127k in debt starting intern year for Radiology residency. My residency program qualifies for PSLF. Is it worth doing REPAYE throughout residency and then deciding on PSLF or should I just refinance now?

Student Loan Management

Im not sure what the best move is here. How do I find out how much of the interest rate gets subsidized through repaye? My head hurts.

Posted Jun 8, 2021, 11:09 PM UTC

818

Only reason I would stay in repaye is that it will likely be a lower monthly payment than when you refinance. Unless you can refinance and get a grace period or they only make you pay $100 a month while a resident.

I never planned on PSLF because I knew 100% that I would not be working at a 501c3 after residency. For me the decision was simple.

4
frequentwind•

Continue doing nothing until federal loans resume interest. Then switch to REPAYE for a year while waiting to see or they pass an across the board forgiveness. Then refinance to a private company. Private practice radiology pays so much more than working for a hospital with much better retirement and vacation.

2
ASAPdocOP•

With REPAYE my interest will be cut in half cause it gets subsidized right? That isnt a bad idea.

1
RufDoc•

If you’re uncertain at all, do RePAYE. The amount you gain for refinancing is very little compared to RePAYE in terms of effective interest. More importantly, avoid closing doors with irreversible decisions if you’re not 100% convinced you don’t want to do PSLF. If you decide you don’t want to do PSLF later on, just refinance when you make the decision. No need to do anything irreversible now.

2
botulism69•

Refi to priv loan with $100 a month capped payments then paying off as an attending

If I did repaye my PP rads salary would more than pay off my 220K loans at 10% agi per year....... Useless! Rather use extra money during residency when money is tight

1
financeben•

Dang didn’t know that was an option in private loans. Some people against refi bc govt.. but I doubt they ever dismiss graduate debt.

2
botulism69•

Yeah public thinks docs are already overpaid. We're not getting any help lol

Sofi, laurel road all are good for priv refi

3
ASAPdocOP•

What is the benefit of doing capped payments? I can probably pay off more than 100$ per month on student loans during residency.

2
botulism69•

I'd rather not pay more towards my loans if I don't have to as I have a family and that's... expensive.

Money is tight now but as an attending, I don't think it will be

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
botulism69•

Which part?

1
SportsDoc7•

Did repaye for one year in residency and then refinanced to sofi. I'd recommend sofi or laurel road. It's nice to have a little money on the side and allows you to start building some wealth. I paid $500 a month sometimes if there were no big purchase in the future and my emergency fund was full.

1
PouffyMoth•

I would suggest sitting down in excel and mapping it out. When my wife graduated I had a rough estimate of $240,000 payments over 10 years on PAYE/REPAYE for over $300,000 in loans. For us this meant that our income could be quite a bit higher than my projection and we would still be getting a 0% loan or better.

As others have said, if your income is going to be so high that you are going to pay well more than the principal, it would be worth using REPAYE for now and refinancing later.

1
ASAPdocOP•

I do not understand why I would not just refinance now? Can you elaborate your point?

1
PouffyMoth•

REPAYE will give you great flexibility because the payments will be low. So if you want to build an emergency fund or whatever else to get your finances in order before refinancing.

If you feel secure in your situation already I’m not sure if you would need to wait to refinance.

2
Mrrgrotm•

That’s valid, but some refinance companies are also offering $100 payments during residency. I’m in the same dilemma.

1
Mrrgrotm•

I’m in the same dilemma. Have you calculated your effective interest rate under REPAYE and compared them to refinance quotes? If REPAYE is lower, stick with it.

1
ASAPdocOP•

How do I calcite my effective interest rate for with repaye?

1
Mrrgrotm•

It’s complicated, You can look it up on wci blog. You need your consolidated interest rate for accuracy.

1