I'm going to attempt to debunk all of the large talking points as realistically as I can. Open debate welcome from all sides.
Howdy all. I've been a bit active here, mostly because this stuff is utterly fascinating to me. Less because of the ARG/Mystery, but the theories themselves are interesting to read and for me, fun to discuss. So, I'm here to put forth discussions and theories of my own.
Note that these are just that, discussions or theories. Nobody really 100% knows what's going through Hasan's head at any moment, so we just have to guess, and this is my guess based on everything that's happened.
You are more then welcome to discuss what I've said, I don't care if you hate all this and think it's garbage, let me know. Discussing it is half the fun! That being said: I'm not here to hate on anyone, or get mad at anything. This is simply a discussion. Do not use this to attack anyone else for their theories/beliefs.
Blue Box Studios itself
So here's the first one. Many question the legitimacy of this studio, their projects, etc. Some have pointed out that their previous game logos look "similar" to Kojima titles. Here's the source I have in mind, it's what I'll be focusing on.
The first thing I'd like to point out: the OP has to physically stretch the logos in order to make it look similar, which should be the first warning sign. To me, if you're having to modify it in order to fit the bill, that probably wasn't the intention.
We have enough evidence to say that Blue Box were a legitimate studio long before all of this. First of all, there's the kickstarter campaign. Here's a link to their first Kickstarter, hosted in early 2015. On top of that, later in 2015, the game was submitted to Steam Greenlight. Link here. Lastly, there's also a legitimate gameplay video, uploaded by a Finnish YouTuber. Link here. There was clearly a legitimate attempt to get this game out there. Now, claiming that BBGS is created by Kojima, relies on a LOT of assumptions and ignores certain things.
For one, that means that from the beginning, both Rewind and the Kickstarter, are false. There never was a Rewind. Secondly, that implies that Kojima was behind it all. Thirdly, that means that YouTuber who played it was paid off to play this weird prototype, 6 years ago. Addressing the Kickstarter, that one is the biggest overhead. This would have to mean that Kojima was banking entirely on the Kickstarter failing hard, so he could cancel it. Which.... seems sketchy at best? What would Kojima do if the Kickstarter unintentionally went viral and got fully funded, and then some? Would he just have to finish developing the game? Would he cancel it anyway? Next, there's the Greenlight page. Again, there really seemed like a legitimate attempt from a dev to get their game out there. A lets play video, a Kickstarter, and Steam Greenlight campaign.
My last big point on this: Hasan Kharaman has an iOS App Store account. It's here. He's posted numerous small apps, ranging from personal fitness apps to shovelware games. Now iOS doesn't show the release date of apps which makes tracking down that impossible, but I managed to track it. Some of the apps say "Requires iOS 10.0 or later". iOS 10 was released in 2016, which, while this is a bit of a stretch, it's the closest info we have to a release date for these apps. This implies that Hasan existed long before the 2021 appearance with Twitter and the blog post. To say Kojima is behind this would seem a bit silly, because it would mean that Kojima was developing mobile shovelware for a short time period.
To me, this is more then enough evidence alone to suggest that BBGS are a legitimate company, hosted by a legitimate dev. Hasan, the dev himself, never had a reason to reveal himself as a developer for the company until recently, when he did that blog post under his own name.
CreateQ/The Haunting
As most people are already astutely aware, Hasan's most recent project was titled "The Haunting: Blood Water Curse", and was released into Steam early acccess in December of 2020. Source here.
Famously, On April 10th of 2021, a post was made to the forums for the game where it was announced that Blue Box were no longer working on the project, and it was now being transferred to one "CREATEQ INTERACTIVE". Upon researching that name, you'll notice they are in fact a real company, but one that does not deal in video games. They deal more in tech products.
There isn't a single trace to me that this CREATEQ INTERACTIVE are a real company. So, I do believe they're fake/made up. But, by who? Again, going by the method that it's done by Kojima would require answers to the problems I've pointed out in the first section, so I don't buy that. So what is it? I firmly believe that CREATEQ INTERACTIVE was created by Hasan himself. Why? To re-direct the blame about the game being abandoned (ironically), as he was moving on to his next project. This would explain why Hasan kept responding on the Steam forums under his own account still after the transfer already happened.
I'm aware that recently it seems like The Haunting has popped up again, this time on PS5. With this, I have another piece of info to add to my theory that CREATEQ INTERACTIVE is created by Hasan. As you can see here, it's supposedly developed/published by our friends at Blue Box Games again. It's most likely way way more difficult to create a fake developer on the PSN store, meaning Hasan was unable to pull the same trick he did on Steam, so it's just uploaded under the BBGS account. We have no idea when/if this game is coming any time soon, so there's not much we can say about this page for now.
Those Dang Accounts (Twitter/Youtube)
So, this is arguably the single largest talking point nowadays. TheAbandonedGame YouTube account, and the BBGS_JP account. I've linked both of them here, so you can check them yourselves if you'd like.
Let's start with the easiest target: The JP account is, 100 percent without a doubt, fake. On June the 25th, the same date we all expected to see the Abandoned gameplay reveal, the account uploaded this. This is a trailer for a game called Sinfeld Remastered, a game by a developer called Rarebird Games. Rarebird are legit. So, with that piece of info we can call that account illegitimate, and just an example of gamejacking by unrelated devs to sell their own project.
Now, the next one is a bit trickier, and I'll be honest it's given me the most amount of headaches thinking about it, but I believe I've gotten it sorted.
So, The YT account. This account appeared a few days before the 25th, and most people immediately shut it down. Hasan already told us the only official channels were the BBGS Twitter he talked on, and the BBGS YouTube that's linked on his website. I won't go too in depth into the activities in this account, because I believe it to be irrelevant. But I'll address this first: Hasan allegedly posted his delay announcement on the 25th, on the exact second this countdown ended. I can't officially verify if this actually took place, but I'll believe the folks on here who claim they saw it.
In my mind: Hasan knew the 25th was his deadline. On that day, people would figure out that he didn't actually have a Silent Hill game, and he wasn't Kojima. But, he knew about the fake YT account, and he saw everyone speculating. He also noticed that this account was hosting a countdown, for something. Why not take advantage of this? He decided then to post his delay video that he recorded, when this countdown ended.
This might seem far fetched, but think of it this way. He needed more time to finish his game anyway, and if he just announced the delay normally, people would be pissed. So, he did it this way. He doesn't have to wink or openly hint at anything, the implication of when he posted it, would be more then enough to keep speculation alive. And, he has plausible deniability. When the truth comes out, his defense is easy. "I didn't know about that, that's just a coincidence".
So, here's my big proof the account is fake. On June 24th, the JP Twitter account posted this. This is a seemingly innocuous picture of the exact same forest asset that Hasan purchased for the original trailer, but as this handy tweet points out: There's red and blue cassette tapes hidden in the scene. This was posted before the majority of the YouTube account's activity.
As we all know, recently the YouTube account has gone off about not only VHS tapes, but Red/Blue as well. Some might see this as a smoking gun, that there really is an ARG behind it all. But, here's the thing. The JP account has been a proven fake, remember? They posted the trailer for a Seinfeld game made by a real studio. Anything this account has done, is fake. So that means....
With this link between the YouTube account and the JP Twitter account, I'm ready to finally present this as the final piece of evidence that the YouTube account is 100% fake. They're apart of the marketing campaign for this Seinfeld game, and have no relevance to any of this.
Kojima Posting Blue/Red
This one, to me, is a big stretch. Red and Blue is a fairly common colour. It's fairly safe to assume that him posting pictures with those colours are indeed, a coincidence. That's all I have to say on this matter. With all the above evidence, this one seems clear and easy. Anything Kojima posts should be taken as coincidences.
Hasan acting weird in the videos
Some are taking Hasan's actions in the videos he's recorded, as strange and unnatural. Some are taking this two ways, either he's an actor or made from CGI.
I have a simple explanation: Anxiety. Put yourself in this situation:
The game you've just unveiled has suddenly gotten more attention then you ever anticipated it to. Suddenly, the trailer has a million views. You've made a few silly jokes on Twitter, and before you know it, there are thousands of people theorizing that you're secretly Kojima and you're developing a Silent Hill game. You know this isn't true. You make a public denial of these theories. But people don't listen. They take that denial as "evidence". There are literal subreddits dedicated to solving the "mystery" that you know doesn't exist. You know that these people are not going to be pleased when they find out the truth, so you're now overwhelmed with panic with what these people are going to do when that news comes out.
Considering all of that, yeah, I'd also be acting a bit weird in some videos.
The "7 Studios" claim/Nuare's Video
This one is probably the most difficult to talk about.
There is zero evidence from either side to back up what he's claimed here. Hasan has, in the past, claimed that he's working with 7 studios. There are only two publicly named studios:
- Nuare
- Dekogon
Hasan also claims he has backing from Sony themselves, and that Abandoned started development in 2017 after he was headhunted by Sony after his Rewind Kickstarter.
This... I don't buy. Not at all. Nuh uh. Rewind's kickstarter (Link if you can't be bothered to scroll back up) was mediocre at best. Sony did not headhunt him from this. Furthermore: He claims Abandoned started development back in 2017, but the Rewind Kickstarter ended in early 2015. When did Sony pick him up? Did he cancel the Kickstarter because Sony picked him up? What was he doing for two years? Or did Sony find the Kickstarter two years later and pick him up? None of that makes sense.
So: I call bullshit. He's lying. The only "Backing" from Sony he has, is that he paid Sony a fee to host his trailer on their account, and on the Blog. Anyone can do this with a fee, the Life of Black tiger is on the PS YT account.
Then there's Nuare and Dekogon. Nuare, is tricky. Honestly? I have no concrete explanation for this, it's the weirdest bit.
Let's start with Dekogon, because it helps my case for Nuare: In this post here, we can see that Hasan has purchased an asset from who else, but Dekogon. The same studio he's "working" with. So, that's my claim. He's not really "working" with these studios, so much as he is buying assets from them and saying that's working with them.
And that's my theory for Nuare. Hasan was panicking after all the theories were going wild, so he made his first video denying them. Then, he asked Nuare and maybe even Dekogon, to make public videos saying that Hasan is a real person, and he's not in a conspiracy. Dekogon might have declined, which is why we didn't hear anything from them. Nuare, decided why not, and put out their own 50 second long video. In the video, they don't really say anything special. There's no hints. In fact, about 40 seconds of the video is just an ad for the studio, he spends all that time talking about how Nuare is a real studio who's worked on AAA projects and has 70 employees. At the end, they throw in that they're "excited to work with Blue Box", which is the closest confirmation we have of any relationship.
So, again, it's just my theory that Hasan is purchasing assets from them.
As for the other "7 studios" claims? Also bullshit, or just more companies he's buying from.
The "App"
This one is also fairly simple to debunk.
The big point most people bring up, is that Hasan is getting "special treatment" because he gets to have some fancy "realtime trailers" special app. On paper, that sounds interesting, and something that indeed hasn't been done much before.
But, straight from the horses mouth: "Think of it as a demo for the PS5"
And that's pretty much it. It doesn't sound like an app at all, but just a demo with some fancy marketing buzzwords thrown in there.
So what's really going on?
Well, if it isn't an ARG and not Silent Hills, then the easiest answer is really true.
Hasan is a legit indie dev. He's got a history of asset flip games, before abandoning them in an alpha state, and moving on.
Maybe he's not really trying to be that. He might just be an indie dev with a lack of experience, and keeps leaving games behind because he feels the projects aren't getting the attention he needs to continue working on them, which would explain why he wanted to pay for a trailer on the Sony PS channel to spread the word out.
He made a few really poor jokes, and is now, in over his head. Fake accounts are swarming to get in on the hype, and now he's literally had to private his PSN playtime because people kept spying on it for "clues". People are expecting some deep ARG and Silent Hills, of which they'll get neither, and they'll probably want his head.
Abandoned really is just going to be some small indie survival game.
Geoff Keighly's Involvement
This should be another short one. Keighly has commented a few times on this subject. It seemed to begin with Hasan messaging him about promoting his game. Keighly asked to see some screenshots of the game that he could share to people, presumably for the marketing. And from that point on... Hasan never responded. Keighly never got the screenshots, and it seems like he got ghosted.
I want to point this out though: Here's Keighly's comment on the whole situation. This is him directly telling us it's not what we think it is, and to set our expectations.
Whatever it is, Keighly is not directly involved, and knows enough to seemingly confirm it's nothing big.
That's it
Now I'm very tired and might have missed a few major things, which I'd be happy to expand upon if someone reminds me of them. For now though? I believe this is how it is.
My only person questions: The money. Hasan must be wealthy or be getting his cash from somewhere to be able to keep running these projects over and over again, and pay Sony for the marketing.
I'm also curious exactly how Nuare fits in, thought I currently believe it to be how I stated it.
Anyway, thanks for reading this extremely long post. Like I said, feel free to discuss it, no matter what you believe in. I'm never here to get angry at anyone, or be an asshole. I'm just here to discuss, and I hope everyone else is too. These are simply my proposals to the table.
Posted Jul 1, 2021, 4:37 PM UTC