'A dream come true': Montreal student wins big at national science fair | CBC News
cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/montreal-student-...Posted Jun 5, 2021, 10:43 PM UTC
Posted Jun 5, 2021, 10:43 PM UTC
Congrats on the win. Fruits Flies and antioxidants is pretty vague subject for a national honor in 2021. I grew up in Florida, US and in the state science fair the winner in 1998 State science fair was creating an algorithm to detect breast cancer in mammogram photos. I know science fairs aren't as prestigious in the US as they used to be, is it the same in the Canada? Or is there a better article on her project?
[deleted]
Cool. I wasn't really trying to put her down, I was just thinking it was too simplistic and that I assume it was more interesting. Are you saying she did a multiyear project with fruit flies that had never gone as long? Like it was further reinforcing previous understanding, which I personally agree is worth studying.
[deleted]
So no one had studied antioxidants and fruit flies before? I just googled it and got 3 hits on 'similar' type experiments (Fruit flies & stimulus & Riboflavin type stuff). Were these longer experiments or just different stimuli.
I guess my point is that I would like to understand better why the judges chose this project. If her technique and volume of data collection warranted winning (which it certainly could be based on how extensive her study was) then that would be interesting.
An algorithm to detect breast cancer in mammograms is more impressive than a fruit fly incubator? Maybe in 1998 but now I promise I can find a bunch of random college kid in CS that can code that in a few days
It is definitely a dated thing, but in 1998 it was pretty impressive for a high school student to learn 2D filtering techniques to the point where it correctly predicted ~90% of cases when compared to doctors.
In the 90s fruit fly incubator experiments were pretty much a standard for 'The effect of X on Drosophila melanogaster'. My brother did one on multigenerational effects of UV light on fruit flies. It was really cool seeing actual mutation and evolution.
I guess my point is that I am just trying to understand what made this project stand out. Was it technique, was it just sheer volume of data, was their a novel discovery?
[deleted]
Damn how rich do you have to be for your parents to even allow such a thing? I mean cool on the science I guess but geez.
As much as my parents encouraged my intellectual curiosity at that age, ruining the only bathroom in our modest suburban bungalow would easily have been a non-starter when I was growing up.
Still, maybe her folks see the big picture, and figure her inevitable scholarships will offset the cost of the renovations?