Big, medium, or small factories?

Trying to figure out what works best.

For small factories I can see it being an easier logistic task. Single product, can double up on production for that singular thing when higher demand. But this means buying more plots, having more managers, and dozens more trade ships. And since each one needs a decent docking area and wharf, you are investing more materials getting a production chain going than with a larger factory.

For Large, where you are doing all the steps from Tier 1 to Tier 4/5 materials, there is greater initial cost involved, and occasional supply issues, but once you have it going it just rakes in money with fewer ships needed because you have multiple wares being made that NPCs are buying. Since you are doing many things at a single location you can just build a few docks and wharfs to sell a whole production chain.

For Medium, it's the middle ground, focusing on 1 or 2 goods, with shorter steps in the production chain. But still needs a good number of ships to get it going and still needs many different plots.

Posted Jun 10, 2021, 4:52 AM UTC

1318

I see some aspects not mentioned:

  • There are no running costs to stations or ships (except the occasional ship lost to pirates or Xenon). So... no particular reason to reduce the numbers, from that point of view.
  • Having only one production item per factory makes it real easy to let *that* station grow. Just click some part and copy the whole chain, and plop down a dozen additional production modules with not a worry in the world.
  • Station Managers and ships seem to work best when they are single-mindedly doing only one thing; i.e. if you assign miners to a station, and there is only one mineral the station needs, then that works great; do it for a station which needs several minerals, and they have a good chance to work badly or not at all due to deadlocking themselves with a full cargo hold of the wrong type.
  • When having many stations, it is more likely that surplus intermediate items are bought by NPCs, thus getting you a little income at the side. So it doesn't matter that much if your logistics are slightly imbalanced.

So - in my first playthrough I *tried* to get a self-sufficient economy with complex stations running, and it felt like constantly battling against the game, even though I eventually used the "Mule and Warehouses" mod to replace the janky vanilla ship behaviours.

Now in my second one, each ship and station does exactly one thing only, and I micro-manage almost nothing; I don't care which ship goes where, I just make sure there are enough traders and miners assigned to each station. The vanilla scripts seem to be made for exactly this simplest possible way to do it, and I am not asking more of them. I'm looking for a situation where there always is between 0 and 1 idle ship per station; that seems to be an easy enough metric to judge how much is needed. The NPCs step in if some more transportation capacity is used.

Also, I did not start out with the tier 1 stations this time, but with whatever item was most looked for on the market - this means that while I had to buy all the ingredients at the start, I made money right from the beginning.

17
Aotearas•

Very much this.

My prime reason to diffuse my player economy was the bonkers station subordinate AI like the issues with miners dropping everything to stock up on a single mineral/gas that was getting low in storage and in the process grinding everything to a screeching halt as all the other ressources emptied out and traders in general having no bloody clue on what to actually sell if you got too many products and resulting in hilariously low-profit runs (why trade a full cargo hold of silicon wafers you can sell for lots of money at literally the next station over, I'd rather go sell those ten energy cells halfway across the galaxy instead ...). Having a station that only requires a single type of mineral and/or gas (you can mix one type of mineral and gas no problem, just don't mix two types of each, that's when miner AI will inevitably go bonkers) most definately eliminated any and all trouble I had with miners not operating properly, something that plagued me frustratingly common previously when I had stations demanding several different raw ressources of the same type.

Another advantage of building dedicated stations for specific wares rather than building complexes is that it's much cheaper and faster to get starting. A dock module, storage type as required and a produciton module and you're good to go already, then scale the station as demand requires.

​

I would however still start out at tier I production (refined wares) as I found that the moment I created a supply, the NPC faction in the sectors around where I produced the stuff started building stations that use said supply up and it did **WONDERS** to the local economy. Playing Spear of the Patriarch start and Split economy tends to have common two problems:

-Their wharfs and shipyards guzzle up hull parts like mad since their strong hull ships demand more of the stuff, making hull parts expensive and almost perpetually low on supply (not a good thing since you need the stuff on vast quantities to build stations)

-Split stations have poor storage capacity so the existing stations you supply don't buy much (though on the offsite it means if you supply the station the prices fall quicker than usual as the storage fills up faster relative to total storage volume)

​

Just chucking a station producing Refined Metals in Family Zhin turned an immediate profit selling to the perpetually starved hull part factories (thus also making future station building cheaper for myself as hull parts became more accessible and cheaper to buy) but the moment my production sated the existing hull part factories (four production modules where enough for that in my playthrough) Zyarth started building a good bunch extra hull part factories, meaning even more customers and hull parts for the local economy. Same deal with the other refined wares. Turned the Zyarth economy from shambling about to an absolute powerhouse. In earlier playthroughs where I tried making entirely selfsufficient complexes I had trouble buying ships as the wharfs and shipyards were easily starved of components, now I can queue up ships no problem and barely run into any component shortages at all.

After I had sorted the tier I base production, I went into high tech, specifically microchips, quantum tubes and plasma conductors in preparation to supply my own high end production. Again, the moment I had that production in place and going Zyarth started constructing stations that would buy from me and the additional claytronics stations that were being build in response were quite welcome (ZYA only had like three claytronics stations total since the playthrough start so even if I had wanted to build a self sufficient mega complex I would've been starved for construction materials).

Helping to build up the local economy will give you better profit in the long run than immediately jumping into market gaps, especially if whatever is short that you're trying to fill in is short because the required wares to produce are in short supply and you have to buy them at high prices and possibly low volumes meaning your factory might stall out every now and then as it doesn't have enough ressources to work. It's also easier to plan ahead for yourself being proactive on your own terms than trying to build reactively but maybe that's just my "it gotta be orderly, damnit" OCD kicking in.

​

I only have two big complexes, one self-sufficient factory churning out everything I need for Split worker population (Chelt Meat, Scruffin Fruit and SPL Medical Supplies) which I just ship to my stations with habitation modules for the sweet worker efficiency bonus ... and one wharf complex producing all components required for ship building which will in time expand to a full shipyard as I ramp up production.

​

Bigger, multi-product complexes might be a more attractive prospect come 4.10 patch where Egosoft said they improved station trader logistics for traders not to drop everything the moment a ware falls to low volume if it's already produced by the station, so less chance for your logistics to grind to a halt or otherwise go haywire. Assuming the change works as advertised, of course.

5
gorgofdoom•

station managers

  1. designing your empire around a defined bug seems illogical.

  2. automine & auto-trade work far better than station managers. Not even considering the bugginess of managers.

They can pick the best trade in range versus only trades at their parent. That means if their station is idle, you have many idle ships. Auto traders/miners are able to prioritize your stations, then take on other local but lower profit trades when your empire is satiated.

This is important because designing oversupply is how preventing idle factories is done.

You’ll probably think that, we’ll, it’s easier to put ships under a trade station. Sure, but they’ll be less efficient than an auto-trader. Station subordinates must first take the goods to the depot, then to the final destination.

On a good route this means a ship will sit at a dock for two minutes extra per trade. On a bad route the wares may move away from their destination first then back towards it, adding travel time on top of extra docking.

P.s. put a three star captain in charge of a ship, set the behavior, then move the captain to another ship. The behavior will persist but will be governed by the lower level pilots skill— so shorter range but still auto trade or mining with the better procedure.

I don’t consider this an exploit because this is precisely how real world procedures are done— put a highly skilled person in a position & ask them to document their procedures. Then hire a lower skilled individual to follow those procedures.

you only need one high level pilot!!!

1

I use station miners, station traders as well as general sector auto-miners and autotraders.

I do *not* use hand-crafted traders or miners on "Repeat Orders" anymore (tried that, was too frustrating).

2
gorgofdoom•

This is kinda a rabbit hole I’ve yet to make sense of.

it makes sense to put refineries close to rich ore spots. The less your miners have to travel they’re more able to generate resources consistently

Sectors with a lot of raw floating around usually have limited workforce, though.

So it may make sense to truck base intermediates from refineries to central sectors for the greater workforce growth.

But it also makes sense to build “end product” complexes right next to asteroid fields as you don’t need any ships to move intermediates.

Most of the time I ignore workforce altogether. I find it to be a big money sink with promises of profit “sometime in the future”, while the entire time it takes to reach greater efficiency it often bleeds credits.

If one were to build many small stations, though, it would be better for workforce. each smaller station gets the same increase per time, as opposed to one huge station getting the same crew per time period.

TLDR: more stations = greater efficiency in the long run. But less initial gains and much greater initial investment .

8
BobbyBeeblebrox•

2 food, 2 medical supply modules will feed a ridiculous number of L habitats and only cost a couple mil, all told. After that your workforce is free and you will see the returns of increased efficiency faster. At one point I had 14 or so L habitats and was also shipping food and meds to a trade station without the factory stocks going below 50%.

2
gorgofdoom•

Only cost a couple mill

(I know about emp bombs and all— piracy is my main gig)

if playing lawful good it is not cheap. Habitat blueprints + food factories for one race cost more than the claytronics Bp. Specifically, I seem to remember the Teladi L habitat costs 20M.

Not to mention when aiming for the maximum workforce growth you have to buy every races blueprints.

1
BobbyBeeblebrox•

Sure.

2
Denamic•

Big, efficient factories that produce everything + ships print money

2
Shads404•

Best is real subjective here, and what sort of initial investment you can make into it. a 100mil large factory needs that 100mil to start with etc after all and takes an age to return on that investment.

The cost of additional docks/traders/plots when doing multiple smaller stations gets offset because those stations can be generating a profit quicker, paying for (or producing the parts needed) for the next stations.

For me personally, if it makes sense for one station to be self contained for the product then that's how I approach it. Hull parts is a classic example here. It usually means I end up with a few medium sized stations rather then one giant factory (unless I'm just doing that for design fun).

Having more stations means better performance on my potato, but it also means less chance of one module being destroyed bring every production line to a halt (like having the module that connects all your storage to the dock destroyed and not noticing for a few hours)

2
liskacek•

Don't forget menu clutter part of the equation. Being able to find what I am looking for without searching through dozens (hundreds) of factories is also worth something.

PS. Anyone got a method for dealing with that?

2
Pfandfreies_konto•

My approach is the following:

Construct a ressource station containing basically only docking Areas and storage in a viable distance between your (futre) factories and ressource fields. I always assign one solid and one gas ressource per station. This makes that your miners will never do stupid things like trying to mine silicon while they are full of ore.

Then build a production facility for only one intermediate good, or at least goods that need the same wares. You can scale up this station as needed.

Then create stations that use the intermediate goods for wares.

Sprinkle in a station that trades the intermediate goods and wares to your liking. Like selling it to neighbours or feed a shipyard of yours.

This approach works best for me since all my miners are assigned to only one or two ressouces trading stations. You can always simply assign more miners without struggling to balance complex production chains.

Use L-miners (or XL if modded) to transfer ressources between the trading station and the production stations.

2
Dark_Lord_Mr_B•

I generally start with a solar power plant to get the starting capital rolling in. Stage two is when I start making it into an intermediate good factory with the panels still attached. When that pays for itself I make moves to a third stage where I make a tertiary good. The final stage is when I make it self sufficient on 90% of its inputs. Hope that helps.

2
JeanMarkk•

I usually go for Large Factories if i need to supply my own shipyards.

When i use factories for direct sales i go for medium sized mono good factories, since i find it easier to keep organized and they are more money efficient (more profit with a smaller investment).

1
Johnsonn98•

Small - Medium

Big may be worth more financially but you'll need literal days to build those. They're not worth the time and you're better off enjoying the game instead of waiting. Yes, even with SETA.

1
JKNinja_tubes•

Stations that receive raw materials, such as silicon or methane, tend to be bigger as I directly refine them into trade wares. The more advanced wares tend to be single producers as I only make them if I notice a big imbalance of supply and demand for that particular product.

I did once build a mega complex but workers are needed to really increase you profit margins and it takes forever to fill up those huge stations. Plus my CPU didn't like me much whenever I was ISS

1
MiPok24•

I am just a few weeks into the game, but my plan is to create simple scalable factories for each produced item/ressource.

Currently I have one mega factory (since it was cheaper), but that has several disadvantages, such as that the storage is not well balanced and most mining ships have to travel far to deliver mined ressources.

Having more stations and getting intermediate ressources from other stations should make my supply somewhat more balanced. (I hope)

1
grapedog•

I create station hubs, ususlly 3 around the map, different locations depending on which factions are friendly or not friendly for that playthrough.

These station hub areas will fill needs as i see them, with individual stations built around the map as needed.

My stations probably average 30-50 modules. That is about the limit for making a station look good, while also being good production wise.

Aesthetics are very important to me, so i dont build any megas.... ive only ever seen one mega that someone built that looked decent.

I don't worry about mining ore and silicon, or two gases at a station, my factories never have problems filling their storage with the required wares.

1
S1lkwrm•

For me I found building medium to large resource refineries in areas with all resources works well and this playthru they almost cover all areas of map with full 5 sector dist in my 3.

I can then use medium high tech factories in radius with shipyards or end products near.

I use small solar plants for rep

Small little specialized stations to fill gaps where profit can be made.

Basically medium factories are the backbone of my industrial takeover.

1