Health Savings Account
Can someone explain why this is a good thing to do? My hospital does not match residents with 401k so was thinking to do a ROTH and a HSA? Any thoughts? ( I just started intern year)
Posted Jul 13, 2021, 9:39 AM UTC
Can someone explain why this is a good thing to do? My hospital does not match residents with 401k so was thinking to do a ROTH and a HSA? Any thoughts? ( I just started intern year)
Posted Jul 13, 2021, 9:39 AM UTC
Few points to consider:
to be eligible for an HSA, you must be in a qualifying high deductible plan. In the info packet about the different options, it should say if it qualifies or not
HSA plans are a great way to save for future health costs IF a high deductible plan makes sense for your situation. If it’s a crappy choice for insurance, I.e. you have multiple medical problems, see multiple specialists, plan on having a kid during the coverage year, etc., don’t choose the high deductible plan. Choose whoever insurance makes the most sense first.
You are likely correct to prioritize Roth contributions while in residency as these will be your lowest tax years until retirement, and maybe even in retirement. Getting a combo of pre and post tax through the Roth and the HSA is a great combo.
Love the user handle.. good job. Although #3 I thought was super on point. Roth early on, health risks and needs are lower and so is income. Caveat you can always do backdoor Roth’s as income overcomes thresholds
Keep in mind that HSAs are taxable in CA
Really???? Remind me never to move to CA. What aspect of it is taxable?
CA does not recognize HSA; so it’s treated like an after tax account. It’s funded with post tax money, and you have to pay capital gains.
That is so crazy that California can do this when HSAs are established federally. Thanks for letting me know.
I believe this is only for CA state tax. It's still tax free federally.
The HSA is the holy grail of accounts if you can get one. It requires you to have an HDHP, but here's a basic breakdown:
You can contribute $3,600 to it, basically irrespective of income, and deduct it from taxable income ($7,200 if married).
You can use the money at any time for qualified medical expenses with no taxes or penalties, so unlike an IRA/401(k) if you break your leg and you're somehow out of money, this is an option.
You can reimburse yourself for medical expenses from your entire life as long as you have the receipt, so most people just pay out of pocket and save the receipts for when they need money later.
In retirement, you can also take the money out like a normal IRA if you run out of receipts or stop needing medical care (who needs less medical care as an older person? Basically nobody).
Basically - no tax on deposits, no tax on gains, no tax on withdrawals if qualified.
The only real downside of HSA is when it comes to bequeathing them - it's not as elegant as IRAs and there are more taxes. But, meh.
This 🔼 on point!
Yes, HSAs are much better used up during your lifetime. Not really a great account to inherit. Fully taxable & you have to take the money out lump sum immediately.
Yep yep yep
Let's say you know you're going to pay for something medical: you have a chronic condition or baby on the way.
You can prepare the money you're going to spend tax free in the HSA.
Lots of great advice here so I won’t beat a dead horse.
I use one and I’m happy with it. Guess what? Having a baby is expensive. Yes it’s mostly covered but what if something goes wrong? What if you need to buy some prescriptions when the baby gets sick? Etc etc.
Very happy to have one and to reap some tax breaks, too. It’s an option so why not use it, ya know?
When you say Roth, are you talking a Roth 401(k) or a Roth IRA? Starting an HSA now is not a bad idea, as long as you have a qualifying HDHP. It does save you on taxes. You need to be sure that the qualifying plan is actually the right one for your needs, though. Take a look at these two posts. The first will help you prioritise your finances during residency, second is HSA-specific.
Roth IRA with Schwab
Then, yes, I would recommend you fund a Roth IRA before contributing to employer retirement accounts without a match.
From what I understand HSAs are the best account there is. Tax free on the way in, our and during growth as long as you use it for medical costs or retirement (unsure what the date cutoff is off the top of my head)
They are only tax free if using for medical expenses
Does it not act like an IRA once you turn 59.5? Meaning that you can take distributions that are non-medical.
You can but they are taxed. Roth wouldn’t be
Most of us will all have some medical expenses at the end
Yes does that mean making it a 100% of your portfolio. No that would be idiotic.
Agreed that would be idiotic, did anyone suggest going 100%? Thoughts like that would make me suggest a financial advisor
Account as far as what? Health type of account?
Check out the white coat investor blog.
HSA has plenty of tax benefits when used for healthcare costs, but something to consider is that your residency may be one of the last times you can really effectively utilize a Roth account. How many healthcare expenses do you expect to incur over the course of your residency?
If that expectation is low, it might be better to take advantage of your lower tax bracket while you can with a Roth 401k and then just start to add to your HSA when you're an attending.
Planned on doing both. My program doesn’t match 401k so using roth instead
Nice, I was under the impression you were asking which to prioritize or which to invest in if investing in both wasn’t an option. If you can comfortably invest in both, that’s great news.
Roth >>> HSA fo sho
Triple tax advantaged. Tax free in, grows tax free, tax free out on health care. If you get free insurance thru work (I’m guessing you do) use what they give you. HSAs are great but free is free.
This simply. And if you do t use it for health use it for retirement