5600x ram question

Help Request - RAM

I’ll be honest, RAM is my overclocking blind spot. I didn’t start messing with it until recently and only got into that to push my benches and frames further. As I understand it, which is vaguely, AMD prefers 4 sticks even though 5600x can only handle dual channel. So all things equal, 4 sticks of dual channel run better than 2 sticks of dual Chanel due to memory configuration?

But how much uplift are we talking? My prior build was intel and RAM seemed much more straight forward but, again, I didn’t mess with it much.

I had 4 sticks of 8 gb 3600 cl18 Hynix cjr but a stick pooped the bed so I’m running two sticks now.

I want faster ram since my frequency is limited. I’m eyeballing the cl14 3600 kit but my wife would probably stab me if I got 4 of those. Is 2 cl14 better than 4 sticks of cl16 3600 with tight timings? Size doesn’t matter(here) right?

My Hynix OC was very meh (3733)so I’m looking at bdie or close. For my combo in timespy I’m 4th out of 50k results. The three in front of me run cooler but I can catch one or two with faster ram me thinks.

Specs: 5600x w/ 240 ek AIO Evga 3080 FTW3 Ultra Hybrid in push/pull Msi x570 Tomahawk Evga 1000 g+ 16gb 3600 cl16 trident Z Neo Lan cool 2

Thanks!

Posted May 31, 2021, 8:30 PM UTC

38
NotTheLipsA few AMD and Intel rigs, with AMD and NVidia GPUs.•

AMD prefers 4 sticks

In general, two sticks, which is easier on the IMC, especially on boards with daisy-chained RAM topology. Two sticks is easier to run at higher clocks than four in this scenario. Dual rank does improve memory performance a bit, but this can be negated by the need to run lower RAM clocks and looser timings for stability with four sticks.

Whatever you get, make sure it's on the board's QVL. Ideally, go for the highest speed, lowest latency, kit that fits within budget.

In truth, the very best scenario (high speed low latency) vs a decent result (high speed with looser timings, or slightly lower speed with tighter timings) will not provide a massive difference overall.

In games that are memory bandwidth and/or latency sensitive, the difference would be a few percent improvement.

Productivity is a bit more nuanced. Some apps are latency sensitive, others are bandwidth sensitive, some benefit from both, and some see no improvement whatsoever. It's case-by-case here, so benchmarking for your particular use-case is important to help determine which RAM config would benefit you most.

2
UrWrongAllTheTimeOP•

Nice! Thank you sir or madam.

1

I'm not sure how popular this set it, but I've found good results using the PVS416G440C9K set. Its bdie and is rated for higher than you would run it plus it's not as expensive as most bdie sets. The only issue was that my mb only had 2 xmp profiles for it (4200-4400) so to run at 1:1 in had to hunt for workable timings.

Coming from Intel you may not know this, but to get the most out of your RAM/cpu you'll want to set your FLCK (infinity fabric - internal memory controller) to a 1:1 with your DRAM speed. As in RAM at 3600 so FCLK to 1800. Zen 3 will not* go past 2000 FCLK (or 4000 DRAM) at a 1:1. Disrupting this ratio will be a severe performance hindrance.

*Exceptions exist

2
UrWrongAllTheTimeOP•

Nice! Yeah I’ve been putting my Fclk in 1:1 thanks to earlier videos. Highest I got with this kit is 3733. Is speed better than latency?

2

That's something you'll have to test with benchmarks, but as the earlier poster said, the payoff can almost be negligible at high speeds. (Depending on how tight you go).

I've just recently gotten into RAM OC'ing myself, but I figured I'd share what I knew.

FYI the Patriot Viper Steel series is not on my QLV list (ch7) but it still works.*

*This is not to suggest that you should use kits no on the list, I just forgot to check the list before buying 🤦

1
UrWrongAllTheTimeOP•

Haha yeah I’ll have to check it out. I actually have that kit I bought for my intel rig that I gave to kit kid for Xmas. I’ll have to pop it in and see.

2
Norenghttps://hwbot.org/user/arni90/•

My prior build was intel and RAM seemed much more straight forward but, again, I didn’t mess with it much.

It's not, Intel has a lot more options for memory tweaking and overclocking than AMD. Intel processors also see a larger gain from memory overclocking in general

1
UrWrongAllTheTimeOP•

Ah ok. I never went to in depth on my intel board. I just through in my 4400 viper ram, set xmp, and away she went. If I nail this down I’ll have to crack that rig open and tune it.

2