r/psych•
Silverwave2

Scary Sherry: Bianca's Toast in my opinion was a very weak episode.

This episode had a good premise, funny jokes, and a killer with an understandable motive, as well as getting to see a side of Jules that was contrast to her normal personality, but it had a big flaw that made it weak.

There was only one real suspect, Alice Bundy, and there was no real doubt that she was the killer. The only other suspect was ,the entire school because the sorority girls were awful, but Alice had a connection to the first victim, motive, and her only "alibi" for her murder was that she went upstairs and no one saw her for the rest of the night.

My first thought to that was, "well she just snuck out then" and that was what happened. You dont need to be psychic to figure out she was guilty.

That aside the episode was great, especially Goochberg, but I feel they kinda dropped the ball on this one when iy came to the mystery behind the deaths.

Posted May 26, 2021, 7:16 PM UTC

86
ThaliaShips•

Solidly disagree. It's a great episode based solely on the scene of Gus and Shawn screaming running to the blueberry😂

5
Moose_Winchester•

The jumping and squealing perfects it. That and the Mrs. Pickles scene make this episode one of my favorites

3
itsonlyfear<Gus's Nickname Here>•

Agreed, but I find I usually know who the killer is halfway through so in the grad scheme of things it doesn’t bother me much. I feel like the point of this one is less about the whodunnit and more about how far you would go for a friend. When Alice asks Shawn what he would have done if it was Gus, that feels like a really poignant moment.

4
PurpleGodandViolet•

Assuming his feelings for Gus are similar to his feelings for his dad, he wouldn't have killed anybody he would have gone on a rampage to bring the person to justice as we saw in SantaBarbaraTown part 2.

So I feel we got an answer for that question and I find that to be satisfying.

1
GirlNinja553psycho•

Hmm, I agree. Good episode, but certainly not one of my favorites

3
FullMongoose•

Agree. It's Psych so I still enjoy it but it's in my bottom 10. Some good moments but overall not my fave..... Agree about no mystery and not even any clever solving of the mystery. I also wasn't a huge Gooch fan so that probably doesn't help.

I still watch it though.

3