Roth IRA vs Traditional IRA vs Paying loans

Student Loan Management

I am about to start residency and I have 127k in debt. A roth IRA is better to start saving because I will be in a lower tax bracket now then when I take out money from it in the future right? Then when I become an attending I will just do a backdoor Roth? Further, I am not paying any loans off until the interest rate for students changes from 0 at which point I will refinance them with a SoFi or whatever. What percent of income should go to paying student loans vs Roth IRA? Should I do Roth IRA or traditional? ( I may have misunderstood the difference) Thanks!!

Posted Jun 3, 2021, 5:12 PM UTC

1825

If I could go back in time, this is what I would do:

  1. Keep a 3-month emergency fund: 5k-ish

  2. Increase 403b contribution to whatever the match is at work.

  3. Max out Roth IRA.

  4. Use the rest of savings on extra loan payments.

27
impossiblegirl13•

This is what I did!

And I stayed on REPAYE for my whole residency. Refinancing after.

9
ASAPdocOP•

Why repaye and not refinance? The interest rate is way lower refinancing.

2
impossiblegirl13•

Because my payments were way lower on REPAYE, and we are saving up for a down payment for a house. Now that we have the down payment, we are going to aggressively pay towards my loans- our spreadsheets say payoff within 3 years.

5

Also interest subsidy on REPAYE make your effective interest rate quite a bit lower than what is listed.

That being said, if you intend on paying more than the minimum payments you may not get the subsidy. This appears to depend on the servicer.

4
innocentius112•

So while on REPAYE when you made extra loan payments were you able to pay towards the principal as well or just the accruing interest? I’ve heard conflicting things about this. I’m going to apply for REPAYE this summer/fall and am wondering what my payments will look like. Planning to do $500/month to a Roth IRA as well.

1
impossiblegirl13•

It’s my understanding that you always pay interest before principal. So yes, extra payments go towards accrued/accruing interest, and then principal. Someone correct me if I’m wrong!

2

This may prevent you from getting the interest subsidy tho... Hoping someone more knowledgeable can chime in regarding how to approach this.

1
WCInvestor•

You should be making Roth IRA contributions rather than traditional during residency. Take a look at this to help prioritise your finances.

Financial Waterfalls

And this one will help with the student loan questions:

Guide to Student Loan Management for Doctors

6

If your hospital does not offer a 401k/403b match then does Roth IRA become the priority account to contribute to? This would be after developing a 3-6 month emergency fund and paying down high interest debt.

2
WCInvestor•

Yes, especially if you don't have access to an HSA. Residency is a great time to max those Roth IRA contributions, and especially so if you don't have access to any other retirement accounts.

3
ASAPdocOP•

THANK YOU

1
ASAPdocOP•

Is PSLF worth it if my residency hospital allows me to be eligible? I only have 130k in loans.

1
WCInvestor•

That kind of depends. That's not a high loan balance, relatively. How long is your residency? Will you also do a fellowship? Do you have any interest in working in academic medicine or other PSLF eligible job when you are finished training? Many PSLF-eligible jobs pay less well than a private sector job, and so it's relatively easier to take a private job and just throw a bunch of money at the loans while living like a resident to pay them off in a year or two. When you get in a situation where you have a very long training period or a very high debt to income ratio in your chosen specialty, PSLF makes a lot more sense.

Should I Go for PSLF?

2
ASAPdocOP•

My residency is 5 years (radiology) with one year of Fellowship. My residency program is under PSLF so I would be halfway there. I really want to do private practice, is it worth working somewhere for 5 years to complete PSLF?

1
Mrrgrotm•

Seems like you already have your answer. After year 6, with your radiology salary, you can knock out your remaining loans in a year or two if you buckle down and "live like a resident."

1
jmrthekid•

I’m not as up to date as money on the current student loan pathways as many are. If you can enroll in REPAYE then half of your student loan interest is subsidized and you can still get govt protections (like the 0% interest rate) and quality for PSLF. So don’t think refinancing right away is necessarily the best move. However interest rates may rise and it might be reasonable to lock in a low rate now. You don’t have a lot of debt so whatever you do will be fine. I maxed out my Roth in residency and am still doing Roth contributions now before I make partner as I’m not in my peak earnings years. If you have a match through your work (I didn’t) then you should contribute to get the match. Beyond that it doesn’t matter. Get an emergency fund of a few months savings and then do whatever you want. Develop good saving habits but don’t lose your mind trying to penny pinch in residency when your salary is going to likely go up 4x+ after. It’s a lot easier to save when you make more.

4
PouffyMoth•

Half of the monthly interest that is above your monthly income driven payment. So it isn’t half overall

5
ASAPdocOP•

My resident program does not qualify for PSLF.

1
lesubreddit•

So long as my effective interest rate on my federal loans is 3-4% after the REPAYE subsidy, I don't really feel much pressure to refinance and/or pay the loans down. You can reliably get better returns through investing in retirement accounts. Max out employee match -> max out personal and spousal Roth IRA -> anything else in Roth 403b. You'd be hard pressed to save more than that as a resident.

Once REPAYE no longer is subsidizing your loan interest below 4-5%, think about refinancing. I think the protections and possibility for forgiveness that you have with the federal loans is worth quite a but, but probably not 3% extra interest per year.

I wouldn't think about traditional retirement contributions at all as a resident. If I had somehow maxed out all of my Roth space, I would try to do the mega backdoor Roth IRA before going traditional.

3

So long as my effective interest rate on my federal loans is 3-4% after the REPAYE subsidy, I don't really feel much pressure to refinance and/or pay the loans down.

I have come to this conclusion as well. I would like to pay off some loans during residency but I am worried about losing the subsidy if I do this. I am wondering if anyone here has a strategy for this?

1
lesubreddit•

As far as I can tell, the only real strategy is to not pay down your loans during residency so long as you have that nice 3-4% effective subsidized interest rate going. There's a psychological benefit to paying loans down but come retirement time, you'll be in a stronger position if you just put your savings during residency 100% into investments and only make minimum payments on loans.

1
boostedbelle•

If when you put your loans into repaye and if you don’t consolidate you can pay of individual loans in larger chunks. That’s my plan during residency. Still working on maxing Roth, but we are maxing our match so it’s a balance. Moving and interview expenses prior to remote interviews was more than I had budgeted for so dealing with some of my own poor planning still.

1
yangerang55•

There is a risk that waiting to refinance until the 0% rate is over will result in a higher refinance interest rate at that time than if you do it now. This is simply due to supply and demand where supply is plentiful now as many banks want to lend and not many people want to refinance while the opposite will be true soon. It's just conjecture either way but something to consider.

2
ASAPdocOP•

Interesting point, I will need to do so math to see if those extra 2 months of 0% interest is worth a little bump in my interest rate.

1
jjllhh92•

I do 10% Roth, 5% pre tax 401 and any money I have leftover I pay towards my loans. I also pay each weekly check so I know how much I have to spend on other things. Refinance if you can to a lower rate. Pay as much as you can without forfeiting your future. A few years in and I’m really happy I did not neglect my retirement accounts

1