Reddit LGBT: Is the "slippery slope" argument a concern within the LGBT community?
People against gay marriage sometimes use the "slippery slope" argument, that basically says that if we legalize gay marriage, that will lead to a whole bunch of other things such as polygamy, polyandry, polygyny and other "poly" varieties. Some have (ridiculously) taken this argument to the extreme, to warn against marriage with animals and inanimate objects, but I'm talking about a more realistic "slippery slope," that still involves love between two (or more) people.
As someone who is poly-curious, I have a couple of questions for you guys:
-
What is the LGBT response to this concern? In your opinion, does this concern have any foundation for being legitimate, or is it unfounded and just a distraction?
-
Is the "slippery slope" argument a point of debate within the LGBT community? Obviously, LGBT people have been through a lot more than poly people as far as progress toward equality...But given the chance, would you attempt to share your successes with other sexual minorities, including the poly-inclined? Or are they on their own in these battles?
Posted Jan 12, 2012, 10:39 PM UTC
Well I certainly see no reason why poly unions (marriages or otherwise) ought to not be legal. And considering the fact that a significant number of polyamorous people are also LGBT (33-54% according to this article), there's a clear overlap between the LGBT and poly communities in the sense that they're both going against the "default" monogamous and heterosexual hegemony (at least in the US).
That said, there are also key differences between the legislative goals of each of these "movements." For instance, legalizing same-sex marriage would simply entail expanding the current rights of married couples to include same-sex unions. On the other hand, legalizing polygamy would entail coming up with new laws to cover things like taxes, divorce/custody, and inheritance rights.
I therefore think it's not unreasonable to suggest that they're essentially different battles, at least in terms of the letter of the law. And frankly, at the risk of sounding selfish, as a gay person who prefers monogamy (on a personal level, of course) I have to focus my "efforts" (whatever those may be) on working towards societal and legal acceptance of LGBT people and unions. I would never condemn polyamory, and I'm proudly an "ally" of the "poly cause" (as it were). And hey, the first step towards legalizing both same-sex and polygamous marriages would be repealing DOMA, so there's a shared goal right there!
Still, achieving equal rights for LGBT people and (monogamous) unions is proving to be enough of a struggle, and for the sake of both "movements," I can't imagine having to take on the "responsibility" of pushing for legal and social poly acceptance as well.
Yeah the legal framework to support polygamy will keep it out of common practice for a long time to come (and that's, of course, independent of societal acceptance of polyamory, which would happen long before legalization of polygamy).
Your comment is what I hoped I'd find- you support poly, but practically they need to fight their own battles to change the system.
I really think it's silly that the government needs to be involved in marriage at all. But as long as it is, we have to work within the system we're given.