Can we ditch the transgender once and for all?
Creating a throwaway for this post because it seems my opinion makes me a bigot.
I think the collapse of the lgbt subreddit was long overdue, and it always made me very uncomfortable since I found out that the moderators are a straight couple. rmuser is a transgendered man in case you didn't know, and silentagony is a straight woman. Why a straight couple appointed themselves community leaders of a gay community, I just don't get. But I think I'm not alone in wanting a gay community for and by gay people.
And I know I'm not alone in wanting a gay community free from trannies. The final nail in the coffin for the lgbt subreddit was the trannies disrupting everything, and rather than do the sensible thing and toss them out on their backsides, they're getting things their way. The lunatics are well and truly running the asylum now. I keep asking people, why does the T belong with LGB? But I'm just told I'm a bigot instead of getting a straight answer. I'm sick and tired of being called a bigot for voicing my opinion, or worse, being called some stupid non-existent word like transphobe. I'm sick of the whole community going along with the fevered dreams of mental cases, men in dresses and dykes who take the butch thing too far.
Can we take back the gay community for gay people once and for all?
Posted Jan 16, 2012, 5:44 PM UTC
This is not only incredibly toxic and bigoted, it's completely ignorant of history.
Go look up the history of Stonewall. The people who were finally fed up and mad enough to fight and defend the gay bars were "drag queens" (edit: transfolk, but also drag queens). The Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence isn't a sex fetish crossdressing club - it started up in San Francisco to protect people of all orientations and provide safety to the streets and people of The Castro.
The fight that the transgendered fight is the same exact fight for GLB rights that you're fighting. Acceptance of gender diversity makes it easier for the average gay person. It makes it easier for everyone, because they're often the most marginalized and abused and misunderstood of the GLBT umbrella.
And you want to throw trans people under the bus? For what purpose? What goal? And what the fuck did they ever do to you?
And last: One of the stripes in that rainbow flag is for straight people. It's meant to include everyone.
Indeed. The battle for LGBTQ rights started as a battle against hostile enforcement of gender expectations, of which sexuality was one deviation from expectations among many.
I wish I could upvote this, like, 20 times. History is important!!
I too wish I could upvote a thousand times for this.. :< people who forget history are doomed to repeat it.. and in this case, repeat the abuse and hostilities against transsexuals, crossdressers, and all other orientations.
Source?
Anecdotal sources: Original members of The Sister's of Perpetual Indulgence who were there in SF when it was first invented and flown. (Yeah, SPI didn't exist as an entity, yet, but the people who founded it did.)
But yeah, you got me. None of the stripes actually represent any particular orientation or identity. The entire flag is about diversity - all of the colors of the human rainbow.
Did you know there used to be eight stripes instead of six?
Wikipedia is awesome, as usual. Your correction is right, none of the stripes represent orientations or identities, but the original 8 colors did have meanings assigned by the designer.