Help me discuss against a TERF

Burn the Patriarchy

Witches, I need help! I am a member of a larger (facebook, but also real life) group of witches and one of them insists on being "gender critical" which I quickly found out is a thinly veiled euphemism for TERF.

The first few queer people, all very dear to me, already left the group in pain, anger and disgust, because of this and the Admins are quite tone deaf. 

I will not leave. 

And I want to start a ... discussion. Or rather, I started provoking back already and I am giddy what gift my goddess Diskordia will present me in the morning.

But I need help in the coming discussion. I must admit that I am not too educated in the nonbinary / transgender details. I want to explain things and as "collateral damage" educate myself and the bystanders. I also must remain very above board, no personal attacks etc, although I am really angry. I do not believe to turn this person's attitude around, but I want the others to see the ugly truth of that person.

What this person claims is, that being "gender critical" is just an opinion and everyone has the right to their opinion. And right now I can't wrap my head around how to counter that. I mean, yes, they are entitled to their opinion, but they already complained that they would not be allowed their "not so mainstream opinion" - while writing a dozen posts about it. But being "gender critical" is harmful, which they do not understand.

Can I repeat how f'n angry I am? I can't let this stand! It doesn't hurt me directly, I am just an ally. So I have a thicker skin and can take some heat. A few others also spoke up in the meantime, but I can't let this stand! You don't hurt my friends and get away with it!

So, if you have ideas or links that can help me discuss, please!

Posted Jul 14, 2021, 8:49 PM UTC

3655
WickedWitchofWTFHedge Witch•

Everyone has the right to an opinion as long as it only affects themselves. Once their opinion starts to affect the lives of others and public policy, it's becomes rhetoric or perhaps even propaganda, which can be incredibly harmful, especially when it singles out a vulnerable or disadvantaged group of people.

Acceptable example of opinion: I really dislike pineapple on pizza. I will never order or eat a pineapple pizza and often express my dislike of pineapple pizza when around it, though I accept that for some bizarre reason that I don't understand, other people enjoy it.

Unacceptable example of rhetoric: I hate pineapple on pizza and you should too. In fact, it should be illegal to serve in restaurants. I shouldn't have to see it or smell it whenever I go into a pizza shop. It's an affront to good cooking, and anyone with good sense agrees with me that it should be banned from restaurants. In fact, we should boycott any restaurant that serves it. If someone really wants pineapple pizza, they can make it in the privacy of their own home where I don't have to see it.

31
Itu_LeonaScience Witch ♀•

This. Especially the first paragraph. (Describes best how I feel about certain religious people and people without wombs making abortion policy.)

6
WickedWitchofWTFHedge Witch•

Yup. In a similar vein, if you don't believe in gay marriage, fine, you don't have to get gay married. But you can't and shouldn't stop others from getting married if they want.

8
OfLiliesAndRemains•

What you're describing basically leads to the paradox of tolerance though. Because if you take your described ideology to it's extreme you might think it's bad that Nazis are Nazis but you can never punch them in the face for being a Nazi. Which is something that you need to be able to do. Which is exactly what this TERF will argue. In fact she will likely argue that trans ideology is exactly like claiming people must like pineapple on pizza and that it should be illegal not to like it and that all pizzas must have pineapple on it and she's just resisting that tyranny.

I prefer to differentiate between left and right wing ideologies as violence versus harmful ideology and violence against innate qualities. Left wing people generally think it's okay to harm people over things they can change, political beliefs, biases, religion, social class and absurd wealth. All those things are changeable. If Besos gave away all his money the left would stop hoping his rocket explodes. If bigots let go of their prejudice the left might take a while to trust them but they would stop punching him in the face. The left hates it when things people can change about themselves are harmful to others and will only hate them for not changing.

The right hates people for things they cannot change about themselves. This includes TERFs. They hate trans women and want them to change in a way trans women can't change. So rather than adapting their ideology to reality they intend to force reality to conform to their ideology. That's classic conservatism. A hateful ideology. And we are allowed say that's a bad opinion to have and that they should change even if they argue that is actually a good and helpful ideology

6
WickedWitchofWTFHedge Witch•

I am aware of the paradox of tolerance, but I think my pineapple analogy didn't translate for you as I had intended. I'll rewrite the examples below but actually in direct reference to trans folk.

Acceptable opinion: I don't find trans women sexually attractive. I'm not going to date them, and if someone asks me my preferences, I will express it. I don't understand what about trans women appeals to others, but I do recognize that other people do find trans women sexually attractive.

Unacceptable rhetoric: Trans-women make me feel uncomfortable and I shouldn't have to see them in public. I will use my political power to ensure that they won't have access to public bathrooms or healthcare. But they can be trans in the privacy of their own homes (AKA exist in shame behind closed doors), so that's proof I'm not being bigoted and this is just an opinion. Anyone who thinks trans-women belong in our society is a pervert.

My bottom line is that I believe that people are allowed to have opinions as long as those opinions don't interfere with the lives and livelihoods of others. I suppose this is partly because I have worked my whole life to get some of my more bigoted family members to that point (where they are still uncomfortable around XYZ, but are no longer lobbying politically against them, know to not use bigoted terminology, and their ingrained hate will die out with them rather than be passed on to the next generation, etc).

P.S. Whenever someone threatens imminent violence against others with their "opinion", I will punch a Nazi in the face. I understand the limits of pacifism.

4
chocolate_zz•

One of the first things to do is have them describe, or define what it is that they mean by the term or terms they are using and kind of focus on those terms and why they are using them and what they mean to them. If you are wanting to try to turn things around and try to turn their thinking you want to be inquisitive and force them to defend their positions, but try to keep them from being defensive. You would then be able to say things like "I thought that ____ was more like ____. Why do you think it's like _____." So you're getting your opinions out there but not demeaning. If you show that you're "open" to maybe being converted to her opinion she might get excited to try and show you her POV, and you can try to use that to undermine her.

20
EriAverySapphic Witch ♀•

Arguing with a terf is like arguing with a hard-core Christian, a republican, or a fucking lamp. They don't care about anything but their own flawed opinion and refuse to listen or care about anything else. Not to mention Facebook is home of all those kinds of people. As much as I wish fighting it would help, it's best for you to just leave.

20
roguecousland•

Honestly, this is the best solution.

OP, you are admittedly uneducated about the lived experiences of those in the LGBTQQIA community. At best, you will just tick off the TERFs more and end up leaving the group out of sheer frustration. At worst, you will risk doing more harm than good arguing on behalf of a community that you are unfamiliar with. You have good intentions, so don't get me wrong! Your heart is in the right place. I just wanted to point out that passion alone won't win the day. You said that you are angry on behalf of your sisters. Anger is a strong emotion and can be a double-edged sword. If you're not prepared with a strong foundation of knowledge and statistics to counter every bigoted attack, your anger will just take over, and then it just turns into Facebook drama.

So, my suggestion? Use your anger for good. Seek out voices you are not familiar with. Get educated. That way, you can be better prepared to support those you care about.

Also, you referred to yourself as an ally and I want to caution you in using that to describe yourself to others. Again, I know you mean well. Being an ally means more than calling yourself one and getting mad at TERFs online. Being an ally means you are taking direct action to challenge and dismantle systemic racism and bigotry. It is more of an honorary "title" earned quietly and acknowledged by those in the marginalized community in which you seek to support. This is not me telling you to stop trying. On the contrary: use this experience to learn and challenge your own inherent biases.

The more you self-reflect, the better you will be prepared to call out toxic behavior in future.

And just for the record, I am not making this stuff up. I have attended multiple multicultural trainings and have been regularly exposed to communities different from my own owing to my career in mental health. I also regularly consume media from BIPOC and LGBTQQIA voices and am always uncovering layers to my own inherent biases for which I am actively working to challenge and change. Thus, these terms (like "ally") have objectively-defined meanings used in qualitative studies and are not just social fad jargon (not that I am assuming you or anyone here is seeing it that way).

Since this is the witches v patriarchy sub, this could also be an opportunity to do some spellwork and cleansing around negative energies? Use our insight and powers of empathy to take bad out and invite good in? Just a thought....

17
Kthanid_Crafts•

I thought lamp was some new term I hadn't heard of, then I realized you mean an actual lamp!

And you are right, the beliefs are different but the sentiment is always the same, they believe they are superior, or are projecting because they fear they are inferior. Either way, they lack self-awareness.

10
OfLiliesAndRemains•

As a trans person I completely disagree. Not engaging is ceding territory. Yes you won't change their mind by arguing with them but you cannot let their ideology stand unopposed. Bigots must be attacked whenever they voice their opinion no matter how useless it is against them. It's still useful for onlookers and fence sitters who might just assume is apparently an acceptable ideology if it isn't countered. And trans people like me will feel safer in spaces like these when allies loudly proclaim their allyship. A good example of this are lesbian subreddits. The more vocally pro trans they are the less TERFs date speak out. The more tolerant they are of TERFs the less trans people participate. Letting bigots run their mouths unopposed makes the world a scarier place. We must always stand up to them everywhere they try to speak

7
EriAverySapphic Witch ♀•

I said this as a trans person, from experience dealing with terfs, and stand by it.

1
[deleted]•

I really carefully consider the pros and cons of arguing with TERFs every time I encounter them.

In some cases, it feels like the right thing to do.

In others, picking a fight with them almost feels like becoming a platform for them to voice/spread their views. Like they were just waiting for someone to bring up all the points they think they’re prepared to shoot down. It’s just engagement in some cases, without making anything better.

I don’t think it’s okay for them to think the way they do. But I always try to keep in mind the end result of this PARTICULAR argument in whatever setting it’s in. I will always come to the defense of actual trans people who are present or otherwise participating in the conversation. But there are also times I choose just not to engage, because I think the harm that will come from engaging them is greater than the harm caused by just walking away.

2
conservative_polyOPWitch ♂️•

As I said in other comments, I don't believe I can change them. But I believe I can draw a line in the sand and tell them "until here and no further". And expose their ugly truth, so everyone else can see and chose to be on one side of the line. It's also not an anonymous group, it's people I know offline, sometimes for years, but also friends of friends and so on. And all of them witches.

All of them have sworn "an ye harm none, do what you will" - and I already fired into the TERF's face, that they violated at least this oath.

1
SantaJoe•

This is a great article about terfs.

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/04/01/opinion/trans-women-feminism.html

There are also the r/trans and r/nonbinary subreddits that should be searchable for some solid anti-TERF talking points. Are there specific “arguments” that she is sharing that need to be rebuffed that you could share?

12
FlickerFallDemisexual Witch ⚧•

r/trans and r/mtf are currently privated due to bot account follow spamming from transphobes. I'd crosspost to there if I could.

7
Euphoric_Forest•

I appreciate that you are looking to improve the community you are a part of and hold space for witches and sisters who may feel hurt by this other community member.

I always try to consider the three-fold law when I find myself in similar situations. If what you want is an inclusive community that finds ways to uphold one another instead of being exclusive, I would try to pour that energy into whatever you choose to say.

May you find the words that lead to positive growth for all 🖤

9
conservative_polyOPWitch ♂️•

thanks for your good wishes :)

2

I had to look up TERF and I’m disgusted. I don’t have anything to offer but, I’m glad you’re looking for conversation points to support your friends 💞

8
conservative_polyOPWitch ♂️•

thanks :)

2
satud2•

Bless you for the hard journey you are undertaking! TERFs are insidious and cruel.

I have found the best way to shut them down is to say that their right to an opinion doesn’t overrule other people’s right to be themselves. Her opinions are actively harmful, and in expressing them she is making that space unsafe for people who are experimenting in gender magic.

TERFs are often of the opinion that trans and gender diverse people are delusional or perverted. That as TERFs they understand what is happening. They insist their opinion is correct, and that the lived experiences of trans and gender diverse people are lies, fabrications, or at worse malice.

They are, of course, wrong.

I’ve got a couple of comments from Reddit saved. People who’ve done deep dives into the research to help people understand the truth behind gender and all its fuckery. I hope you find them useful:

https://reddit.com/r/changemyview/comments/mllqhq/_/gtm623p/?context=1

https://www.reddit.com/r/TheRightCantMeme/comments/eajzx2/ok/fatk1an/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf&context=3

These techniques usually don’t work on TERFs. They are not asking in good faith, they don’t want to be educated. But sometimes being pointed out the awful harm they do is enough to make them consider being less shitty.

I hope this helps!

8
conservative_polyOPWitch ♂️•

their right to an opinion doesn’t overrule other people’s right to be themselves.

Well said! Noted for later use :)

I'll also check out the links, thanks! As I said, I do not really expect them to change their bigot mind, but I want others too see their ugly truth and show those hurt by it, that they are not alone and most people do not agree with the TERFs!

2
OfLiliesAndRemains•

Best way to fight her is to treat her comments as a teachable moment for others. You won't convince her and you might get her to go mask off but that's only functional if you manage to communicate why she is wrong. Consider asking this question on r/asktransgender for extra info and check out their wiki as well. Also consider watching the videos Marxism, gender and witchcraft, transphobia, sex work and social constructs by philosophy tube. They are very good primers into the relevant talking points. I put sex work in there because most TERFs are also SWERFs (sex worker excluding radical feminists) and because the magic trick she uses as a metaphor to describe the strategy of anti sex work narratives is the same trick they are trying to do on trans people. I think she mentions that in the transphobia episode too. Her videos are amazing in general and I highly recommend her channel.

4
conservative_polyOPWitch ♂️•

4x bookmarked :)

1
FlickerFallDemisexual Witch ⚧•

I don't have any specific trans points, because it's hard to answer such a broad question, but it'll be good to watch out for fear based tatics and exclusionary language. People who stick fervently to their ideologies even in the face of calmly stated facts tend to be living in their own view of the world. If worst comes to worse, leveraging that disconnect by pointing out flaws in their reasonings should be a viable option so long as it doesn't get personal. Don't go for beliefs, aim at the fallacies.

Just because people have opinions doesn't mean they're entitled to listeners, especially if said opinions promote harm.

7
Meewol•

Just so I’m clear, is this person calling themselves “gender critical”? And if so, what do they mean by that?

Also, they’re right in some ways. Everyone is entitled to their own opinions. What’s not acceptable is to come into an inclusive group and try to use your opinions to make it less welcoming.

There’s a big difference between having a belief and inappropriately using/ expressing that belief to make other people unwelcome.

7
chocolate_zz•

Gender critical feminists are the self term for what other people call TERFs. They're the lovely people who say things like, trans women can't be women because gender isn't an identity and that it's somehow forcing lesbians to no longer exist? It's something else to hear.

5
Meewol•

Ahh, it’s just straight up terf nonsense. Thanks for explaining that. Theyre “point” (I use that term loosely) about lesbians is that they think anyone can now identify as a woman and say they’re a lesbian which undermines they’re concept of lesbians (which is they think it should be kept for cis woman only). They’re the sort that gives us a really bad name in the LGBT+ community.

A few prides ago, I was chatting to a group and someone asked about my sexuality. I said I was a cis lesbian and someone in the group said “ah, our token terf”. Even though it was said in jest it fucked me off.

4
chocolate_zz•

Yeah, they're just not going to call themselves by TERF since it's an insult now so they had to come up with something else. 🙄 I know what their point is, I'm in the community too and I guess since I'm bi the idea that someone is attracted to someone's sexual organs, and really they're reducing it to someone's chromosomes, is just ridiculous to me. Everything they say also has so much cross over between bio sex and gender and just ugh. I try not to think about them too much because my blood pressure is already on the slightly high side.

3
Meewol•

Ah, sorry for assuming you needed an explanation. It must be awful on your end to hear what they have to say about your sexuality too. These people really don’t deserve our time and energy (or blood pressure levels ;) ).

1
valsavana•

What this person claims is, that being "gender critical" is just an opinion and everyone has the right to their opinion.

Sure, just as neo-nazis, white supremecists, and extreme misogynists have a right to their opinion. Ask if she would be comfortable with those kinds of people spewing their "opinions" all over the group.

6
ProNocteAeterna•

This. When your go-to defense of your position is that it isn't literally illegal to take it, it's clear that your position doesn't have much else to recommend it.

8
valsavana•

Exactly. And to pretend opinions don't have the capability to cause harm to vulnerable groups of people is just playing dumb.

6
conservative_polyOPWitch ♂️•

to pretend opinions don't have the capability to cause harm to vulnerable groups of people is just playing dumb.

also a good point!

4
conservative_polyOPWitch ♂️•

When your go-to defense of your position is that it isn't literally illegal to take it, it's clear that your position doesn't have much else to recommend it.

That's a great way to phrase it! I'll write that and pretend I came up with that myself ;)

4
Lady_NefariosaQueer Baba Jaga. Witch of Woods and Disco.•

TERFs are Transphobes. Bigots. And they should be recognized and treated as such, imo.

The problem is their subscription to what is called GROUP-FOCUSED EMNITY.

Same as many others. Racists. Antisemites. Misogynists. Homophobes. Haters of homeless people, of Romani people, of people with disabilities,... Generally people hating on minorities, and/or from a position of privilege, who threaten the bare existence of people who are much more vulnerable than themselves. That is what a TERF is.

How can this be the stance of a witch? TERF witches? Get out of here (figuratively and literally, LMAO).

5
conservative_polyOPWitch ♂️•

That's my dream goal, that they run away and the good witches return. But I don't think that will happen. I am happy if they realize they should shup up and others see that it's not ok and those who are hurt see they are not alone!

2
purlturtle•

Reach out to the mods. Explain the situation. If the mods are decent people, they will remove the TERF from the group, just like a bar owner will throw a Nazi out.

5
conservative_polyOPWitch ♂️•

sadly they already said "being gender critical is not a reason to get kicked" :(

2
purlturtle•

If that's their stance, their group isn't worth it. Or you could go a step further and become a mod and change things.

4
conservative_polyOPWitch ♂️•

I was thinking about becoming a mod there, maybe. But not sure if I can commit to that.

First step will be teaching them about the topic and hoping they learn.

2
RiaMimWitch ♀•

I can't give links right now because mobile, but some of my favourite trans/LGBTQIA youtubers who have tackled the subject quite succinctly and comprehensively (and are being good cookies to always quote reputable sources!) include jammidodger, Riley Dennis and Jessica Kellgren-Fozard. Loads of fact-based information on trans matters in general and dealing with TERFs in specific - just search for vids on JK Rowling for the latter... (insert eyeroll emoji here.)

If you're into wildly excellent, far-too-long and gloriously dramatic videos on the same subject, on the other hand, check out PhilosophyTube and ContraPoints.

Might help you fight that good fight, might send you down a deep, beautiful research rabbit hole that you'll emerge from several aeons later, wondering when your tea went cold.

3
conservative_polyOPWitch ♂️•

looking forward to that rabbit hole :) also, bookmarked those names!

3
Dumbold_Turnip•

It’s not really an opinion when in flies in the face of hard science. That’s just willful ignorance.

Check out Jammidodger on YouTube. He has a PhD and explains things a thousand times better than I ever could. I’m sure you’ll find some insightful stuff there.

2
conservative_polyOPWitch ♂️•

Jammidodger

Ah, I recognize that guy! My wife showed me some vids recently. :) bookmarked!

2
DomeAcolyte42•

Having the right to do something doesn't mean you should do it, and it certainly doesn't absolve someone of being shitty, for doing something. People should keep their harmful, hate speech to themselves.

2
SDG_1982•

Go to Jessie Gender on YouTube. She has Great videos on TERFS and gender issues!

1
conservative_polyOPWitch ♂️•

Jessie Gender - bookmarked!

1
PigeonCities•

arguing with a stranger over the internet is not allyship. read and listen to the stories of trans people with an open heart, donate to local trans organizations, don't try to be a protagonist in a fight that is not your own.

1
conservative_polyOPWitch ♂️•

it's not only online and they are driving my non-binary friends away. I do listen to them, but there's still more to learn - I don't have a PhD in Gender Studies ;)

And the problem is, this group is not just a random group, it's a wider social circle. I met this TERF in person like five years ago, but I regularly meet (if not for Corona) some of these people and other people meet others and so on. So this does affect me and others offline as well. People organize witch camps and stuff and invites are given to everyone in the group for example.

Throwing my weight into these discussions, to show every nonbinary and queer person, that they are not alone, that they are seen, that their pain is not ignored. I count that as allyship.

Also, it is my fight. They hurt my friends.

5
OfLiliesAndRemains•

Throwing my weight into these discussions, to show every nonbinary and queer person, that they are not alone, that they are seen, that their pain is not ignored. I count that as allyship.

This.

Thank you. It might be useless to try and convince a TERF for the sake of converting them but their rhetoric cannot be allowed to stand unopposed. Thank you for standing up for us.

5
conservative_polyOPWitch ♂️•

Thank you for standing up for us.

You're welcome. Though you shouldn't need to thank me, perfect world lalala ;)

1
itealaichKitchen Witch ♀♂️☉⚧•

We have a saying here in the south: "Don't wrestle with a pig. You'll get dirty, and the pig will like it."

I wish you luck with this goal, but it'd be better if you educated yourself more about the trans community before you try to wrestle this pig.

And for the record, those FB mods are complicit in allowing the TERF to spread their message.

Scratch a TERF, find a fascist.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1