r/AskBaking•
AbsoluteGrime

Is it possible to use food coloring to make peanut butter frosting look like mint?

Cakes

I'm making a peanut butter/chocolate cake for my partner, but I'm thinking of coloring the icing to look more like it's a mint/chocolate cake for goofs. Is that possible or will the coloring just make the tan frosting look off?

Posted Jun 23, 2021, 3:29 PM UTC

16
valerian_spiel•

Not really, unless by "mint" you mean "unappetizing shade of pea green".

6
AbsoluteGrimeOP•

That's what I was afraid of lol. Prolly not the best idea anyway since the whole point of making it look like mint is because they hate mint. Seemed funny to me on paper but in practice seems like a bad idea. Wish me luck on the cake regardless!

1
valerian_spiel•

Best of luck! 🍀

1
plaidpants033•

you could do a peanut butter frosting between the layers and a green vanilla frosting on the outside of the cake

5
turningtogold•

I think the only way to achieve that would be to make a buttercream using a peanut butter flavouring, and then colour that. It wouldn’t be as good though so probably not worth it.

2
cranberrybries•

Try white chocolate peanut butter, if you can find it. It's a lot lighter in colour and really tasty.

1