What did MLK think about gay people? – CNN Belief Blog - CNN.com Blogs
religion.blogs.cnn.com/2012/01/16/what-did-ml...Posted Jan 16, 2012, 10:09 PM UTC
Posted Jan 16, 2012, 10:09 PM UTC
"my father did not take a bullet for same-sex marriage". What a sickening quote, especially given that Coretta Scott King was an activist for gay rights. Blah.
Bernice, unfortunately, is a bit of a mess. She was only 5 when her father died. I don't think she can be taken seriously when it comes to figuring out what MLK's goals were, as I don't see how she would know him as well as others in the family. Especially when she is indeed contradicted, and strongly, not only by Coretta, but also her older sister, Yolanda.
Interestingly enough, today she was apparently inclusive of the LGBT community in a speech she gave.
Bernice King's Gay Inclusive Speech at MLK Rally Surprises LGBT Participants
I think it's pretty established that Dr. King was a pretty cool dude.
edit: even if he held prejudices, I mean.
I think his work with Rustin shows that he felt no ills towards the gay community, but he also was forced to compromise including them in order to ensure his movement didn't fracture and fail. But as the author points out, he laid the groundwork and pushed forth the ideal that all of us are equal to give the gay community and others who were marginalized a strong foundation to begin their fight from.
To be honest articles like this confuse me a bit. It seems like when people analyze things in this way, they really show an inability to understand context. I don't know if this has been stated by someone else, but truth be told if the man was homophobic I don't see why that should be held against him considering he was living in a different time and dealing with different issues. Everyone has prejudices, and I don't think it should be a major issue. Maybe someone can better explain to me just what this article is trying to say because when I read through it I felt myself growing more and more confused.
Ghandi was also an adamant racist who often went out of his way to explain how hard working productive Indians should not be confused with what he considered the lazy black African. People are products of their time for better or worse in many situations. The Nazis for all their atrocities also created the Highway, so you can thank them for that next time you are driving on one. The world is grey and most everyone tries to be good I think, even if they are mistaken.
oh cool so a reddit made with the idea that it's dumb as hell to be nice to transgender people is hard at work upvoting stuff to increase even more tensions between the lgbt community and people of color
It's an article on CNN, it's not racist propaganda.
what the fuck do you think CNN is cracker
ಠ_ಠ
Troll harder.
oh look /r/ainbow is showing its true colors
ಠ_ಠ
Really? Really? You find this to be an appropriate response? Really?
yes it is. i fucking lived through the prop 8 aftermath and know just how fucking shitty and racist the lgbt community can be. oh hey this organization over here clearly has a paper trail of having thousands of volunteers and millions of manhours and dollars spent shoving this down CA's throat couldn't POSSIBLY be the culprit OH I KNOW LETS BLAME ***BLACK PEOPLE***
this shit needs to stop and posting dumb "makes u think..." articles highlighting that King had to make unfortunate compromises between human rights and the extremely anti-gay atmosphere of that time in order to get anywhere doesn't help a goddamned thing
Yes, keep creating tensions between the LGBT community and the black community, keep showing the world your true colors, its delicious. Im glad you all are leaving /r/lgbt
...How is posting an article somehow inciting a queer/black conflict? You're really not making much sense.
For the record, I just checked, and this was posted to r/lgbt at about the same time as I posted it here. I have not visited there at all today and found this elsewhere. I posted it as a discussion point.
But clearly, us "leaving" did not prevent this from being posted there.
Is the article not asking a valid question? Shouldn't we know what MLK, the man, thought in order to better understand who MLK, the symbol, is? I find the article to be entirely fair, and your reaction to be over-the-top, not supportive, noncontributing, nonconstructive, condescending, asinine, and completely biased due to the butthurt from the shitstorm at lgbt. And while you and and some others are CLEARLY trolling /r/ainbow and probably ought to be banned outright, I will respect your right to be spiteful little enemasacks and just downvote pretty much any of your comments. The clouds must be hard to see through from the top of that high horse you're squatting on.
You really are a bitter, insecure little troll. You are much more bigoted than anyone you have claimed to be a transphobe. Good Job on being such a lovely, lovely person!
Im bigoted for not wanting to allow people to be bigoted to me...ಠ_ಠ
One person linked (on Martin Luther King, Jr. Day) to a topical article that pretty much boils down to "Martin Luther King, Jr. would most likely support LGBT rights". Another person posted a picture of someone in a KKK outfit. Which of these people is trying to create tension?
This is not in any way a racist article. In fact, if anything it seeks to bring together the black civil rights movement with the LGBT civil rights movement.
Whoever believes in Reverend King's dream should make room at the table of brother and sisterhood for lesbian and gay people. A dream of a day when all people can be free.
Yeah, I'm like, hearing theremin music play in the background as she tells us how racist this is. I am really not seeing where she is getting this from, and I decidedly don't want a shot of whatever she's having. I am just increasingly creeped out by all the steely-eyed dogmatism I am seeing from the transfolk -- who, if anything, should be "my tribe" in this idiotic conflict.
I'm going to risk REALLY setting Laurelai off and just come right out and say it: the transition process is painful and difficult. Not everybody survives it with their sanity intact. And saddest of all, some of them become shrill, dogmatic, and annoying as all fuck in the process. And I'm not sure where they get off acting like the rest of us in the genderqueer community are behind them -- most of us just roll our eyes.
It's a damn shame such people are running around giving a bad name to such a generally awesome community -- and slowly making me think it's time to distance myself from it. At least from the people for whom it's an identity, a political affiliation, a religion, and a jargon all rolled into one.
I wouldn't say it's from "the transfolk". It seems to mainly be people from SRS/are friends with the mods from LGBT who are coming here to take, I guess, revenge for the whole debacle and the development of a new subreddit. Laurelai and their ilk seem to epitomize the problems of not only message boards, not only the internet, but pretty much dogmatic and self-righteous group. They're the one's who give "being open-minded" the negative connotation it has to some people as well as "so open-minded except to other people's views". And while there are, without a doubt in my mind, ACTUAL transphobic/homophobic/etc. comments, there also seems to be too much of an overreaction to any potential slight that any sort of meaningful dialogue becomes impossible and the creation and transfer of knowledge becomes stifled and slowed.
One of the... well, I'll just come out and say, one of the more hopeful members of that coterie gave me an example from her days in the Navy. She said that they had a code of Green, Yellow, and Red. Green light conversation was simple every day stuff. Yellow was stuff that was innocuous on it's own, but could become harassment if it continued, like "Hey, baby, you look sexy". Red is stuff that's not okay at all, like "bitch, get over here and sit on my lap"
She claims that Transphobia Project--I don't think she's affiliated with SRS--goes after the Yellow because there's so much of it, but that they mostly go after the Red.
But the way I see it is that there's far, far too much going after the Yellow. Her example was that when one person bumps into you it's okay, but how many people do it before you punch someone in the face. And that's the perfect example of what's wrong with... well, Reddit's transgender community. They see Yellow as red. The intentionally offensive Tranny or Granny game is an example of yellow. There was very little actual transphobia in that thread; no one said much of the obviously transphobic comments like "I hate men in dresses" or "these trannies will never be women". Offensive, yes, but not overtly, and no one was trying the whole "quash their rights" or "they deserve to be killed" schticks. In fact, I'd wager it never featured in most people's minds anything other than "which of these is an ugly old crossdresser and which is an ugly old woman"
SRS on the other hand? And the more militant members of /r/transgender or /r/transphobiaproject? They go after Green lights. They're the ones who see using the wrong pronouns, even accidentally, even unknowingly as near capital offenses. They're the ones who see the word "bitch" as misogynist, but want to laugh at the very concept of Men's Rights, because everyone knows men are always better off, you know, in paternity suits, when women lie about birth control, when they want custody of their children, when they're charged with a capitol crime, you know, equality stuff. The harpies there are the ones who see any indication of the patriarchy as evil and villainous. And, don't get me wrong, I hate the concept of a gender binary, and I wish that we had a more open and tolerant society. But tolerance of intolerance is a thing as well.
We all are intolerant. Everybody's a little bit racist, and that's okay. We've all got little preconceptions based on stereotypes. We think men think with their dicks, we think women should cook, we think gays are good with fashion, and blacks are good with sports. Hell, I have those preconceptions. Me personally? I don't get gay people. I only get straight people because they're the default. It literally boggles my mind that more people aren't bisexual, and the concept of a non-fluid sexuality actually kind of weirds me out. It's one thing to attack the Red, it's even one thing to attack successive yellow. But attacking the innocent, unknowing? To constantly post that same fucking article about how "Intent: It's fucking magical" as if everyone was responsible for your feelings more than their actual meaning...
That's just balls out retarded.
Distancing yourself from the transgender community because of Laurelai and /r/transgender? I have no idea what you mean, and I certainly didn't make this image that mirrors those feelings.
Although, don't get me wrong, there are plenty of people who identify as genderqueer who are as equally "die cis scum" about things, going all heavily punk about their flagrant disregard for cisnormativity, which to me all just comes off as reactionary counterculture. Of course, it's always difficult to sort out who's feelings are real when it comes to a minority like the queer groups and who's are just anger at daddy. Although I suppose that would bring up the question of at what point something becomes "real"...
You didn't distance yourself from the trans community, I banned you and you called me a cunt, people have been telling you to get the fuck out of the community for months and you wouldn't. Fuck right off.
^Oh, no transphobia and shit talking about trans people here, guys. Move along
And the whole "shrill" thing, which smacks of misogyny. Wheeee.
This is perhaps the most meaningful sentence in the entire article, and the correct view to take IMO. We should recognise that in the past some men - great men - made mistakes that while common at that time are not excusable. At the same time, we should celebrate and respect them for the good that they did achieve, and recognise that as fallible human beings they nevertheless advanced the cause of human freedom and made our struggle today possible.
Mistakes like plagiarism?
I like what the late Queen said: