[Announcement] Trying again: attention subreddit moderators! Help me help you...

About a month ago, I posted this thread in response to finding that a few (mostly small, but a couple of prominent) reddits were disabling RES functionality, and I got some emails/messages about it from some rather frustrated RES users...

Well, I don't know how else to get the word out to those I'm unaware of short of posting here - and this sub has gained a few thousand visitors since that post, so I'm posting again in the hopes that this post garners more attention.

Just recently, another discussion about this was started here, in a thread that's downvoted into the negatives so maybe you guys haven't seen it

The bottom line:

If there are features of RES that you feel conflict with your subreddit's stylesheet - please contact me! I'm happy to work with you to try and make RES more subreddit-style-friendly...

What I am not cool with is subreddits trying to disable parts of RES through stylesheet trickery. Ultimately, I strongly believe in supporting the users of my software. They installed it because they presumably want that functionality... My stance is that it's their browser, and they should get to do what they want with it.

I want to work with Reddit to allow RES to mesh nicely with subreddit stylesheets -- there's some damn nice stuff being done in a number of subreddits and if I can structure RES's html differently, etc to make it easier for you to style how it looks in your neck of the woods - I'm all for it... please let me know what changes would help, and I'm happy to assist.

Posted Jan 9, 2012, 8:21 AM UTC · edited

18834
I_know_HTML•

I too am willing to help subreddits with a minimum of 100 members fix RES-related problems with their stylesheets. :D

18
gavin19support tortoise•

I'll cover all the ones with less than 100, sounds fair!

13
[deleted]•

[deleted]

7
solidwhetstoneUI Designer•

r/apple is the sub in question. Follow the link in hbs post that takes you to the apple mods submission.

11
kodemage•

Why am I not surprised that r/apple decided to break your extension instead of working with you to co-exist.

16
solidwhetstoneUI Designer•

I wasn't either :D

7
kodemage•

Yeah, I'm reading the thread right now and that/r/apple mod is kind of an asshole.

7
agentlameSherlock Holmes•

I'm confused as to why you say this.

r/apple has what I would consider some of the best RES support. They are the only subreddit I've ever seen style the 'shortcut' and 'dashboard' buttons, 'Use subreddit style' is clearly visible and functions as expected, and they integrate the top menu as if they designed it.

Example.

Hell, I even prefer their smaller expando icon in comments.

4
honestbleepsOPRES author•

to expand on solidwhetstone's response:

/r/apple had removed:

  1. The ability to enable/disable the stylesheet... which, although i quite like the stylesheet, is an anti-user-centric behavior in my opinion.

  2. The ability to add/remove the subreddit as a shortcut to your top bar (+shortcut button)

  3. The ability to add/remove the subreddit from your dashboard (+dashboard button)

The only reason these functions are back is because I sent mod mail asking what was up with that... Their moderator felt that removing them altogether was perfectly fine, because he didn't like the way they looked, aesthetically...

Whether or not you choose to side with a subreddit moderator's choice or the RES choice is entirely up to you - i just feel you should have more of the story.

11
agentlameSherlock Holmes•

I see. I agree they shouldn't be mucking with my functionality. But, it seems he made up for it in spades. RES looks it's best on r/apple. (Short of r/Enhancement, of course.)

As an aside, you guys should consider styling the three subscription buttons in that gray style.

4
solidwhetstoneUI Designer•

Some of those features had been removed originally by the r/apple mod. They are only back in because hb had a talk with him.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2
gavin19support tortoise•

Use it to destroy moderator

Slight exagerration.

who tried to help

Only after being approached by PM and offered assistance to work around his stylistic preferences. He was the one who decided to open it up to the public.

Is no-one bothered by the fact that he decided that removing functionality for many thousands of RES users was justified because it didn't adequately fit his design vision?

4
honestbleepsOPRES author•

Damn. I didn't realize I got destroyed. :(

2
RangerSix•

Goddamnit, he must have spoofed your IFF transponder.

No wonder my sub captains were so confused...

2
Duffman3005•

SRS currently hides the "Use subreddit style" checkbox. To be honest I never really go there, but I saw this was brought up in the previous thread here.

1
gavin19support tortoise•

It was hidden at some point, then removed a while back. Seems it has been reinstated.

1
JohnStrangerGalt•

You could try in /r/modclub as well.

3
honestbleepsOPRES author•

thanks, I'll post there!

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
gavin19support tortoise•

It's still functional, just a bit... broken looking. Change the CSS for the side bar that reads

div.side .titlebox {
border: 1px #000 solid;
padding: 10px;
background-color: white
}

to

body:not(.res-nightmode) div.side .titlebox {
border: 1px #000 solid;
padding: 10px;
background-color: white
}

The header needs a fair bit of tinkering though.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
honestbleepsOPRES author•

I don't think it looks too bad in night mode... It looks like you had the right idea with how you tried to style .side for nightmode, but your titleboxes live "on top" of the .side div, so you actually need those styles to cover .titlebox elements... something like the following (totally untested!) may work:

.res-nightmode .side .titlebox {
  background-color: #000000;
  color: #dddddd; /* or whatever your preferred text color is here */
}

EDIT: gavin19's solution is likely a much better one!

0
[deleted]•

I am not sure if you added it back or /r/apple messed up, but they have the checkbox back, but in the wrong place.

I noticed in their html they have wrapped the checkbox in a div

div style="display: block !important;" class=" styleToggle"

At least now I have it disabled now in /r/apple, so whoever did it. Thanks.

1
gavin19support tortoise•

That's the div created by RES to house the checkbox/label, which is what subreddits target when they want to hide it.

1
k3n•

Contact them directly. Pass-agg posting to a sub that they likely will never see isn't going to help much of anything.

-8
honestbleepsOPRES author•

I've contacted many of them directly.

This post is intended to reach those who I have no idea about, because I haven't visited every subreddit on reddit.

8
littlemange•

Well get going!

1