r/actuary•
Dark_AceX

For those who took GH FV-CU in Spring'21, did anyone notice the SOA put a Case Study despite the website saying "The GHFVCU exam will not have a case study"

Exams

Not sure if it's just me, but I found it really dumb how the SOA specifically said on their website up to the day of the exam (screenshot as of May 5th: https://imgur.com/a/gve3zwZ) that the exam won't have a case study, yet they put a case study during the actual exam. After I emailed the SOA, they changed their updates website to this: https://www.soa.org/education/exam-req/syllabus-study-materials/edu-updates-exam-group-health-finance-val/

Not sure how it impacted anyone on the actual exam, but I also found that particular problem (#4) a really bad problem. Although the info needed to solve the problem was within the "case study", I found it extremely stupid how they didn't refer to any specific exhibits and instead gave some weird financial statement in the Excel file that had nothing to do with the problem. Also, the case study they gave on the exam actually referred to the Segment "A" exam instead of "C" lol.

Really wished the SOA just got their shit together, because mistakes like these can be really misleading during the actual exam. Wanted to see if anyone felt the same way, and notify the SOA about this (doubt they'll do anything, but it may help the curve to our favor lol).

Edit: The SOA posted Spring'21 Exams here: https://www.soa.org/education/exam-req/syllabus-study-materials/edu-multiple-choice-exam/

Also for those curious, I emailed both the exam committee ([email protected]) and customer service ([email protected])

Posted Jun 9, 2021, 4:01 PM UTC · edited

249
S3v3n0fNine•

Yes, I had the same issue! I was thinking it wasn't too big of a deal even though I wasn't expecting a case study because of the website, but then I just stared at that problem for 15 minutes without being able to write anything. I could not figure out how to work the problem until I went into the actual case study and found the table needed. I couldn't believe they didn't put it in the excel file. Very frustrating. I emailed the SOA about it, hopefully they will do something.

17
montrex•

As a member of a different institute, that is so horrible. With the amount of exams we have to do and how much they are pushed as being part of the profession these things should really not happen at all.

Hope you guys don't pay tons for these exams.

15
MikeGlennonForMVP•

Only $1225

13
montrex•

Oof

2
PootNDHealth•

ok, i'm glad you pointed this out. When I got to the question, I was like "i thought C didn't have a case study but I wasn't checking the SOA updates as much as I should so I must have missed an updated".

It also took me a couple of minutes to realize that the necessary charts were in the Case Study PDF and not in the Excel file, especially since the random financial statement was for the same company AND for FV-A, I believe all the relevant information was provided to you in Excel.

13
PootNDHealth•

The question wasn't too bad itself but still took some time to process on an already tight timeframe to finish everything within the required time

5
microwave_sushiHealth•

My favorite part is that some of the charts you needed were in the spreadsheet for your answers but you had to go in the case study for a later part of the question to make sense. Didn't have a problem with that question, just a terribly administered exam. I have to wonder if it's peer reviewed at all, with so few people taking it still compared to DP.

4
FrankAbignell•

I studied only the parts of the case study that were specific to part A, since that was the only part of the exam that would use the case study, or so I thought. The case study practice videos for TIA emphasized this multiple times.

The exams are difficult enough to get through with no second guessing and back tracking, but twice as hard if you are unsure what you’re supposed to be doing in the first place.

One consolation is that we are all in the same boat anytime there is some glaring error or inconsistency. I just feel bad for anyone who spent way too long on something that was an error.

On a tangent, I wish the exams were easier in terms of question difficulty and clarity but passed the same percentage of people. There would be no difference from the SOA’s perspective.

2
Fuck_the_SOA•

BwaaaahahahaHahahahahahah

1
Fuck_the_SOA•

Did anyone alert the SOA to this?

1
Dark_AceXOP•

I have, and so did several others. It would help if more people bring this up to the SOA, because mistakes like these are truly unacceptable.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
Dark_AceXOP•

Lmao true that. Your username is hilarious btw 🤣

1
SeasplashThe Squirrel Actuary•

Any updates?

1
Dark_AceXOP•

Not really. The SOA did get back to me and said they’ll look into it. They also corrected their website after I told them (which was after the exam lol).

At the end of the day, pretty sure they won’t do jack shit about it. Everyone took the same exam under the same conditions, so it is what it is. Wishing for a better curve, but hopefully it doesn’t happen again for future sittings.

1

Good luck. You’ll be waiting months for a response if you ever get any.

1