r/dndnext•
RecarmToo

DM Here. Player told me he doesn't like that I don't fudge rolls

After tonight's game, a player in our group told me he didn't like my dming style because I didn't fudge rolls to make combat easier. We're playing Icewind Dale: Rotfm and I told them in session 0 that the game would be very difficult with a high risk of character death. They all agreed that this was okay. I even made a point at session zero that I don't fudge rolls and didn't want to. I even told them someone could most likely die early on. No one has yet as of session four tonight. Which I am actually surprised by.

If I feel one of the prewritten encounters is unbalanced, I alter it beforehand. I almost ended up killing one of the other PCs (a different player that isnt him) tonight and that's what got him to say something afterwards. He said I used "too much logic" or something to that effect.

Here's what happened:

(This was a homebrew encounter btw)

There was a downed player (they got crit badly) who had their maximum hp reduced a lot by a few vampire kobolds (who drain max hp) and was knocked down with the massive damage rule likely to take effect because they had been reduced so much. They also just got really unlucky with positioning and falling prone at the worst time.

There was a gnoll with a bow far away taking pot shots and all the other players were behind full cover except for the downed PC. So the gnoll being chaotic evil and not being able to advance far enough to be in line of sight of anyone else, takes a shot at the downed PC. It missed and the party was able to finish off everything else and protect the downed PC. It was a great moment of the party coming together to protect their teammate.

I asked him if the difficulty was something that would make him leave the group and he said he didn't know. He just gave me a vague answer.

Now I feel I have to either:

A.) Nerf the encounters more and kill the tension of the game.

B.) Fudge dice rolls (which I am not going to do)

I don't want him to leave the game as he is a great addition in some respects. I just feel as if he wants an easy power fantasy.

I'm honestly just baffled that he straight up said he didn't like my dming style because I didn't fudge rolls. NO ONE HAS EVEN DIED YET.

What does everyone else think about this?

Side Note: I think fudging roles is perfectly valid and okay. I just don't want to run that kind of game.

Additional Note: Other players in the group have said they liked the difficulty of the game so far so I don't know what to think.

Posted Jun 3, 2021, 3:42 AM UTC · edited

2.1K551
Loading comments…