r/transgender•
[deleted]

[meta] regarding changes in /r/lgbt

In case you have not noticed the mods of /r/lgbt have taken steps to try to make their subreddit a safer space for transgender people, their announcement of intention to do so was received well in both here and /r/lgbt , however when they applied the actual moderation on a grand total of 3 people who had a long history of shitposting and trolling cisgendered people from /r/gaymers took it upon themselves to create a shitstorm and attempted to

  1. Intimidate the mods into reversing their policy

  2. Lie to the LGBT community as to exactly what happened to start a witchunt.

  3. Compared labeling trolls as trolls to the atrocities committed in nazi germany and engaged in various other logical fallacies in an attempt to provoke emotional reactions.

Make no mistake the main people responsible for this attempt have in their comments defending their positions engaged in transphobic and bigoted behavior, one stated that cisgendered people have a right to determine what is and isnt transphobia, another called us all "delusional men in dresses" and yet another implied that since the word transphobia was not in the dictionary they used, that it did not even exist.

What I would ask of you is to subscribe to /r/lgbt if you are not already and post about transgender issues and things there as well as here, basically anything you would want to post here please crosspost there as well. Make our presence known in the subreddit and let rmuser and SilentAgony know that we are grateful for them trying to make their sub a safer space for us.

Edit: downvote harder /r/gaymers so you can prove me right, keep trying to silence transgender voices in our own subreddit.

Edit 2: If you are from r/gaymers and you see your comments disappear and you wind up banned, remember you have no inherent right to post here, this is a trans safe space.

Posted Jan 17, 2012, 8:08 AM UTC · edited

65119
harmonical•

I tend to lurk here and LGBT, and I spent the better part of my time after work trying to catch up on what happened. I completely appreciate the move to make lgbt a more transfriendly place. The resulting fallout from the threads and discussions on the usage of the word tranny exposed a lot of really disgusting and disheartening words from a small vocal subset of the users in lgbt.

I am also saddened to see that in some cases it has essentially become a shouting match between the trolls, bigots, and ourselves. I feel reading through some of the comments that there are people who are being yelled at, cursed at, or otherwise that don't really deserve it (on both sides). I would love to see our community be the bigger people here and not retaliate in the same manner as those who are attacking us.

I know that it is unreasonable to tell people how to act and feel, though I think it would go a long way to having a peaceful and better community if we could be the voices of reason in all of this.

On the subject of the markings in lgbt, I'm personally torn. I don't like them as a symbol of a poster who likely should have been banned if their infraction was worthy of the treatment. However, I can also see the side that, in a place where creating a new account is as easy as this is, that a system of marking people could be an alternative. Its really hard to keep a community free of garbage and trolls, but I still think I would prefer a system of bans and user/moderator interaction, as opposed to making them a more visible user in a community where their contributions have already been deemed as rule breaking.

edit: grammar errors. I'm up too late.

27
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
harmonical•

My phrasing might not have been the best, but in no way was I trying to assert that there are only two sides. I was trying to speak to the current situation where those showing the least amount of restraint and causing the brunt of the pain consists of those three groups. There are a lot of posts in which mostly reasonable questions and statements have been downvoted to hell, or responded to in such a manner that really hurts the perception of the trans group as a whole.

I completely agree that the current state of back and forth is completely unacceptable, and the idea if you're not with us then you're against is is harmful.

Sorry for any misunderstandings. I certainly didn't mean to convey what you gleaned from the post.

2
popsicle_time•

i appreciate your thoughtful response, and I'm glad we can see eye to eye on this.

6
[deleted]•

Well if it were me I would ban them personally but you have to remember rmuser has had a hands off approach for like 5 years, and considering how much backlash this had imagine how bad it would have been if she had just started banning and deleting posts.

-13
[deleted]•

The sheer number of [Deleted] in this thread scares me a little. I'm going to just try not to ask why, the same way as whenever r/transgender has a link to a news article I try not to read the comments....

25
[deleted]•

Its probably for the best.

-17
Mewyabe•

As a /r/gaymers , a genderqueer, and bisexual. I could not be more confused... I can't determine if this is an attack on /r/gaymers.

If so: Lets please not just do downvoting wars as that's as silly as flooding other boards on 4chan. If you see something on /r/transgender though, go ahead downvote/report it.

If not: If you see something on /r/transgender which is transphobic go ahead downvote/report it.

Between this and the cinsere//r/trees shit, it makes me sad at times.

23
CedarWolfDual Gender•

Just a heads up, there's subreddits for genderqueers on reddit, too: /r/genderqueer and /r/DualGender. I thought you might like to know! :D

16
ratta_tata_tatGenderTerror•

As well as subreddits for specifically trans- gamers. r/transgamers

13
[deleted]•

r/gaymers is filled with fucking dipshit white cis people, which is why its so disliked hth

-28
Mewyabe•

I apologize for being a /r/gaymer or not knowing rettiquite, but that seems silly. I don't agree with straight up carpet bombing a reddit as it has been pointed out that it was 3 people who started and led this.

16
[deleted]•

yeah lets not forget the "gingerbread trannies" incident and the resultant backlash of us calling them out on it

-7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
LastUsernameEverTransgender•

So r/gaymers was behind the downvote brigade?

20
trans42•

No, it wasn't. I'm a trans who is a member of both communities, who is friends with the mods there and thought I was here. There were 3 people who also happen to be subscribed there who were trolling. r/gaymers is a very safe and happy place, but has it's bad apples as does anywhere else. Laurelai is convinced, however, that the entirely subreddit is full of transphobic hatemongers, and that simply IS NOT true.

38
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

Yep

-22
[deleted]•

[deleted]

13
[deleted]•

It sure was weird that most people supported rmuser when she posted about the new rules, yet subsequently she and SilentAgony have been constantly downvoted. I was getting downvoted brigaded apparently because I showed them some sympathy and most of the upvoted whiners had extensive posting histories on r/gaymers. The fact that you're here and getting a disproportionate amount of upvotes compared to Laurelai says it all.

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
smischmal•
-3
laldans•

As a Gaymer, I just want to say that not all of us are transphobic. I support everyone, regardless of sexual orientation or gender identity, as I wish everyone to do the same with me. I think it's incredibly unfair towards the majority of the Gaymer community that you're calling out all of us.

20
thevernabeanTransAsexual•

If the gaymer community isn't safe for transgender redditors, then it isn't safe. The fact that most of the people there are perfectly nice won't change the fact. Especially if people won't speak up against them and even upvote their bigoted comments. I appreciate that it is unfair to be lumped with those bigots but until you speak out against them we have no way of telling the difference between you and the people next to you that silently agree.

-1
[deleted]•

Mmm, and /r/gaymers never characterises all of /r/lgbt or /r/transgender in a negative manner. Stop the persecution complex and try listening to the complaints people have.

-8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

11
[deleted]•

If you're this upset about it, try speaking up next time /r/gaymers or /r/ainbow have their next anti-/r/lgbt/ circlejerk or characterizes the entire reddit trans* community as a bunch of radical, angry tr*****s. See how receptive they are to the idea that we aren't what they say we are.

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

19
[deleted]MOD•

Yes, here. People get mad but i put down the banhammer.

-2
TheJumboShrimpMid-transition trans woman•

If I want to fight ignorance, I'll trek over to r/LGBT. Let r/transgender be a sanctuary. Please ban anyone who would let the real world leak in and make this magical place become hurtful like everywhere else.

6
[deleted]MOD•

You got it.

-9
[deleted]•

oooh they are downvoting this as well. SO BRAVE

17
[deleted]•

Yes lets silence trans voices in their own safe spaces SO BRAVE

10
[deleted]•

Can we get SRS-style dildz in here for bennings?

-3
RobotAnna•

lol to be fair as awesome as the dilz are, they are super inappropriate for a place with a lot of people dysphoric about their genital configuration

-1†
[deleted]•

Augh, that makes sense. I take back the thing about the dildz. That was super privilege-denying of me 'cause I don't have any genital dysphoria and really didn't consider that others do. I apologize.

-3
[deleted]•

No. Just my banhammer coated in troll blood.

-8
[deleted]•

b-but I like the dildz

-3
smischmal•

The number of downvotes in this thread is too damn high!

-4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

16
ratta_tata_tatGenderTerror•

Every trans- related post in r/lgbt tends to end in people either calling us trannies, bickering about why were are even in the acronym, or some other asinine fight.

15
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
lazyjayPotential MtF•

Sad but true.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

14
ratta_tata_tatGenderTerror•

As the moderator of r/transgamers, I want to personally tell you shit like this (what is going on in r/lgbt) does not fly. I believe in a hands on approach to moderation like we have here. So far we've only have one incident of a very obvious troll.

12
[deleted]•
5
[deleted]•
-5
isleepinahammock•

I have to ask, what on earth does SRS stand for in that context?

9
FNRI•

shitredditsays

2
[deleted]•

I do believe it refers to /r/ShitRedditSays

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

12
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
[deleted]•

This is a safe space, your freedumb to be an idiot doesnt apply here.

-5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

11
[deleted]•

Exactly right!

-11
[deleted]•

Bye!

-14
CptKrotovinatreehugging transgirl•

Could you explain to me why a ban is an appropriate response to these comments? I found your original post encouraging in that you seemed to be taking a mature, reasoned approach, but this person is calmly raising concerns with the approach being taken at r/lgbt. Instaban seems like a rash and disrespectful reaction to me.

18
[deleted]•

got zero tolerance for concern trolling

-17
CptKrotovinatreehugging transgirl•

Concern trolling? How do you know he was trolling?

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
[deleted]•
-15
[deleted]•

[deleted]

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

9
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
ratta_tata_tatGenderTerror•

We generally direct questions to r/transgender that are asked here. They have taken upon themselves to answer the questions. While it is no lie that most of those questions get downboated and all, there are some people who DO try to answer them.

The big issue is that 99% of these questions asked can be answered through 5 seconds of googling and most of the trans- community is just damn tired of answering them.

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

It is not a marginalized persons responsibility to educate a privileged person, if it was we would literally spend every waking moment justifying our existence to cisgendered people

-13
happyhappyjoejoe•

That is the complete opposite of the truth. It is absolutely up to marginalized groups to educate the ignorant. What keeps marginalized groups marginalized is the lack of understanding from outside groups, and the outside groups will never understand on their own. That's why so much of the LGBT community is about awareness. Making others aware and teaching them how you want to be treated is what will incite change.

Edit: That being said, it is when previously educated groups continue to oppress groups that they are doing wrong. Their is no malice in ignorance, but there is in making a conscious effort to continue wronging others.

3
[deleted]•

They really don't get it, Laurelai, BUT THEY KEEP DOWNVOTING YOUR POSTS NEVERTHELESS. Perhaps if they read them things would go better.

-7
smischmal•

Compared labeling trolls as trolls to the atrocities committed in nazi germany

When I got back on reddit and was totally confused as to what the hubbub was that had gone down while my back was turned, I asked about it and the first explanation I got was some guy linking to a comment on r/gaymers that did exactly this. The opposition to the new policy immediately took a serious nosedive in credibility with me right there.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

Do you have proof that r\gaymers was responsible for the downvote brigade, as you call it?

Well how did you get here? Judging from your posting history, you've never posted here before and regularly post at r/gaymers. The downvotes are certainly not coming from this community and it's well known how much /r/gaymers dislikes the "uptight PC brigade" that supposedly inhabits this subreddit and r/lgbt.

-1
My_Faithful_Student•

The downvotes are certainly not coming from this community

Some of them are.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

12
taliphoenix•

Don't worry. Some of us made two mistakes. Seeing your comment and still clicking. Sigh Can I just start hitting people with my clue-wand?

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
[deleted]•

Hey taliphoenix :3

-9
AliceHouse•

you say this is a friendly place, so i aint gonna bother humoring you by prefacing this with "no offense."

<stewie griffin voice>how in the blue hell does one's sexual taste dictate their identified gender?

3
[deleted]•

They have zero posts in /r/transgender and zero comments, and they post things that objectify trans people, chances of being trans is about zero

-10
AliceHouse•

chances of you knowing is zero.

you're not in anyone else's skin but your own.

14