Sunisa could have scored 15.6 +

WAG

Obviously, the bulk of the attention is on her fall, but can we note that she easily could have gotten the highest UB score of the quad if she hadn't made uncharacteristic mistakes?

Her fall alone cost her 1.7 (1.0 fall + 0.3 time deduction + 0.4 in CV). Removing that mistake would bring her score to a 15.6.

She also had a 0.3 deduction for her straddling her Nabieva. If you remove entirely remove that deduction, or reduce it to a 0.1 deduction, that would bring her to a 15.8/15.9

She also repeated her maloney, which led to at least 0.1 in extra deductions (leg separation, and potentially other deductions)

Posted May 23, 2021, 2:00 PM UTC · edited

3822
gerdinots•

What’s up with her nabieva recently? She used to not straddle it this much

45
ValuableNerve•

She may have grown a little and is still adjusting. She also has a lot going on in her life right now and has had to put up with way more hardship than anyone, especially her age, should ever have to. She understandably may not be in peak form right this second (and doesn’t have to be yet) and need to get some bars strength/endurance back.

28
ndrwpf•

I think it’s a combination of nerves and fatigue

17

I think it’s a combination of nerves and fatigue

and camera angles.

-2
ndrwpf•

She’s done plenty of good ones in the past lmaooo

3
sr0570•

my guess is she's gets nervous about the opening combo, so she is straddling to get a little more counter-rotation to be able to see the bar a bit earlier.

she has to catch the nabieva perfectly with arms stretched to be able to swing high enough on the bhardwaj to rotate it enough to then be able to go into the maloney directly.

her growing a bit and having an adult body now probably makes launching yourself into the nabieva harder, but we know she can do it because she's done her full 6.8D cleanly with her normal nabieva in podium trainings and warmups this year.

9
ArnoldRimmersBeam•

Last night's was particularly bad, it looked like she was off right from the start.

5
fairretOP•

Could Suni petition to add the straddled Nabieva / laid-out Ray to the CoP? That way she could get the skill named for her instead of incurring a huge deduction. It could be her insurance policy (kind of like how Wieber and Biles submit their Weiler 1/1 incase they fall over the side of the bars)

2
ValuableNerve•

No, there is no such position as a “laid-out straddle” FIG wouldn’t buy that, it would be like adding a straddled flight Maloney to avoid a leg separation deduction, you can’t make up a skill to just avoid a deduction.

3
fairretOP•

Hmm, but what about a "piked-straddle" Maloney? lol :)

2
potatoismyreligion•

I guess when push comes to shove it doesn’t matter unless you can actually pull it off without mistakes. A lot of girls fell and we could look at what their scores could have been but to me it doesn’t really matter? I guess we have to see which girls are able to pull it together, and which are injured or past their peak. I was certainly surprised by some of the falls that occurred today.

33
greenandbluepillow•

The recovery from the beam fall was wonderful, and I think shows her strength. I love her, she’s become my absolute favorite. But she needs to get it together and hit.

17
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

Doesn't matter. She didn't. Hopefully we see this at Nationals.

10
brecollier•

I'm wondering if you are a gymnast? My daughter is a L10 and she always says things like OP. My guess is it's a way of positive thinking/glass half full. Like without a fall and some other blatant mistake that I usually don't make in practice that I know I can fix, my score would have been 9.45...so I know I had a hit routine, or minimal other deductions. Obviously it doesn't help with that meet, but I think it helps with the mentality and what you take back to the gym on Monday.

My point is, I think OPs thinking is very common for a gymnast to analyze routines that way, I watched with my daughter yesterday and that's what she was doing. "Well if she hadn't stepped out of bounds or landed XXX she would have gotten XXX." Forward thinking for future meets and making predictions for the final team too, and I'm guessing Tom looks at the routines that way as well.

But yeah, if Suni doesn't nail them Nationals and Trials, I don't think she goes to Tokyo.

15

I agree, I don't think it doesn't matter that she didn't. Of course, if she goes through Nationals & Trials without succeeding either, that'd be a different story.

However, as a fan who likes the scoring/numerical aspect of the sport, I think it's interesting to play through these scenarios. It shows what gymnasts are capable of. It gives leniency for uncharacteristic errors. It lends itself to strategy possibilities. It's fun to speculate.

Not completely agreeing with OP's analysis (i.e. judges would have other deductions to take on the skill if they didn't take the full -1 for a fall; she might've had more deductions if she had to keep going through the routine without coming off and having a slight "rest" on the ground). But it does show that we can be optimistic about how well Suni can score. This was an outlier low score that's only concerning if she continuously competes this way.

Consistency is important, but if it was all we cared about then we'd just average a gymnast's score throughout the year and select based on that.

5
fairretOP•

Hahaha, I'm not a gymnast, just a couch potato gym fan!

I don't believe that having a fall on a skill necessarily prevents judges from taking additional execution deductions? Either way, her Maloney typically isn't a magnet for deductions..it's more that geinger that gets like two foot of height that worries me

0
[deleted]•

I think that thinking this way is great from gymnast and coach point of view, as it is optimistic. I think that from a viewer perspective (I've been watching gymnastics since Sydney), I have seen so many gymnasts with the potential to score high or win, but struggle to put it together under pressure.

From a viewer perspective, I just go off what has happened, not someone's potential. You can rearrange almost any podium in history by saying, "well if so and so didn't do this or did this then they would win." From a gymnast perspective I think doing that is smart, because you learn the code better and you realize that you could win, or that you could score much higher at least. From a viewer perspective, I will believe that someone actually can hit a certain score or a certain routine or a certain skill when they do. I've been disappointed too many times :P

2
fairretOP•

I reminds me of how Li Shan Shan got a silver medal in 2007 on beam with a fall. She would have scored a 16.9 otherwise, which is mind-boggling!

1
pja314former gymnast, coach, & judge•

She would have scored a 16.9 otherwise, which is mind-boggling!

I'm way late to the party in this thread, but in 2007 the deduction for a fall was .8, not 1.0.

16.7 would still be insane though!

1
Justafana•

She seemed a little tired and defeated, like maybe something was weighing on her mind. Hope she’s ok, would love to see her show her usual calm style of fight at nationals.

4

Pretty much everyone looked tired to me, I think the long break then first competition back put a lot of stress on them.

3