PBE Bug & Feedback Thread: Astronaut Maokai

Collective Bug & Feedback Thread

Hello All!

https://imgur.com/a/q6aeNoN

Astronaut Maokai is branching out on the Rift featuring:

  • New models and textures!

  • New VFX!

  • New SFX!

  • New Recall animation!

Astronaut Maokai is set to 1350 RP and is available on PBE!

Feel free to leave any feedback or questions you have down below!

-6armedrobot

UPDATE

Hello all! Thank you everyone that was able to leave feedback. We very much appreciate hearing from you. The team had a look at everything and feels that Astronaut Maokai is good-to-go as is. A couple of points for context:

  • In regard to his Taunt (Ctrl+2), the team had a good discussion here. A rework at this point would be a very expensive and the team didn't feel the current animation was too far off thematic, after all he throws saplings at enemies and they explode. The Taunt (Ctrl+2) will remain as is.

  • For those concerned about the size of his saplings in his Sapling Toss (E), they align with his previous skins. If they appear larger, it's most likely due to the brighter coloring.

Hope this helps!

-6armedrobot

Posted Jun 8, 2021, 7:47 PM UTC · edited

1013
Dbash56•

1st of all... THANK YOU FOR A NEW MAOKAI SKIN! Love my big tree boy!

2nd of all - this might be one of the best, if not the best Maokai skin released. The voice over, the walk animation looking like low-gravity, the auto attack hits, OMG. Perfection.

The only nitpicks I have are as follows -

  • The taunt where Maokai throws and then stomps on the sapling is kinda... brutal for this skin since he's supposed to be like, a caretaker overgrown terrarium type of thing? I would like to see Meowkai's taunt animation here where he almost throws it but then shakes his head and gently puts his arm back down.

  • When Maokai dies could maybe the lights on his helmet/jaw/terrarium area turn off or maybe red? Just a little touch might be pretty neat.

  • There are a few tiny clipping errors with the sapling that is held and his fingers, especially when he is grabbing a new one.

  • There are a few shadow clipping errors near his feet that kind of make it look like he is sinking into the ground

  • The VFX on his passive, especially from looking behind Maokai, is sometimes hard to read if the passive is up or not because of the ambient green particle effects coming off his back. I would suggest maybe changing the color of the passive VFX to something more teal-ish like the color of his lights on his helmet.

Otherwise this is a wonderful wonderful wonderful skin that I am so excited to see hit live. Thank you!!!

10
TheDarkRobotix•

all fair points and good ideas!

2

Is there any chance you can change his taunt animation to the one used for Meowkai so that he doesn't stomp on the adorable alien?

8
TheDarkRobotix•

omg I didnt know he did this for his taunt cause I'm always using meowkai so I hope they can change this but also for the laugh, sapling sounds should be replaced with alien meep sounds

3
raphelmadeira•

sapling sounds should be replaced with alien meep sounds

https://twitter.com/RiotKDan/status/1402429696768319488

2
TheDarkRobotix•

Oh I meant in the laugh specifically like here https://youtu.be/iZogSGBtJbY?t=50

edit: added timestamp

1
raphelmadeira•

"Hello all! Thank you everyone that was able to leave feedback. We very much appreciate hearing from you. The team had a look at everything and feels that Astronaut Maokai is good-to-go as is."

Oh, ok. So I gonna keep playing with Meowkai aka best Maokai skin. I will wait for the next Maokai skin! I love the Astronaut skins, but this Astronaut Maokai is so unfinished to me.

4
Dbash56•

yeah super dissapointing that they ask for advice, people make great points, and then they go "haha ok no thanks tho!"

2
dodgebr•

2 things:

This could use another taunt because obvious reasons

Is his E that big on his other skins?

The rest is amazing :)

3
AutoModeratorMOD•

#Remember to follow the SKIN AND CHROMA FEEDBACK GUIDELINES and to remain constructive while giving feedback!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
MaidsandThighs•

love this skin, only feedback id have is a different sfx for start of his ult cause it doesnt really represent the thematic. The hitting part is great tho

​

Something more space like instead of sounding like rocks

1
TheDarkRobotix•

I love this skin so much, easily my favorite out of the batch. That recall is funny af.

Any chance of making the face on his arm into something else? IMO I think it doesnt look too good and a bit jarring like he ripped out another astronauts head and is now wearing it as a gauntlet o_o; here are a few things you can change it into: 1) just have a big logo there, 2) wires and cables, 3) UFO launch pad kinda like Astronaut Bard shrines, 4) meeps sitting inside a glass dome (like the splashart), 5) monitor display of heartbeat/lifeline and some stats, 6) a radar/gps thing

His shirt is kinda empty in the splashart maybe he could use some accessories like some tubes or like a satchel or cannisters where he would store the seeds he's planting there? and maybe the logo on his suit should use the same one found on Astronaut Bard's suit and Poppy's R https://imgur.com/E0cZFhD

W is really neat when he transforms into a meep but maybe he should have black eyes? maybe there can be some patterns behind him and the root effect could use some metal circles (kinda like Astronaut Bard portal) on the ground level

E is a bit sad tbh but maybe have their ghost wave goodbye like in Corki's Q, the bush version also looks a bit too big lol, maybe both versions need to be scaled down a bit?

R looks like octopus/squid tentacles for some reason? I think just cables or actual branches with glowing green and blue energy would be better. maybe some patterns behind each root like Q would be neat

edit: maybe his claws can be more rounded and 'friendly'? and he could use some happier eyes in game too

edit2: sapling sound should be alien meep sound in his laugh as well

edit3: probably out of scope but if there were tiny meeps riding the ult and run off when it hits someone/ends, it would be a super cute detail

1
raphelmadeira•

AstroNautilus blinks his eyes. Would it be possible to use this technology in Maokai's hand where there is a second space helmet on this Astronaut skin?

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/E3dCIrSWYAU8OQE?format=png&name=360x360

Is it possible to reduce the size of the Alien that is on the back of the Maokai hanging from the tree? Just like the size of baby Alien in splash art? This Alien doesn't have any animations, so smaller it might be a cuter detail for this skin.

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/E3cKYkXXIAoQ1Az?format=jpg&name=medium

1
Amy_SeryMOD•

Heya everyone! The new testing cycle will begin very soon. Riot is no longer collecting/considering feedback on the current cycle and its content, which means that this thread is now closed. Any bug reports/feedback on live servers can be posted in the r/leagueoflegends bug megathread or the Riot LoL Report a Bug webpage. See you next cycle! o/

1