This is gonna get me downvoted, but I think trans people are weird.
Posted Jan 13, 2012, 9:50 PM UTC · edited
Posted Jan 13, 2012, 9:50 PM UTC · edited
If it was body dysmorphic disorder, being transgender could be "treated" with psychotherapy. That has been tried. There's a reason it's not done any more in respected facilities.
Thank you for responding earnestly. If you could show me the research I would appreciate it, especially if anyone explored my question explicitly.
www.wpath.org contains many resources, specifically should http://www.wpath.org/medical_necessity_statement.cfm help you. I've been digging a bit but hit a couple of paywalls. I'll get back to this later, if I get the chance.
Edit: RES messing with my links
Oh god. Finally. Somebody civil. Thank you for existing. I am not actually joking.
First off, we do not chop our genitals off. Secondly, it's really not your call to make, is it?
[deleted]
what's wrong with BDD?
What's wrong with anorexia? Or plastic surgery addicts? Or anyone that is never satisfied with the way they look.
whats wrong with your posting?
oh right it sucks
not sure if trolling...
edit: gonna downvote just in case...
[deleted]
then you're a shitty human being
You don't really have much to go off here to make that assessment. I get on here to ask serious questions and instead I get labeled a "shitty human being".
Yes she does
I think trans people are weird.
want to chop your genitals off and switch sexes
How is this any different than, I don't know, skin bleaching to change your ethnicity?
A bunch more stupid armchair psychology
Yes you are a shitty human being for thinking these things
what teefs said
here is a serious reponse: you are a shitty human being and you should really google things to understand them before denigrating people who have to deal with shitheads like you their entire life
all you fucking crackers are the same
Now you're being racist.
How is it different from having BDD?
no im not racist some of my best friends are white. they hate crackers too.
and what is wrong with BDD?
I answered that question for you already.
And your question is kind of a digression because it does nothing but distract from my question. I never said there was anything wrong with having BDD. But that still doesn't answer how transgenderism isn't related to BDD.
personally im not convinced they're not related to each other in some way but i am a) not a medical professional nor an authority on the subject and b) not sure what that proves even if they are and most importantly c) your posting is terrible
Your argument is "GID = BDD, prove me wrong". That doesn't seem like a great way to go about learning something..
My argument is GID ∈ BDD and why isn't anybody taking that line of reasoning seriously.
Because "you're weird" isn't a serious line of reasoning. If you're interested in scholarly citations it's always much faster to do an internet search than to insult random internet strangers.
it's always much faster to do an internet search than to insult random internet strangers.
Apparently not because that's exactly what every responder in here is doing.
The thing is, your expecting every trans person to know all the ins and outs of it. May I ask you about all the Studies that explain why Homosexuality is not just that you hate the opposite sex / parent issues.
Well I'll give you my own experiences as a trans person, but note that my experiences may differ from others'.
I never really looked at my male body as "defective" or like there was something inherently wrong with it, like people with BDD do. It's just that I hated my body because 1) it meant that other people would see me as a boy/guy/man and not a girl, and I didn't want to be perceived that way, and 2) I wanted to have sex as a girl, and my very male body prevented me from being able to do so. I never felt comfortable acting like the female I feel I am because of my body, and wanted to change my body because of that. What made me have these desires? I have no idea. What makes you want to have sex with the people you're attracted to? What makes you feel like your sex perfectly matches who you are? I'm sure you have no idea, either. There has been research to see if transsexualism and homosexuality have neurological causes, and there is some evidence they do.
That said, just go look up the symptoms of each disorder. GID and BDD have two completely different sets of diagnostic criteria.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Body_dysmorphic_disorder#Symptoms_2
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_identity_disorder#Diagnostic_criteria
EDIT: I should also add, people with GID are not trying to seek out perfection in the eyes of others. They simply want to have the correct body that reflects who they are as a person, and allows them to have sex with others the way they feel they were meant to.
Thank you, so far I think you have the most substantiated reply in here so far.
Well.. did you take anything away from my post other than the fact that I didn't flame you right off the bat?
If you wanted serious responses, you shouldn't have worded your question with mostly insults and hurtful language. Most of the trans community here on Reddit is willing to be friendly and helpful, but they are rather notorious for blowing up on you if you fail to show any tact when posing your questions.
but they are rather notorious for blowing up on you if you fail to show any tact when posing your questions.
so like any other person anywhere ever
[deleted]
long = like also i meant to quote a bit of that post
[deleted]
Well I gutted it to the gist of my question I guess.
You call us 'weird' in the post title, and then your question is veiled in a rant about why you consider us weird. You don't see how that puts people off? You don't have to like us, or even understand us, but if you want us to take you seriously, you at least have to be polite. I'm generally a blunt person myself, but you can be blunt without being excessively negative and hurtful.
I would hardly qualify anything I said excessively negative or hurtful. And perhaps weird was the wrong word. Strange? Doesn't fit with "LGB"?
To answer your first question about BDD; it's not the same as, nor is it mutually exclusive to being transgender. Being transgender isn't all about the body, it's about a disconnect between gender identity and assigned sex. Simply put, the motivation for transgender people to take hormones and have surgery isn't about perfecting problems with the body, it's about correcting a mistake nature made when our bodies developed.
Secondly, the reason LGBT includes Transgender people, as well as genderqueer, etc... is because we're all marginalized groups because of who we are, and although Gender Identity and Sexual Orientation are not one in the same, they carry similar struggles and stigmas.
Many people think of transgender people and they picture poorly passing transvestites or late-in-life transitioning transsexuals who retain many of their male secondary sex characteristics. This portrayal of the community at large is the reason for lots of transphobia in the world.
Seriously? How do you not understand that any statement in the form "...but I think people of group x are weird" has a large potential for being offensive, especially if group x is a very marginalized group in the first place? Surely you're smart enough to comprehend this?
Simply titling your thread "How is transsexuality different from Body Dysmorphic Disorder?" would have been a very different thing, but no, you came in being insulting, and then got mad when people responded in kind.
You're an idiot and fuck off with your transphobia.
To address your question: I think the big difference between BDD and transsexuality is that those conditions have barely something in common. While BDD is the fear of your body being different or inferior to others, transsexuality has something to do with your own gender perception and identity.
How would you feel if you realized the other day that you are born in the body of the gender you are not identifying with? At first you might deny it and hate yourself for not being "conform" to your expected role in society but finally you will accept it.
Sexuality and gender identity is something so deeply rooted in the human mind that you can't simply change it (or rather can't change it without doing harm to a person's mind and sanity). So the only "cure" for transsexuality, which is in fact rather the cure for your misery being trapped in the wrong body, is changing your sex to match your perceived gender. This process of changing your gender might still be a rather poor copy of being a "normal" cisgender but for the affected people it's a relief and in fact, your chromosomes do barely affect your gender - it's all about the hormones (both while developing while pregnancy and in the full-grown human body).
Hence transgenders aren't (in my opinion) "sick" or "weird" in any form - I also wouldn't call myself sick or weird for being gay - and are in no way inferior to cisgenders.
...I hope I could clear your view on transsexuality with this post.
I dunno about everyone else, but I'm personally pretty embarrassed at the responses of some people to this thread/question/whatever. I'm not commenting on the wording of the OP, nor the tact. I just feel like everyone attacking the OP, calling him/her a shitty human being, and generally just offering nothing other than insults is a really crappy thing to do. Not to mention people getting upvotes for it.
Ever heard of "kill 'em with kindness?" How does it make you any better of a person when, instead of offering helpful links (like some have), you just sit there and say "your posting is shitty" or "you're an awful person?"
Personally I try to be a bit inbetween, I wont start swearing / like that unless really upset, however I wont ignore stuff either, I will point out and explain, or simply make voice heard.
People can't be coddled and spoon fed all the time and oh noes, someone might swear. You are expecting trans people to be all "please, oh thank you" while someone is shitting on us. No thanks. Oh wait that was polite. How do you think a straight person would be taken if they came to this subreddit and talked about how rude and impolite responses to homophobia are? Do you really think they wouldn't be laughed right the fuck off?
I never said I expected anything other than some decency. Please don't put words in my mouth.
I never said I expected anything other than some decency. Please don't put words in my mouth.
ok but...
I'm not commenting on the wording of the OP, nor the tact.
...but only from trans people. Please don't deny our agency regarding anger when someone is saying bigoted things to get a rise out of us (possibly among other reasons...but that was there, too.) Do you think trans people can't discern transphobia?
I would bet that most of the trans people responding here have (like myself) devoted many hours to education. It's not as if swearing in an insensitively worded reddit post is the only thing any of us ever do.
I look at these "controversial trans posts" of the last day, and I'm excited to see trans anger and sarcasm and snark. We need all of those things--it means we aren't just turning shit inward, but also focusing it back out where it came from. Trans people have constantly had to do that, because the world is a cruel shitty place.
Please check yourself for http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaslighting you might be wandering kind of close to it.
All I'm getting at is people responding to the OP and offering nothing other than insults doesn't help anyone's case. Sure, trans people have the right to be upset about ignorant and/or close-minded-sounding posts, but it doesn't really help anyone, prove anything, or advance any cause when you choose to respond with insults about the OP.
I'm not trying to start a flame war.
I think there is a serious issue in here where anybody who responds cannot construct an argument instead of just throwing abuse. The op is very serious in his remark, and very polite and concise in his opinion, but you lot see very keen to just throw abuse at someone who does not share the normative POV?
Bullshit, there are plenty of substantive replies if you're willing to take the time to look for them. But regardless, you're making an awfully big leap when you assume that people who choose not to educate - which is nobody's responsibility but the OP's - can't do so.
If he truley wanted to know the difference between BDD and being trans then maybe he would have worded his title a little better than "I think trans people are weird." He was rude, so people are being rude back. Not the most productive response but you really can't blame anyone else for it.
do you not think a more mature approach to pointing out differences is to try and convince with sensible opinion, research and evidence rather than abuse?
yes, but I also think a more mature title asking for actual information than just "you guys are weird" would have also been a better approach. Claiming "The op is very serious in his remark, and very polite and concise in his opinion" as you did in your first post is incorrect.
"I think X is weird" is VERY different to saying "X /is/ weird"
just because someone thinks they are "weird", does not give you the right to hurl abuse. I think a lot of people are weird, for example, lesbians, I think liking vagina is VERY weird... it is just an opinion.
The post has also been heavily edited.
I personally also see trans as a gender identity issue not a sexual orientation, it has always strikes me as odd they have been lumped together as the same issue, they are not - anyone who thinks otherwise is kidding themselves frankly.
I think we're mostly in the same basket because to the General Public we're all the same: dirty fags and queers. United in the face of a common enemy, so to speak.
Trans people are with lgb because we all receive discrimination along the lines of gender. Yes, before you remind me, sex and gender are different things. But heterosexuality is a part of "traditional" gender norms, so when a man is gay for example he is transgressing a gender norm no matter how masculine of a man he may be. So when a genetic male transitions they are also crossing a gender norm. We are all together because to the hatred that is homophobia is usually based in the same place as that of transphobia.
Also trans people have been with lgb people from the beginning, we were just as involved in the stonewall riots as everyone else but unfortunately many cis people have tried to minimize the role of trans people in that affair.
yea, and why would civil rights activists side with labor unions? theyre not the same thing!!! durr!!! i cant see correlations because im a fat idiot!!! durr!! derp le herp!
using "fat" as a slur is fatphobic, but i do otherwise agree with your tone and premise.
i needed something to break the flow between "a" and "idiot" because "an idiot" doesnt work as well. apologies & namaste
It's not "lumping together" it's solidarity as marginalized human beings.
I agree. You can be Trans AND LGB for example.
[deleted]
(and I think you will find the medical community agrees)
Agreed. "Transgenders" (a false term, the real term is Transsexuals) are scum, and like the Homosexuals, the Semites, the Africans, and the filthy Roma, they hold back the progression of human evolution. This disorder cannot be allowed to exist, and any individuals with it should be put to death. Only beautiful, strong Aryan peoples should be allowed to carry into the future, to create a new race of super men and women. Ron Paul 2012.
its amazing how you channel reddit into a pure, distilled form
FNRI missed the woman-hating / women-objectifying parts of reddit and didn't appeal to evo-psych.
lmfao this post owns
[deleted]
prolly like the dsm dude, maybe im just a dumb psych major but generally i take years of academic studies and the Big Ol Book of medicine's word over that of some guy on the internet
[deleted]
i had a big post written up but really the fact that the standard for academia recognizes them as different disorders (though dsm-v might drop the disorder from gender identity disorder) is really enough for anyone except a researcher with a hypothesis