Why is there a Mimic in Death House?

HELP / REQUEST

I cannot see to find an explanation as to why a freaking Mimic is just chillin in Death House. It seems completely out place to me. Maybe there's an obvious reason i'm missing but does anyone know why it's there?

Posted Jul 6, 2021, 10:01 PM UTC

3724
Erik_in_Prague•

In fiction? I have no idea. I guess you could rationalize it that Strahd has partially populated the lower levels as a dungeon to test adventurers.

From a game design perspective? To really screw over players who touch the orb, then try to escape via that door. It's a death trap. Plus, mimics are a classic DnD dungeon monster and they're pretty scary.

I've removed it every time I've run CoS.

50
legend_forge•

I keep it in there expressly because of how it interacts with the orb encounter.

I do lay the foreshadowing on thick on the orb though. If they touch it that's on them.

25
geeca•

I just made the mimic a social encounter that "cannot properly gauge the party so it doesn't try to fight them." Then the mimic will run at the first sign of aggression and transform into a brick to hide in the wall when it turns a corner. Then the mimic becomes a recurring character trying to find a new place to live in Barovia. Mimics are pretty intelligent and capable of speech so... <shrug>

I guess that it kind of took away from the horror element and made it more humorous but honestly. A mimic vs a level 2 party after the shadows is a bit much.

10
Hrilmitzh•

I love this idea, I just tossed it, myself, but this would be a great bit of levity.

1
OldAndOldSchool•

A mimic is a classic dungeon monster, it goes all the way back to first edition. The purpose of such a beast is to teach new adventurers to not always believe what they see and check for traps.

25

As intended? Probably none. But is there an explanation? Yes. It's not actually a "mimic".

The house itself is Walter's fever dream, a supernatural manifestation of Walter's twisted & traumatized subconscious. Walter is the strongest ghost in the house - possibly even the only one - and is the source of the House's powers. And being an infant, Walter wants 100% of his parent's attention all the time, so he keeps his parents literally inside himself, in the walls, hoarding them to himself. When the Players intrude on his parents, Walter's subconscious - and therefore the house - reacts violently, trying to ward the group away from his parents. The mimic stat block is just the closest approximation of the actual door coming to life and attacking.

21
Amdy_vill•

Mimics are wild animals drawn to vacant houses and dungeons. So thier lore kinda explains it but I removed it.

18
Goofybynight•

It's not a mimic, it just uses the stat block of a mimic. It is a manifestation of the evil done in the house. It is essentially a haunted door.

11
Necroticbanana•

I felt the same way about the animated broom. I replaced it with a rug of smothering and then described it as blood stained bed sheets.

10
Crawlerzero•

If I were to keep a mimic in Death House, I would make it one of the random chests in the sleeping quarters near the well.

4
[deleted]•

My take on it is that the house itself is like a really big mimic.

4
SirLeonel•

Don’t forget you can always “skin” the mimic as you can, and probably should for every monster that you think appropriate to do so.

The setup: I used Death House in my homebrew as the “gate” that brought them into Ravenloft. Their first two levels played out as a traditional high-fantasy game. When they were about to hit three I teased them with this mysterious haunted house that promised decent adventure (xp) that was a line building tainting the local forest that had overgrown a long abandoned settlement.

Cut to the mimic which I described as the souls of the graves “the house was built upon”. It played like a mimic but I described it (once it revealed itself upon the rogue pressing his ear to it to hear the muffled agonized screams emanating from it) as a supernatural undead doorway. I made a custom token pulled from an image of hands grasping from their grave. My experienced gamers were shocked and terrified of it. All in all it worked well.

Best part was after it was over, when the players “defeated” the house and escaped, badly injured, and found themselves on a road walled on both sides by mist and the faint outline of an approaching gypsy merchant cart rolling slowly, a distance ahead of them.

The fact that they were not prepared for RL, ratcheted up the tension. And the are loving it.

4
nokomarie3•

Nice

1
D1301•

I removed it, because it didn't quite fit the horror theme of the rest of the house (IMO).

If you want a reason, you could look at it the same way as any animal being somewhere - it found a safe space with a food supply (in this case, hapless adventurers).

Or an out of control pet from the Durst cult

3
SundayNightDM•

Not gonna lie, one of the times I’ve seen a player most scared was at level 2, when they tried to block a door with a sofa and found out the sofa was a mimic who was now restraining them.

2
FunderbunkPlays•

It's officially a Mimic, but really it's a door that transforms into a meaty glob with teeth that tries to eat unsuspecting explorers of a haunted house. Don't get hung up on the name.

3
freudiancascade•

Giving players (1) mimic early on means they spend the rest of the campaign poking every object they see with a stick before interacting with it. :)

(Seriously, I think it is just to make escape from the orb encounter that much harder if the party is dumb enough to set it off!)

Personally, I let my players discover it with a strong perception check when they were exploring the room. I didn't directly say it was a mimic, framed it more as "you've felt watched the entire time you were down here. And as you look around you see that this door--a part of the dungeon itself--seems to be BREATHING, waiting in malice for your approach." It worked well! Added a bit of extra tension and paranoia to the crawl. And when the whole house came alive later, it was a bit more contextualized as they'd already found concrete evidence that it was sentient.

3
JoshIsFallen•

For the same reason as everything in the death house: Because fuck you, that’s why.

2
MisterFisk•

I probably will avoid it in this particular dungeon.

1
Ander_Goldleaf•

Besides being a classic, at least the mimic could have decided to live there, being a living being. I'm more confused about the living armor on the bedrooms floor

1
Task_wizard•

I just posted my take on the mimic and how I recommend changing it! Basically I recommended to treat it more-so as a door that feels like part of the house than as a mimic.

1
BikeProblemGuy•

I replaced the mimic with a trap for this exact reason.

1
SundayNightDM•

A mimic in a vacant house makes perfect sense. Like gelatinous cubes, rust monsters and carrion crawlers, they infest deserted places where they can isolate like adventurers, or any animal that creeps in.

1
PyramKingWiki Contributor•

I felt the same way, also about the animated broom. I later learned it was a separate Adventure League Module of a haunted house, later added as a supplement to the appendix of Curse of Strahd.

While a very good, deadly, introduction horror game for Dungeons and Dragons, I felt (IMHO) it was not well connected to Curse of Strahd. Part of that feeling was the broom, mimic, and even the cult and flesh mound.

I rewrote the adventure (two parts) into the Counts Manor and Counts Crypt, tying it further into Curse of Strahd and Barovia with an optional start. There is a detailed video and PDF guide if interested.

Death House Pt 1 the Counts Manor

Death House Pt 2 Count's Crypt

0