fordist manufacturing dominated economy there was a greater share of low barrier for entry “semi-skilled” jobs that still provided some opportunity for advancement, and could provide something approaching a respectable career if you were a good “company man”. These days we have many more high paying jobs available for those with the background and skills to get them, but relatively less of the kind of job that you can get without a college degree and then gain skills on the job. These still exist of course, they just make up a smaller relative share of things.

So what about incentivizing personal growth? Well the studies I’ve seen haven’t shown this to work in the direction you’re implying. Sure not getting stuck flipping burgers motivates people to go to college, gain skills, etc., but there’s a pipeline here where if you ever fall off it can be hard to get back on. If you end up in a situation where you need to work 60 hours a week to scrape by, it makes it more difficult to gain skills, look for other jobs, and so on. The studies I’ve seen on UBI pilot programs in low income communities have suggested that living on the financial edge is an impediment to upward mobility, rather than an incentive to improve your position.

All of this said I actually don’t think a flat federal minimum is the greatest solution. Bernie’s favorite Scandinavian countries manage to have high “minimum wages” without mandating it because of sectorial bargaining that covers most workers, but we’ve got no currently existing infrastructure for something like that in the states. Maybe something like a UBI, or a Friedman style reverse income tax could work better. I don’t however think it’s productive to just say, “if you’re only offered low wages that’s all your worth” to people often working multiple jobs desperately trying to make ends meet, not just because I think it’s a tad cruel, but because I think our society is the worse off for it, and if some of those people had a little more financial room to breathe they might be able to actually change their situation so they can become a more economically productive worker.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
Duranel•

Same. I agree with practically nothing he says, but I do like that he actually stands for things. My only real gripe with him is that he never really spent time as one of the proletariat, but that's the same as wanting a requirement for military service to run for President.

2
bobsagetsmaid•

Your pay is determined by how easy you are to replace. Not sure what's complicated about that.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1