Am I the only one who really dislikes voice acting in dialogs?

The new characters in the Enhanced Edition and especially Siege of Dragonspear has a lot of voice acting.

IMO it's pointless and annoying; I read a lot faster than I can listen and reading while someone is speaking is distracting. I ended up just setting "voice volume" to 0, which is the closest thing I can do to disable it (although it loses the confirmation voices etc. too, which is a bit jarring at first).

Surely I can't be the only one who really dislikes this?

Also: they changed Khalid's voice for this :-(

Posted May 25, 2021, 7:22 AM UTC

011
CarverCreator•

I saw a YouTube comment talking about voice acting in Baldur's Gate, and it clicked with me. It was how in BG you'll oftentimes hear a little voice acting, just enough to get an impression of what someone sounds like, and then you're able to fill in the rest while you read the text. I really like this format since it lets you read at your own pace, while also utilizing a bit of imagination and a bit of actual voice acting that lets you get into what's being said.

11
Yawzheek•

This. Exactly this. I always wondered why I didn't care for voice acting. It's this.

I don't mind the new characters being voice acted, but I prefer the method Baldur's Gate originally went with. I love it. I could never figure out why, but now I know: I read faster than people speak, so just give me a taste of what you have the voice actor sound like, and I'll read the rest in my head in a similar voice. I move at my own speed, you save money.

Things like battle speech is perfectly fine. Great, even. But long dialogues I prefer to read silently.

On a related note, if it's something that is hard to determine the pronunciation of (Faerun, for example), voice act that once.

4
Malbethion•

I'm sorry that you feel that way, old man.

5
Naturalnumbers•

They actually used the same voice actor for Khalid (Jim Meskimen). It's just been a long time and voices change over time. I really liked hearing the old voices again. :shrug:

3
arp242OP•

It's just different from what I'm used to. It's like watching a cartoon in Dutch while I grew up with the English version, or vice versa. It's not bad, but it just sounds all wrong.

1
ThaTastyKoala•

It depends on my mood but admittedly voice acted dialogue is a bit of a drag in these games sometimes considering there's no character animations that go with it. I'm much more tempted to skip while playing these over say, Mass Effect or Dragon Age.

2
[deleted]•

The Beamdog voice acting isn't great.

1
acetami•

Just strike it as just one more thing they did wrong.

1
Gosu_Horaz•

Well, I agree that fully voiced games are a bit much. There really is no point in voicing every merchant and peasant. But sometimes I wish they had a few more fully voiced dialogues. I always found it to be kind of a let down that not even Sarevok's last dialogue is fully voiced.

1
MisterOfScience•

For me voice acting is nice, but it's the last thing I would spend money in a game. I would rather have two more quests and a new map than voice acted entire game. I would rather hire three more QA people than ten voice actors.

1
[deleted]•

Voice acting is one of the best aspects of the game. It really brings every character to life. You wish there was none of it? I wish there was more of it.

0