You are not a good swimmer.

This is primarily aimed towards young adults and over who think they can swim across whatever distance or to whatever island or landmark in open water to stroke their ego.

In my area, every time the local news reports a tragic drowning and the takeaway is that they drowned only because they weren't wearing a life jacket, it drives me up the fucking wall. It sends the wrong message. I strongly agree that a life jacket significantly contributes to a swimmer's survivability, but a lack of one isn't the sole reason they drowned. Even more so, I am here to argue that it's not the primary reason they drowned.

Safety devices are not a substitute for skill and knowledge.

"But all their friends and family said this person was a good swimmer!" No. I would not consider that person a good swimmer. We need to redefine what it means to be a "good" or "experienced" swimmer.

So you swam 100 meters (~4 pool lengths) in under 1 minute and 15 seconds. First of all, great job. That's honestly a fantastic athletic feat. That does not mean you are a good swimmer. A competitive swimmer does not instantly make a good swimmer.

If you cannot tread water for 30-45 seconds at a time, you are not a good swimmer. If you need to touch the pool floor or hold onto a wall to recover instead of floating or switching to breaststroke, you are not a good swimmer. Try this. Try any swimming workout but when resting, don't touch the pool floor or hold onto the wall, or replace your rests with an easy 50-100 breaststroke. If you can finish your workout by doing that then you are well on your way to become a good swimmer.

The other thing is that if you don't understand what currents are and how weather affects any open body of water, or you just don't know what you're swimming in, then you are not a good swimmer. If it’s determined that the location, the weather, or even your own condition, whether by alcohol impairment or general un-wellness, is deemed unsafe, a good swimmer would walk away.

These are essential survival skills you need if/when you end up in any body of open water where dry land is several hundred meters away from you. All of this should be normalized as common knowledge, but for some God forsaken reason, they're not. At minimum, floating/water treading skills should be revisited in advanced swimming lessons or courses.

Saying something so generalized like this person drowned because they didn't wear a life jacket sends the wrong message. The message is further muddled by claiming the victim is a good swimmer when in reality that person was not. We need to respect the water, not by throwing life jackets on everyone and calling it a day, but rather by learning/relearning survival swimming skills. We can prevent so many more deaths this way.

And again, this is not an attack on life jackets. Children should always be wearing life jackets but for the rest of us I will say this: If life jackets are apparently too unfashionable or uncool for you to consider protecting your own life with, then maybe consider a swim buoy? Or maybe, just maybe, don't go for that island or landmark in the distance.

Posted Jun 30, 2021, 7:59 PM UTC

103

This is very important and thank you.

1
paquerat•

I can't tread water at all, it just isn't happening. I can float on my back, though my legs try to drag me down. Due to excessive bone density, I'll probably never learn to swim.

0
igiveup1949•

Yes you can. You have to relax. I am the only one in my immediate family that can swim. I got pushed into the deep end of a pool with no life guard. I drank a lot of water decided to go to the bottom pushed off and dog paddled like hell till I got to the side. Every day I went back to the pool watched people swim and practiced till I could go side to side then 1/2 the length of the pool then the whole length. I did mile swim eventually and took life saving. If you ask me if I can swim I will just say I am OK at it. I know I can at least swim a mile under normal conditions but knowing that anyone can drown is still with me. If you make the water your friend and relax you will come to enjoy it. Baby steps like me.

1