Dear /r/ainbow:

Please, please, please do not let the r/shitredditsays crowd take over this sub. I'm honestly as sick of them in r/lgbt and r/transgender as I am sick of the trolls.

That being said, if this turns into a cesspool of "Why is the T in LGBT?" posts, I'm outie. I identify as two of those letters, and I really don't like when one of them get's picked on by the other 3.

TL;DR, can we all just be cool and party with eachother?

Posted Jan 16, 2012, 10:46 PM UTC

95471
madeofghosts•

shitredditsays: never before has such a justified and reasonable concern led to such an unpleasant and obnoxious subreddit.

58
AspelMtFtM•

What worries me the most about the posters of Shit Reddit Says is that their overreacting aggression delegitimizes many legitimate concerns that people have.

They are effectively the avatars of the radical feminist movement turned up to 11 for every group other than straight middle class white cismales. And much like the radical feminist movement, they make the moderates, the ones who are reasonable, look bad. They're like the people who claim all men are rapists. People like those feminists are the reason some say "I'm not a feminist, I'm a humanist".

Only SRS does that for every topic. Every demographic.

30
SunriseLollipop•

Exactly. It seems like they basically said "How can we take something legitimate and turn it around to make it look awful, nasty, and disgusting?"

19
AspelMtFtM•

Some menwomyn want to watch the world burn.

13
moonflowernot here any more•

I think most of the SRS mob are men, and I don't think they really support women, they just use fake outrage as an excuse to be vile to everyone

11
AlyoshaVMy pearl-handled kitty-cat will leave and press your noodle back•

shut the fuck up aspel

-18
[deleted]•

this is my favorite way that anyone has put it so far.

21
[deleted]•

The thing is, people say stupid ignorant shit all the time. Getting uppity about it rarely accomplishes anything beyond furthering the circle jerk and patting each other on the back for being so enlightened and so, so victimised.

6
bobappleyard•

shitredditsays should be banned for violating reddiquette

48
ebcubeClinically cynical•

As much as I dislike SRS, reddiquette is a guideline, not a rule. It can be applied at will by the mods.

Now, banning trolls (who happen to be from SRS) from this subreddit until spacetime freezes into a puppy-sized taco? That would be great

43
TexasJefferson•

Raiding actively interferes with the ability of communities to function as such.

10
ebcubeClinically cynical•

Yes, it does, and I hope the mods take measures.

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
DocFGeekHippy Chef Guy•

Captain Barbosa couldn't have said it better.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
moonflowernot here any more•

hey wait a minute, aren't you a mod of SRS?

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

Eeeheheheheee

-5
[deleted]•

SRS is not a downvote brigade. It is an upvote brigade, and that scares fear into the heart of redditors.

-5†
headphonehalo•

While they upvote other threads, they usually downvote everything in their own subreddit. Which is fine, because the problem isn't upvoting or downvoting, it's that they're bigots.

9
[deleted]•

Pointing out bigotry is bigotry itself, riiiiight?

-2
Olpainless•

Telling everyone they're horrible people and disgust you because they asked a question makes you a dick. Maybe a bigot even.

12
thedevguy•

r/bigotryshowcase

It often features examples of bigotry by posters, even mods, of SRS.

So no, pointing out bigotry isn't bigotry. However, bigotry is bigotry. Here are a couple of examples:

http://www.reddit.com/r/ShitRedditSays/comments/m18oj/she_said_she_was_bisexual_on_topgear_who_takes/c2x9fw0?=fucksrs

http://www.reddit.com/r/SRSDiscussion/comments/og5et/a_horrible_srs_thread_on_misandry/c3h4561

4
headphonehalo•

You can justify your bigotry in any way your like, it's still bigotry. Sexism, racism, classism, genderism and so on.

3
SnifflyWhale•

Oh yes, let's ignore the child porn subreddits, the rape subreddits and the racist subreddits. Clearly SRS is the real problem. /s

-10
headphonehalo•

It's a competition, you see.

6
RobotAnnaI LOVE GAY MEN ^_____^•

excuse me downvotes are not for DISAGREEING but for saying THIS DOES NOT CONTRIBUTE TO THE DISCUSSION

-20
Sluthammer•

Discussion is not even a part of that community. As I've always said, I agree with their views but they squelch anything that goes against the established leadership. That is not right.

10
RobotAnnaI LOVE GAY MEN ^_____^•

/r/SRSDiscussion is there for a reason

if i wanted to bathe in concern trolls all day in the name of FREEDUMB OF SPEECH id post on r/ainbo--fuck

-21
Sluthammer•

This is exactly the problem I'm talking about. Labeling me a "concern troll?" You're full of shit, and you know nothing about me. If you want to have a civil discussion without calling me a troll, then I would love to have it.

18
headphonehalo•

/r/SRSDiscussion is there for a reason

That's probably the most hilarious subreddit ever. What's next, /r/beatingwomendiscussion?

5
TroubleEntendreDestination Girl•

STOP YELLING AT ME!

9
shanoxilt•

You're being downvoted for being a consistent troll. You're a shitposter and nobody likes you.

8
AspelMtFtM•

Yet so often you use them wrong.

2
jacobheiss•

It kills me that this is being down-voted...

Oh the irony :(

-3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

12
CJGibson•

But I agree with it.

Oh god, I'm so torn! /headexplode

0
[deleted]•

can we all just be cool and party with each other?

That's the plan!

29
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
[deleted]•

I guess SOME people don't like being cool and partying. Or plans.

14
TexasJefferson•

Plans caused 9/11.

Er, wait, that was *planes*.
19
mckatze•

Well they certainly had to plan for the planes..

5
scoooot•

PARTY AT t-n-k'S HOUSE!!!

2
Shacod•

I went into shitredditsays earlier.

After 3 pages, I quickly decided that it was mainly 1: People angry at racism towards their race (acceptable), and 2: Angry people who can't take a joke and think that everybody ever is a horrible disgusting person and that humanity is doomed to eternal suffering.

The latter is what I saw much more often, and what I find incredibly unacceptable.

24
Kensin•

I got the impression that maybe half of them were serious and the other half were trolls.

14
daemin•

Indeed. SRS is a perfect example of Poe's Law, though I think the the case of SRS, it has transcended Poe's Law and just turned into a cluster fuck.

16
museveni•

Is being angry at racism against another race unacceptable?

13
Shacod•

It is acceptable but I don't imagine many white people are going to shitredditsays to complain about people using the N word.

5
[deleted]•

Really? I do. Those people just want something to get angry at, regardless of whether it's something that effects them, or something that's really offensive, or whatever.

Mind you, I have seen some genuinely offensive stuff linked to on there, but most of it just makes me chuckle.

9
headphonehalo•

Really? I do. Those people just want something to get angry at, regardless of whether it's something that effects them, or something that's really offensive, or whatever.

Haha, SRS users would misconstrue you statement with something like "he thinks that white people shouldn't care about racism towards black people!"

After all, SRS really cares about white people.

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

9
Olpainless•

Exactly. They're just fucking ridiculous.

1
ssmathias•

I agree with your views, and appreciate that you expressed them as nicely as you did (at least in the TLDR part)

14
redDITringofdeath•

Hooray for getting along! This is what a community should be :) BecomingMolly, I fully support you for who you are and am glad that you are a part of the community.

11
RobotAnnaI LOVE GAY MEN ^_____^•

yeah we should all like get together and sing kumbaya and just all finally fucking agree that what we really hate is trans people

-30
[deleted]•

As a trans person, judging by the response to this thread, I'd say the only source of hate towards anyone in this thread are you and your /r/srs cronies. Everyone else has been very friendly, and several have expressed support of me as a trans person despite not explicitly saying it in the OP.

23
RobotAnnaI LOVE GAY MEN ^_____^•

you're the one who posted a diatribe against the people who are trying to help make /r/lgbt a safe space for trans people, not me

where was i during that whole thing? oh yeah calling out anti-trans bigotry and trying to fucking do something about it

-22
[deleted]•

Diatribe? Where. I hardly think a critical opinion equates to a diatribe.

Exaggeration seems to be your strong suit.

14
redDITringofdeath•

Uhh actually no because I don't hate them and nobody should.

14
RobotAnnaI LOVE GAY MEN ^_____^•

that's basically why this subreddit exists, fyi

a bunch of people are upset because they couldn't say transphobic shit in r/lgbt because they started enforcing rules and labelling people with a history of saying transphobic shit

so yeah nothing about this subreddit screams "hey let's all get along and be friends"

-15
redDITringofdeath•

No, it definitely isn't. This subreddit exists as for LGBT people who want a friendly environment. The labelling was bad for sure, but that doesn't mean we hate transgendered people at all. If you do, then you need to reassess your values.

19
dentoniteWish I'd been an artist, not a lawyer•

I just can't tolerate self-righteous bullying from the mods, myself.

13
[deleted]•

[deleted]

12
mckatze•

Can you PLEASE just keep the snarky, bitter, sarcastic, circlejerk r/SRS shit in r/SRS? Is it that much to ask that you come here and be nice like every body else is trying to do? What bigotry are you calling out here? What are you actually doing to change people's minds and help? Nothing! You're not doing anything. You are in fact doing worse than nothing, you are actively hindering us in having free discourse and educating others by barging in and being an asshole.

If you see bigotry, you call it out where it is. You correct them, you downvote them, and you move on.

8
RobotAnnaI LOVE GAY MEN ^_____^•

ok let me call out some bigotry

hmm yeah we're all talking about singing kumbayah and holding hands and finally defeating the evil menace of the r/lgbt mods actually doing something about the horrible transphobia that was/is rampant

-11
mckatze•

Are you a troll? Are you drunk? Or does this shit just fly right over your head? Do you think the people who are genderqueer/trans/whatever just came over here because we wanted to be transphobic, too? Did you stop for one fine second to think maybe we disagree with the handling of transphobia on that subreddit? Personally, I would rather handle it by educating people and this is why I've come to this subreddit. Redtext and SRS-style aggression will not "fix" the transphobia problem in the LGBT community.

You are, however, obviously not interested in actually discussing ANY of this and are only interested in bringing back the same tactics that ruin it for people who are trying to actually make it better for ourselves.

Again, keep the circlejerking in the circlejerk. How hard is that for you?

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
runpmcDefinitely drinking•

yeah we should all like get together and sing kumbaya and just all finally fucking agree that what we really hate is overbearing assholes.

FTFY. Have a nice rage.

3
RobotAnnaI LOVE GAY MEN ^_____^•

once again let me remind you that the definition of "overbearing asshole" to you is "moderators who say enough is enough with regards to transphobia"

-6
runpmcDefinitely drinking•

Sweet! You're telepathic! Now tell me what I had for dinner tonight...

3
headphonehalo•

Get out.

0
Cythrosi•

Can it be a pool party?

8
[deleted]•

I don't have a pool D:

5
LibraryGeek•

but...but...it's the internet you can have whatever you want :D

5
[deleted]•
8
LibraryGeek•

Lol that's awesome~

2

Can it be a cool pool party?

4
[deleted]•

Use a bath. :P

3
Cythrosi•

How about a hot tub then?

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
KesslerAgain•

Agreed. I don't think that there will be many of those particular types of posts though. From what I've seen they are downvoted almost immediately.

I am a bit of an optimist though.

7
harmonicfoxy•

Let's get wasted on sunshine and friendship.

7
Gehbstemmer•

Okay. I will it to be so.

6
sinbetweens•

I vote for resolving any internal disputes through pillow fights!

5
[deleted]•

Sexy, naked pillow fights?

Me gaysta.

5
feilen/r/furry is leaking kitties•

Pollow fights

1
[deleted]•

my typo was delicious. but it is now fixed.

2
Lizbeanism•

No worries, the community seems to be fairly decent. That being said this won't be as hyper politically correct as r/lgbt or the other subreddits.

4
RobotAnnaI LOVE GAY MEN ^_____^•

yeah political correctness sucks

i hate like, being a decent human being and shit

-15
Lizbeanism•

People should accept the fact that some people are bigots and then there are some people who are just a little bit ignorant and genuinely trying to change their opinions and become more informed.

It doesn't help to call the people in the second group anything with the suffix -phobic.

Subreddits that focus on minority interests and inclusion should strive to be PC, but not sacrifice openness and stifle legitimate in the process.

17
[deleted]•

<3

4
scoooot•

It doesn't help to call the people in the second group anything with the suffix -phobic.

Yeah. People should try to be more politically correct than to use words ending in -phobic.

You are correct that people in the latter are not -phobic... but just because something they say has been identified as -phobic does not mean that they personally have been called -phobic. The no-need-to-go-overboard-with-being-offended goes two ways.

0
headphonehalo•

Yeah. People should try to be more politically correct than to use words ending in -phobic.

It's definitely intellectually lazy. Given the broad sense that these people use the words in, they don't actually mean anything, they're just convenient and stigmatising labels for them to throw around.

People like RobotAnna don't know what "transphobia" is. I'd be surprised if they've ever even met a transphobe in real life.

4
[deleted]•

Rofl, is she for real

-8
Lizbeanism•

He*.

7
RobotAnnaI LOVE GAY MEN ^_____^•

cool thanks for your worthless input on this subject, cracker

-23
Lizbeanism•

How do you rationalize using a racial slur and then saying you're PC?

9
madeofghosts•

This and dismissing /r/gaymers as "a bunch of gay white dudes" - let's not, yeah?

9
TwistTurtleGetting a grip so you don't have to•

I fully support the banning of anyone who's part of the r/shitredditsays crowd from this subreddit. That place really is the lowest point of this entire website. For every genuine cunt they condemn, they condemn 10 innocent people who just said something they don't agree with.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

13
JRutterbush•

Banning someone because of where they're from is a bad idea. I think banning could be a valid response, but only to people who are actually, actively causing problems in this subreddit. Banning people because of posts made elsewhere is a little too close to the sort of draconian policies that prompted the creation of this sub in the first place, after all.

9
LibraryGeek•

I have to agree with this. Banning someone because they are members of another subreddit comes awfully close to banning someone because of who they are rather than what they do. Focus on how they behave here.

1
[deleted]•

How about we be the bigger people about it, and do what they wouldn't: Let the subreddit decide what's worthwhile and what's not. I can see so far that pretty much all /r/SRS jerks are getting downvoted into oblivion, I'm pretty happy with that.

They'll get tired once they realise we're impervious to their bullshit and move on to the next subreddit that dares contradict their hivemind.

EDIT: Also, if someone from /r/SRS comes here but doesn't act like an arse, I say let 'em stay. Just need to be worried about them usurping power ala /r/lgbt.

5
Druuf•

GOOD IDEA

2
netcrusher88•

Not sure if trying to be ironic or just an idiot.

1
[deleted]•

You want to ban 10,000 people, lol. Goodluck. Why not give us all Scarlet Letters while you are at it. Burn the witches! Burn them! WITCH HUNT--

Wait, I thought that's what we did!

-15
TwistTurtleGetting a grip so you don't have to•

Nice try, but I'm determined to not be responsible for the first trollbait on this subreddit.

11
[deleted]•

Heh, 'Try'.

You poor dears making a subreddit because you want to be transphobic and we're the monsters. Tickles me pink.

-19
TwistTurtleGetting a grip so you don't have to•

Mmmhmmm. Well you can call me what you like. While you do that, I'll be over here, actually doing something positive in the name of an Egalitarian society. T'ra.

14
[deleted]•

The argument started because there were some transphobes. The community split because of how they were dealt with. I don't think linking derailing for dummies is a mature response, nor do I agree with the redundancy of red flair, when the downvote system exists to hide trolls and unpopular opinions.

5
headphonehalo•

You want to ban 10,000 people, lol.

To be fair, you're not all bigots. Most are probably just there to see the college kids dream up persecution.

1
[deleted]•

Rofl. I gutlaugh every time someone claims SRS is full of bigots. That's how you KNOW someone is a privileged little shit.

-3
headphonehalo•

Yeah, racism, sexism and classism definitely isn't bigotry.

1
RobotAnnaI LOVE GAY MEN ^_____^•

i agree with this post

-10
jhunt04•

I just have to say that I don't want you to go anywhere because I like your name too much!

2
qaera•

boogies

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
30percentAlpaca•

I identify as none of those letters, and 1) wtf has been going on (apparently I haven't been paying attention) and 2) seriously, what up with peeps not getting along?

1
SnifflyWhale•

SRSer here who just wants to party. Don't give me a reason, and I won't post to to SRS. I have hopes for this community. I will contribute to it. But the moment anyone starts getting upvoted for bigotry, I'm out.

0
[deleted]•

Or, you could try the mature, adult response: downvote and ignore them.

Welcome to the motherfucking internet, you can't control everyone.

10
[deleted]•

The mature, adult reaction to bigotry in any form: Hope it goes away.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

8
AlyoshaVMy pearl-handled kitty-cat will leave and press your noodle back•

Give me three examples of posts on SRS that are unmerited.

0
[deleted]•
8
literroy•

Surely there are better examples than a post someone clearly made as a joke trying to have a little fun?

0
Olpainless•

You post anything that doesn't comply with your rules that everyone has to be offended by everything, and if you're not offended by it then you don't have a right to say so.

GTFO of our fledgling, tolerant of other's questions and opinions, community.

3
Ortus•

Don't give me a reason, and I won't post to to SRS.

You know how much of a mobster you sound with that one?

0
stopthefate•

I don't agree, but I respect your opinions. I'm all for trans rights and will always support trans people and treat them with due respect, (proper pronouns, not using tranny, etc.) but I don't think it is unfair for people to ask why there is a T in LGBT.

I think ultimately it stems from a desire most people have to be part of a group they fit in. A lot of people feel that LGBT being so inclusive sort of causes a rift in each minor community because there are HUGE differences in situation (besides societal perception) between say, trans people in general and gay people in general.

That being said, I understand why T is included in LGBT. It is supposed to be a community of ostracized sexuality and gender. An all-inclusive community for the minorities and their supporters.

I think a lot of people simply feel that they have to be part of the community. But we choose what we want to be a part of. If those people want to be part of a sexuality-minority community (LGB) they are at liberty to do so. I personally do not feel like a member of lgbt even though I am gay, and that's totally fine.

Ultimately, I think that to bring up the question is fair. r/ainbow is a community created so that we can educate, tolerate, and have fun instead of whine, see who is more "privileged" or "victimized", or censor opinions that shocker we may not all share. Ultimately it is the enforcement of this "worldview" that will either make or break this sub.

-3
[deleted]•

I'm a lesbian, and i'm also trans. I belong in the LGB community, but that doesn't mean that I'm going to (or can) leave my own T out. Excluding me because of my trans status would be cissexism.

16
simonask•

It's not that trans people should be excluded (I mean, what the fuck would be the point of that?), it's that their sexuality is what counts, not their gender. All the straight trans folk have a worthy fight upon them, but it's a different fight from ours.

We all know the historical reasons why the two are conflated, but I don't think that's a reason to keep it up.

There is also the argument that trans women, gay men, and feminists are actually fighting the same thing — misogyny. There may be some truth to that for some people, but ultimately I don't think our enemies should decide how we group — our goals should. :-)

Generally, I'm not a fan of exclusive groups — everyone is always welcome to join any discussion, and to fight for any cause (plenty of straight people hang out with LGBT people, so why shouldn't T people be hanging out with LGB people?).

If you disagree with the points I've made, I'll be happy to hear your thoughts.

boogie

2
scoooot•

They are included because the whole reason we are together is because we don't fit hetero-normative social expectations.

Society says that because I was born with a penis, that I should be attracted to girls. Society says that because a transgirl was born with a penis, that she should identify as a man. That's why our fights, while different and, share more than should be ignored.

7
simonask•

Sure, there are similarities (as I pointed out). That doesn't mean they should be conflated. More importantly, it means that it's quite legitimate to question the conflation.

To most of us, gender and sexuality are two distinct things. I don't feel less "male" for liking guys, and I'm pretty sure a trans person doesn't feel less gay if their birth sex was the opposite of their preferred partners'.

Indeed, a big part of the struggle for homosexuals is convincing people that we're not actually less male or female because we're gay. Heteronormativity is the notion that people of opposite genders form a couple — that means trans people can fall under that umbrella. A trans person does not necessarily challenge heteronormativity, unless they're gay or bi or whatever. They do challenge what you could call "cisnormativity", and that's fair, but it's different.

1
throwawaydirl•

All the straight trans folk have a worthy fight upon them, but it's a different fight from ours.

And what, exactly, is a "straight trans person"? You mean, for instance, a person identified as male at birth who now, as a female, dates men? Such a person is seen to be gay by many, especially by bigots. There is no such thing as a trans person who is seen to be straight all the time - we are all gay.

1
simonask•

And what, exactly, is a "straight trans person"? You mean, for instance, a person identified as male at birth who now, as a female, dates men?

Yes, of course. :-)

Such a person is seen to be gay by many, especially by bigots.

Only by bigots, I guess. But that doesn't make them right, and I don't personally think they should decide the sexuality of trans folk.

There is no such thing as a trans person who is seen to be straight all the time - we are all gay.

While I appreciate the "Ich bin ein Berliner!" sentiment here, I don't think it's that important what others see you or me as. The important thing is the truth.

1
stopthefate•

You wouldn't be excluded. Only non-homosexual/bisexual trans persons would not be included. The community would deal with same sex/gender issues.

The only requirement for entry is, do you fall under any of the above categories? (LG or B)? The answer is clearly yes, so what's the issue, you'd be eligible for being part of that community.

What are the requirements for being in a trans community? Being trans, regardless of sexual identity. Do I as a cis gay man fall under that category? No, so I wouldn't be eligible to join.

LGBT is all inclusive and is less strictly defined. However because of this, it includes groups that literally may have nothing in common. For example, I am a very "heteronormative" (for lack of a better term) gay man. I am also cisgender. I have basically nothing in common with say an mtf trans person who is fighting against gender norms. Why? Because I fall directly into societal expectations for gender roles and gender. The trans person might be attracted to the opposite sex. Once again, even less in common because I am gay.

My point is, there are communities for everyone and you can choose what you are a part of. I prefer a more targeted community so I consider myself part of the lgb community. If you are gsy, regardless of gender identity, you can be a part of this as well. I simply don't identif with heterosexual trans people. This does NOT mean I won't stand by each and every trans person and fight for their rights, I simply do not consider myself part of the community due to separate issues.

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
questionplz•

This does NOT mean I won't stand by each and every trans person and fight for their rights, I simply do not consider myself part of the community due to separate issues.

I think the problem people have with these kinds of statements is due to history there's a lot of distrust for those kinds of statements. The dangers of incrimentalism have taken a group that fought along side to start the LGBT rights movement (Compton Riots and Stonewall) to being at one of the lowest rungs on the social ladder.

I'll agree that in a social context that there is perhaps some validity to your posts, but in a political and rights movement context LGB and T are allies and both groups have a responsibility to fight for each others rights, together. so when we say LGBT we're often talking about the rights movement and less "oh man, I love hanging out at the LGBT friend" which is a bit nonsensical.

1
stopthefate•

Oh there's no doubt that from a political stand point this is the case, however, myself and many, many other lgbt'ers do not come for the politics.

1
Olpainless•

ಠ_ಠ

You understand that non-heterosexual people very often don't feel the need to conform to gender boundaries? And that much of the gay movement is about giving sexual and gender boundaries the big ol' middle finger?

LGB is as much about gender as T. I don't want to ever have to type the two separately again. I wuv my trans counterparts <3

9
[deleted]•

why there is a T in LGBT

Read this and learn your history.

3