Help me discuss against a TERF
Witches, I need help! I am a member of a larger (facebook, but also real life) group of witches and one of them insists on being "gender critical" which I quickly found out is a thinly veiled euphemism for TERF.
The first few queer people, all very dear to me, already left the group in pain, anger and disgust, because of this and the Admins are quite tone deaf.
I will not leave.
And I want to start a ... discussion. Or rather, I started provoking back already and I am giddy what gift my goddess Diskordia will present me in the morning.
But I need help in the coming discussion. I must admit that I am not too educated in the nonbinary / transgender details. I want to explain things and as "collateral damage" educate myself and the bystanders. I also must remain very above board, no personal attacks etc, although I am really angry. I do not believe to turn this person's attitude around, but I want the others to see the ugly truth of that person.
What this person claims is, that being "gender critical" is just an opinion and everyone has the right to their opinion. And right now I can't wrap my head around how to counter that. I mean, yes, they are entitled to their opinion, but they already complained that they would not be allowed their "not so mainstream opinion" - while writing a dozen posts about it. But being "gender critical" is harmful, which they do not understand.
Can I repeat how f'n angry I am? I can't let this stand! It doesn't hurt me directly, I am just an ally. So I have a thicker skin and can take some heat. A few others also spoke up in the meantime, but I can't let this stand! You don't hurt my friends and get away with it!
So, if you have ideas or links that can help me discuss, please!
Posted Jul 14, 2021, 8:49 PM UTC
Everyone has the right to an opinion as long as it only affects themselves. Once their opinion starts to affect the lives of others and public policy, it's becomes rhetoric or perhaps even propaganda, which can be incredibly harmful, especially when it singles out a vulnerable or disadvantaged group of people.
Acceptable example of opinion: I really dislike pineapple on pizza. I will never order or eat a pineapple pizza and often express my dislike of pineapple pizza when around it, though I accept that for some bizarre reason that I don't understand, other people enjoy it.
Unacceptable example of rhetoric: I hate pineapple on pizza and you should too. In fact, it should be illegal to serve in restaurants. I shouldn't have to see it or smell it whenever I go into a pizza shop. It's an affront to good cooking, and anyone with good sense agrees with me that it should be banned from restaurants. In fact, we should boycott any restaurant that serves it. If someone really wants pineapple pizza, they can make it in the privacy of their own home where I don't have to see it.
This. Especially the first paragraph. (Describes best how I feel about certain religious people and people without wombs making abortion policy.)
Yup. In a similar vein, if you don't believe in gay marriage, fine, you don't have to get gay married. But you can't and shouldn't stop others from getting married if they want.
What you're describing basically leads to the paradox of tolerance though. Because if you take your described ideology to it's extreme you might think it's bad that Nazis are Nazis but you can never punch them in the face for being a Nazi. Which is something that you need to be able to do. Which is exactly what this TERF will argue. In fact she will likely argue that trans ideology is exactly like claiming people must like pineapple on pizza and that it should be illegal not to like it and that all pizzas must have pineapple on it and she's just resisting that tyranny.
I prefer to differentiate between left and right wing ideologies as violence versus harmful ideology and violence against innate qualities. Left wing people generally think it's okay to harm people over things they can change, political beliefs, biases, religion, social class and absurd wealth. All those things are changeable. If Besos gave away all his money the left would stop hoping his rocket explodes. If bigots let go of their prejudice the left might take a while to trust them but they would stop punching him in the face. The left hates it when things people can change about themselves are harmful to others and will only hate them for not changing.
The right hates people for things they cannot change about themselves. This includes TERFs. They hate trans women and want them to change in a way trans women can't change. So rather than adapting their ideology to reality they intend to force reality to conform to their ideology. That's classic conservatism. A hateful ideology. And we are allowed say that's a bad opinion to have and that they should change even if they argue that is actually a good and helpful ideology
I am aware of the paradox of tolerance, but I think my pineapple analogy didn't translate for you as I had intended. I'll rewrite the examples below but actually in direct reference to trans folk.
Acceptable opinion: I don't find trans women sexually attractive. I'm not going to date them, and if someone asks me my preferences, I will express it. I don't understand what about trans women appeals to others, but I do recognize that other people do find trans women sexually attractive.
Unacceptable rhetoric: Trans-women make me feel uncomfortable and I shouldn't have to see them in public. I will use my political power to ensure that they won't have access to public bathrooms or healthcare. But they can be trans in the privacy of their own homes (AKA exist in shame behind closed doors), so that's proof I'm not being bigoted and this is just an opinion. Anyone who thinks trans-women belong in our society is a pervert.
My bottom line is that I believe that people are allowed to have opinions as long as those opinions don't interfere with the lives and livelihoods of others. I suppose this is partly because I have worked my whole life to get some of my more bigoted family members to that point (where they are still uncomfortable around XYZ, but are no longer lobbying politically against them, know to not use bigoted terminology, and their ingrained hate will die out with them rather than be passed on to the next generation, etc).
P.S. Whenever someone threatens imminent violence against others with their "opinion", I will punch a Nazi in the face. I understand the limits of pacifism.