The Death of the Long Sentence?
I admit I haven't read enough - or widely enough -literature from the past 50 years or so to really know, but I seem to remember a few years back reading an article concerning the dearth of long sentences in contemporary literature - to its detriment. If anyone knows of something like this, please link it below!
I also admit that when I come across very long sentences in writers like Proust, Woolf and Henry James, I've found them somewhat irritating and cumbersome to follow, but I don't know if that's only due to the fact that I'm not used to them. Regarding Proust alone, I seem to find it easier to parse his prose the deeper I get into his work (though this case probably depends a lot on translation too). I do find that a long sentence with many clauses has its own effect - like leading you through a twisting alleyway - that it would lose if broken up into smaller parts.
Do you guys think there's a notable lack of long sentences, and if so, is this a bad thing?
Posted Jun 21, 2021, 9:33 AM UTC
Another recent award-winning novel, 1,000 pages in a single sentence, is this one. "Ducks, Newburyport has won the £10,000 Goldsmiths prize for “fiction at its most novel”, praised by judges as a “masterpiece”.
Ducks, Newburyport wins £10,000 prize for fiction
Iirc it technically isn’t a single sentence novel, sometimes the main narrative stops and tells the tell of a lioness. But yeah it is pretty close to a single sentence.
I guess it's just the claim then. I started the book but couldn't find traction. You?
I had the same experience. I read about 70 pages of it (given, this isn't very much) and for a moment felt like I could get into it, but the repetitiveness was definitely more a chore than anything else. I would experience brief moments where it felt like I was gliding along the prose sort of hypnotized by the repetitive syntax, and this was a cool feeling, but I couldn't sustain it, and I didn't want to go back to it because it felt like it was just going to be more of the same for 900 pages.
As I said it is pretty close to a single sentence novel so I get the narrative pushed.
I actually loved it. It left me this feeling of overthinking and anxiety. I read it in early 202 while I was studying and it really hit me with all the stuff I was processing. College stuff, personal life, trying to make new friendships, family, getting engaged in politics and trying to find who I am, all this was too much for me and I would constantly overthink every single thing going on without being able to focus on each at a time. I wanted to read more literature but then I also had to do this work for college and I had to listen to family problems, all this left me exhausted and I would simply flip flop through all these thoughts without giving them proper time or dealing with them. All this overload of information, reading more and more depressing news. I actually started reading it in January 2020 when the Covid news started and I remember getting so angry and exhausted with the narrative that it was a Chinese lab made virus created to conquer the world. When I read this book, the writing style was exactly how I was feeling. Just one huge mess of different kinds of thoughts all mixed together: going from wondering what I want to have for lunch to “my relationship is falling apart” as if both had the same importance and deserved the same amount of consideration.
I’m sorry for the rant, 2020 was a rough year and while I read it before Covid hit in my country, it certainly helped me with the lockdown as I felt that someone gets me, someone feels like how I feel in the current state of the world. I get this not being a book for everyone and I don’t intend to say it in a pretentious manner; the writing style is either something you love or hate. I wouldn’t even recommend to push through some more pages as I don’t think that will make you fall in love with it. In my opinion this is a book for a certain time and place in a person’s life and only then should it be read.
Thank you for your excellent review! Your comments are very helpful and empathetic.
I've been really interested to read this book for a while. Part of what's turning me off is an interview with the author.
I think she comes across as intelligent and humorous in that interview. Not quite seeing the issue.
Alright, took a little break and just came back and finished that interview. It was definitely humorous and entertaining, but I can see why it would bother a person for sure.
Really? Criticizing perpetuating the species, sure, I'm down with that, logically it's not the most sensible or ethical thing to do, but I think it's a stretch to assume moms will be emotionally and intellectually absent for 20 years. For someone who is constantly bringing up sexism in that interview that's a pretty fucking sexist viewpoint. Also one of her pros about having kids was getting to relive your own childhood and play with toys? Okay. I mean I guess that's cool and all but it definitely doesn't top my list of the most rewarding things about being a parent.
ETA: Basically this writer comes across as a bit of an edgelord. Nothing new for writers haha, but I think I prefer Lionel Shriver for my edgelord controversial opinions.
what's wrong with perpetuating the species?
[deleted]
Reading the interview, I personally felt as if her politics somewhat overemphasized the importance of the patriarchy in comparison with other institutions; I got the sense that, in her world, things would fundamentally be in a much better place if only women and men had swapped places in the social hierarchy, leaving all other axes of oppression intact. It's a sort of idealistic or reductive view, I'd say, and many men will be repelled by even the slightest insinuation of it.
Some particulars: in what way might patriarchy be behind the "the big divide ... between mothers and daughters"? Should "women rule collectively" and (implicitly) exclusively? Are prehistoric matriarchal societies really only called prehistoric because they "predate male rule"? Maybe this is all satire, but I can see how people would be turned off by it—if only just enough to pass on the 1000 page, 1 sentence door-stopper.
I am a woman and I also thought some of her points were a bit strange. Is she for real that she'd like to see women venerated in her hypothetical Utopia, or was she just joking? I couldn't really tell. If she's real that's just dumb imo. Also the mother/daughter divide? Not something I've seen in my life among my friends and family at all. I don't get that that's a thing.
Anyone that comes to the conclusion that things would be super different if this group of humans were in charge instead of that one I will always just fundamentally disagree with. I think humans are much more similar than we are different, with all of our foibles and lesser traits.
I find it strange that someone could read older books and come to the conclusion that life (or at least human nature) was markedly different then. I come to the exact opposite conclusion. It always amazes me how little humanity changes, for better or for worse.
Philosophically I found myself disagreeing with a lot of what she had to say. On a minor note she also considers exercise a "supposed form of self-improvement actually just meant to bug people", and I'm a hobbyist athlete haha, so yeah, different worldviews indeed.
Maybe because she's a contemporary writer with lots of plaudits shitting on other contemporary writers who get lots of plaudits? It is a bit weird, presumably she thinks readers should read her books, but otherwise we should all be reading Kafka or something and skipping anything new? I mean as a gossipy person who loves in-group drama I found her complaining about the clique-ishness of British writers pretty entertaining, but I can see where it rubs people the wrong way. I also got that she made some valid points in there too of course.