Can we ditch the transgender once and for all?

Creating a throwaway for this post because it seems my opinion makes me a bigot.

I think the collapse of the lgbt subreddit was long overdue, and it always made me very uncomfortable since I found out that the moderators are a straight couple. rmuser is a transgendered man in case you didn't know, and silentagony is a straight woman. Why a straight couple appointed themselves community leaders of a gay community, I just don't get. But I think I'm not alone in wanting a gay community for and by gay people.

And I know I'm not alone in wanting a gay community free from trannies. The final nail in the coffin for the lgbt subreddit was the trannies disrupting everything, and rather than do the sensible thing and toss them out on their backsides, they're getting things their way. The lunatics are well and truly running the asylum now. I keep asking people, why does the T belong with LGB? But I'm just told I'm a bigot instead of getting a straight answer. I'm sick and tired of being called a bigot for voicing my opinion, or worse, being called some stupid non-existent word like transphobe. I'm sick of the whole community going along with the fevered dreams of mental cases, men in dresses and dykes who take the butch thing too far.

Can we take back the gay community for gay people once and for all?

Posted Jan 16, 2012, 5:44 PM UTC

0227
loquacious•

This is not only incredibly toxic and bigoted, it's completely ignorant of history.

Go look up the history of Stonewall. The people who were finally fed up and mad enough to fight and defend the gay bars were "drag queens" (edit: transfolk, but also drag queens). The Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence isn't a sex fetish crossdressing club - it started up in San Francisco to protect people of all orientations and provide safety to the streets and people of The Castro.

The fight that the transgendered fight is the same exact fight for GLB rights that you're fighting. Acceptance of gender diversity makes it easier for the average gay person. It makes it easier for everyone, because they're often the most marginalized and abused and misunderstood of the GLBT umbrella.

And you want to throw trans people under the bus? For what purpose? What goal? And what the fuck did they ever do to you?

And last: One of the stripes in that rainbow flag is for straight people. It's meant to include everyone.

144
lifeinneon•

Indeed. The battle for LGBTQ rights started as a battle against hostile enforcement of gender expectations, of which sexuality was one deviation from expectations among many.

50
chimpanzeerather strange•

I wish I could upvote this, like, 20 times. History is important!!

37
Nesetalis•

I too wish I could upvote a thousand times for this.. :< people who forget history are doomed to repeat it.. and in this case, repeat the abuse and hostilities against transsexuals, crossdressers, and all other orientations.

12
jaki_cold•

One of the stripes in that rainbow flag is for straight people

Source?

6
loquacious•

Anecdotal sources: Original members of The Sister's of Perpetual Indulgence who were there in SF when it was first invented and flown. (Yeah, SPI didn't exist as an entity, yet, but the people who founded it did.)

But yeah, you got me. None of the stripes actually represent any particular orientation or identity. The entire flag is about diversity - all of the colors of the human rainbow.

Did you know there used to be eight stripes instead of six?

13
chimpanzeerather strange•

Wikipedia is awesome, as usual. Your correction is right, none of the stripes represent orientations or identities, but the original 8 colors did have meanings assigned by the designer.

6
[deleted]•

yes you are transphobic.... use your real account coward.

97
[deleted]•

Don't bring your drama over here. This subreddit was created to get away from the maliciousness of r/lgbt.

-96
alsoathrowaway•

And yet here's some asshat on a throwaway starting the drama right up. Or, wait, is it that it's okay to start the drama, but not okay to respond to it?

76
lifeinneon•

Classic bully tactic: throw a punch, and cry foul when you get hit back.

61
fantasyreality•

This . So much this. Frankly, what the mods did in /r/lgbt was quite over the top, but it's not hard to see from this thread who's actually being malicious and started all the drama.

27
[deleted]•

I'm part of the fucking rainbow too- our drama is your drama... Trans people are done being left in the dust- get over it.

50
fmota•

I think onetimer's "Dont bring your drama here" was directed towards your "use your real account coward". We don't need that. Nothing good can be gained from that.

-1
TheJizzard•

There's certainly nothing malicious about this thread

21
smischmal•

Wow, I don't think I've ever seen anyone with such low comment karma before. I seriously hope you're a troll, because you'd probably end up in some kind of hatred hall of fame.

3
[deleted]•

Basically, your argument, in non-ambiguous terms:

I don't hate trans people, I just don't want them around, don't care about their problems, don't care how my actions hurt them, and don't care about any flaws in my logic. That is why we shouldn't care about trans people.

Notice how you don't introduce any positive discourse, either. I'm really glad you decided to leave r/LGBT and I hope you encourage everyone like you to do the same! Good luck!

90
ucofresh•

Thats not what he was saying.. Basically he's asking what it has to do with homo/bisexuality

-29
[deleted]•

And when his question was adequately answered, he revealed that he doesn't actually care about that, he really just came here to insult trans people:

Heres the thing. I don't care about any reasons for the trannies to be included. When I asked that question, I was being rhetorical. Like when you ask a guy who's overstayed his welcome at a party, are you still here?

33
[deleted]•

I know I'm not alone in wanting a gay community free from trannies.

Hey, you know what, fuck you.

90
[deleted]•

We'll start our own lgbtq community! With black jack! and hookers!

28
lifeinneon•

Forget the community, and the blackjack!

20

ahhhh! Futurama!

5
feonix83•
2
wintertashmostly-gay poly cis boy•

Two points:

  1. Here's a pretty good set of arguments on why the trans* community has a place with the gay lesbian and bisexual one: http://www.bilerico.com/2011/10/5_best_reasons_for_lgbt_to_support_t.php

  2. If you don't want people to perceive you as a bigot for expressing your opinion, maybe using slurs like "trannies" is not the best way to go about it

78
0000again•

He isn't trying to explain why. He just thinks that making a sum up like "tranny" is supposed to just imply what he means, because he thinks it should just be "natural" for people to be offended by transgendered people. He doesn't explain because he doesn't think it should have to be.

In other words, he HAS no explanation because he hasn't thought of one. He's trying to represent himself through impulsive actions, the first thing that comes to mind, what comes "naturally" to him, which is apparently being prejudiced and violent, and he just expects people to "get" that.

1
throwawaymonkey77OP•

Heres the thing. I don't care about any reasons for the trannies to be included. When I asked that question, I was being rhetorical. Like when you ask a guy who's overstayed his welcome at a party, are you still here?

Tranny or trannies is not a slur. Never has been, and I'm not going to stop using it. I ain't gonna be bullied by this nonsense any more, and I'm not paying attention to trannies who pull this crap.

-96
mckatze•

So you bitch about nobody giving you reasons, then when someone gives you reasons, get butthurt and become all "Nooo I don't want to be corrected I was just being RHETORICAL can't you see how much of a special faerie faggot person I am?"

Frankly you're an over-reacting cry-baby who isn't actually raising any real points, doesn't want to debate, and just wants to piss and moan about something you've blown up in your own head.

edit: I hope I don't offend you by calling you a faggot. I mean, if tranny is ok, then certainly faggot is alright.

56
alsoathrowaway•

Tranny or trannies is not a slur. Never has been

That's horseshit. Go to Google, turn safesearch off. Do a search for "transgender", for "trans", and for "tranny", and see how your results differ.

50
joeycastillo30,male,gay');DROP TABLE flair;•

I think the downvotes and the community response have given you an answer to your question.

Also, don't paint with such a broad brush. I've known fantastic trans people in my life, who have nothing at all in common with the "lunatics running the asylum" that you speak of. Are there substantive differences between gender minorities and sexual minorities? Sure. But there are substantive similarities too. There are reasons for us to support each other, and in this community, we're going to do just that. No bullying. Just respect.

37
[deleted]•

Here's the thing. I don't care about any reasons for the fags to be taken seriously. When I asked that question, I was being rhetorical. Like when you ask a guy who's overstayed his welcome at a party, are you still here?

Fag or faggot is not a slur. Never has been, and I'm not going to stop using it. I ain't gonna be bullied by this nonsense any more, and I'm not paying attention to fags who pull this crap.

34
MyschyfHere, Queer, Used to it•

If transgender people say it's a slur, then it is. You don't get to decide what terms are acceptable or not, as you're not transgender.

20
ExceptionToTheRule•

Troll troll is trolling.

16
[deleted]•

Tranny's been a slur for fucking years. Go crack a damn book sometime, you ignorant fuck.

9
ucofresh•

Regardless the downvotes, I agree. And there is a shit ton others who do. Outside of the politically correct reddit there is a lot and lot of people who agree.

-22
FollowerofLokiFluffy Bunny Liberal Hippie•

So I'm a gay trans man. Should I not get to be a part of the community because I was born with a defect? There's a r/lgb for you if you seriously want to continue being an asshole.

60
proddette•

being trans isn't a defect.

13
FollowerofLokiFluffy Bunny Liberal Hippie•

I consider it born with a birth defect -for me- and no one else. :) I promise, I don't think being trans is a defect for anyone else. Sorry I didn't specify.

17
[deleted]•

Different trans people have different experiences. Some experience trans-ness as a defect.

16
throwawaymonkey77OP•

Youre a straight woman. A woman who wants to chop off her tits and take steroids is still a woman.

-99
[deleted]•

You're a straight man. A straight man who is confused and needs help. We shouldn't treat people like you like you're normal human beings, you're a sinner who needs to repent and get back on the path of righteousness, marry a woman and raise a family.

76
throwaway_timeGenderfluid Asexual•

I think I love you, Heliotroper :P

22
[deleted]•

;D

18
[deleted]•

I was a confused straight man once, then I fired my psychodynamic therapist. He was a bad person.

8
ExceptionToTheRule•

What make a woman a woman? I would really like to know, Because no definition I can think of would fit here in any way. I mean literally I cannot think of a definition that fits every man that doesn't fit a single woman.

21
[deleted]•

You're a vile human.

12
[deleted]•

I find it rather offensive how straight men and women want to be minoritiez by pretending to be lesbians and gay men whilst shitting all over our spaces.

-66
jaki_cold•

What the actual fuck?

31
ExceptionToTheRule•

I find it rather offensive that lesbians or gay men are such because they CLAIM to be, because they THINK they are and SAY they are, and yet trans people who they SAY they are a man or woman, who they THINK they are a man/woman and who they claim to be aren't.

Why is that? Do you just think you're better than them?

27
[deleted]•

Gay/Lesbian - Person who is sexually attracted to the same sex as them.

Transsexual - Person who believes they are the opposite sex, denies biology and that gender is a social construct.

And please don't bring up the intersex strawman...

-38
throwawaymonkey77OP•

Well said. I find it ironic that so many lesbians get extremely pissed off when a straight guy hits on them, yet so many want to go out of their way to usher in the same straight dudes into gay spaces if they wear a dress.

-58
ExceptionToTheRule•

Yeah honestly I hate it when people say they're gay or lesbian, I mean really just because a girl had daddy issues and thinks that fucking other girls will get her attention shouldn't get her any special treatment. After all, all she really needs is a good fuck from a real man.

30
derpinita•

If it's such a big fucking deal to you go create r/lgb. Then other bigots like you can flock there and you can quit your whining.

50
Naberius0•

In answer to your question. No.

45
lifeinneon•

Well, it didn't take long before this popped up.

44
MatrixFrog•

That's what he said.

18
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
AspelMtFtM•

I almost feel like this was something someone did to test the community.

Also, that is what he said.

9
Erzbet•

And judging from the up and down votes, it looks like the community passed...

2
AspelMtFtM•

Indeed.

I think everyone voted on that one. Are there automatic upvotes like there are autodownvotes?

2
[deleted]•

Your opinion doesn't seem to make you a bigot, you are a bigot, fuck you.

41
smischmal•

Opinions never make people bigots, they merely reveal one's bigotry.

5
[deleted]•

No john, you are the bigots.

-12
[deleted]•
38
Lizbeanism•

Not all trans people identify as the gender opposite their own. Trans belongs within the umbrella of LGBT because together we form a much stronger front for the equality of all and many members of the trans community are also members of the LGB community.

Instead of getting obsessed over petty distinctions we must work to build a community that prizes the acceptance of all. R/ainbow should not work to become an exclusive subreddit that caters only to the whims of the LGB community it should be an open place for all people to visit, ask question and find support.

Exclusion never works out. If we try to have a community just for gay people we are doing exactly the same thing society does to us. Some may say that we deserve exclusion, but I don't understand this form of reasoning at all. How are we to become accepted in the real world if we work so hard to exclude everyone else? People will just begin to ignore our community. We must be vocal, welcoming and most of all patient and reasonable with those who may not directly be a part of the LGBT community by gender identity or sexual preference, but still want to be a part of r/ainbow.

35
[deleted]•

[deleted]

31
timetide•

yes, you are a bigot please fuck yourself out of our community

28
CokeHeadRobFuck yeah!•

Why can we not coexist? I don't see the harm in it.

27
TehGrav•

No we can't take it back because we never lost it.

27
[deleted]•

[deleted]

24
Gehbstemmer•

Obvious troll is obvious.

22
badger035•

Is it really possible for you to write that and not see the disturbing parallels with what homophobes say about us gay people? Seriously, read through what you wrote again, and replace "trans" with "homo" and "trannies" with "faggots," and then tell me you're not a bigot. We have made big strides for gay rights, and we did it with trans people. Now it the time to support their struggle for equality, not throw them under the bus.

21
Aerik•

hey OP, you don't know what you're talking about.

rmuser is a woman. rmuser's birth sex does not define her. She defines her. She identifies as a woman, therefore she is. Which makes them a gay couple.

Given you don't know what the LGBT spectrum even is, you are the last person that should be starting a thread about how an LGBT subreddit should be run.

19
J0lt•

rmuser is a woman.

I thought they were genderqueer or genderfluid or something like that, but the intent stands nonetheless.

9