My friend demanded I bake gingerbread "trannies" today instead of gingerbread men... I think I nailed it (NSFW) (please don't hate me!)
Posted Dec 22, 2011, 9:28 PM UTC
Posted Dec 22, 2011, 9:28 PM UTC
This is really fucking offensive, even if you don't realize it. A ton of trans* people struggle with issues that they, for the most part, have almost no control over. *transgender, transsexual, whatever To put this into perspective, imagine if I made "nigger cookies" in which a black person with stereotypical and racist features and posted it to a subforum that deals with racism.
I understand you were just trying to be "funny" and that you probably didn't know much better, but this is just wrong in so many ways.
(I also realize my example could have been phrased a ton better, but still. )
Not trying to be a douche, but i laughed so hard when i read nigger cookies. I don't promote racism, or transphobia, but damn. You get an upvote, i laughed so hard my dog started whining.
Not what I expected when I looked at unread messages. Hahaha.
I probably would have been okay if you used this wording in some situations; however, the main thing that bugs me is the beard stubble, the penis sticking out from under the skirt, the mustache and unibrow, the fake looking breasts...
For most trans people, coming out and getting to accept yourself and other people to do the same is a very hard thing. Some people equate transitioning on the same level as plastic surgery- a cosmetic thing. Some people say that it makes a mask, and it's not really you. Some people call us men still because that's how we were supposedly born as.
Do you know what that stubble means to most trans people? It's a huge burden that is very expensive and hard to get rid of. For transguys as well, it's just a huge burden for most to have breasts.
For transwomen, I'd say the occurence of BA surgery is just as common in the cis female population. Next time you portray a women assigned unfortunately as a male at birth, understand that these things may look funny, but they're really really hard to get rid of and to stop people from making fun of you.
That is so disgustingly offensive it isn't even funny. For one, the word tranny is a disgustingly offensive word. Not to mention this just pushed the stereotype and belief that all transwomen are just men who dress up in female clothes and never pass. No, you DIDN'T nail it. If you want to make gingerbread t--nnies, you would have done regular gingerbread men and women.
Now, proceed to downvote me into oblivion.
Sorry you had to come to the forum and see this.
.<
Honestly, I still wonder why I expect anything GLB to be accepting of T anymore, especially on reddit.
Don't think that way. It's honestly the minority. Especially here.
I like this person.
[deleted]
No. I guess if I was making a stereotypical black person and going: I was asked to bake gingerbread "n-ggers" instead of gingerbread men....I think I nailed it. Would that be ok? No. No it wouldn't. Stereotypes and derogatory words are HURTFUL and OFFENSIVE no matter the context when spoken and used outside the marginalized group.
[deleted]
No. Not all crossdressers are like this either (me being one of them), a man in a dress/woman's clothing would probably be the least offensive way to put it.
No, because that would still be shitting on crossdressers.
Why is tranny offensive? To my understanding, it's just a shortened form of transexual transvestite. I mean, if it were used in a derogatory manner then sure, but that isn't the case here.
No, it's a shortened version of transvestite. Also chinky is a shortened version of Chinese. Try that in Chinatown and see how that goes down.
Sorry, edited the comment. But I'm pretty sure Chink is just a racial slur, akin to nigger. And like I said, used in a derogatory manner, any of these words (and most words) can be offensive. I was just trying to say that OP was not trying to belittle anyone and was getting unnecessary flak. Save the rants for those who are genuinely trying to demean LGBT folk.
I don't care whether you're trying to be derogatory or not, if that is what you are being. the word has all kinds of associations with bad things for us, just like nigger does for black people, or fag does for homosexuals. It isn't up to you to decide it's not offensive. Stop it.
By putting it in quotes and asking for people to not hate them they OBVIOUSLY know this was wrong and offensive. They are not getting unnecessary flak. You can demean a group from within the group and do it in an 'unintentional' way.
I'm not a car part. Trans- is the shortened form of trannsexual/transgender.
But he wasn't calling them car parts. Just because they are both shortened to the same word doesn't mean they are the same thing. I saw it as similar to the word homo. Yes, in certain contexts it can be very offensive, but it can also just be another term.
In certain contexts faggot can not be offensive, however that is to SOME PEOPLE. It doesn't change the fact that the word is a derogatory and offensive word used to demean and marginalize a group no matter the context.
Nigger was a shorted and slightly altered (added er) version of Negro, the then polite term for Black people, yet it is considered offensive.
It is considered not offensive in other contexts.
There is no 'other' context where it is not consdered on a whole, as offensive. some black people use it themselves, but then they are the only ones who can decide if it is not offensive to them, on a whole, they still deem it so.
Look, I'm trans*, I don't think this person deserved downvotes. They were just seeking the answer to a question.
EDIT: Nevermind, I read the rest of the thread.
What the...? Fuck you, OP.
Check your privilege before you are so grossly insensitive to one of the most oppressed groups in the world.
Someone PM'd me about this whole mess (something I very much appreciate) and it gave me the time and the ability to fully type out WHY tranny and other such slurs are so offensive, no matter the context, outside of the group of marginalized people. I'm going to post this and be done with this mess. I've argued this mess to the ground so many times.
There is a difference between the word being used inside the group and outside the group. I know a lot of people take issue with this but, it's the truth. I'm sure you've heard about reclaiming words before, correct? Reclaimation (making up words now) can only take place inside the marginalized group such as trans- people making fun of and using the word 'tranny', gay people making fun of and using the words 'dyke and faggot', black people using and making fun of the word 'nigger'. Why? Because when used among the group of people in this way, they are stripping the word of its power to separate and marginalize them as a group of people. Outside of the group, no matter the intent or context, the word is used to marginalize a group of people. It is a slur and offensive, even if used in a joke due to the history of the word used outside the group. Trans- people did not come up with the word tranny, just like black people did not come up with the word nigger, and gays with faggot and dyke. These were words created by privileged and outside groups to demean, insult, marginalize and dehumanize these select groups of people.
When a group of people are collectively reclaiming a word, they are taking the privilege away from the people who created the word to use it and making it their own word, flipping the meaning and the power of it to something personal and positive. A lot of people have a problem with the, this is our word and you can't use it, philosophy and I understand this. However, I've noticed a lot of people with this stance do not understand the significance of words, their origins, and their meanings outside of literal sense. People also tend to fight that they weren't around when the word was created to be derogatory means it is ok. It's not ok. If you are outside the group, you are continuing its use as a slur.
This doesn't mean that it cannot be a slur inside the group. Any word, used with malice or hate behind it whether inside or outside the group can become offensive once again. However, a trans- person calling another trans- person a tranny doesn't have the same power as someone outside the trans- group using it. Same with faggot. Why? Because the word is thus being used to describe the attacker (so to say) in the same negative light instead of entirely alienating and marginalizing an entire group of people.
[deleted]
When a privileged group takes a word and uses it as a slur or derogatory term, it becomes such. The origins do not matter once the word is taken from the group, so to say. A person of the marginalized group can use the word to describe themselves. Gay people can use faggot, dyke, etc. to describe themselves but if a privileged person outside of that group does it, it's not ok. I mentioned this in my above post though.
[deleted]
I'm kind of surprised at what I'm seeing. Like saying that trans people deal with issues they have no control over. Talking about that like it only applies to transsexuals is totally disregarding every other non-hetero sexuality
This is incredibly ironic to me, as there are hordes of LGB people who know nothing about trans people, disregard us, or even do blatantly offensive things like making these "tranny cookies", and don't even know or care that it would offend us. We're not the ones who are disregarding you, it's pretty clearly the other way around, and to pretend otherwise would be disingenuous.
Transsexuality is likely the most noticeable sexuality
It isn't a sexuality. You obviously know nothing about trans people.
This person's intentions were good, even if they don't know completely what they were talking about.
Oh, but you get what I mean. I guess I should've said transgendered unless that's wrong too. And saying "I obviously know nothing about trans people" is a rude thing to assume.
They didn't assume; you very clearly demonstrated how much you know.
yeah, so why the fuck is it grouped in with LGB? T is a whole other ball park
I see from your history that you are probably not subscribed to r/LGBT, but this topic comes up probably every other week there. Basically what it boils down to is this.
We face similar sorts of discrimination.
We have overlapping goals (i.e. marriage freedom)
We have overlapping membership (that is, there are LGB people who are also trans*)
There is also the slippery slope argument that could be made. After all, if trans people shouldn't be included, maybe polysexual people shouldn't be allowed either. And, you know, while we're at it, gay men and lesbians have rather different issues too, maybe they should be separate too. Down this path lies division and chaos.
That's an idiotic and facile argument. There are overlaps between every class of people on this planet, and the fact that you would even propose a slippery slope argument shows that you have not garnered even a nuanced approach to the issue. Sexuality and gender identity are just about as the same as they are to every other differentiating characteristic of people that we have.
This probably wouldn't be so bad if it didn't over exaggerate the stereotypes.
And maybe not trying using slurs as well? or is that too much to ask? It depresses me that it doesn't surprise me in the slightest to see this in a supposedly inclusive community for LGBT and straight alliance redditors."
[deleted]
The whole point of gay themed groups like r/gaymers is for people with these similar issues that they can't control to come together and just be amongst people like them.
ah, yes, homosexuality: an uncontrollable "issue"
I apologize for overreacting on my part. I only did so because I recieve enough criticism and harsh words from myself- when I see it from others it just upsets me even more.
Thanks. I kind of feel like an ass now, because I just added a huge edit to my previous comment which mentioned your saying "transsexuals deal with issues they can't control". I mean, we're all discriminated horribly and in the same ways, and saying it like it only applies to transsexuals disregards everyone else in the Homo Hate Boat.
Yeah, sorry. I didn't mean it like that. :)
I was only mentioning it like that because that's the same that applies to me and also what the OP is referring to at the moment. I'm not trying to disregard any other groups, I promise! I think it's just because I get all ranty about one subject once I talk about it for a bit. Sorry if I offended anyone, and I apologize for not mentioning other groups. :)
Your post has been [linked up in r/SRS, an unpleasant subreddit dedicated to scouring reddit for posts they would love to downvote](http://www.reddit.com/r/ShitRedditSays/comments/nncsb/transsexuality_is_likely_the_most_noticeable/) (but insist they do not). Not affiliated r/SRS, nor any groups or causes.
My friend demanded I bake gingerbread gay men so I put the OP in my oven
Well where's the gingerbread in THAT?
OP is a redhead?
Wow, Not much more I can say. ^^
These gingerbread would be hilarious if they weren't so offensive.
D'awww
Based on the post title, I assume that the OP is quoting the terminology their friend used when making the demand. The poster did make cookies on request of a friend, and is sharing that with us. I feel the word has been known as derogatory, but even NPH later apologized when he used it on TV. I think that shit happens, and we need to just educate those around us. I work in a place where some very derogatory words are spoken, but as I know those using them, I know they use them in completely non traditional ways. The group I work with actually go out of their way to not actually offend others, despite at times being jerks, assholes, and trolls to each other.
Edit for spelling
The word is a problem, but not that big of a problem in comparison to the picture posted.
That's fucking awesome dude
haha that looks pretty ridiculous. edit: I guess any downvotes I receive are from people who think the image is not ridiculous?? :P
Seriously, it's a cookie, everyone please calm the fuck down.
OP uses an offensive slur in the title and portrays a very negative stereotype of trans people in the image.
When you're in the group with a 1 in 12 murder rate, you'll understand.
A quick heads up, [you've been linked to by r/SRS](http://www.reddit.com/r/ShitRedditSays/comments/nncsb/transsexuality_is_likely_the_most_noticeable/), a group of redditors who search reddit for posts they deem offensive, and then direct hostile traffic to that post. Not affiliated r/SRS, nor any groups or causes.
I thought it was funny as hell. Definitely not the right audience though; no tact op :P next time toss that bizitch up in r/funny where it doesn't come across like an attack.
I feel like the biggest bastard in the universe.
You came across as privileged, naive, and a little bigoted maybe, but not a bastard. I, for one, would appreciate an apology in the text of the post, as this title and, in particular, that image, are massively triggering. However if you din't know or hadn't thought it through you can be forgiven.
Some of your defenders here, though, are just being vile. This is the stuff we have to deal with that you don't because any time you want to you can be totally stealth.
I can't edit the title, but I have used the deletion link for the image.
Can you not edit the text box? If not, then you've done all you can do. I thank you for showing understanding and contrition.
[deleted]
It was just a mistake, don't worry about it. I think I came off a tad too harsh, to be completely honest. I spent 3 hours last night trying to explain to a friend about how I felt about being trans and she basically ended up being nice about it but didn't really understand that by transitioning I was taking off a mask, not putting one on so to speak.
So yeah, bad day.
Please don't. You offended some people, but it was not on purpose.
Well, if it had been on purpose then he wouldn't feel bad about it, would he? He's made his apology and we accept, and he's been great about this whole thing.
So you agree with me?
It's a shame you were made to feel this way by some people. You were just sharing something you created that you thought was funny and it was obvious that you meant no offence from the start. You were using over-exaggeration to carry the humour of your creative piece. I agree, in the future don't put it in a subreddit where you can be singled out and attacked in such an aggressive manner over a cookie, r/funny would have loved this.
It would have been just as offensive in r/funny. In fact probably far worse, as it would have inspired even more transphobic comments. Although it wouldn't have seemed as much of a betrayal there.
I understand I upset people, I thought an apology would be enough to show that I didn't mean offense and to clear the air. Guess that's not enough though, some people are going through all of my old comments and downvoting them to oblivion. :s
Chill. You made a mistake, but honestly, I don't blame you, this community is usually a lot less butt-hurt than r/lgbt, but you definitely crossed the line by posting it in any lgbt forum :P Like I said, there are audiences that this is appropriate for, but this is not it.
I lol'd when I clicked it though ;)
Christ.
You realize if this had gotten posted in some non-lgbt forum it would be even worse? The image reinforces a negative stereotype about trans women as hideous monsters. But hey, maybe we should make a cookie of a child rapist with AIDS and call it a "Fagnutbutter cookie." You know, a good ol' fun representation of gay people? And you know what, I'm sure r/funny would get a kick out of it too.
God I fucking hate you privileged assholes.
"I fucking hate you privileged assholes" - Guess hate isn't limited to the transphobes. Well go fuck yourself you oversensitive butt-hurt bitch. It was a fucking joke, not an attack on trans people, grow some thicker skin this isn't r/lgbt, its r/gaymers, where people don't take everything is a goddamned personal attack.
Its not "privilege" btw so get off your high horse, we all have our own different issues and if you can't laugh at them every once in a while, you're a pathetic, oversensitive soul.
The wiener is odd. The stubble gave me a good chuckle tho, and the horridly short arms lol.
OP uses an offensive slur in the title and makes an image that reinforces a very negative stereotype about trans women.
But at least you don't see anything wrong with it.
(Tip: When you're in the group with a 1 in 12 murder rate, you'll understand.)
[deleted]
perfect lol
i think they're great. trans people need to have thicker skin when it comes to the 't' word.
No. No we don't. People need to be more caring, understanding and less marginalizing people. Guess black people should grow thicker skin towards being called n-ggers, mentally disabled people should grow thicker skin for being call r-tards, gay people should grow thicker skins for being called f-gs and d-kes. No. Doesn't work that way.
[deleted]
It's still commonly used as an offensive slur. It's like me using "faggot" casually in conversation with people I don't know. Just because I'm not using it offensively, doesn't mean it's not an offensive word.
For the record, the wording wasn't as offensive as what was contained in the picture.
Using it offensively or not doesn't change the meaning, origin, or how the word is used to marginalize the group. It IS the same as n-gger because it is a slur used to ostracize, demean, dehumanize, and marginalize a group of people. Same with f-ggot, ch-nk, d-ke, etc.
[deleted]
Actually, considering the rate at which trans people are discriminated against and even assaulted and murdered, and the vitrol with which the word is used by the people who commit those atrocities, it's probably the slur with the most nastiness after the n-word.
And the n-word has had more successful re-appropriation, so you can more reliably find contexts in which it isn't considered an offensive term.
you're right gay people should grow thicker skin. The human race as a whole should all grow thicker skin and then we'll have to deal with a lot less whining because somebody said something that hurt your feelings. gaaaaaaaaaaaawwwwwwwwwwwwddddddddddd
I'm very sorry that so much offense was taken by this. I really did not intend for that to happen. Upon reflection, and after reading through the outraged comments here, I feel a little ashamed that I didn't consider how this would affect some users.
In honesty, I should have known better. I have a few close Trans. friends, and have been involved in fundraising for, and supporting people who are facing the challenges of transition. So to think that I completely disregarded my knowledge of the issues the Trans. community face only adds to my sense of sorrow.
Thankyou! I really do love it when people are big enough to apologise, and I dont know, nor can speak about others, but really shows the difference between some people that they can be big enough to.
[deleted]
Apology accepted. I'm glad you owned up to your mistakes. Hopefully this is a learning for you and hopefully for others. Own up and learn from your mistakes, makes the world (and this subreddit) a better place.
I'm not sure why anyone would downvote this?
Because it was linked to on /r/SRS, since then pretty much every comment I've posted has had mysterious new downvotes. That's not so bad though compared to messages like this.
Actually, those of us from SRS are upvoting your apology...
I am sorry, I even came here from TransphobiaProject, and that is rediculous, made a mistake, apologised, why continue it?
A lot of people make mistakes, not everyone learns from them. Thank you for the apology :)
Big mistake. From what I've seen, when you apologize to transgender activists they start demanding money from you. I'm surprised they haven't suggested that you donate to their causes yet to show how sorry you are.
And some of them are actually accepting your apology. It seems r/transphobiaproject has grown up a bit.
You make it sound like there's something wrong about apologizing. Yup yup, he should be a big man like you and just tell us to fuck off. Yup yup.
I have a shit-ton more respect for him than I do for you.
In the case of transgendered people, though, it validates their oppression complex, and actually does them more harm than good.
This coming from a cisgender person. Classic. Let's hear more of your armchair psychology, it's adorable.
Your post has been [linked up in r/SRS, an unpleasant subreddit dedicated to scouring reddit for posts they would love to downvote](http://www.reddit.com/r/ShitRedditSays/comments/nncsb/transsexuality_is_likely_the_most_noticeable/c3ag2c5) (but insist they do not). Not affiliated r/SRS, nor any groups or causes.
Is this one the real bot, or the guy with no life outside of reddit who posts these by hand?
Because, if it's the latter, goddamn, you're stupid. Wigglebury linked their own comment.
It's a bot. Although, most of the bots have real people behind them who also comment.
I think this is the one that claims to be the latter, but is demonstrably the former.
Thank you, 'SRSsucks', but I'm pretty sure he's already aware of that, considering he's the one who posted it there.