Anyone else miss Mark?

I know he's probably not coming back, but I don't understand why so many people thought he was dead weight and forgettable. I didn't like the Leslie-Mark-love-interest angle in S1 but I thought they really got past that in S2 and Mark became more than just a Lothario. His relationship with the other supporting cast members was great, he was sensible and he had a cool sense of humor.

Posted Dec 29, 2011, 2:39 PM UTC

2533
tehRoyal•

He was the piece in the puzzle that really gave weight to the "PandR is just another Office clone" argument- his character is essentially Jim.

That's not to say there's anything wrong with Jim-like characters, it's just Mark needed to go for PandR to become a show of its own. Leslie had begun to break away from a very "Michael Scott" feeling at the beginning of S2, but Mark didn't have much wiggle room in terms of where they could take his character... so they let him go. Good decision, IMO.

29
Dave6480•

I completely disagree.

Mark was not Jim just because he was a straight man.

Anne is far from Pam.

Leslie is FAR from Michael Scott.

Ron is FAR from Dwight.

It makes sense that, because Greg Daniels and Michal Schur were involved, and it was the documentary style, that those comparisons were coming, but the similarities end there.

Mark was not a lovelorn prankster who is constantly frustrated by an annoying co-worker and a ridiculous boss.

Just because he was handsome and not as over the top as the rest of the cast, it doesn't mean that he was anything like Jim.

That is a really unfair opinion and it seems kinda lazy

2
[deleted]•

Okay, but tehRoyal wasn't making those other comparisons; just Mark to Jim. Watch Season One and you can't deny a Michael Scott feeling with Leslie Knope. The writers also went for an more-awkward-equals-more-funny approach, similar to that of the Office. Just watch the one where Leslie gets her hair done for that event. I can't really see Season Four Leslie Knope doing that.

Yes, the show is brilliant, but it took a while to hit its stride. When I recommend it to anyone, I usually tell them to start at Season Two.

As for Mark, he was a nice guy, and a key part of some very funny episodes, but bringing him back wouldn't add anything to the show.

6
Dave6480•

My point is that all of those comparisons were based more on the laziness of the viewers in immediately looking for those comparisons than those comparisons actually making sense.

Leslie's haircut was based completely on her ambition and ambition is not something that she has in common with Michael Scott.

Awkward = Funny is more David Brent making a joke and nobody laughing than Leslie Knope getting a silly haircut.

I could totally see season 4 Leslie Knope doing that. If she felt as if going to see Salvatore would help her campaign for city council.

I agree that they did not hit their stride until season 2, but it isn't because they were too similar "The Office." It is because - by design (I believe)- the writers didn't lay all of their cards on the table. They slowly unveiled the characters personalities and quirks.

I think a short Mark storyline could be really funny.

1
pancakesandhyrup•

I really liked that his humor was more subtle. I wish he would come back for at least a brief cameo or something. Mark telling Jerry that he was adopted is still one of my favorite things.

24
ohhbietz•

Jerry? He's probably going to go anger pee in the courtyard.

14
Dave6480•

Yeah, that was GENIUS!

2
zedelghem•

I recently rewatched Season 2, and was consistently amazed at how the energy was sucked out of any scene with Mark in it. I never really found him funny. He always seemed to come across as a really bitter curmudgeon. I can't say I miss him.

17
Dave6480•

I can't recall any scene at all in which he was either bitter or curmudgeonly.

Do you have an example?

4
zedelghem•

Curmudgeonly might bit a bit of an overstatement, but he's consistently down in his attitude. I think in an effort to make him a straight man character, they went too far with it. I can't think of a specific example off the top of my head, I'd have to go back and watch some of the first half of Season 2 again. From my recent viewing, it was basically any scene he was in where I just was really glad he's not around anymore.

1
Dave6480•

I loved Mark's relationships with the other characters.

He had a genuine comraderie with Ron and Tom.

In one of the first episodes when the obvious sex offender asks about the park and he tells April to walk away, it made me laugh.

When he and Ron had to bring Ron's workshop up to code, it was really funny.

I cried laughing when he told Garry (Jerry/I'm so confused now) that his adopted mother had a pot charge and Garry didn't know that he was adopted. Mark's response, "Oh Garry" was hilarious.

He was definitely the downbeat to the high energy Tom and Andy, but that was his job as the straight man.

Ben's character has been 100% more negative in his run on the show and he is still a very funny character.

Adam Scott and Rob Lowe are great actors and their characters were written when the writers had really hit their stride. It is not really fair to compare Mark to his replacements.

7
radda•

He was okay.

Do I miss him? No, because we got Ben and CHRIS TRAEGER! in exchange, who are far funnier.

15
characterzer0•

Yeah, he was pretty good. But that guy's best work was on The Assassination of Jesse James, etc..

"I'll knock on your door, and I will be as mad as a hornet..."

3
spirit_spine•

That was weird :/

1
agehaya•

I have to be honest, I just found him kind of boring. Perhaps being more subdued is an asset considering the energy of the other characters, but in the end, I wasn't sorry to see him go. I think he fit in with what the show was at the beginning, but for me he'd seem out of place now.

8
drkstr632•

Hated him. Now Ann Perkins is becoming dead weight too.

8
sathka•

I can see where you're coming from, even if I don't necessarily agree. I happen to love whenever she's such a downer to Leslie's chip and charm, like the scouting trip.

6
[deleted]•

She's up and down. Her part in the penis pic episode -- hilarious. I also like whenever you see how close her and Leslie's relationship is. There would be a hole in the show if she left, as opposed to the lack of Mark-hole.

4
[deleted]•

There's a possibility he might come back.

He wasn't my favorite character, but he was pretty decent. Great support for the other characters, I do agree with you there, and definitely one of the most grounded-in-reality. I wouldn't mind seeing him in an ep or two this season.

7
snowlarbear•

no.

6
footinmymouth•

exactly.

1
ThatGuyTy86•

"I can't wait to talk to Justin again. Last time he told me about how he snorkeled with whale sharks in Madagascar. That was after I told him that I sometimes go swimming at the Y."

By no means was he one of my favorites, but no one on the show could have said this line better. Don't miss him too much, because the show has a different direction. He served his purpose and moved on.

6
ypod•

I didn't like him, because he felt like a ripoff of Jim from 'The Office.' The rest of the characters felt a little more fresh.

4
Kostanzer•

I do. I liked him a lot and thought his stodginess added some good humor. As tehRoyal pointed out, he was essentially the Jim of P&R, although IMO there's enough separating the two (especially now that The Office has more or less fallen off of a cliff and is on life support) for P&R to develop into its own show even with Mark. As long as the writing could keep up, I could see him staying on. And didn't Schneider leave the show to work on movies instead of getting booted?

3
chronberg•

I have a friend who stopped watching the show when mark left. Mostly because she thought he was hot.

2
SavageNoble•

To be fair, I started watching Parks and Rec because of Amy Poehler, Rashida Jones, and Aubrey Plaza, so I guess I can't judge.

7
Eeveelutions•

I had literally forgotten who Mark was, and sat there for a few minutes trying to remember. So...uh yeah, he's pretty forgettable, I guess :/

2
Twibb•

I just rewatched all of Season 2, and to be honest, I completely forgot he existed until I saw him again.

I'm not saying he's a bad character, I'm just saying he can't have been very good if he left and I didn't miss him.

2
piisnotthree•

Well, I think we should all hope that they use his time away to perhaps change him (to reduce Jim-ness) before bringing him back. I mean, did he leave Pawnee? It's a pretty small town.

2
[deleted]•

Couldn't stand him.

2
ElderCunningham•

I thought I would miss him when I first heard he was leaving, but now that he's gone, I don't miss him at all.

2
scrufjz1•

I always thought he was kind of like Jim...except more of a dick.

1