Looking for general advice on 2 new windows laptops for 2 different people.
Hi everyone, I am looking for recommendations on 2 laptops. 1 is for someone else the 2nd is for me personally. fairly similar needs but mine are a bit more specific and might require a bit more specs. Person 1 is looking to get their machine asap, person 2 can wait a bit for whatever reason.
#First person:
LAPTOP QUESTIONNAIRE
Total budget (in local currency) and country of purchase. Please do not use USD unless purchasing in the US:
$800 USA
Are you open to refurbs/used?
No
How would you prioritize form factor (ultrabook, 2-in-1, etc.), build quality, performance, and battery life?
Build quality isn't that important but definitely need something that isn't going to break super fast, this person does not upgrade technology when they do not absolutely have to. Performance is relatively important but tbh anything modern on an SSD is going to be so much better than their current situation it won't matter too too much. Form factor is relatively important. Won't be used much on the go but will be used without too much in the way of extra space, and the person isn't looking to cart around a lot of weight if they have to. Would be in the regular laptop/ultrabook area. Battery life is similar to form factor. Needs to be at least decent but won't be tested too often.
How important is weight and thinness to you?
Its all relative. its very important that it not be extremely heavy or large but the extremes of thinness and weightlessness are not necessary.
Do you have a preferred screen size? If indifferent, put N/A.
15 would be prefered. Makes it big enough for the person to see what they need without being too big overall. Could probably do a 13 if everything else was perfect tho, this will be used with an hdmi monitor mirroring the desktop pretty frequently.
Are you doing any CAD/video editing/photo editing/gaming? List which programs/games you desire to run.
very light audio editing would be the highest load activity happening here. Adobe Audition with Waves audio plugins would be the main softwares.
If you're gaming, do you have certain games you want to play? At what settings and FPS do you want?
no gaming
Any specific requirements such as good keyboard, reliable build quality, touch-screen, finger-print reader, optical drive or good input devices (keyboard/touchpad)?
optical drive would be a very big plus. a build quality/keyboard that will feel good but doesn't have to be regularly tested on that quality so it doesn't have to be to the 9s. definitely don't need any touch stuff. Will be using USB audio deceives and other USB peripherals so having traditional USB type A ports would be better than type Cs.
Leave any finishing thoughts here that you may feel are necessary and beneficial to the discussion.
This is a computer that will be used for the internet (streaming, social media, blogs, occasional remote work), ripping CDs to iTunes, and using adobe to rip and restore old vinyl and cassettes and stuff to MP3s. Very simple stuff. I know 800 is probably pretty high for the budget but I also want to get something I can be relatively confident will for these circumstances. Also if something goes wrong with it, needs to be a company with a smooth and effective RMA/support department. This person is not very good with the ins and outs of tech of this sort.
#Second person:
LAPTOP QUESTIONNAIRE
Total budget (in local currency) and country of purchase. Please do not use USD unless purchasing in the US:
$800 high end but would prefer to get closer to 600 if in any way possible.
Are you open to refurbs/used?
Yeah if there are guarantees. Would most likely be replacing the harddrives anyway (have an m.2 already for OS, would grab an extra 2.5 SSD too.) so as long as I had confidence in support for most of the life of the main shit I'd be down for a good refurb.
How would you prioritize form factor (ultrabook, 2-in-1, etc.), build quality, performance, and battery life?
Don't care at all about form factor. I guess not having a giant 20 pound laptop would be nice but also I've done it before and can do it again. Build quality is a big priority. My current laptop I'm looking to replace is an Asus tuf fx504 which is only a few years old and has already been RMA'd 3 times, is out of warrany, and is coming apart at the seams. Tuf my ass, the screen is falling apart, every time you open the case something plastic cracks, just not my kind of machine. My previous one was also asus, ROG, last me like 9 years with only needing 1 harddrive replacement. So not fully against asus even just need that kind of reliability vs spending 800 bucks to be dying in 3 years. Performance is a must, this will be used for audio recording and production, potentially in live settings. It is also used for moderate gaming (have a desktop that does most of the heavy lifting, but would like to be able to play some stuff like indie games and shit on the go if possible. Battery life would be a plus but isn't make or break. My preference would be longevity of the battery so I could have consistent battery life over years that I just prepare for, but I know that that probably isn't realistic.
How important is weight and thinness to you?
Don't care even a little. TBH too thin would scare me that I'd break it. So I guess something that isn't too too easy to like bend in half or something.
Do you have a preferred screen size? If indifferent, put N/A.
15 or 17.
Are you doing any CAD/video editing/photo editing/gaming? List which programs/games you desire to run.
Like I said above, indie/lighter gaming and lots of audio. Ableton Live, Adobe Audition/photoshop/occasionally premiere, shit off Steam
If you're gaming, do you have certain games you want to play? At what settings and FPS do you want?
Rocket League, Risk of Rain, Ori and the blind forest, indie stuff where if I was playing with my partner I could put it on the big screen in my living room without much issue, or if I wanted to game a bit on a train trip for example. Nothing big and wild in 1440 60fps or anything, thats all on my desktop. Would ideally be able to achieve some form of 60fps/1060p on the kinds of indie games listed tho even if its lowered settings.
Any specific requirements such as good keyboard, reliable build quality, touch-screen, finger-print reader, optical drive or good input devices (keyboard/touchpad)?
I'm VERY partial to a keyboard with the number pad. just works better for me. I am also very partial to optical drives but this is not make or break as I have an optical drive elsewhere. Please god no touch screen, and I don't care about finger prints. Will use an external mouse most of the time but would probably want a touchpad with a good build to it, both the touchpads on my last 2 asus machines have left something to be desired.
Leave any finishing thoughts here that you may feel are necessary and beneficial to the discussion.
This is a box for doing things on the go/in my living room. All the massive load stuff like mixing albums and playing games in 4k I have a desktop for that I love. This is going to be doing the kind of cursory work like starting a tune or messing with a sample while out and about, doing a bit of remote work, or taking some of my gaming into a more social part of my home. I don't like buying new stuff all the time, thats what I have the desktop for. With a laptop, I want something thats gonna hit these points and last (with upkeep and expected things like harddrive replacement) for quite some time.
Looking forward to the recommendations, thanks in advance yall.
Posted May 29, 2021, 7:25 PM UTC
Hi, unfortunately, optical drives are obsolete, so you will definitely need an external one. So, for the first device, I would recommend the Acer Aspire 5. It has a 4-core i5-1135G7 processor, 8 GB RAM, a 256 GB SSD, and a 1080p 15.6" display, which is fine for general use tasks. It is about 4.19lbs, which I'd consider to be portable.
As for the second device, I would go for the Lenovo IdeaPad 3 Gaming Laptop. It comes with a 6-core Ryzen 5 4600H processor, 8 GB RAM, a 256 GB SSD, GTX 1650 graphics, and a 1080p 15.6" 120Hz display. This combination should handle modern games at 1080p medium-high settings easily.
This external optical drive from Dell will work.