Terms like CIS and other feminist attempts to define the sexuality of Men .

Ive been looking through everything and a couple of other threads today and a few things caught my eye, and its usually the following . 1, what the feck is CIS genderd, I am no Cis genderd, im a Hetrosexual Male . 2, I keep seeing articles claiming that if a man finds a woman who fits within the slim, attractive categories we are considerd sexist . 3, If we dont find there definitions of what a woman should be attractive we are pretty much the usual list of all things mysoginist.

Im baffled as to why women are empowerd by choosing there own sexuality as its there own but they feel that they are entitled to define ours with no hint of irony ....... why is this ?

Posted Jan 2, 2012, 7:24 PM UTC

060
[deleted]•

[deleted]

28
Scott2508OP•

you really need to read more of what I said , that was a discussion about the attempts to define male sexuality and in a conversation about and ill quote the heading of this thread " terms like CIS and other feminist attempts to define the sexuality of MEN".. the other thread about radfems excluding transwomen is the thread about trans, not this one

-10
[deleted]•

not defining the sexuality. why are you having such a difficult time separating gender identity and sexual orientation in your head?

also cis is not a term specific to men. there are cis men and cis women, so i guess maybe your confusion has to do with your own internalised trans man erasure?

14
Scott2508OP•

so as well as a bigot you are a moron ...... this isnt the discussion about transgender, thats a different one , this is a discussion about women defining the sexuality of men , transgender men in terms of what it would take to actually do that justice would require something much more than this thread ( and an interesting one considering the clieu becker and the physical aspects in relation to gender orientation but not the discussion on this thread ) , we are talking about women telling us that finding certain things attractive wrong , its a co opt and is totally unfair .

-10
HarrietPotter•

this is a discussion about women defining the sexuality of men

No it fucking isn't. Did you read anything teefs said?

12
[deleted]•

you really need to read more of what I said

I would but it hurts my brain and makes no sense.

2
[deleted]•

Your entire first point is nonsensical. CIS and TRANS are some feminist conspiracy words to define male sexuality. In fact, they have little to do with sexuality. They are words to define gender. Think of it this way:

Heterosexuality and Homosexuality are terms used to define sexual preference. Male and Female are terms used to define biological sex and thus correspond to heterosexual and homosexual. You could be a heterosexual male or a homosexual male (and other categories not listed here).

CIS and TRANS and words to define gender identity. Man and Woman are words to also describe gender identity and thus correspond to CIS and TRANS. You could be a trans-man or a cis-man.

23
Brutal_Antipathy•

I believe the actual term before feminist lesbian 'scholars' decided to redefine it we used, and for the most part continue to use, gender normative. If that happens to offend someone, perhaps heterogender is more applicable.

-1
hardwarequestions•

this was my understanding as well. not sure what about "gender normative" made turned them away from it as it serves its purpose just fine.

-1
Brutal_Antipathy•

I think that those who fail to fall into the majority gender roles are offended by the (correct) implication that the majority gender roles are the norm. These are usually the same people that insist that gender roles are social constructs despite ample contradictory evidence.

2
hardwarequestions•

agreed.

4
Unconfidence•

Dude, I don't think it's going to be possible to evidence that gender roles aren't social constructs. The fact is, gender itself, much less gender roles, is only recognized by difference; if there had never been any women, men would not think of themselves as men. The very idea that men and women are different and have different traditional roles implies that these roles are constructed in light of social interaction. I mean, there are some things which aren't constructed, but which are just a part of biology. But much of what we know as gender in a modern sense is just a construct of society and social norms.

And I think it's a very important thing for people to get upset when they are marginalized because they aren't the majority. It's okay when it's just you saying "Heterosexual is normal", but it never quite stops there. Normalcy is used as a guidepost for policy, and when policy reflects normalcy, it detriments the abnormal. So it's understandable that homosexuals are upset by heterosexuality being called the norm; it was precisely heterosexuality being viewed as the only normal relationship which led to the persecution of homosexuals for the past few centuries. The same goes for transgender people.

3
Scott2508OP•

southern . you missed the point my issue is that these are being used at all .... everyone has the right to be who they want to be , by insisting that people behave in certain ways depending on what box they fit is about as backward thinking as we can be , and , ill apoligise for the frankness of this next part but its the only way i can think to get the point across ...... if i am told I am wrong for finding a woman attractive based round attributes i enjoy and that i am some form of fucking anti christ for not finding someone who is unattractive to me attractive simply because feminists claim i should is not just patronising but also totally fucking hypocritcal.

-7
[deleted]•

And the point you were trying to make is lost int he fact that you dont understand the terms you are railing against. Like it or not, words have certain meaning and we use those words to accurately communicate aspects of reality between individuals.

everyone has the right to be who they want to be , by insisting that people behave in certain ways depending on what box they fit is about as backward thinking as we can be

And this has shit to do with your complaints about the word CIS. However you decide to behave or express yourself, eventually there will be a word that is used to describe those actions or behaviors.

11
Scott2508OP•

it has everything to do with it , again going back to srs the number of times its used as a derogatory term and as long as something labels me that i didnt choose and is used by others in a manner that is ethically repugnant to me i am entitled to dislike it .

-4
[deleted]•

again going back to srs the number of times its used as a derogatory term

Yes, they use it derogatorily the same way the use "white" and "male" as insults. That doesn't change the fact that the word itself is an accurate descriptive word that is neutral in its definition.

as long as something labels me that i didnt choose

It doesn't really matter whether or not you chose it if it accurately describes you. You are, in fact, cis-gendered. The fact that SRS finds that to be awful is their problem.

5
thelittleking•

Cis doesn't define sexuality, it defines your mental identity in relation to your body.

A cisgender individual identifies as what they are, in comparison to a transgender individual who identifies as what they are not.

Your failing to understand this, alongside your horrible spelling, makes you likely trollbait. Try harder.

15
Scott2508OP•

king, its common knowledge gaelic is my first language , i am well aware of what the term is supposed to mean, when it shows up in peer reviwed material and psychological journals ill buy into it , until then its a worthless term .

-8
[deleted]•

Oh look at this

Edit: Downvotes, really?

15
thelittleking•

Here and here.

Now fuck off, troll.

12
Scott2508OP•

so two google searches based around self identified situations with no actual studies to back them up , not really what i was talking about .

-8
thelittleking•

These are google scholar searches. They are, by definition, scholarly articles. They are studies, you fucking superdense moron. ARGH.

17
Unconfidence•

You know, I love all these people claiming that "They're trying to redefine my gender!"

So, if I call a duck a "Jimmy", is that redefining duck? No, it's just calling something another term. It doesn't change who you are, or how you're perceived. You didn't complain when someone said you were "A Man", or even when someone said (possibly) that you were "Straight". Did you choose the word straight? Or man? Or cisgendered? Did transgender people choose that term? Or gay people?

It's not an attack on you, this isn't a feminist plot. I'm an ardent MRA, but this shit is absolutely ridiculous. If this is all we have to fight against, we really are a movement with no real issues.

5
Demonspawn•

Im baffled as to why women are empowerd by choosing there own sexuality as its there own but they feel that they are entitled to define ours with no hint of irony ....... why is this ?

Why? Because Feminism was a giant society-wide shit test and we, as men, failed it and have allowed women to run all over us. So they will keep pushing further and further until either men snap back or women destroy the system.

3
Scott2508OP•

thats why we fight , its funny I tried an experiment tonight on facebook , i posted 30 mother in law jokes , the only person who found it offensive was a man , everyone who clicked like was a woman.

-3
ghebert001•

If we dont find there definitions of what a woman should be attractive we are pretty much the usual list of all things mysoginist.

They do this for the same reason they want to rid the world of pornography and prostitution...they think they can't get a date because men have other options and they want to be men's only option even if they are horrible human beings who would just make a man's life miserable anyway.

1
JeremiahMRA•

Just wanted to say I agree that "cis" is a bullshit, unnecessary, and intentionally marginalizing term.

-2
Brutal_Antipathy•

Thank you, Scott. I made this point, albeit with humor, just a while ago. Humor aside, I refuse to sit idle while those not my sex decide to redefine what I am.

-3
Scott2508OP•

I watched a chapins vid earlier today that was about women trying to define mens sexuality to suit themselves and there own egos and the fact that this is a to quote Demonspawn "a shit test" , Its part of what draws me to the masculinisim side of things, the only person who should be allowed to define you is you , for some to hold the right of self autonomy as vital yet are guilty of trying to take it from others is a hypocrite pure and simple.

0
hardwarequestions•

but...but...we have to define and label EVERYTHING! that's the only way for us to gauge just how tolerant and advanced we are.

/s

-4
Brutal_Antipathy•

Can you imagine a form of communication that exists without definitions? If you go to a store and ask for potatoes and they give you bananas while explaining that they can call bananas whatever they want, there is a serious breakdown in communication via definition there. We define because we could not communicate otherwise. Only idiots think it silly to define things.

2
hardwarequestions•

Only idiots think it silly to define things.

thanks for calling me an idiot while simultaneously showing your low reading comprehension skills.

my mockery implies over-defining is silly, not defining alone. perhaps your brain will understand the concept if we use the word "label" instead. labeling many things is important and neccessary, but eventually a bored society will begin to overlabel things out of run-amuck oversensitivity and continued desire to please every little subgroup who wants to be different from everyone else.

-1
Brutal_Antipathy•

Thanks for insulting my reading comprehension while demonstrating your ineptitude at grasping simple concepts.

My insulting of idiots that reject definitions was directed at your actual statement, not whatever you conceived in your mind for your statement to imply, or perhaps what you later chose to redact for purpose of argument. Perhaps your brain will understand the concept if we use the words "Write with clarity" instead.

As for pleasing 'every little subgroup'...shall we then continue to employ the terms fag, dyke, sissy? After all, those are simply little subgroups, right?

3
hardwarequestions•

awww, you can dish it out but can't take it?

you seem to be the only one who didn't grasp my statements implication. indeed, you seem to have applied your own beliefs onto it. that's your problem.

fag, dyke, sissy

those first two have been near-universally rejected by the groups they supposedly even apply to, so no. "sissy" is a term preferred by those it truly applies to, so sure, if you want to. not sure what derogatory terms have to do with anything else we're discussing in this thread though. perhaps just more of your own issues coming out.

please return to the topic at hand...non-derogatory terms being applied to a group who has yet to validate them.

-2
tailcalled•

There's nothing wrong with defining what your labels mean, but you are correct that there shouldn't be a label for every concept.

1
hardwarequestions•

thank you. that was essentially my point.

0
tailcalled•

Then you shouldn't have written

define and label

0
hardwarequestions•

true point.

0
Brutal_Antipathy•

Let's not forget how vulgar and unacceptable I would be considered were I to refer to a cross dressed man that takes a subservient role as a "Sissy" despite their willingly adopting that title themselves and not considering it to be in any way derogatory. And so it is a morally superior position to consider the term cis to be offensive as it is not one that we chose ourselves.

-5
Scott2508OP•

even more ironic considering some of srs and amr's loudest voices are in the bdsm and D/s community and as such know these things yet still misrepresent in an attempt to find bigotry .

0
Brutal_Antipathy•

You've no idea just how fempowered the BDSM commiunity is. Their mockery of power exchange is so ridiculous that I created the terms Overbottom and Undertop to distinguish where the real authority lies in it.

0
Scott2508OP•

oh no I do , I have a LOT of friends in it , i even know a few MRA ... its in many ways the most openly honest group of people I have met .

0
[deleted]•

'Transsexual' is disingenuous as it physically impossible to change your biological sex. Likewise gender is a social construct; an effeminate man has every right to mutilate his body and take hormones however this does not make him a women. Transsexuals like to demean what it means to be a man or a woman in a similar way to white people dressing in blackface. In addition terms such as cis (sissy?) have popped up as an attempt to shame natural born men and women.

Transsexual love and tolerance!

-13
Brutal_Antipathy•

There is research which demonstrates that gender is biochemical, as in the case of David Reimer. If you have research which indicates that it is a social product, please present it.

11
Scott2508OP•

wow , complete and total pish . hijras ( sp ) have been around for centuries, in many eastern cultures transexuals are revered and they have co-existed with non transfolk with no problems, its only the west , and to a great extent modern west that has issues with it , centuries ago the genders were blurred , look back at bonnie prince charlies time so sorry your full of shit. I disagree with the term CIS , but as i said its because its used as a label and i find the idea of others labelling and defining people abhorrent , we apparently live in a culture where autonomy of oneself is demanded, yet only natural born women have this, and blackface , that is a bullshit strawman , if you are using blackface the only comparitive is either drag queens or panto dames, blackface was used by people to imitate black people for the purpose of humour , transgederd people are actually born into the wrong body, massive fucking difference.

2
TheOtherSarah•

I very badly want to address your claims, but can't think of a way to explain that won't turn into an argument. So I'll just let you know that "cis" just means the opposite of "trans", no matter what word it's attached to, and is used that way in several fields that have nothing to do with this; if someone is trying to use the word to shame others, that person is no less bigoted than anyone they dislike, and should not be considered representative of the community (every group has a few intolerant people).

1