So someone made a "S**t Trannys Say" video, and guess what, it was a cis man. [TW: extremely offensive] [x-posted on r/transgender]
Posted Jan 13, 2012, 3:21 PM UTC
Posted Jan 13, 2012, 3:21 PM UTC
Ah, and apparently the person who made it is a drag queen. I'll let others tackle the implications of that...
Drag Queens are transexuals.
Nope!
Transgender. Either way you're splitting hairs. Everyone is being made fun of by the typical stereotypes. You're just going to have to get over it.
You're an idiot.
Since no-one else is explaining the difference to you, I will have a try: a transgender person is one who feels they are the opposite gender to their biological body type ... so a drag queen could be a biological male who actually feels that he is a male, and is therefore not transgender, but he dresses up in a parody of a female
By some definitions, drag queens are transgender, but they are not transsexual. (I know some transsexual women who are also drag queens, but that doesn't mean all drag queens are transsexual.)
Technically, they're transgender by the definition of not ascribing to typical gender roles, but they do it for performance.
Also, him being a drag tranny explains why he seems to wear that outfit so well.
Oh look at the latest comment by uploader: "Definitely offensive. EXTREMELY OFFENSIVE!! I am disgusted by this video... Tell ya what, If it gets 1,000,000 views, I'll pull it down. Hows that sound, twats?"
So, basically, by posting this the uploader was given exactly what he wanted views and attention.
And that comment has been removed now.
You censored "Shit" but not "Tranny?"
Yeah, I thought about doing it, then decided against it, then kind of regretted not doing it after I did. I blame my lack of coffee this morning prior to posting. Sorry! :-(
Just bringing it to your attention. As far as I'm concerned, this is an appropriate response on your part.
Why censor any of it?
I really don't understand that at all.
I think that was how the video uploader, not the OP, made the title.
It was not.
I couldn't check for myself, I'm redditing from my phone. I was just being charitable.
No problem; I understand.
[deleted]
it's certainly not your posting
The cissplaining in these comments is pretty terrible.
I don't even bother following this subr anymore.
I thought it was slightly offensive, and not really funny at all. This "Shit Drag Queens Say" by Pandora Boxx is actually pretty hilarious...and I never would've seen it, if not for your post, so...thanks? :-p
cross post from r/transgender. I'll elaborate on any points if someone wants.
Yea, I agree. There are a few comedic elements, but the whole thing is just in such poor taste it really misses whatever mark it was aiming for. I got really pissed off at the shoulder size stuff, for some reason. They claim to be a parody of the other "Things ____ say" but there's two problems:
"Trannies". Since I'm in r/transgender, I'll skip over why that's problematic.
Like you said, it's just a bunch of statements of things that trans people really say, BUT THERE's NO COMEDIC CONTEXT. The other videos achieve comedy because they are comments that are, on the face, false or absurd in some way. That's why "Things white girls say to black girls" works because you can hear the privilege oozing out of every comment and that's what provides the humor. In this case, the problems are (sub numberings?)
A) Doing it all in a 'ditzy' voice. Seriously, there are obvious implications to that presentation style, and going 'oh my god, I have breasts!', or 'are my shoulders big' in that voice is just... asdashdq. Yes video uploader, it's funny that I have to take a lifelong hormonal regimen to feel comfortable and make it a note of pride when I get my breasts. Thank you for pointing that out to me like a valley girl and using me in a 'parody'.
B) As noted, it's literally just things trans people say. No hints of privilege. No clear reason why any of it is absurd. So, yea, thanks for presenting my struggles like a valley girl, I'm glad you can take your breasts off at the end of the day and abandon that persona. The things have no comedy, except maybe "Where are my hormones?". The most barest, tiniest inkling of amusement entered my (what I'm sure I'll be told it is) cold, withered, humorless activist soul.
tl;dr: a video called 'shit niggers say' done in blackface repeating totally innocuous statements would be a poor parody move
Best TLDR I've seen all week.
Why isn't this the top comment?
Damn, I was having a good day until I watched this. Why is it that drag queens have their scopes on transsexuals? Is it because they have cis privilege? Is it because of sissyphobia in the G community?
Why are you attacking us so ruthlessly?
"Sissyphobia"?
Also, this is really not ruthless at all. It's annoying and repetetive, like all the other Shit X Says videos that I am seriously tired of seeing, Goddamn.
Poor production quality and not very funny (Though I did laugh at "doctors in Thailand", I have to admit), but I felt the stupidity of it was great enough not to be offended that much by it.
The only thing I kinda found offensive was "I'm not a drag queen; I'm a transsexual." There's a big fucking difference, and a cis person lampooning the statement implies that the difference is insignificant and doesn't matter. It's like if a lesbian did something like this and said "I'm not a butch lesbian; I'm a trans man." There is nothing wrong with being either, but implying that the distinction doesn't matter is insensitive. If a trans man said it, it could be seen as a relatable joke to other trans men. If a trans women said "I'm not a drag queen; I'm a transsexual" in a video like this, it would be seen that way, too. But it was said by a cis male, so the implication of the joke is different and insulting. But, being the stupidly unfunny video that it is, I can't really get too upset by it.
I don't see it that way. I wouldn't see "I'm not a dyke, I'm a trans man" any different.
Although the only thing that really made me laugh was "Do you have these in a size 16?"
For someone who's been on 4chan a lot, you sure suck at picking up on this video's >>implying's.
I'm sorry - this may be an ignorant question, but what is a "cis man"?
Not Trans basically Cis means that Gender identity matches the body they are in. Trans means it differs.
huh. is 'cis' short for anything?
Nope. Cis and Trans are both latin prefixes, and they've been used in chemistry for hundreds of years to describe the shapes of molecules. Cis basically means "same side" and trans means "opposite side". So for example, cis-2-pentene is a carbon double bond with two "legs" that are on the same side, but trans-2-pentene is a carbon double bond with two "legs" that are on opposite sides.
When talking about gender identity, cis means that physical and mental gender are "on the same side". Trans means that they are not.
Thanks for the definition. That's the first time I've actually seen the Latin meaning for it.
It is short for Cisgender Trans and cis are common terms in chemistry too they both are prefixes relating to wether something is on the same 'side' or different 'side' For further information you could look here at the wikipedia article for Cisgender
TIL
It is also used in geography. See Cisalpine Gaul, or Ciscarpathia, for example.
No, it's pretty much a recently made-up term with a prefix borrowed from chemistry that annoys the hell out of most people.
"Cis" is a perfectly legitimate Latin prefix.
Why do you find it annoying?
[deleted]
Basically they wanted a different term for normal because it implies anything else is abnormal.
I love making up new words as much as the next English speaker but I don't think trans folk are making life easier by using language thei allies have to be educated on.
I agree. That's why this whole sodomist's rights movement will fail, they keep coming up with these fancy new words! I mean, homosexual? Homophobia? Heterosexual? Who studies their Greek roots these days! Let's not even talk about "heteronormative!" Come on! This is way too many new words to learn! Why can't we just say "Sodomite" and "normal" instead?
[/sarcasm]
it is not a made up word, it is an existing word that has allways meant basically, the opposite of trans, right back from the latin days.
I don't know whther to upvote or downvote
I'd suggest getting the can of petrol, myself...
I'd suggest targeting the youtube video itself (flagging, commenting, etc.), but then again it is my karma at stake lol :-)
Downvoting doesn't affect your link karma, AFAIK
[deleted]
[deleted]
Dear Trans community, is this offensive? Yes. Does every other group possible have similar videos? Well judging by the side bar...YES. Shit fat people say, Shit lesbians say. It's a new fad that got started and it will pass.
This is still the place to discuss this sort of thing, no? I've seen less offensive things said about gay people discussed here and pretty unanimously complained about and thought of as offensive.
And I post the same shit in those topics about how we should stop acknowledging this and be the bigger man or woman. Feeding into this and letting the poster get the reaction they want is well letting them win.
it's just a joke!!!!!!!11 like on top gear!!!!!!
This reminds me of when people take offense at South Park.
south park is a piece of shit show and it is only funny if you've had a lobotomy
I hate that I find it funny. Damn crackers and their mindcontrol...
Psychosurgery, often nonconsensual, ("if you've had a lobotomy") is not fodder for your immature jokes, RobotAnna. Lay the fuck off the lobotomy jokes.
I don't understand why transsexuals go out of their way to find stuff on the internet which offends them and then wallow in their own self-pity. I don't go searching for homophobic content which I'm sure there's a lot of on the internet.
There is plenty of links on this subreddit alone pointing to and complaining about yet more people speaking / acting against LGB.
its almost like its so pervasive it can't be avoided or some shit
[deleted]
well the ENTIRE LGBT community tends to do this. I usually just come on /r/lgbt and laugh because of how pessimistic it is. People act like just because they are being "Attacked" no one else is.
[deleted]
I dunno, I thought it was pretty much like all the other ones: nothing hilarious but nothing to get offended over.
In my mind there's an enormous difference between making a video of shit other people say to members of a group you yourself are a part of vs. lampooning a marginalized group who you apparently don't have any kind of understanding of. Plus, if you're going to be offense, you've got to amp the cleverness up quite a bit, something this person absolutely didn't do. Pointing out that we take synthetic hormones and struggle to get acceptance for our identities is not exactly a very incisive observation.
You said it yourself (and I checked myself) that he is a drag queen, so I wouldn't say that he's devoid of any kind of understanding. I just think that the T community as a whole needs to really pick their battles as to what we get offended by. The recent Libra tampon commercial? Yeah, pretty tasteless and offensive. The whole Totino's debacle? Offended for the sake of it. This video is just someone jumping on the bandwagon of "Shit (group) says" videos and can be dismissed pretty easily.
Wait, how does being a drag queen make him understanding of trans women? Apparently to him we're just histrionic hormone fiends who are so insecure about our identities that we have to spend what little free time we have between popping birth control pills to reaffirm our genders to ourselves in the mirror. This is not understanding trans women.
And nobody's making a "battle" out of anything, this is just some raging on reddit about a stupid, offensive video. The only thing I see people here getting mad about is people telling us what kind of portrayals of us we can and can't find offensive, rather than letting us decide for ourselves.
People can be offended by whatever they want. Just don't be surprised when after a while you're taken as seriously as this.
Yeah...but there are plenty of other videos that are just "Shit Fat people say" And other like things.
So, one bad thing existing makes another bad thing okay. Got it.
I'm not saying it's okay. But what is the point of acknowledging people who do these things? LGBT people are so negative all the damn time.
Couldn't agree less.
Did we watch the same video?
no. the other ones are mocking privileged assholes, in this one, the person who made it IS a privileged asshle
I agree... I think these are all intended to be slightly offensive. Last night I watched "Things Christians say to Jews" and while there was some offensive stuff in there, I don't think it's anything to get upset over.
The difference is those videos were made by Christians and Jews.
And most of the other ones weren't. Shit black girls say? That certainly wasn't a girl...
Then I'm just as angry about that one. I stopped after the second video in this meme :/
Okay, I have to admit that the "doctors in Thailand" part actually made me giggle. Otherwise, I don't know what to say… he's a drag queen, so I think he was trying to make a dramatic statement. Rude and offensive? Absolutely.
[deleted]
cissplaining.txt
[deleted]
Note to everyone: this guy started r/beatingtrannies because he's mad that r/TransphobiaProject called him out on his transphobia.
Um...is that trying to be ironic? I hope so 'cause otherwise I'm going to be sick.
Does it matter whether it's ironic? It's not witty, clever or insightful. It's just advocating violence, no two ways about it.
I agree it's super offensive and seriously transphobic.
But oh no, oh hell no, not this trigger warning (tw) shit. This isn't LiveJournal or Tumblr. Fuck that. If you are actually thrown off balance by things on the internet you should fuck off, unplug your router, and go play with puppies in a bright grassy field.
Trigger warnings are for people who actually don't want their PTSD set off in easily avoidable ways (thank you very much), you ableist jerk.
cool story bro
go away troll.
Not a troll. I've been a member of this comm for ages. I just don't like this kind of crap creeping in.
Taking the position that everyone who disagrees with you is automatically a troll is shaky ground.
While it is offensive, it is no more offensive than the other 'shit blanks say' videos. If you laugh at one, you have to accept them all, despite certain topics being more taboo than others. Maybe learning to take a joke is a step toward acceptance. Maybe all the videos should be criticized equally.
The point OP is making, and that you missed, is that it IS different than those videos. Shit Black People Say had black people in it, making the jokes. Yes it was offensive. This video was made by a cis person to ridicule a community of people. It is different.
The actor in 'shit girls say' is a male.
exactly. why did i not see anyone jumping on the patriarchy enforcing stereotypes of "shit girls say"?
That probably happened in r/feminism(s) or a similar subreddit, much as one on trans people goes in r/LGBT.
Because I can't be everywhere at once.
Yo mods of r/lgbt: Do something about the transphobia & cis privilege in this subreddit please.
[deleted]
Whats the problem? Are you saying cis people aren't privileged over trans people?
[deleted]
How? Are you kidding? Did you even read any of the posts in this thread? Or this entire subreddit? There's a deep current of transphobia, cissexism, and cis privilege in all of r/lgbt.
I feel like this has been said before when people point out homophobia. How is this any different? Saying someone is "complaining" about something that is generally offensive to a group of people is just a way of belittling an issue.