Gemini dollar (GUSD) finally added to Earn with 7.4% APY

Posted May 26, 2021, 10:38 AM UTC

Posted May 26, 2021, 10:38 AM UTC
Being a Blockfi and Gemini user, I am quite surprised the APY ain't the same.
I just withdrew anything over tier 1 on blockfi so like 70% of my funds, to put in Gemini. If I'm getting low rates would rather have the way safer service that doesn't let users withdraw $10million of accidental bitcoin
Not surprised. It's been known from the beginning that blockfi subsidizes their rates with VC money to attract customers.
What APY does BlockFi pay vs the 7.4 at Gemini? thanks
8.6%
I’m trying it with $100 first just for fun. 7.4% interest is great IMO. I like the idea of 7.4% plus the compounding effect over time.
Did you end up putting more in?
No, I actually pulled my money because I needed it.
If you pulled $100 out because you "needed it" then this might not be for you.
LOL. I had wayyyyyy more than $100 in there when I pulled it out.
Oops, I answered wrong, yes I had added quite a bit more.
HUGE
That’s pretty sweet!
Great! Nice to diversify GUSD further. Personally I am happy with Blockfi but having the assets in both, for me, is a nice peace of mind
Still stuck with in kind payments on other crypto though
I will put $2,500 in that. Better paying then my savings account. 🤙
Knowing Gemini customer service I would be wary using them as my actual savings account even with the high interest rate, besides I am going on month 4 still waiting to get verified lol
Yeah, I'm on Coinbase a lot more now for the lack of customer service on Gemini. Most of my stash there is crap anyway; it was my first exchange. I've got some stuff on Coinbase pumping even through this crash, whereas on Gemini... it's downright funereal. 😎
How is this fully backed? I want to know what level of risk we're dealing with even if they claim it's FDIC insured.
The same question I have. I have multiple savings accounts and why in the world would I keep my money there? FDIC insured is why.
GUSD in Earn is not backed by anything
Okay, so, it's Gemini is FDIC insured but Earn is not. Because the site says that there is risk involved with Earn because you are technically moving the crypto off-site which means if something happens to it then it's just frigging gone. I feel like people here aren't getting that. Or maybe there's something I'm not getting.
As far as I know only USD on Gemini is FDIC insured. All crypto is uninsured and I don't think there are any exchanges where it is insured. There is risk that the loans used in Gemini Earn are not necessarily insured. You have to trust that Gemini has thoroughly vetted it's third-party lenders, and that is the risk that you get paid 7.4% for.
Exactly. And, for my couple hundred dollars, not worth it.
Yuppp. I was a little surprised pulling this up and seeing all the positivity. The first thread I ever saw here a few months back was downright hostile.
It's held by Genesis, which serves several bad-credit cards (I have two) and they're not exactly primo. Fairly predatory and... below-par. Now, the custodial might be an entirely different division but... yeah. I had a pile of DAI and, when we crashed, immediately switched it back into USD.
I'd feel a lot more comfortable with a silver-pegged coin but I guess we're not really there yet.
Please tell me how Genesis cards are predatory? Really curious.
Nice, I really don't like using BlockFi for this.
Is there a trading fee to buy /sell GUSD? (Coinbase USDC is free to trade but offer bare min interest.) I like the 7.4% here, and I'm seriously thinking of contributing on a weekly basis. But if the fees are bringing down, it kills the point of owning this.
I don't think there are any fees to convert USD to GUSD on Gemini.
EDIT: Confirmed. Just added some USD to Gemini Earn and there was no fee to convert it to GUSD.
Super, thanks!!!
thanks for the help confirming. I don't have an account yet. So rather than taking a random user's referral link, do you have a referral code to share?
I'll use yours since you helped me. thx again.
Is it FDIC insured when you have money on gusd (not in liquidity) in Gemini account?
Couldn't find a way to covert my USD into GUSD, what gives? Is there certain limitation based on country?
I was able to do it from the Earn page. Click on "Earn" and you can use you fiat balance to buy GUSD for the Earn balance. It was not immediately intuitive.
i think there is a change recently in Gemini. Couldn't find it yesterday when i trying to send GUSD to Celsius.
then i found another thread here saying that you need to Buy GUSD through the Trade on the mobile app. initially i couldn't see GUSD in my list, until i changed my base currency to USD, then it appeared. so worth a try
I think in theory the dollars stored in your account are technically GSUD. You can for instance withdraw your cash balance as GUSD to your ETH wallet.
looks like gusd is now treated like other tokens, so you need to swap in/out against usd on the app or retail ui. looks like zero fees to do so still so that’s great
if you use active trader for some reason gusd is only available on the basic interface.
This is great news, but what's the argument here for keeping your excess GUSD on Gemini vs, say, Celsius, where you'd get 10%? I assume the implication is a less risky lending strategy.
As a New York State resident seems like GUSD with GEMINI is the only way to earn interest on a token with a licensed exchange. Celsius is not licensed in NYS is a total dud for me. Also Celsius is not FDIC insured, Gemini is. As a US citizen that is important to me.
You can use Celsius in NYS, you’re just limited to their 4 approved coins. (BTC, ETH, CEL, USDC).
Also while Gemini has some kind of FDIC insurance, I really don’t think you’re covered if your money is in GUSD. Here’s the fine print from Geminis website: “¹ FDIC insurance applies only to the USD reserve funds. GUSD exist as ERC-20 tokens on the Ethereum blockchain; tokens are under the user’s self-custody, and are not insured through Gemini.”
Thanks for this and the fine print. I know I can store in Celsius, but are you saying that the four coins on Celsius incur interest in NYS?
That is my understanding. I’m moving to NYS soon and asked support this question.
“Hello (RSFQ’s real name here),
Thank you for contacting Celsius with your inquiry. I'm pleased to be able to help you.
Due to local laws and state regulations in New York, Celsius users in this region face limitations on coins that can be deposited, and subsequently the interest reward payments that can be earned.
The coins that are available in NY that you can deposit and earn interest on are ETH, BTC, USDC, CEL (however US users cannot earn rewards on CEL tokens if you have BTC, ETH, USDC you would have to earn your rewards in-kind on these.)
We hope to be able to offer a wider range of coins to our NY users in the future. If/when this occurs we will communicate this to our users via our social media channels and weekly newsletter.
Should you have any further queries, please feel free to reach out. Best regards,
Customer Support Agent | Celsius”
Gemini's reputation for security.
Both are pretty secure and reliable. I guess the difference is when redeeming from gemini earn it takes anywhere from instant-5 business days but it also has the convenience of everything being in one account if you also use their exchange. And with Celsius if you don't mind signing up for another kyc and having to go through withdrawal/deposits to and fro, all their rates are pretty much better than gemini earn.
If you're a hodlr and don't plan to sell for long periods i recommend Celsius due to their way superior rates
I think that's my move (long term hodlr). I'm surprised Gemini didn't offer at least 8.6%, given that's what BlockFi does- and BlockFi uses Gemini for all their storage!
Idk shit but I'm guessing it's because they're banking on the convenience of having their exchange and savings wallet in one account that they offer lower rates than other savings accounts like blckfi and Celsius. Also maybe cause geminis main is their exchange and secondary is earn savings. While celsius main is savings/lending and their secondary is buying coins directly . So each one works on what the other doesn't focus on.
In the end i don't think you can go wrong with either. Both are reputable and secure, just make sure to set up security on your account and pray they don't default lol
Blockfi subsidizes their rates with VC money to attract new customers.
Slightly less risk. As the interest is made from possibly unsecured loans, there's a chance your principle is not repaid. With rates of 7.4% you're at 100% gain after 9.3 years.
Gemini is partnering with accredited third party borrowers including Genesis, who are vetted through a risk management framework which reviews our partners’ collateralization management process. On a periodic basis we will conduct an analysis of our partners’ cash flow, balance sheet, and financial statements to ensure the appropriate risk ratios and healthy financial condition of our partners.
But monthly 10 free withdrawals and Celsius pays 10% APY weekly just for hodling there… how come not more ppl just doing that? and before anyone mentions state restrictions, can I just say VPN it?
Can you even VPN that though? What happens if you want to withdraw/deposit a big amount and they KYC and see your ID? Unless you Vpn and use passport? I live in Hawaii and Coinbase doesn't support here when so many other exchanges do...
So, continuing the tradition of paying lower crypto interest rates than BlockFi (8.6%, with 10% promotional rate for all deposits after like April 22 this this year until July 31.)
Help me understand this. What makes this, as well as Dai which is also 7.4%, attractive as they're stablecoins? Why not invest in Filecoin which is the only other 7.4% APY but isn't tied to the dollar and can rise in value? I get that it's a lot better than a traditional bank minus the insecurity of it but why stablecoins over Filecoin?
Why not invest in Filecoin which is the only other 7.4% APY but isn't tied to the dollar and can rise in value?
It can also lower in value.
This is a 'safer' investment like a savings account.
Way better than any traditional savings account
I'm not interested in taking on crypto risk because I'm buying a house in a year or two. But 7.4% on a stablecoin is nice. Much better than you would get on a HYSA with just a tiny bit of risk.
I have Filecoin in Earn. Sure Filecoin can go up, but the risk is, it can also crash, which it did. All my Earn and money put into Filecoin is currently at less than what I put in. Stablecoins are immune to crypto crashes. It's a risk reward thing, stablecoins are slow, risk free.
I had this same idea a month or so ago, and bought $1000 worth of filecoin at $170 to put into Earn. That is now worth $370 including interest.... So I guess that is the risk haha. If I would have just put in in Dai, I'd still have $1000.
Safety and stability of the asset like a savings account but much better with the 7.4% apy.
So this is slightly related - I asked in the other GUSD thread but don’t know how many people are still reading that one: now that deposits into Gemini are automatically added as GUSD and need to be “sold” to be withdrawn, does that mean any conversion is a taxable event?
In theory, I would think so because the IRS says any buy/sale is a reportable, taxable event but it seems extreme.
Dang, I had given up on Gemini (issues linking a bank account) but this blows away anything for basic savings… might give them a third try 😛
So in theory this beats most high yield savings account APY. But if we convert and cash out, is that gonna need documentation come next tax season? I know for me with my savings, with so little as it is, it never needed reporting. But I wonder about this now.
Yeah you have to pay taxes, but it is only on the gains. If you put in $10,000, and have $10,740 a year later, you made a gain of $740 and have to pay taxes on it.
This is no different than any other savings amount or investment.
Making Money on Money. I like it. 🤙
After a year keeping , they will reduced the capital gains 10% tax?
No, you are taxed in the year it is accrued. There is no concept of long term capital gains with interest earnings.
How much tax?
But it's higher taxes than would be imposed on bank account interest, right?
No
Yes it'll need reporting for sure, and it is treated currently as property, like Gold. I'm fairly confident you'll have to put it in a 1099-MISC. Here's a write up from BlockFi, a US based crypto-interest company (who uses Gemini for storage):
https://blockfi.com/what-to-expect-for-tax-season
Key in this is that I believe that you will have to report this interest EVERY YEAR, not just when you cash out.
Yes, you have to report it every year. It is taxed as earned income, just as an interest earning bank account would be.
Now I'm wondering if this is a good bet for say a Savings account and a deterrent for Inflation
Last bullet point in section 1
So don't count on getting any document if you made less than $600. Though it looks pretty easy in the Earn interface to figure out the interest. Maybe the disclaimer is more for non-stable coin use, as you have to figure out your tax lots when you move coins in and out of Earn.
Edit: you only get a 1099-MISC if you made more than $600
I'm fairly sure they will provide reports, just like other exchanges do for similar services. I think the comment is just to eliminate anyone suggesting they did not file taxes because gemini didn't give them a particular form.
Found another page that says you only get a form if you make more than $600/yr.
That would make sense. $600 is the cutoff line for income to be reported.
it has to be on your taxes and gemini would also be submitting it and giving you the tax form download.
its same with any savings account or stock trading.
Unless it’s changed, I believe it has to be over $600.
Lol anything over $10 made from savings has to be reported
Oh wow, I didn’t realize it had gone to such a low amount 😯
What 1099 does Gemini send us: 1099-MISC or 1099-INT? It is over $10 reported if interest earned, but is Gemini considered a bank? It is $600 on 1099-MISC.
It would be 1099 misc. the $600 amount applies for 1099 int. Self employed people
I assume Gemini will send you whatever the tax form it is 1099 INT or something like that - but maybe not.
[deleted]