Comfort or Limit? Sleeping bag temperature.

GEAR

Okay, so I'm an EU hiker in the market for a new sleeping bag and I want to make sure I get one that's right for what I expect to be using it for for the next 5-10 years.

Now I've read a lot of posts about people recommending temp ratings to go for, where I get confused is which temperature they are talking about.

When Americans (sorry probably generalising) say a 10 or 20-degree bag, I know they're talking Fahrenheit, but are they talking about the comfort temperature or the limit temperature?

If you can enlighten me on this I would be most grateful.

Posted Jun 10, 2021, 12:48 PM UTC

26
SvalbarddasKat•

Usually you're going for the comfort temperature, when buying a sleeping bag. The extreme is pretty much a "you won't die of hypothermia in your sleep, but you def. will not feel comfortable" - situation.

I usually suggest to get one that is a bit warmer, than what you need (especially if you get cold easy) or to get a sleeping bag liner, because it's always an option to not close the zipper 100% and air yourself out, rather than having to wear 100 layers in the bag, just to not shiver all night. And we all know, a good night sleep is much needed, on multiday hikes.

6
Vyrck•

100% agree. Good summary.

2
quantum_dan•

I've generally heard people describing their bags by the Limit rating, and that's definitely what they're sold as.

3
cloroxism•

This. If you only see one rating on the product, it's a survivability rating, not a comfort rating. Some manufacturers are kind enough to list both ratings separately, but many do not.

2
OrponSWE•

People discuss LIMIT, which is sometimes referees to for male sleepers, and COMFORT for female sleepers. Where in EU will you use the bag? Summer / fall only in continental Europe: a 30F bag will be warm. In northern Europe I would get a 20F bag for 3-season. Note that Marmot’s 20F bag for women has more filling than same 20F bag for men.

1
UtahBrian•

Usually men's bags are marketed at the limit temperature and women's bags at the comfort temperature. So a woman's bag in the same rating will have significantly more insulation.

But not always. If the manufacturer doesn't have both ratings clearly marked in its publicity or on its web site, you may have to ask.

1