r/bikewrench•
420boy

Crankset first, then new BB? Upgrading from cup and cone to cartridge bottom bracket.

I rescued an abandoned vintage mountain bike with a cup and cone square taper bottom bracket. The left crank was missing and the spindle was rusted out. I want to replace it with a cartridge BB. The original spindle is 3N aka 120mm and asymmetrical. Sheldon Brown says the symmetrical cartridge equivalent is 124mm.

It seems like the cranks determine optimal BB length. Let me know if I'm understanding correctly: if I use the crank that was originally on the bike, a 124mm cartridge would fit, but if I bought a different crank, that size BB might end up being too long or short?

Should I get a crankset first, then measure for chainline and try to figure out ideal BB length that way? Or is the 124mm a safe enough bet for any crankset I'd use? I would be keeping the triple chainring setup that the bike was originally made for whether I get a different crankset or not.

Bottom bracket service is outside of my personal bike wrenching experience (aside from one piece cranks), and I've been taking in so much information these past few days I'm beginning to get overwhelmed and probably overcomplicating things.

Posted Jun 16, 2021, 11:24 AM UTC

23
UrIsNotAWord•

It seems like the cranks determine optimal BB length.

This is correct.

Let me know if I'm understanding correctly: if I use the crank that was originally on the bike, a 124mm cartridge would fit,

It might work, and it might be optimum (chainline-wise). But I know from experience that "translating" a cup-and-cone BB spindle to the equivalent cartridge BB spindle length via the Sheldon Brown table does not always result in an optimum chainline.

but if I bought a different crank, that size BB might end up being too long or short?

Yes, because it is the design of the crankset that determines the optimum BB spindle length.

Should I get a crankset first, then measure for chainline and try to figure out ideal BB length that way?

Yes, this is the way.

Note: Some replacement cranksets come with a recommended cartridge BB spindle length, which makes it possible to order the new crankset AND the new BB at the same time.

Or is the 124mm a safe enough bet for any crankset I'd use?

Nope, this is NOT the way!!!

4
420boyOP•

Got it. I'm finding some modern triple cranksets that state the BB size they should pair with so I'll be going with that. Thanks for Ur help ;)

1

I'd say that 124mm is a safe enough bet. With square taper cranks, any measurement you do for chainline before installing a bottom bracket would be an approximation in any case. Since you're keeping a triple chainring set-up (and therefore a front derailleur) chainline is less of an issue than it would be going to a 1-by.

1