So someone made a "S**t Trannys Say" video, and guess what, it was a cis man. [TW: extremely offensive]

Posted Jan 13, 2012, 3:20 PM UTC

2253
patienceinbee…and that's typical of you•

It's "shit cis gay men in drag say of trans women."

In short, this condenses every trope in the mind of cissexist cis gay men of what they think trans women are — in just under three minutes. Not bad, not bad. It's from this head space where their minstrelsy of trans women (and, through comparably cissexist means, trans men) emerges. From this cissexism, some goes further to generate transphobia at its most extreme. This is the new conservatism of cis queer people who only recently have begun to feel as if they finally belong as part of social and political cisnormativity (previously known as heteronormativity).

When cis gay men throw their hands up and say, "I don't know what the problem with those trannies are," point them to this. Point them to Willam Belli (aka noextrai on Reddit). Point them to Sandee Crack (the Libra tampon dude). The sheer cattiness by CAMAB cis gay men against CAMAB trans women is unfounded, driven by self-loathing, and driven further by their own fear that gender and sex are not what they believe it is (that is, that "gender is drag" and "sex is junk." They aren't).

It's this behaviour that is setting a stage show for the simmering backlash toward cis queer people who have outright rejected trans lives and trans bodies with bald-faced derision. They erased us from our own civil rights involvement — some of it now benefiting only them and other cis queers now that trans people are erased (mmm, time to listen to some old Erasure). We gave them our blood to help them get where where they are now. They are now trying to pick a fight to see whether we'll cower or we'll stand up for ourselves.

These — the cis queer people who look down on queer and straight people with trans bodies — are our immediate bullies, perhaps more so than the cis men who, in their infinite homophobia, vow to kill trans people who "trick" [sic] them. As that distracts us, cis gay men have been doing the substantive harm where we genuinely thought we were being helped. That's what makes this so invidious. It's truly an "et tu, Bruté?" pause in this live narrative. Dan Savage, Barney Frank, Xtra magazine in Canada, et al., are inclusive of this.

I'm girding for how this will eventually be met with truce. We're presently far from it.

18
nebarnixCrazy Cat Lady•

Couldn't have said it better myself! No seriously. I really couldn't have. Thank you for clarifying and informing <3

5
patienceinbee…and that's typical of you•

Sure thing. We can all stand up to this cissexism.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-7
[deleted]•

Ironic since trans is the epiphany of heteronormativity, originally thought up to cure gays and lesbians of their affliction.

wait -- is janice raymond using reddit now?

20
patienceinbee…and that's typical of you•

Just like how you minstrelise real women?

I don't. If I minstrelise anybody, you bindel of a coward, I minstrelise myself. And I doubt I even do that.

Or is it transphobic now for men to ditch archaic gender stereotypes and dress in drag?

I don't know. It's cis men who largely seem to benefit from divisions of labour and social order based on the language of gender and how binary opposition hurts those who are not in their placement.

For the rare cis man who grasps this and then does his part to counter misogyny and cissexism amongst his cis peers, I applaud him. There aren't many, and ironically, I find more cis men and cis women who are het who grasp this far better than a staggering share of cis queers — both men and women.

Ironic since trans is the epiphany of heteronormativity, originally thought up to cure gays and lesbians of their affliction.

Are you simple?

This much I know: you're not a scholar or anyone who has completed much homework, much less doing so insightfully or thoughtfully. You do, however, subscribe to a static dogma, not unlike any holy book.

There is nothing heteronormative about homosexuality — nothing heteronormative about my esteemed friend, a trans man, who has a boyfriend (whether that guy is cis or trans, I don't know, and it doesn't matter to me).

Further, if you did your bloody homework (which you have not), you would find in short order that it was heteronormative cis people who threw both cis queers and trans people (both queer and het) into state hospitals and performed transorbital lobotomies on them both to "cure the gay, femme, and butch away" until the early 1970s. And incidentally, in 1973 when the APA depathologized cis queer people — thus eliminating said psychosurgery — the APA developed the modern pathology framework for "diagnosing" trans people. Funny that coincidence.

Incidentally, lobotomies persisted at a hushed level after that APA de-pathologization — including on some people who were recognized by cis adults as trans (not very hard to do, incidentally) while they were still in their single-digit childhoods. Without their consent, of course (of course).

Cis queer de-pathologization came at the expense of trans people.

Today you learnt! Oh, one more lesson: gender cannot be eliminated, because it is a social language upon which practically everything social in humanity (in fact, what probably made us a social species separate from other primates) was built. This includes spoken languages, divisions of labour, cultural separation, how objects get described, how people look, what they wear, what they don't. Everyone, including Butler, has fallen short of figuring this out.

tl;dr: Trans people have been on this planet as long as cis queers have been on this planet. Spoken language to describe both cis queer and trans people came later, while viable remedies (for morphological sex being screwed up, since we now know that neurological sex is never screwed up) came later for some trans people. These followed evidence-based research as we moved away from "the four-bile" approach for treating evil demons toward the scientific method (the very same scientific method which brought us things like sanitizing and penicillin, for fuck's sake).

Since when is not being a driveling sycophant to your cause erasure?

Kind of tough to be sycophantic when when speaking face-on and without rhetoric or dead book dogma. Actually, it's nigh impossible to be servile when you speak up of your own accord. On the contrary: it's easy to do this when you're being bindellic or even paglialic.

Get bent. Or show us what you know — or what you don't, as appears to be the case.

[EDIT: after that self-deletion, I think I can get on with things now. They were about what I expected.]

13
alsoathrowaway•

Wow, cowardice is about right.

Well put, by the way.

5
patienceinbee…and that's typical of you•

I speak like this because — read my lips — enough is enough.

[There is only the smallest hint of irony when appropriating cis queer survival/resistance/protest songs for today's resistance to cis queer cissexism.]

5
alsoathrowaway•

What exactly is your problem? Did a trans person kick your dog, or something?

10
javatimesgender tater•

Wow, trans people had to be "thought up". You don't even give trans people the credit of credible existence.

10
jgohlke♂ to ♀•

Ironic since trans is the epiphany of heteronormativity, originally thought up to cure gays and lesbians of their affliction.

Get off the internet and go read a history book. Thanks.

9
natasha_six•

Amazingly offensive, flagged as inappropriate. No humor at all, just cruel mocking from what I can see.

13
ava_marxOP•

That's the amazing bit of it. There isn't a single shred of even borderline incisive commentary in the whole thing. Yes, many/most of us take synthetic hormones. Yes, many/most of us have certain issues with our bodies. Yes, many/most of us struggle to find acceptance from ourselves and our communities for our identified genders. How is simply pointing that out and repeating it over and over again supposed to be clever? I wish the asshole who made the video had had the courage to allow ratings just so he could see how offensive many people, trans and cis, would find this.

13
patienceinbee…and that's typical of you•

I wish the asshole who made the video had had the courage to allow ratings

That's how cowards bullies work. Oldest trick in the book.

11
smischmal•

Plus, the comments are moderated, so one cannot even see the outrage it inspires if he so wishes. Oh well, that just encourages the only other route to express one's displeasure on youtube, flagging it.

6
[deleted]•

Yeah, I think everyone should just flag this video. It'll go down pretty quick.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

11
FNRI•

uhhh what the fuck

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

You can't post peoples personal information on reddit, its against reddit wide rules, we are forced to enforce this by the admins, sorry.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
gooseberry85•

No I don't know what you're saying, but it sounds a lot like inciting violence against this person. Pathetic and disgusting, IMO.

There are shit ton of videos like this about every other group out there, sometimes it's good to be able to laugh at yourself too.

0
[deleted]•

There are shit ton of videos like this about every other group out there, sometimes it's good to be able to laugh at yourself too.

You may be in a social and economic situation and positioning with regard to cisnormativity in which you can dismiss this video as "just a troll", or tell us to just "laugh at ourselves". This, however, indicates a position of privilege which not everyone has. I can't laugh at my oppression as a trans woman. There's really nothing funny about it :-F

13
[deleted]•

Yes. I hate to be that asshole that quotes herself, but...

If your life has been so sheltered, so free of prejudice and pain that you cannot imagine why or how a slur so innocent could cause someone distress, then I honestly envy your ignorance. It must be bliss.

9
[deleted]•

[deleted]

6
[deleted]•

cis people tell us that "we need to pick and choose our battles", but when they do so, it's them who want to pick and choose our battles. It seems to be the same here with the "laughing at ourselves" thing. all they want to do is to laugh at us without being called out for it.

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
nadleeheThick Thick Thickety Thickface from Thicktown•

Oh no gooseberry...no violence. I didn't mean reach out and touch him in that way at all. Unless glitterbombs are violent, which last time I checked, they aren't.

It doesn't even need to be that dramatic. Simply having someone walk up to him he doesn't know and give him a piece of their mind would be enough.

Seriously folks no violence please

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
javatimesgender tater•

If Seattle were drivable, I'd consider it...

1
patienceinbee…and that's typical of you•

When bullies are afraid of saying incendiary things to the faces of those they harass publicly and in drive-by capacity (like a YT video), they get brazen. They hurt harder. Non-violent confrontation of a bully in a public space of assembly — atop having a public persona which is marketed as such — is not off-limits. Bullies usually back off once people stand up to them.

Anyone who might go to confront him: no violence, no name-calling, no screaming. Stand together, stand strong. Speak as one. If he wants to leave abruptly, let him leave abruptly. Don't follow him. You've done your part by just being there and showing the human face to what he mocked.

3
FollowerofLoki•

Is it bad that I am actually kind of frightened to see the response to this thread in /r/lgbt? 'Cuz seriously. I don't really think I have the energy to see people who should be our allies whining about how awful trans women are to cis gay men.

6
javatimesgender tater•

Yeah, the failboat ran aground there and spouted freshly picked fail over everyone. I do think moderating on reddit is a thankless tough fucking job. Shit goes so fast.

10
ava_marxOP•

Not at all. That comment thread has turned into a fairly epic clusterfuck.

8
FollowerofLoki•

So I've seen. Sigh

2
EjectNow•

I couldn't finish the whole video and I'm actually kind of stunned. Sure there are a lot of things trans women say that could make for a funny video, but it seemed like most of the topics picked for this video were just mean spirited.

5
RoryWalker•

It seemed like some of it would be funny little "hey, here's some silly stereotypes" if they weren't said five times each.

I really can't wait for this Shit X Say (to Y) meme to die. It seems to be in every single combination all over the LGBT subreddits.

I don't care what Shit Black Australian Cismen Say To German Transwomen.

1
alsoathrowaway•

Yeah, that video is pretty much maximally offensive.

5
nekosuneTrans woman programmer•

Oh look at the latest comment by uploader: "Definitely offensive. EXTREMELY OFFENSIVE!! I am disgusted by this video... Tell ya what, If it gets 1,000,000 views, I'll pull it down. Hows that sound, twats?"

5
kellyrosettapink•

You know, its just a video talking about stereotypes, and generalized crude humor.... I'm not saying I'm a Fan of it or anything, just saying its like what shit girls say, or what shit Spanish chicks say, or any other things along those lines, to those individual groups I'm sure it ticked them off, the same way if you made a joke about a race, religion, or sex in the presence of that race religion or sex, they May or May not be offended by it, depending on the depth of there ability to relax and take it in as a joke instead of an insult. On that note, even if this was definitively marked as an Insult, if you allow it to harm you or be taken as such, then it will bother you That much more, just allowing yourself to detach from the personal bits on this and look at it from a third party view as just comedy, will make it much easier to just not care, perhaps even enjoy the joke, as with many stereotypes they can be funny, at times, when used right. Again not saying it is being used right, not claiming this was meant as just humor, or as an insult i do not know, what i do know is allowing it to hurt you or bother you, Is not going to help anyone, or anything in this situation.

4
stayclosegrey•

The thing is this: Most of these videos are about making fun of the subject because they are an idiot. "Shit white girls say to black girls" is the prime example of this. The video takes a horribly racist character and make their absurdism funny. You're supposed to laugh at the subject because they are so very wrong and offensive. This is the joke in the majority of these videos.

THIS video, however, is positing that the subject is laughable merely because they are trans. It's not eve cleverly satirizing the trans community, it is just laying bare pieces of actual lives as if it's funny. The video is saying, "Look! Aren't transwomen ridiculous?"

This is a key difference. And while I think there are some funny things to be said about this communities sensitivity and elitism, this is straight up mocking a group of people and it's pretty offensive.

It's also not funny. Like, if it was mildly funny, I'd be half as offensive, but there aren't even any jokes. It's stupid.

4
kellyrosettapink•

i can understand this, but it is still ment and intended as comdey, the person who made it is a drag queen, and friends of many trans people, (i have spoken with them now), it was not intended to be insulting, more just a bashing on stereotypes, again, each group is conformed of there own members, i can understand why you find this insulting, i myself am transsexual, i started hormones less then a month ago, iv been in full time for 5 months now, but again, this video was meant for humor, be it crude humor or not it was meant for that, and obviously any methods we have been using to try and Reason, if we may use that word for this instance, with the person who posted it to perhaps request it be augmented or removed, have failed so far, so it would come to reason perhaps another approached is required????

2
KingOfSockPuppets•

Yea, I agree. There are a few comedic elements, but the whole thing is just in such poor taste it really misses whatever mark it was aiming for. I got really pissed off at the shoulder size stuff, for some reason. They claim to be a parody of the other "Things ____ say" but there's two problems:

  1. "Trannies". Since I'm in r/transgender, I'll skip over why that's problematic.

  2. Like you said, it's just a bunch of statements of things that trans people really say, BUT THERE's NO COMEDIC CONTEXT. The other videos achieve comedy because they are comments that are, on the face, false or absurd in some way. That's why "Things white girls say to black girls" works because you can hear the privilege oozing out of every comment and that's what provides the humor. In this case, the problems are (sub numberings?)

A) Doing it all in a 'ditzy' voice. Seriously, there are obvious implications to that presentation style, and going 'oh my god, I have breasts!', or 'are my shoulders big' in that voice is just... asdashdq. Yes video uploader, it's funny that I have to take a lifelong hormonal regimen to feel comfortable and make it a note of pride when I get my breasts. Thank you for pointing that out to me like a valley girl and using me in a 'parody'.

B) As noted, it's literally just things trans people say. No hints of privilege. No clear reason why any of it is absurd. So, yea, thanks for presenting my struggles like a valley girl, I'm glad you can take your breasts off at the end of the day and abandon that persona. The things have no comedy, except maybe "Where are my hormones?". The most barest, tiniest inkling of amusement entered my (what I'm sure I'll be told it is) cold, withered, humorless activist soul.

tl;dr: a video called 'shit niggers say' done in blackface repeating totally innocuous statements would be a poor parody move

1
stayclosegrey•

That is a wonderful tl;dr. I think it really draws a parallel of what is a parody of stupid people of a demographic and what is a hateful slam against a demographic.

Parody: Shit black people say: "No, dude, that's our word."

Hate: Shit niggers say: "I'm a burden on society because I don't work."

I know you see the difference, SockPuppet King. It's just sad that some people don't. (I actually got to this thread because a drag queen friend of my posted it on facebook. He thought it was funny.)

1
rivermandan•

I swear to god, the internet has been pissing me off all week. if I look at my comment history, it seems every comment is in response to something infuriating some asshole says about transfolk.

1
eternalkerri•

Its not even fucking funny. I mean I am totally down with a Shit Trannys Say video if it was at least funny. This is so forced, so over stereotypical (if you have stereotype flavored things done well, its amazing...aka Chapelles Show), and poorly edited.

Its just simply not funny!

0
ratta_tata_tatGenderTerror•

Isn't the point of this Shit x says meme supposed to be about offensive shit one group says to another? So it fails on that part.

As for the rest of it, sorry. Not funny. This is just dumb and I can't find why this is even a thing.

It wasn't so bad at first but then...as it went on...Oh god. Just no, seriously. Stop.

0
MadxHatter0Pansexual Transgender•

Well, that was incredibly offensive. Somethings might have been funny, if it was an actual transgender person saying them, but the way this guy did it was just offensive. I mean, this is promoting a stereotype, and a very hurtful one.

I hate this entire shit_says meme since it's just a bunch of hateful things being said with no basis.

0
RoryWalker•

Can we stop this "Shit X Say" meme?

I'm really, really tired of seeing all of this. It's so annoying. Shit Blacks Say to Gay Guys, Shit Girls Say to Transmen, Shit Straight Guys Say to Gays, Shit Spanish Girls Say, Shit Fat Girls Say...

That aside. This seems like light hearted teasing, not transphobia. I'm curious why you censored shit but not tranny. I don't care either way, just curious. Also, can we please stop this meme?

-1
[deleted]•

Don't you guys think you're over-reacting a bit? There's tons of these videos and no one reacts to their videos like you guys do to this one.

-7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

7
Andrensath•

And how many of these videos are mocking one of the most marginalized groupings in society?

4
PraefectiaI came for the rainbows•

People will always be offended about something.

I've laughed at too many minority jokes to have any right to be offended with this myself.

2
Ayonyx•

I thought it was funny xDD

-10
gooseberry85•

I thought it was funny.

-11
patienceinbee…and that's typical of you•

Of course you did.

6