A Sister Asks For Aid Against A TERF
Posted Jul 14, 2021, 9:49 PM UTC
Posted Jul 14, 2021, 9:49 PM UTC
Ideas:
Always aim to convince other people to regard anti-trans hatred as unacceptable, not to actually change a TERF's mind - trying to do that is like banging your head against a brick wall.
Avoid theoretical discussions of "what is gender?" Honestly, if it were just a philosophical question of what the word "woman" ought to mean, I don't know that there would be one universally correct answer. But it's not - it's about A. questions of objective fact (are women's sports really being invaded by legions of trans athletes? No. Is there really an epidemic of cis women being assaulted by queer people? No. Do more than a tiny minority of people regret transitioning? No.) and B. serious moral issues - the elevated rates of homelessness, unemployment and under-employment affecting trans people, the pervasive anti-trans discrimination and harassment and, above all, the violence done to trans people by cis people (and not always cis men, by the way), especially the murders of black trans women and the astronomical rates of sexual assault of transmasculine people.
Part of the reason why so many trans people suffer violence and sexual exploitation is homelessness, due to being kicked out as teenagers by transphobic parents. That is the real-world consequence of the anti-trans hatred that "gender-critical" activism seeks to spreads (and calling us paedophiles, rapists and cross-dressing serial killers is definitely spreading hate).
Yes; people are entitled to hold and express opinions. I don't believe anyone should be physically threatened just for saying something, or punished for the government just for saying something. If you were saying TERFs should be put in prison, it would be relevant to point out that she is entitled to her opinion - but you're not (I assume). Freedom of expression doesn't mean there are no social sanctions for spreading dangerous BS - if anything, it requires social sanctions. I'm a free-speech absolutist to the point that I literally don't think holocaust denial should be illegal, but that doesn't mean that, as a culture, we shouldn't still treat it as a dangerous lie and make it socially unacceptable in polite society - obviously we should. Likewise, "gender-critical" is a widespread and successful hate movement that seeks to make daily life materially harder for an already marginalized part of the population; there is no reason it should be more socially acceptable than any other form of explicit bigotry.
Links:
Contra points on YouTube has produced a fantastic video on this topic. If you want something to read try these, Are trans and gender nonconforming identities new trends? , Anti-trans activism by some UK queer people is shocking and damaging. Athletics is waging a war of transphobia and misogynoir - and black African women are losing out. Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie's viral essay show why context will forever be key. Why we will always take a stand against transphobia in the British press. . The work of Julia Serano is also worth a read.