Girl scouts leaders resign after a chapter said it will let a transgender child join
nydailynews.com/news/national/girl-scouts-tro...Posted Dec 23, 2011, 4:27 PM UTC
Posted Dec 23, 2011, 4:27 PM UTC
So wait, 3 leaders in Louisiana resigned after the Colorado chapter said Miss Montoya could join? Seriously. They resigned because a girl 1000 miles away who could never "confuse" their precious little children wanted to feel a part of something? Kudos to the Colorado chapter for allowing her in. Boo on the crazy Louisiana ladies.
The story on the Christian Post is even more disgusting.
Jeff Johnston, a social issues analyst specializing in homosexuality and sexuality at Focus on the Family, told Baptist Press that the Girl Scouts' practice of admitting transgendered children has implications for other girls in the troop. It can lead to gender confusion, and already some parents have contacted Focus with concerns over Girl Scout camping trips with boys pretending to be girls.
Oh good, I'm so glad they brought in an expert.
Jeff Johnston, a social issues analyst specializing in homosexuality and sexuality at Focus on the Family
Translation: Self hating, homophobic, closet case.
... camping trips with boys pretending to be girls.
Proof that this man has absolutely no credentials to assess this situation. Trans != boys pretending to be girls. Even most ex-gay BS "therapy" programs will admit to that. It seems like he said that just to be a dick.
"...at Focus on the Family.."
Oh yea, that's totally legit.
gender confusion
I bet those kids aren't going to be nearly as confused as this supposed "expert." I'd think small children can handle this sort of thing just fine.
I only skimmed this before so I thought it was the leaders of the troop she joined who resigned because of not wanting to lead a troop with a trans girl in it. This is even more stupid then I thought.
Leaders resign in protest of Girl Scouts of Colorado's decision to admit boy
...
a 7-year-old boy who identifies as a girl
...
her son, Bobby Montoya, who identifies as a girl
...
Boy wants to be a girl scout
...
views himself as a girl
I think perhaps this is not the preferred nomenclature.
This really bugged me, too :|
Now this is something that actually gets me a little confused and embarrassed whenever I talk to transgendered people. It takes effort getting used to not referring to them by their biological gender, and I feel bad when I accidentally do so.
But in an article like this, do you think people could be confused if they wrote "girl" and "daughter" instead of "boy" and "son"? Meh, probably not.
The point I'm trying to make is that they may be in the same boat as me, and mean absolutely no offense by it. Perhaps the better approach would be to change the title: "Leaders resign in protest of Girl Scouts of Colorado's decision to admit boy who identifies as girl"? Then for the rest of the article, refer to her as a female? What would be the most politically correct?
Here is what I would have liked to see:
Leaders resign in protest of Girl Scouts of Colorado's decision to admit transgender child
...
a 7-year-old who was born a boy but now identifies as a girl
...
her [transgender] daughter, Bobby Montoya
...
Transgender child wants to be a girl scout
...
views herself as a girl
As a former Girl Scout, this disgusts me. We had to recite the Girl Scout Law every meeting; did they just fucking forget it?
I will do my best to be:
Honest and fair,
Friendly and helpful,
Considerate and caring,
Courageous and strong,
Responsible for what I say and do,
And to respect myself and others,
Respect authority,
Use resources wisely,
Make the world a better place, and
Be a sister to every Girl Scout.
Shame on them for deciding what makes any little kid "worthy" of being a Girl Scout. FUCK THAT NOISE.
Isn't the official Girl Scout organization the one saying she can join though?
It's just the bigoted leaders of certain troops that are being bigoted, as far as I can tell. And they're quitting.
I was talking to the leaders, not the organization.
GSUSA is actually quite progressive. Nothing but love for them.
Yeah, I'm surprised at how much better the Girl Scouts seem to be than the Boy Scouts.
I wish I could have been a girl scout.
There's always the opportunity to be a leader or a volunteer at a camp! GSUSA really loves volunteers. They especially love showering them with awards and pins and things.
Also, early access to Girl Scout cookies.
I'm surprised at how much better the Girl Scouts seem to be than the Boy Scouts.
Really? In the US at least, girls seem to be given much more leeway for "gender & sexuality issues" than boys.
I will do my best to be:
Honest and fair,
Friendly and helpful,
Considerate and caring,
Courageous and strong,
Responsible for what I say and do,
And to respect myself and others,
Respect authority,
Use resources wisely,
Make the world a better place, and
ban all dem tranniez cuz god
FTFY Girl Scout bigots.
These people are making a problem where there just isn't one. Boys can be registered girl scouts (my little brother even came camping when my mom/leader didn't have anyone to leave him with), what could possibly be the objection to a transgendered child being a scout?
It's all very well when they are 7 years old, but when they are 13, most parents would want to keep the boys and girls in different tents at night, and it's not reassuring enough to parents to say boys are allowed in the same tents as girls as long as they call themselves girls
Which is immediately one of the biggest problems surrounding transgenders: people still think they're the gender they were born as. You'll never see one of these parents or leaders admitting she's actually a girl and not just a boy in dress-up.
I was talking about the children's biological sex, not their socially accepted gender, and you can't deny that you are advocating putting 13 year old biological males in the same tent as 13 year old biological females, and it would be naive to insist that there is no chance of them ever playing around with each other's bodies, and that's why parents are concerned
you can't deny that you are advocating putting 13 year old biological males in the same tent as 13 year old biological females, and it would be naive to insist that there is no chance of them ever playing around with each other's bodies
If you put biological girls in a tent with biological girls there is a chance they will "play around with each other bodies".
I'm not denying anything? I'm confirming that most parents are closed minded bastards, and that they think all transgendered people are still the gender they were born with, which I think is absolutely stupid.
Also, I've had sleepovers with girls, I've never 'played around' with their bodies mind you.
edit: I'm a guy btw
Put two adolescents of any genders and biological sexes together in the same tent, and there's a chance they'll play doctor.
That's why camping trips are supervised. And if some kids get makey-outey in the tents late at night - well, that's adolescence for you. It isn't the end of the world.
"This goes against what we believe,” she said"
Fuck people that think like this, seriously. I understand that you have certain beliefs, and I appreciate that not everything may seem familiar to you, but sometimes you've gotta look behind what you've been told is true and open your mind a little. This girl just wants to have a great time with other girls and I don't give a flying fuck what you believe, no one has the right to stand in the way of that.
Edit: spelling mistakes that are too stupid for words
Do you think boys who identify as girls should be allowed to join the Girl Scouts?
Yes 38% No 52% I'm not sure 9%
Wow, what the fuck is wrong with people nowadays, I'm going to have to wait to be an old man to see an America that's not an asshole.
The article doesn't help either, especially by using male pronouns where they clearly should be using female ones. :\
[deleted]
I voted yes because there wasn't a "This question is poorly worded"
I wonder if responses would have been significantly different, if they'd phrased the survey as "Do you think girls who were born trans should be allowed to join the Girl Scouts?"
These people just keep shutting themselves off from society more and more.
Sooner or later, they'll be seething with rage at the very idea of DEM GAYZ but nobody will be able to tell because they'll be boycotting literally everything outside their house.
Yay Colorado, Yay girl scouts, boo, ignorant Christians from Louisiana.
Good riddance. Don't let the door hit you on the way out. I LIKE the resolution to this story, the wackos are slowly taking themselves out of society for us, to be replaced by real caring people. For all I care, these closed-minded bigots can shut themselves in their houses and try to ignore the real world as much as they want... I'll just be glad they are not out there poisoning the minds of more children with their hate.
BTW: When I was a boyscout, we had a few girls who thought they were going to cause trouble by insisting that they be able to join (not transgendered, just looking for controversy). The situation was pretty much defused when the scout leaders said 'Cool, here is when our meetings are. Can't wait to see you'.
They came to a few meetings before getting bored. I think they were more into the 'fighting for their rights' than actually wanting to be in the boy scouts. Maybe if we'd made them fight harder for it, they would have had more fun. :)
I think 'Boy scouts' and 'Girl scouts' are outdated anyway. I'd rather just have some kind of outing/adventure club that welcomes all genders of curious kids who want to learn and explore their environment.
[deleted]
opted to enforce its policy of inclusion for transgendered children
Good for them!
Read the comments on the story. Disgusting...
This is really surprising to me. Traditionally, the girl scouts are pretty progressive.
Well, that's why these folks resigned instead of the national organization stepping in to crush the transgender child's dreams like the Boy Scouts do.
I feel bad for the girls in the troops that got disbanded because of their shitty leaders. Sends a way wrong message.
That being said, i live down here in the south and am not surprised by this behavior at all. I hate it down here.
Cool. Non-bigoted people will take their places now.
I wish a bigot resigned every time someone makes a reasonable and compassionate decision.