This is why Star Citizen will fail

Discussion

Looking at the military logos for each game, successful or not, depends on designer team coordination and tools to complete said organization to release a game.

CIG is extremely lazy when it comes to even designing a logo for their military, which is front and center for most, if not all combat operations presented in the game. For comparison on the right, Halo's Airborne logo is a true representation of a fighting force where with CIG... none.

They are not making a game.

https://preview.redd.it/a18yu43aq8771.jpg?width=613&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=7adcc58d6ef692aa079f7ef09e475f5b02fe95e9

Posted Jun 24, 2021, 4:29 PM UTC

125
MihalysRevenge•

Being someone who is Ex-military and was involved with the United States Army Institute of Heraldry the SC logos are laughable and beyond lazy.

17
Reveille12•

I severely doubt your credentials with this claim. Have you ever heard the Army song? Seen the Army logo? Looked at 3rd ID or 45th ID? Lol Our military looks like it was designed by a '90s teen.

1
MihalysRevenge•

I do admit the Army song is pure cheese as is the US Army Marketing logo, but what is wrong with the Thunderbird for the 45th ID? IMHO it's a great SSI but being from the southwest and part NativeAmerican I am a bit biased toward the 45th ID. I am more thinking about the symbolism of unit DUIs and the official army logo.

1
Reveille12•

Frankly there's not a thing wrong with any of our Army symbols (except maybe that stupid big A in our logo). It is steeped in tradition. But I use it as a point arguing that more or less detail in military symbols, particularly fantasy, is a bit of a moot point to be hanging our hats on. Look how simple the design for the both the Rebels and Empire in Star Wars originally were. Yet that franchise is one of the greats.

2
harrison23•

I think the reason Star Citizen will fail is because the game is never going to release complete, not because of logos

13
MihalysRevenge•

Well, IMHOthe logos show a lazy development and focus on only surface-level things.

5
nobodyuknow187•

It represents the low effort put into things, and why it can't be completed.

4
Flharfh1•

They both remind me of the low effort clip art logos sports games have for user created teams.

8
MihalysRevenge•

The Templin Institute touched on this a bit.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j2PGjGFrFZI Go to the 25 minute mark

8
Reveille12•

This video is meant to destroy SC yet it catches Star Wars, Star Trek, and several other successful scifis in the crossfire. Not exactly the most well researched resource for an argument synthesis.

1
SidditsOP•

To most, it would seem like silly nitpicking.

However, when Star Citizen was being revealed, someone said, "I don't want to build any old game, I want to build a universe."

Star Citizen gamers talk about how things like details in the game have never been done before.

If CIG spent 300+ million on design and features, why aren't the developers working on detailed lore, symbolism and institutions we assume the backers are so eagerly defending?

Are they defending those who designed these half-baked military symbols?

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
Dayreach•

one is cartoonish, and the other looks like a clutter mass of clip art.

10
MihalysRevenge•

Some of us do. To militaries, logos have meaning, and having well thought out logos and emblems is usually is a hallmark of good worldbuilding.

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
MihalysRevenge•

To me at least the Halo one has some Iconography that has some meaning (Airborne jump wings, oak leaves, and globe), It a tad busy but not horrible as the SC one has zero meaning and to me, as someone versed in military DUIs just a thrown together jumble.

4
nanonan•

Check this guys video if you have an hour to kill. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j2PGjGFrFZI

1
merrycrow•

I've not been following this game very closely but everything about its style and aesthetic is so uninspiring and generic.

1
Reveille12•

Arguing the failure of a game based on its logos is a bit of a stretch.

Have you ever heard of the 45th ID? Neither of these are remotely realistic.

1
SidditsOP•

Everything I hear from Star Citizen players is how fully fleshed out their universe is, and how things are NEVER DONE BEFORE.

You talk about fidelity and detail.

So... why are your military symbols so bland, a ten year old could make something better. If the devs at CIG cared so much about their game and lore, should more be devoted into the detail you talk about so much... the NEVER DONE BEFORE aspect?

None here, but yet you defend the lazy, and I mean, lazy design of military logos in a game which is centered around their military.

Your game, not mine. I'm just a spectator reading what you say, but astonished you defend the opposite.

1
Reveille12•

Where are you coming from? Lol I don't think I ever said anything about fidelity or detail. I just thought it was goofy to be touting a secondary logo design as an evidencial factor of success. "NEVER DONE BEFORE" is your quote, not mine 🤣

Actually though Google my own unit's logo, 40th Infantry Division, and tell me how having a goofy looking logo is unrealistic. 😝

1
SidditsOP•

You talk about how much you love Star Citizen.

So... this means you are in the same camp as the ones who praise the detail and fidelity, right?

Remember, if you want to build a successful game, you have to care about design. The fact the game is a military backed story... right? Means things like logos- the very thing you SHOULD be paying attention to- since you love this game so much-

And the fact they are garbage- low imput images- means the CIG team put little or no effort into design. This should concern you. But it doesn't

You defend a lazy project. The design is lazy. The game is broken.

1
Reveille12•

That's called stereotyping at its finest. You are really hanging your hat on this "bad logos make bad games" thing.

1
Fr4rion_•

Logos aren't priorities lol. Saying a game is gonna fail because of "logos" makes no sense mate

1
SidditsOP•

You're absolutely correct.

Logos aren't priorities, and neither is the game. That is my point.

The game is gonna fail because the laziness in development led to marketing ships. That is the priority, not a finished product- the game you are currently theory crafting.

1
No_Collection8573•

This is why Star Citizen will fail

clickbait much?

0