r/Borderlands•
ACWHH

Does anyone else miss weapon proficiencies from BL1?

[BL1]

One thing I love about BL1 is the more you use certain weapon types the more your proficiency with them improves. I know badass rank/guardian rank kind of replaced it but I always enjoyed working in weapon proficiencys.

Posted Jun 9, 2021, 10:18 AM UTC

62390
GracieThunders•

The more you use it, the better it gets

I miss a lot about BL1

178
GiverOfZeroShits•

I liked it but one definite downside was that it discouraged using other weapon types

117
TheGreenGobblr•

Well on Lilith I just used Smgs the whole time, on mordecai i just used snipers and revolvers (and melee), and on brick I just used shotguns (haven’t played much Roland). The fact that certain characters level up faster kinda sucks because it makes it harder to do an unorthodox build

35
SSJSalgado•

roland was good with combat rifles and shotguns, i never used mordecai until yesterday so far it's fun remembering i have a blood thirsty bird to help out

1
jaquick•

Not exactly. My Lilith has max proficiency on every weapon. Just a matter of time.

25
heyitsYMAA•

Then I'd ask what the point of the mechanic is.

I don't think weapon proficiencies add anything particularly satisfying to the gameplay, while leveling up or in endgame.

70
John-ZeroI have long opinions•

Just a fun additional form of leveling up.

11
Jester97•

"Fun".

I'm glad some of you aren't game devs.

-9†
polchickenpotpie•

Yeah at that point I'd rather it be restricted to class, like Mass Effect 1/2, if there had to be a mechanic in there

8
ZindaeHE'S ON FIRE!•

Fun. You won’t believe how much FUN is important in a game, no matter how pointless. If only BL3 had some of it.

Elite dangerous is a game with no goal or point, everything you do is your own goal or fun. I’ve got 2000 hours in that.

-4†
Matrixneo42•

Yes. But eventually you just farm them all up via that big rakkHive. Just take it down to 1% health and then finish with gun type you want to earn proficiency in.

15
Geralts_HairNice Hat!•

Ahh the good ol’ exploit, a Borderlands staple.

16
Lightningslash325•

I like thinking of it as a way to divvy up weapons in a team. X has this proficiency so they should take this, Y has that, etc. I’m sure there are other things it’s good for that trumps discouraging other weapon types.

4
Taken4GrantD•

I like the idea, but not the implementation. It took really long to get to a good point on many and made the early game feel worse. In particular, I never got eridian weapon proficiency up since it was rare to get one and by late game they couldn't really compete vs. say a level 50 proficiency rifle (not to mention the other issues with those weapons).

I'd like a rework where you leveled individual weapon styles like 1, but instead you gained points to put in a level tree for that weapon type. These would be small tweaks, not game changing skills like the character tree, and ideally preference based. Two people might like using assault rifles but one prefers putting all points into accuracy so they can use it at range but another might put it all into ammo storage and fire speed cause they just hate picking up ammo and reloading. Small little tweaks like that would be nice so long as one trait doesn't dominate the others.

72
PaulBradley•

My last playthrough a few months ago I deliberately set out to level my weapons as evenly as possible, it didn't work out perfectly of course, and I will go back to see if I can max them all this time, but I do have some pretty bad-ass eridian weapons from half way through the game onwards. Lots of one-shot kills.

I'd imagine this would be easier to boost in two-player as well as your oppo could do the most boss damage and you'd still reap the experience in lower rates weapons, although I don't play two-player so I'm stuck grinding.

11
FacelessHumanFace•

If you kill the Erdidian people at the end you can max out every profiency in a couple hours easily

5
Csl8•

you can also do the same with the rakk hive

3
PaulBradley•

Yeah, Rakk hive works for me, for the first 75% at least, you have to be pretty proficient already to take on the Guardians at the end on the highest level or be using the right elemental weapon.

1
infernalxs•

Yes, I really liked seeing my proficiency go up with each gun, it seems like such a simple thing they could easily bring it back

56
brunocar•

I think it was a great but very flawed mechanic, it needed more developing, but badass ranks feel nowhere near as meaningful (in fact they feel entirely superfluous 90% of the time) and guardian ranks feel more like a specific grind to give you something to do after hitting the cap that isnt OP levels.

The strenghts of the BL1 system is that it encouraged something specific (using certain weapons with each of the 4 characters) and rewarded you with stat bonuses for each, they also had a cap, so it was an objective to work towards.

The flaws were that the rewards were unclear, you couldnt preview them to aspire to it and some were very buggy (namely the half cut lvl requirement change), if they fixed that and maybe had a capstone in each weapon type for each class (a specific bonus or effect for reaching max level with that type thats also a unique modifier to said class) it would help the class identity of each character AND make the system more meaningful.

28
Reniconix•

The level requirement change getting cut was a visual bug only, and there was zero impact on gameplay, considering the only way to equip a weapon above your level was to cheat it into your equipment slot. The only reason we even know that mechanic was planned was that the level changed when the gun was equipped, but that is the only remnant of it in the code and there is no easy way to enable it.

10
brunocar•

i know, thats why its a shame, there was proof that the mechanic was gonna have more meaningful rewards

3
Britten_One•

Yup.

17
lsparischi•

No.
Borderlands is all about lots of loot and gun diversity (end-game debatable).
Gun proficiencies and specific weapon buffs in character skill trees are contradictory to that (we already have some skill trees that are fully thematic to elements, usually).

15
XDracam•

I actually liked gun-specific skill trees in BL1. They improved the replayability. If you can use everything well with every VH, then why try out another one?

And indeed, BL3 has no DLC vault hunters because apparently most people picked their one VH in BL2 and stuck to them, so its not worth the effort to develop new ones.

1
Konork•

If you can use everything well with every VH, then why try out another one?

First of all, because they have skills that might have a more significant effect on gameplay than the weapons, or skills that might synergize with more broad categories of weapons that just their type. Second of all, to flip this whole thing around, if only certain classes can use certain weapon types very well, what's the point of trying other weapons on said classes?

4
Enough-Okra9621•

God yes, easily one of my favorite features from BL1.

13
ValdraxNumbers, numbers, math-math-math.•

No. I disliked how it encouraged specialization and devalued loot outside of it.

Thankfully the damage scaling in BL1 was gentle enough that you could often use outleveled gear for a long time, and that also extended to being able to get some use out of guns you weren't well trained in, but it was always sub-optimal.

If that system had made it into BL2, I can only imagine that it would have prompted the designers to make the damage scaling there even more aggressive.

13
Zoomemy•

Fuck no

11†

Gets down voted for just saying no god people are easily butt hurt

-11
QuillVance•

easily butt hurt

Giving a shit about the vote system

9
UnusedUsername76•

Or they disagree? Downvotes aren't a personal attack jfc

4†
noah9942I'M THE CONDUCTOR OF THE POOP TRAIN!•

They also aren't a disagree button

5
UnusedUsername76•

And there shouldn't be, the downvote button already exists for more or less the same reason

0†
MonolithyKFools! They called me maaaad!•

I think a fair amount of the commenters here are not understanding the difference between the actual Weapon Proficiency system and characters with weapon-specific skills. Weapon Proficiency was the same across all characters, and encouraged using a variety of different weapon types.

I personally miss it - although I wish it took longer to max out each proficiency rank.

11
Reniconix•

You wish it took longer? Max was 3,060,000 XP, and there were 8 weapons that you had to gain that experience with INDEPENDENTLY. That was the equivalent to leveling up your character to level 48, 8 times, or to level 124.

There isn't even enough in the game to get to level 69 without grinding enemies.

15
MonolithyKFools! They called me maaaad!•

I have 1,600 hours on the first game - I’m sure others here have similar numbers. There are quite a lot of players who appreciate grind in looter shooters.

0†
Reniconix•

1600 hours is way above the average playtime. I've beaten the game on all 4 characters 100% (besides weapon proficiencies) and haven't even broken 600. Making things harder to cater to the 1% of players who WILL max out everything puts off the other 99% who now see this as a useless mechanic not worth playing with. It also exacerbates the major problem most people had with weapon proficiency that lead to the introduction of Badass rank instead.

19
LegitGingerDude:Roland:•

I agree with you. I prefer weapon proficiency IMO, but what’s the deal with these people that “love the grind” in looter shooters. I don’t want to sound like a dick, but I hope they find a different game series. I’m so tired of people who complain “there’s not enough grind! Why am I finding so many legendaries?!” Like you do you, but your fun seems like the antithesis of my fun.

Sorry, microrant.

6
MonolithyKFools! They called me maaaad!•

I maxed my proficiency on all four characters within the first 400 hours or so - the average player doesn’t even do playthroughs with all of the characters. I’m not saying they should have doubled it or anything, but I did wish it was something I worked towards for at least a little longer.

Why do you think the Badass Rank system in BL2 basically has an endless ceiling?

-1
LegitGingerDude:Roland:•

As a fan of the series who’s favorite game is BL1, I hate the grind. I don’t know why people enjoy it, it seems like the exact opposite of what the game is. The fact the devs keep listening to people that like it and make it grindier sends a whole lot of people away.

2
MonolithyKFools! They called me maaaad!•

Are you the kind of player who killed Crawmerax a singe time for the mission completion, and called it a day? Or did you return even a few times in the hopes of getting a pearlescent drop?

If you are the later, congrats! You partook in a loot grind - the very mechanic looter shooters are based around. There’s nothing wrong with not liking a grind per-se, but to say the game isn’t largely about the grind is a pretty massive oversight.

1
tsukinoki•

encouraged using a variety of different weapon types

I have to disagree with this, as it did quite the opposite.

For example by the time that Eridian weapons started dropping in BL1 you had other weapons with much higher proficiencies that you were using that buffed their damage, reload/rate of fire, and accuracy/stability that picking them up was basically "Well unless this rolled extremely well then its utterly useless unless I spend 10+ hours grinding using only eridian weapons to get the damage bonus to the point where its roughly on par with my other weapons...."

The weapon proficiency bonus really told you "You used these weapons early on? NEVER change as it will just never be worth it unless you plan on grinding 10+ hours to get this other weapon type on par with your main weapon type!"

Say you've been using SMGs for most of the game and want to branch out to the other weapon types...they are going to utterly suck in comparison until you do tons and tons and tons of grinding with them in order to bring them on par...and its not even the fun grinding as there isn't any way to speed it up or make it bearable.

The only good thing that weapon proficiencies really did was make it easy to go "Hey I picked up a sniper, let me give this to the person that has been using snipers the entire game" without ever looking at the card because you sure as hell won't be using it considering your main weapon has +48% damage, +102% reload speed, and +144% accuracy meaning that it can't hope to be worth even trying out even if it is a legendary or pearl.

6
CozyGhosty•

If there was a gameplay loop similar to BL2 where you could go beyond TVHM and replay the same file infinitely, I think I’d like it a lot more.

As it currently is, the gunplay only really starts to feel responsive and accurate once you’re in late-mid to endgame. And by the time guns finally feel good, the game is practically over.

It impacts certain weapons worse than others. There’s nothing worse than playing as Mordecai, being like five feet away from a bandit, having your sniper crosshair DEAD CENTRE on his silly little face and still somehow whiffing because your sniper proficiency is so shit.

I think you could make a case for bringing wep proficiency back and doing it better but in my opinion it just feels like a chore in BL1

11
S7E4Z3M3I5T3R•

Proficiency systems are one of the most satisfying game mechanics. BL1, Phantasy Star Universe and Advent Riding did it right. I miss those mechanics.

8
CyperFlicker•

Personally I prefer each class (or character) being specialized in a weapon or two, but that's just my opinion ¯\(ツ)/¯

7
pinksweater204•

Yeah it just makes sense, weapons are a part of each class, like snipers and revolvers for Mordecai and SMGS for Lilith

1
SardamanBack to you, voice in my head!•

Proficiencies were cool if you picked a gun type and stuck with it for the whole game, but they heavily discouraged using any type you didn't have a high proficiency in, which is why they were removed.

7
Hybr1dThe0ry•

Yeah definitely! Thanks for posting this now I feel like playing BL1 tonight haha

7
SwirlyTGaige best girl•

I loved that side grind.

6
4look4rd•

it’s not good game design since it incentivizes players to use only one rather than try out different ones. I like guardian ranks better.

6
Eternalm8•

I used to miss it a lot when Borderlands 2 first came out. As I've gone back to BL1 to revisit it over the years, it feels more and more restrictive, and I'm glad they went with systems that promoted you to try more experimentation with playstyles.

4
BIG8L_117•

Nah the gameplay aspects of bl1 I miss are being able to use guns 3 levels lower and have them actually work. And how the gun generator worked giving the possibility of hybrid guns

4

You could use guns 10 levels off your level and still be effective in BL1. Thats one of my favorite things about it. You could find a gun you like and actually use it for a while and not have to swap out every 2 levels like BL2.

1