Has anyone ever had a piece of major media come out that resembles a part of your world?

Discussion

This has happened to me at least once. A part of my world includes a race of non-gendered alien beings with gems embedded inside them. Sound familiar? (I'll describe them in greater detail at some point later) I assure you, I definitely came up with these beings before Steven Universe was even a thing. I'm talking in 2008 at least. Of course, I've never met Rebecca Sugar and there's no way she knew of my content, as I'd barely posted any of it on the internet at that point.

There are a great many differences between my race of Gemonites and the Gems from Steven Universe, but it's still interesting to see when things like this happen.

So, has anyone else had something like this happen to them?

Posted Jul 7, 2021, 6:35 PM UTC

1013
smekrasSundered Realms•

I used to be a StoryTeller for the better part of the last 20 years. Back when the new World of Darkness came out, and for a period of about 3 years, almost everything that happened in the IRC chronicle I was running would find a close analogue in a nWoD book a few months later. It was so bad that I suspected one of my players worked for WhiteWolf.

It was quite amusing, I have to admit.

7
gamingAlan975•

that is so annoying! I was talking with a friend about my world and they just go "so dragon age?"

I had not played dragon age before that, I had not seen dragon age nor even heard about it.

7
Kartoffelkamm•

Oh God, yes.

Though, admittedly, they (mostly) go back to me watching anime while half asleep when I was sick as a kid, and me then remembering it years later and thinking it was a dream.

Some time around 2016, a memory popped into my head. A girl in mostly black clothes, with red accents, and frills, beating the sh*t out of a giant vacuum cleaner monster, or stopping a falling elevator by tying the cable to herself and pushing off of both sides of the elevator shaft. After a while, I remembered two words: Pretty Cure.

So, I tried to look it up on my go-to anime streaming site. Nothing.

And that is the kind of site that has shows I've never heard of, nor understand how anyone could seriously approach a producer with the concept, let alone why anyone would produce that.

For a few years, I thought I had watched so much Sailor Moon and Dragon Ball that my mind, in my delirious half-sleep state, combined the two into something amazing.

A bit over a year ago, I discovered, purely by chance, that that wasn't the case, and that there is actually an anime called Futari Wa Pretty Cure, which got dubbed as Pretty Cure outside of Japan back in 2009, five years after its initial release.

Also, I later discovered that some other idea I had, about a magical girl fighting evil spirits in paintings, thus ruining them and being seen as the bad guy by the public she protects, is also not from my dreams. It's called Phantom Thief Jeanne. I only found this because one of the people that worked on a Pretty Cure season worked on that one as well.

There are a few other examples of me thinking some magical girl anime was in a dream of mine, only to discover that it actually exists already, which is why I chose to not write any stories with humanoid main characters in it, to avoid accidental copyright infringement.

3
[deleted]•

It’s only copyright infringement if you’re seeking to make money off it. Kitbashing an anime into a tabletop for you and your friends to play is fine

1
Kartoffelkamm•

Yeah, but I was planning to write a novel based on those ideas, and sell it, which would definitely be illegal.

2
Degleewana007•

For me its always been the other way around, I come up with an idea only to find out its already been done by some major media that I never heard of up until that point. Here's just a list of a few of these instances.

  • I came up with a world where a mysterious artifact randomly grants people superpowers that (usually) manifest as shadow-like entities called Shades, then I told a friend about it and they informed me of a long running manga series called Jojo's Bizarre Adventure which features a very similar thing called The Stand Arrow and superpowers called Stands.
  • I came up with a world where people used their souls to perform magic, which corrupted some of them and turned them into soul devouring demons. I later found out that its a similar plot to the game Demon's Souls.
  • I wrote a short series in which a vigilanty detective was investigating a string of chases connected to a recently unearthed ancient artifact that caused people to either evolve into a powerful lovecraftian being if their mind was able handle the eldritch truth revealed by the artifact, or devolve into a bestial monster if they're unable to handle it. I later found out about a game called Bloodborne; which from my understanding has a similar plot and themes.
3
MrManicMartyCreative Hell•

Okay, so I never did anything with this, but like - I had an idea for a world where the main premise centered on biologically altered dragons, who were piloted (from the inside) by humans. And then there actually was an anime made about that exact premise called Dragon Pilot. So... how about that.

3
[deleted]•

A long time ago, inspired by a video game glitch I saw, I decided to create a dark fantasy world, featuring macabre giant supernatural artificial humanoid weapons in an alternate World War I, but I recently discovered a fairly popular anime that is literally all of those things but better than what I had in mind, so I no longer felt the need to make it myself.

3
Awryl•

Twice, actually. Both with fledgling ideas, luckily, so not much was lost. The first was with a fantasy race I had created, and China Miéville's khepri race in the setting of Perdido Street Station. Both races were insectoid, and were highly valued as artists for the secretion they could produce, which could be used for sculpting.

The second time was with a sci-fi setting of mine, and the setting of Skyward by Brandon Sanderson. More with Starsight, though. The ideas behind both were the same, with a multi-species spacefaring civilization that valued non-aggressiveness, where humans were actually the "aggressive warrior species," like klingons, and were kept out of the civilization because of it.

2
SlayerOfDerp•

There was one time several years ago now where I was describing a part of my world to my dad and he just went "sounds a lot like the white walkers from game of thrones". Now sure, mine were still a bit different (the actual inspiration was the necrons from warhammer 40k where I'd swapped the metal for ice, reduced tech level so they didn't look like robots (they were instead made from dead creatures magically turned into this "living ice") and the "big units" was stuff like polar bears or stags (or dragons/giants even), possibly with riders, rather than bug robots and removed necron-specific cultural elements like their gods and architecture and added some of my own stuff instead)

But the core concept of "undying legion from an icy waste" combined with - I think - the fact that he was reading through the a song of ice and fire books (and/or watching the show) at the time made him make the connection very quickly.

1
NuclearWalrusNetworkSanctum/Solace/Mindscape/Caldera•

I know the book series has been around for a while though I hadn't read it, but when I first saw Shadow and Bone it lined up very very closely with the version of Solace I was working on at the time. The setting has since been overhauled and made distinct but damn they were practically the same in some aspects.

1
riftrender•

Very rarely with fictional work, but I've had ideas and found it an actual history and I was like this is perfect for a source.

1
Crawlingchaos19•

My world bears major similarities to R Scott Bakker’s work. Even the major characters are extremely close in personality and ability.

1