ApolloshotOntario•

This is different than Rempel-Garner apologizing for being a cis gendered heterosexual white woman — which was just unnecessary and made her look silly.

What we allowed happen in 2014/2015 was an error on our part, and when were wrong we should admit were wrong (wouldn’t it be refreshing if we had a government that apologized for things and meant it?).

Banning religious attire is antithetical to Conservatism, we can’t be the party that preaches freedom to practice religion and then try to limit the rights of religious people — unless those rights infringe on others freedom obviously.

Which leads to the second issue: the barbaric cultural practices hotline. I honestly feel like that was an idea that they thought sounded great in a political back room and didn’t realize just how stupid of an idea it was. We already have a phone number for emergencies like that: 911. All the hotline would have became is “spy on your brown neighbours” — not a great look for the party.

11
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
dunesy•

Looking back at it, there was a lot of shenanigans that garnered media attention.

Harper's economic track record was really the only thing going for him during that time period and the establishment of the TFSA, and the aftermath of the 2008 / 2009 Financial crisis.

Majority of the attacks were directed at the party's lack of transparency (Muzzling scientists, No Press Addresses), and embarrassing blunders (Sen Mike Duffy). There was a lot of outrage.

2
-Sythen-•

This is different than Rempel-Garner apologizing for being a cis gendered heterosexual white woman

It's the same useless virtue signalling.

What we allowed happen in 2014/2015 was an error on our part

You mean by not firing every LPC appointee at the CBC and restoring some credibility to the news? We completely ignored how the media treated the different candidates and it lost us the election.

when were wrong we should admit were wrong

"Hello fellow Conservatives, aren't you all ashamed you don't support Liberal positions? Maybe we should apologize!"

Banning religious attire is antithetical to Conservatism

Banning oppressive and demeaning symbols are necessary for a tolerant society to exist.

we can’t be the party that preaches freedom to practice religion

There are literally women being murdered in the Middle East protesting against the need to wear these coverings. Your ignorance and half truths are getting old.

We already have a phone number for emergencies like that: 911

Again, your half truths are ridiculous. It wasn't an emergency line, it was similar to a battered woman line.

Are you against suicide helplines because 911 deals with those, too? It was a line where members of any religion or skin colour (I know you Liberals love to focus on "brown" people, but it applied to LGBQ people in ultra Orthodox Christian homes, too) could get help and advice if they believed they were in danger.

The police won't, because they legally can't, do anything unless a crime is happening. If you're a woman who doesn't want to adhere to your family's religious practices, and you suspect they are going to "honor kill" you, 911 won't do anything unless they are currently trying to kill you.

-3
ApolloshotOntario•

You’re talking to someone who half of their ancestry is middle eastern Christian. My father had rocks thrown at him by Muslims when going to school. I’m wholly aware of the atrocities carried out in the name of Allah. The office of religious freedom under Harper did fantastic work saving my people and other middle eastern Christians from religious tyranny in Iraq, Iran, and Syria. Thousands of Christians can directly thank their work as the reason they’re alive.

But you’re conflating two different issues. A symbol can represent both freedom and oppression at the same time, and failing or ignoring the context of individual choice is just ignorant.

You boldly claim I speak in half truths but then make an outrageous claim that somehow the hotline would somehow fix the problem when you point out the RCMP can’t do anything? So then what? Is the person on the other end of the hotline going to have extrajudicial authority? If so why not just legislate a law to give police that authority.

Understand now why it doesn’t make sense? Without giving more power to police a hotline provides no more help to women afraid of being honour killed than screaming from a roof top. Your comparison to a suicide hotline is ridiculous and only exposes either your ignorance, stupidity, or both.

I doubt anything I say will change your mind though. Half the time I see you posting on this sub you’re calling other Conservatives Liberals. If you hate the big tent so much maybe go find your own safe space somewhere else with the QAnon people or something.

3
-Sythen-•

"Hurr durr QAnon!"

go find your own safe space somewhere else

If you need a safe space, you're not a Conservative. But I could tell that from your posts. This sub is infested with Leftist shills like you.

Go back to your BlueAnon echo chambers, your conspiracy theories are ridiculous.

-3
ApolloshotOntario•

Apparently you lack reading comprehension too. I’m not the one that need a safe space. I enjoy rigorous debate.

You’re the one that lashes out like a child, defaulting to ad hominem and name calling, which implies you don’t have the emotional stability to engage in meaningful discussion, which means you need a safe space.

3
Sher_Singh1947•

Ok, so who decides what an oppressive and demeaning symbol is?

My Kirpan is a 3ft sabre..

I wear a Turban in a government job & you had certain styles be attacked for being 'extremist' not too long ago.

Will it just be educated white people who decide what's passé? What about when they no longer have power. Riddle me this,

ਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕਾਖਾਲਸਾਵਾਹਿਗੁਰੂਜੀਕੀਫਤਿਹ

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

6
dunesy•

They do this all the time, but it was objectively slammed by all the non-conservative parties.

3
cc88gradCanadian Thatcher•

And the funny thing is that I can't even remember that bill lol

1
AcanianIndependent•

Full disclosure here, I'm not at all a conservative, but I've recently become politically homeless federally after stints with the NDP and Green, which have left me disaffected. I dislike the current iterations of all of our federal parties.

As such, I'm following attentively movements from across the political spectrum to see if there's anything decent anywhere that would make me want to move there, either temporarily or permanently, under new leadership. So take the following with that in mind.

I'm extremely baffled and concerned to see a bunch of CPC MPs, from Tim Uppal to Michelle Rempel Garner, flat out disavow their previous stances on controversial but important issues. Like the whole niqab citizenship matter.

Whilst I couldn't abide the way the CPC campaign seemed to pile on muslim-related issue after muslim-related issue in 2015, with the useless "barbaric cultural practices hotline" (911 exists) in 2015, it doesn't mean that individual proposals such as the niqab ban don't deserve further appraisal. 90%+ of Canadians will remain anti-niqab. Plenty of countries with different political, religious and ethnic demographics (some of them muslim majority) have enacted restrictions.

So, what, is the CPC just going to cede ground to the other parties on these issues? To be clear, I believe that the CPC was needlessly divisive in a bunch of ways when in power and since their time in opposition. First thing that comes to mind is that M-103 debacle. It's unconscionable that condemning Islamophobia couldn't pass so so soon after the 2017 mosque attack. But I worry that many are using the recent anti-muslim tragedy to silence needed discussions. And these questions should persist regardless of increased online radicalization and unfortunate tragedies.

5
Own_Carrot_7040•

Doesn't seem to matter what ordinary people want. A poll taken around the time of the last Tory leadership campaign showed over 80% of conservative supporters wanted lower immigration. Not a single candidate took that position, and O'Toole has enthusiastically embraced immigration at whatever number Justin Trudeau decides it should be.

1
AcanianIndependent•

When I was still with the NDP, this is what I heard about the 2015 immigration debate, from an NDP MP :"The CPC and NDP came up with their immigration targets, then the Liberal strategist told our NDP strategist that they were going to exceed whatever targets the NDP had just put, just to brag about being more "open" and pro-immigration". In other words, Liberal policy-making was more about image than intelligent reasoning.

2015 was an abnormality re: the prioritization of immigration during the campaign. Subsequent polls have shown that this is at the bottom of priorities of most Canadians. Being in Atlantic Canada, I tend to favour more immigration to our region because of our aging population.

But I believe that immigration targets should be decentralized by region, and only adopted with population buy-in. And I certainly believe targets ought to have a rationale, and that rationale, worthy of discussion. Unfortunately it seems we're stuck with politicians going either "lower immigration, just because" or "increase immigration, just because", with no thoughtful debate behind the targets.

2
-Sythen-•

First thing that comes to mind is that M-103 debacle.

If you want to live in a police state, fuck off to North Korea. Canadians need a Constitution that absolutely defends free speech and we don't have that. Any further attacks on free speech must be met with total opposition no matter the subject.

-1
AcanianIndependent•

M-103 was simply about condemning anti-muslim hate. Not about anything else. Certainly not about introducing some loony tune kind of police state.

2
-Sythen-•

If you're gonna shill, you should at least read the text of the Bill first.

Bolds mine:

That, in the opinion of the House, the government should: (a) recognize the need to quell the increasing public climate of hate and fear; (b) condemn Islamophobia and all forms of systemic racism and religious discrimination and take note of House of Commons’ petition e-411 and the issues raised by it; and (c) request that the Standing Committee on Canadian Heritage undertake a study on how the government could (i) develop a whole-of-government approach to reducing or eliminating systemic racism and religious discrimination including Islamophobia, in Canada, while ensuring a community-centered focus with a holistic response through evidence-based policy-making, (ii) collect data to contextualize hate crime reports and to conduct needs assessments for impacted communities, and that the Committee should present its findings and recommendations to the House no later than 240 calendar days from the adoption of this motion, provided that in its report, the Committee should make recommendations that the government may use to better reflect the enshrined rights and freedoms in the Constitution Acts, including the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

Giving the government power to "quell" poorly defined and politically driven behaviour, especially considering they specify anti-Islam and conveniently leave out anti-Christian behaviour, then that is a police state.

When the government can decide, arbitrarily, that your behaviour is "increasing public climate of hate and fear", and remember this is from a group that says criticizing someone's opinions is racism if that person isn't white, then that is disgusting and anyone who supports that isn't a Conservative.

Add onto that, the Bill was put forward by an illegal immigrant who received no penalty for lying on immigration forms, and who is a sitting MP it amounts to gross government overreach.

1
twobelowpar•

This narrative that the Harper era was divisive compared to other eras is just insane.

5
-Sythen-•

You need to realize that the mods here, as well as most of the posters, are Leftist shills. The nonsense and talking points spewed here by most people are ridiculous.

1
splashfactorOPNova Scotia•

Uh oh people have different opinions than you, they must be shills.

If we were really all lefties, you'd be banned for your bigoted opinions.

3
-Sythen-•

If you're spouting Leftist rhetoric and attacking Conservative views, you're not a Conservative. And since you try to claim to be one, you're just a shill trying to spread lies.

I'm glad you agree that Leftists always try to ban everyone to create a safe space for their fragile selves.

0
Sodadog1900🇨🇦Tory🇨🇦•

Lol

Groupthink and group thought, eh? No one can ever have a view outside the orthodox or else they’re a traitor and a leftist?

Get outa here, let’s not turn this subreddit into a groupthink r/politics clone. Let’s be reasonable, conservatives have room to disagree with each other. We’re not dogmatic that’s what makes us conservative.

Go to r/metacanada if you don’t wanna think and just wanna have a hard right circle jerk.

1
Own_Carrot_7040•

See, the way it works is you're divisive if you take any positions which offend the Left. But if you're the government and take all kinds of positions which offend the Right, well that's good! That's certainly not divisive!

1
Own_Carrot_7040•

Maybe if we were a little more choosy in who we let immigrate we wouldn't need such a tip line. Other countries try to weed out people whose religiously inspired social beliefs and values make them unlikely to adapt easily to a western culture. But Canada is too noble. We don't ask anyone any questions. Hate Jews? We don't care. Think any woman showing bare shoulders is a whore who deserves to be raped? Here's your passport! Want gays imprisoned or killed? Welcome to Canada!

Our system just processes the paperwork, and does it so fast there's often little time to even verify if those university credentials or job reports are accurate or forged. Certainly no time to do an actual interview to find out what sort of person we're inviting into our home. And why? Because that would presume we believe our culture and values better than theirs. And we can't have that! The very idea that we might take pride in Canada and think our values are better than that of the people of Pakistan or Afghanistan is so... racist!

1
[deleted]•

I can see how that tipline was an extremely poor idea for a campaign but in all honesty ISIS was at their peak. We had droves of Muslim Canadians leaving to fight for them. We had weekly domestic terror attacks and even a parliament shooter. It's not divisive politics, it's homeland security. Then when the proud boys in another country go out and stir some shit up with some equally charged idiots, the liberals place them in the same category as ISIS. If that's not divisive politics, I don't know what is. A stupid little club that was made to go fight SJWs at protests are lumped in with people who kidnap and behead others is actually clearly divisive but if you disagree with logic, you become a racist and divisive... Like why wasn't there a tipline for judaic extremism? Why not Christian extremists? Hindu extremists? Sikh extremists? This is becuase there was no threat or evidence of a potential threat from these communities. Uppal is clearly pandering but for what reason it's not very clear.

-1
Sher_Singh1947•

Yea, but it creates a precedent for there to be a tip line for everyone but the ruling Anglo upper middle class

1
[deleted]•

Not at all. It set a precedent that the government would crack down on Islamic terror in the Canadian Islamic community. I mean look at the precedent now, fight for Isis and get a free poetry lessons in the name of diversity.

1