The Death of the Long Sentence?

I admit I haven't read enough - or widely enough -literature from the past 50 years or so to really know, but I seem to remember a few years back reading an article concerning the dearth of long sentences in contemporary literature - to its detriment. If anyone knows of something like this, please link it below!

I also admit that when I come across very long sentences in writers like Proust, Woolf and Henry James, I've found them somewhat irritating and cumbersome to follow, but I don't know if that's only due to the fact that I'm not used to them. Regarding Proust alone, I seem to find it easier to parse his prose the deeper I get into his work (though this case probably depends a lot on translation too). I do find that a long sentence with many clauses has its own effect - like leading you through a twisting alleyway - that it would lose if broken up into smaller parts.

Do you guys think there's a notable lack of long sentences, and if so, is this a bad thing?

Posted Jun 21, 2021, 9:33 AM UTC

5654
asanandyou•

Another recent award-winning novel, 1,000 pages in a single sentence, is this one. "Ducks, Newburyport has won the £10,000 Goldsmiths prize for “fiction at its most novel”, praised by judges as a “masterpiece”.

Ducks, Newburyport wins £10,000 prize for fiction

29
JoaoMau-Tempo•

Iirc it technically isn’t a single sentence novel, sometimes the main narrative stops and tells the tell of a lioness. But yeah it is pretty close to a single sentence.

8
asanandyou•

I guess it's just the claim then. I started the book but couldn't find traction. You?

5
so_sadsWilliam H. Gass•

I had the same experience. I read about 70 pages of it (given, this isn't very much) and for a moment felt like I could get into it, but the repetitiveness was definitely more a chore than anything else. I would experience brief moments where it felt like I was gliding along the prose sort of hypnotized by the repetitive syntax, and this was a cool feeling, but I couldn't sustain it, and I didn't want to go back to it because it felt like it was just going to be more of the same for 900 pages.

10
JoaoMau-Tempo•

As I said it is pretty close to a single sentence novel so I get the narrative pushed.

I actually loved it. It left me this feeling of overthinking and anxiety. I read it in early 202 while I was studying and it really hit me with all the stuff I was processing. College stuff, personal life, trying to make new friendships, family, getting engaged in politics and trying to find who I am, all this was too much for me and I would constantly overthink every single thing going on without being able to focus on each at a time. I wanted to read more literature but then I also had to do this work for college and I had to listen to family problems, all this left me exhausted and I would simply flip flop through all these thoughts without giving them proper time or dealing with them. All this overload of information, reading more and more depressing news. I actually started reading it in January 2020 when the Covid news started and I remember getting so angry and exhausted with the narrative that it was a Chinese lab made virus created to conquer the world. When I read this book, the writing style was exactly how I was feeling. Just one huge mess of different kinds of thoughts all mixed together: going from wondering what I want to have for lunch to “my relationship is falling apart” as if both had the same importance and deserved the same amount of consideration.

I’m sorry for the rant, 2020 was a rough year and while I read it before Covid hit in my country, it certainly helped me with the lockdown as I felt that someone gets me, someone feels like how I feel in the current state of the world. I get this not being a book for everyone and I don’t intend to say it in a pretentious manner; the writing style is either something you love or hate. I wouldn’t even recommend to push through some more pages as I don’t think that will make you fall in love with it. In my opinion this is a book for a certain time and place in a person’s life and only then should it be read.

4
asanandyou•

Thank you for your excellent review! Your comments are very helpful and empathetic.

3
AntiquesChodeShowAiiieeeee!•

I've been really interested to read this book for a while. Part of what's turning me off is an interview with the author.

7
OxygenCrab•

I think she comes across as intelligent and humorous in that interview. Not quite seeing the issue.

5
Nessyliz•

Alright, took a little break and just came back and finished that interview. It was definitely humorous and entertaining, but I can see why it would bother a person for sure.

You watch people get pregnant and know they’ll be emotionally and intellectually absent for 20 years. Thought, knowledge, adult conversation and vital political action are all put on hold while this needless perpetuation of the species is prioritised. Having babies is a strong impulse, a forgivable one, but it’s also just a habit, a tradition, like weddings or putting butter on popcorn.

Really? Criticizing perpetuating the species, sure, I'm down with that, logically it's not the most sensible or ethical thing to do, but I think it's a stretch to assume moms will be emotionally and intellectually absent for 20 years. For someone who is constantly bringing up sexism in that interview that's a pretty fucking sexist viewpoint. Also one of her pros about having kids was getting to relive your own childhood and play with toys? Okay. I mean I guess that's cool and all but it definitely doesn't top my list of the most rewarding things about being a parent.

ETA: Basically this writer comes across as a bit of an edgelord. Nothing new for writers haha, but I think I prefer Lionel Shriver for my edgelord controversial opinions.

9
AssuredFrank•

what's wrong with perpetuating the species?

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Ethost•

Reading the interview, I personally felt as if her politics somewhat overemphasized the importance of the patriarchy in comparison with other institutions; I got the sense that, in her world, things would fundamentally be in a much better place if only women and men had swapped places in the social hierarchy, leaving all other axes of oppression intact. It's a sort of idealistic or reductive view, I'd say, and many men will be repelled by even the slightest insinuation of it.

Some particulars: in what way might patriarchy be behind the "the big divide ... between mothers and daughters"? Should "women rule collectively" and (implicitly) exclusively? Are prehistoric matriarchal societies really only called prehistoric because they "predate male rule"? Maybe this is all satire, but I can see how people would be turned off by it—if only just enough to pass on the 1000 page, 1 sentence door-stopper.

3
Nessyliz•

I am a woman and I also thought some of her points were a bit strange. Is she for real that she'd like to see women venerated in her hypothetical Utopia, or was she just joking? I couldn't really tell. If she's real that's just dumb imo. Also the mother/daughter divide? Not something I've seen in my life among my friends and family at all. I don't get that that's a thing.

Anyone that comes to the conclusion that things would be super different if this group of humans were in charge instead of that one I will always just fundamentally disagree with. I think humans are much more similar than we are different, with all of our foibles and lesser traits.

I find it strange that someone could read older books and come to the conclusion that life (or at least human nature) was markedly different then. I come to the exact opposite conclusion. It always amazes me how little humanity changes, for better or for worse.

Philosophically I found myself disagreeing with a lot of what she had to say. On a minor note she also considers exercise a "supposed form of self-improvement actually just meant to bug people", and I'm a hobbyist athlete haha, so yeah, different worldviews indeed.

3
Nessyliz•

Maybe because she's a contemporary writer with lots of plaudits shitting on other contemporary writers who get lots of plaudits? It is a bit weird, presumably she thinks readers should read her books, but otherwise we should all be reading Kafka or something and skipping anything new? I mean as a gossipy person who loves in-group drama I found her complaining about the clique-ishness of British writers pretty entertaining, but I can see where it rubs people the wrong way. I also got that she made some valid points in there too of course.

2
asanandyou•

I recently read Solar Bones (2016), a single-sentence novel. It was brilliant and memorable. The author commented -

McCormack, 51, called on more publishers to take risks with experimental authors.

"Readers are smart. They're up for it," he said.

"That was what the people at Tramp Press taught me. There are readers out there and they have been proved right."

Goldsmiths Prize: Single sentence novel wins £10,000 award

21

Solar Bones is beautiful, glad it got the attention.

7
asanandyou•

I was quite swept into the work. After a time, the lack of periods became a non-issue. There are sensible paragraphs and spacings of sections after all. Speaking to other potentially interested readers, if you enjoy richly poetic prose (as I do) it's something special.

4

It's poetic but moreover McCormack manages to do all this in the voice of a middle-aged civil engineer working for the county council, dealing with bridges and where to store spoil heaps and all that, who is proud but concerned and confused about his daughter's art installation, as 'normal' a character as you could imagine. It's quite a feat.

11
asanandyou•

So true, a good reminder. Another aspect of his story that penetrated deeply had to do with the manner of perceiving the places and scenes of the countryside in the writing, through all the perceptions; and without giving anything away, the intensity builds.

3
exponentialismOP•

Thanks that book sounds interesting!

I was thinking more of general trends (though that's a lot harder to measure) than of extreme outliers like that novel though.

2
asanandyou•

Right, my posts, those books, are examples of tangential trend-busters. How many years has it been now that the term "long-form reading" has been in play? When I first heard this term I was shocked - what? So, novels, novellas, and substantial literary magazine essays - all in this group?

Long-form reading has become a choice to be eschewed, by habit. This is what I first thought of, reading your post - it's not just the sentences, it's the forms and formats, the whole ball of wax that's a casualty of the new virtual attention economy. Johnathan Haidt and Tristan Harris are two prominent authors who address the phenomenon. It would take a historically-based chronological corpus-collocational study with a massive database to answer the long-sentence question accurately, within as well each genre of interest. Not a bad topic for graduate study.

2
exponentialismOP•

I'll be interested to see future writing and analysis of it.

I've been thinking a lot recently about the effects recent changes in the way the average person consumes media may have on art in general, not just writing. Maybe it's always this way, but if someone asked me what I thought from our current age would be remembered in 100 years I would have absolutely no idea.

2
Unique_Office5984•

You might be thinking of this essay by Gerald Murnane, who writes some of the most beautiful long sentences around:

https://meanjin.com.au/essays/in-praise-of-the-long-sentence/

20
exponentialismOP•

This isn't what I was thinking of, but thanks for the link!

I don't agree with much of his value judgements, but it's an interesting point of view to read - I particularly like the distinction between "film-script fiction" and "meditative fiction".

3

José Saramago is a pretty popular writer and he's all about those long sentences, if not to the same extent as some of the other authors mentioned here. They're key to his style, can't imagine what he'd read like without them. Probably fits into the class of sentence/non-sentence that Murnane disapproves of in the other linked piece though.

15
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
137-trimetilxantin•

Krasznahorkai is doing long sentences, Esterházy has a one-sentence novel, and I've come across others in the page-long range that were borderline more natural than normal length sentences.

I don't think it has much raison d'etre in itself, but it can be used as a tool to express long interlinked thought-precesses and probably other things as well.

11
exponentialismOP•

I don't think it has much raison d'etre in itself,

I don't either, I see it just as a tool to create a certain effect, but I do think it could have wider repercussions if your average book neglects longer sentences, many don't get used to reading them and may struggle to parse them - but this is supposing that there is a trend of shorter sentences.

2

Completely depends on the skill of the author, whether it fits the style, the story and all that. As with everything, it can be done bad or well and I personally don't put much importance on singular stylistic technique. There is time and place for both long and short sentences.

From personal standpoint of yet-to-be-published writer I feel that long sentence is somewhat done. I don't feel I have much to contribute to that style with authors like Bernhard and Krasznahorkai looming over it. On contrary, I feel like my own personal style will be found rather in paring down things, sentence lenghts, lenght of chapters, novels. Moving to the opposite direction of the long sentence, long book and other such things.

9
Batenzelda•

I’d argue that long sentences don’t necessarily go against a minimal style. Have you read any of Jon Fosse’s prose works? I’m just wondering because in his later works he starts eschewing periods, leading to novel-long sentences. And yet, he doesn’t have a complicated style like Krasznahorkai or Bernhard; instead, it’s rather simple, compressed and minimalist.

4

No, i havent. Nothing by Fosse has been translated into finnish as far as I know and due to financial situation I cannot afford new books, although I avoid buying softcovers as much as possible and based on cursory look nothing by Fosse has been released in hardback in english either.

1
exponentialismOP•

There is time and place for both long and short sentences.

Agreed, but what do you mean by "somewhat done"?

2

That should be taken as a personal feeling or subjective feeling rather than as an objective criticism. As I explained, I just personally feel that at least I don't personally see how I could stylistically create something new or move foward with the long sentence since it has been done so well already. In general, my preferences in literature has turned from the long, difficult and big into short, simple and easy to understand, not necessarily structurally or thematically but languagewise. Ive developed this taste for minimalistic writing and short books, doing more with less.

1
MorelliBuendia•

"Los santos inocentes" by Miguel Delibes has two or three stops in the whole book, which are in very specific, intentional moments, and I like that one a lot.

Any great author knows how to play with the length of sentences to evoque different feelings and change the flow of the narrative.

I think Ulysses, which is one of my favorite books, is a masterclass when it comes to making you feel a thousand different ways, not because of what is happening, which is mostly common stuff, but because of the way it is narrated, the rhythm, the length of the sentences, the aliterations... Beautiful book.

7
pancakes_inthehouseDany Laferrière•

almost all of these "its 1,000 pages in one sentence" books are sort of full of shit. The last sentence of ulysses is not one sentence. Aesthtetically a choice was made not to use punctuation.

That's not 1 sentence. Thats an aesthetic choic to avoid punctuation. I have a hard time imagining any linguist listenining to Molly out loud and saying, "She just said one sentence. of course that's one sentence."

2
agusohyeah•

There was an Argentine writer called Juan José Saer who wrote throughout the XX century and he wrote really long sentences, whole pages. Really good.

6
The_CoreIIian•

Call it by its name, Hypotaxis

6
songs-of-love•

There's obviously the issue of writers going almost entirely unnoticed until after they pass, which has been a phenomenon affecting literature for centuries. I'm curious if it could be linked to creative writing courses and the like giving more merit to "invisible prose" as it tends to be more easily marketable than heavily stylized writing (frankly speaking: I'm parroting what I've read on here, this topic isn't my area of expertise my any means - if this isn't a recent phenomenon or is totally inaccurate I'd love to know!).

Either way, Krasznahorkai is a great example of what you're looking for - his sentences are immaculate. He's one of the only contemporary authors that I care enough to keep track of, along with Pynchon.

6
AbbathOccultaWilliam Burroughs•

As you've noted, this was mostly a phenomenon of the late 1800s and early 1900s. James is referred to as pre-Modernist by some lit historians (or, at least, experimental) and of course Woolf and Proust are experimental in their own ways. I dont find long sentences especially interesting, myself.

5†
exponentialismOP•

Do you know if people found the long sentences of those authors hard to parse when they were first released?

I suppose I'm wondering if complaining about the difficulty of parsing long sentences is a more recent phenomenon, which if so could be due to people not being used to reading them. Moving away from behemoth modernist sentences, I feel even looking at popular nineteenth century authors like Dickens and Austen, their sentences were notably longer on average than your average novel today, but I could easily just be wrong.

3
AbbathOccultaWilliam Burroughs•

They arent longer, no. It just depends on who you are reading. Also, punctuation use and conventions have changed, so this is part of it, too. Trollope and Dickens wrote what we would typically call normal sentence length. Austen or Burney or Radcliffe might use a whole host of semi-colons, technically lengthening the sentence, but really just cramming a bunch of shorter sentences together.

I work on editing some older books, and one thing you find is that there is also no small attention paid to page use, since it costs more to have your characters get a new line for each speech action or a writer to divide paragraphs up more frequently than needed. I dont know about the original written manuscripts, but you certainly see it in older texts as a way to converge space.

3
exponentialismOP•

I suppose part of what makes me wonder if they were longer is the difficulties many seem to have with older prose - to take the example of Dickens, a very popular author in his day and not typically seen as a laborious read, yet you only have to look at an r/askreddit thread about books people hated studying to see many seemed to find the prose difficult and overly wordy.

Thanks for the information - this part:

since it costs more to have your characters get a new line for each speech action or a writer to divide paragraphs up more frequently than needed.

I found particularly interesting - I've noticed reading Proust, at least my translation often has two characters "speaking" on one paragraph which can occasionally be a little confusing - do you think this may be why? I don't remember seeing this in any other novels from around that time I've read.

2
AbbathOccultaWilliam Burroughs•

People are just unfamiliar with the style of language. Also, in general, Victorian writers like Dickens were writing for a smaller, more educated audience, as well as an expectation among his readers that it was preferable to demand work from your audience over providing clarity.

Ultimately, though, you're seeing young readers confronting their first text that's older than anyone they know. Its mostly convention over difficulty.

3
asanandyou•

The opening sentences of Don Quixote (in the Grossman translation). Some here are of a length, and exquisite:

IDLE READER: Without my swearing to it, you can believe that I would like this book, the child of my understanding, to be the most beautiful, the most brilliant, and the most discreet that anyone could imagine. But I have not been able to contravene the natural order; in it, like begets like. And so what could my barren and poorly cultivated wits beget but the history of a child who is dry, withered, capricious, and filled with inconstant thoughts never imagined by anyone else, which is just what one would expect of a person begotten in a prison, where every discomfort has its place and every mournful sound makes its home? Tranquility, a peaceful place, the pleasant countryside, serene skies, murmuring fountains, a calm spirit, are a great motivation for the most barren muses to prove themselves fertile and produce offspring that fill the world with wonder and joy.

5
Earthsophagus•

I think when you look at writers like Samuel Johnson and Henry James, you see a type of sentence that has an obvious structure that's rare to find in today's authors. Authors now who write long sentences (to generalize) don't sound "composed" they sound "discursive", they're just piling more in, without an arrangement other than their train of thought.

To say "Shakespeare doesn't stick to rules of composition for a given genre, but achieves realism by depicting a wide range of events," Johnson says:

Shakespeare's plays are not in the rigorous and critical sense either tragedies or comedies, but compositions of a distinct kind; exhibiting the real state of sublunary nature, which partakes of good and evil, joy and sorrow, mingled with endless variety of proportion and innumerable modes of combination; and expressing the course of the world, in which the loss of one is the gain of another; in which, at the same time, the reveller is hasting to his wine, and the mourner burying his friend; in which the malignity of one is sometimes defeated by the frolick of another; and many mischiefs and many benefits are done and hindered without design.

Johnson's work is so studded with parallel constructions it can seem almost like automatically generated text. Here, his points are really a bucketful of stray observations, but his composition gives the impression of logic, authority, elevation, considered-ness.

Now your Henry James though, he's not given to slathering regularity over hodgepodge, he's more inclined to luxuriantly elaborate on one or two metaphorical approximations of some very nice social observation: "It may be said of her that, during these passages, she plucked her sensations by the way, detached, nervously, the small wild blossoms of her dim forest, so that she could smile over them at least with the spacious appearance, for her companions, for her husband above all, of bravely, of altogether frivolously, going a-maying." But still there is syntactic and metaphoric structure there, which contribute to the length, it's not "one damned thing after another."

5
BreastOfTheWurst•

I wouldn’t say it’s dead at all. Just off the top of my head we have folks like Joshua Cohen and Joseph McElroy still releasing and still crafting long, winding, breath averse sentences.

I could find more but I’m lazy and others have.

4
Craw1011Denis Johnson•

I think the long sentence has certainly depleted, but it's not extinct. Both Pynchon and Franzen use it quite a bit, but then again these are American writers. My understanding is that because of Hemingway, minimalism took to American literature in a way that didn't occur in other countries, so it might still be going well elsewhere

4

It depends on the writer’s voice and ability to make it flow. Philip Roth has sentences that span the better part of a page and half but somehow he doesn’t lose me but actually engrosses me in the tangled, tangential mind of his characters. Give him a shot if you haven’t.

3
rohmer9•

I don't know if there's a lack of them, but if you're looking for a possible antidote you could try A Cup of Rage (1978, Nassar) - 47 pages, and only 7 sentences.

I read it last year and although I wasn't a big fan of the style, it was quite absorbing. It's a strange effect really, because unlike most novels you don't have much time to pause & reflect, it's like the author is pushing you headlong down a hill.

3

Reading this book feels like it's being yelled at you, which I guess is exactly how it's supposed to be since it's basically two people having an argument. It's engaging while you're reading it, but after a couple months I couldn't remember a thing about what was said in that book.

2
rohmer9•

Yeah that's pretty much how I felt about it too. Because it's a continual white-hot stream of animosity with a run-on structure, it does become a blur. I guess it's one of those books where you enjoy the effect, or you just find the whole thing rather unpleasant. Either way, it'll be over pretty quickly.

2

The best long sentences I’ve encountered recently are in The Pale King (DFW).

3
GirTheRobot•

From what I remember of Infinite Jest, it would have a sentence going on for at least a page, with a parenthetical stuck in it, and then a footnote inside of that you had to stop and go read, then you get back to your parenthetical...It was very fun if you like that sort of thing.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2†
exponentialismOP•

I didn't mean to imply that long sentences are dead, I wanted to know if anyone had noticed such a phenomenon. I thought I remembered reading an article bemoaning the shortening of sentences but I could easily have just misremembred of magnified a throw away comment in my head over time. As I said I haven't read that much contemporary lit (of those you've listed, only a little Pynchon which barely fits in the last 50 years)

Teachers are telling you long sentences are dead

I've never heard this from a teacher, the last time I got feedback on anything I'd written I was 16, and they were easily pleased at my school tbh.

I suppose with things like fragmentary sentences having been fashionable for a while, it may just be that the average sentence is shorter but not because of a lack of long sentences but because of shorter ones being used where they weren't before.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
AbbathOccultaWilliam Burroughs•

I think the real problem with this question we should have likely killed much earlier is that it cherry-picks a few writers among hundreds and tries to create a phenomenon that basically doesn't exist. Or, rather exists all the time in particular writer's work.

0