This is why I will be unsubscribing from both /r/lgbt and /r/ainbow.
Posted Jan 17, 2012, 8:36 AM UTC
010
[deleted]•
I honestly do not understand what the addiction some gay men on here seem to have to using the word 'tranny' after being asked by trans people to stop.
Is it like crack or something? Does it somehow make them get high?
This idea that there was some great debate that the mods came in and stomped on is bullshit. Not using slurs for minority groups that you're not part of is the uber-basics of "Not Being a Shitty Person 101", and as you yourself said, this is meant to be a safe space.
I agree that it's an age old argument. I don't like being called a Tranny either. I just don't think the mods went about it in the best way.
5
[deleted]•
If you've got a community where you've got a large majority of members of the dominant group who prove systematically incapable of treating members of minority groups within that community with respect, then the only way to actually ensure that that changes is to lay down the law.
Treating it as if it's a debate or a difference of opinion just legitimises the behaviour when it's something most people learn not to do in preschool.
while I agree, is the best method of "laying down the law" marking people as opposed to simply deleting the comment or actually refuting the claim?
3
[deleted]•
Trust me, any member of a minority who's engaged on Reddit has tried 'refuting' claims before. It works in about one in twenty cases. More usually, they just defend their bigotry to the cows come home.
Red flair sends an extremely clear message that certain behaviour is not tolerated. Quietly disappearing comments just doesn't have nearly the same effect in changing a culture gone bad.
The entire community of /r/lgbt had gotten entirely too tolerant of transphobia: transphobic commentary and those telling anyone who said they were uncomfortable with it to shut up were both upvoted wildly.
Red flair sends a far more effective message than quietly banning one troublemaker when the problem is bigger than them.
I honestly do not understand what the addiction some gay men on here seem to have to using the word 'tranny' after being asked by trans people to stop.
Is it like crack or something? Does it somehow make them get high?
This idea that there was some great debate that the mods came in and stomped on is bullshit. Not using slurs for minority groups that you're not part of is the uber-basics of "Not Being a Shitty Person 101", and as you yourself said, this is meant to be a safe space.
I agree that it's an age old argument. I don't like being called a Tranny either. I just don't think the mods went about it in the best way.
If you've got a community where you've got a large majority of members of the dominant group who prove systematically incapable of treating members of minority groups within that community with respect, then the only way to actually ensure that that changes is to lay down the law.
Treating it as if it's a debate or a difference of opinion just legitimises the behaviour when it's something most people learn not to do in preschool.
while I agree, is the best method of "laying down the law" marking people as opposed to simply deleting the comment or actually refuting the claim?
Trust me, any member of a minority who's engaged on Reddit has tried 'refuting' claims before. It works in about one in twenty cases. More usually, they just defend their bigotry to the cows come home.
Red flair sends an extremely clear message that certain behaviour is not tolerated. Quietly disappearing comments just doesn't have nearly the same effect in changing a culture gone bad.
That's what bans and time-outs are for.
The entire community of /r/lgbt had gotten entirely too tolerant of transphobia: transphobic commentary and those telling anyone who said they were uncomfortable with it to shut up were both upvoted wildly.
Red flair sends a far more effective message than quietly banning one troublemaker when the problem is bigger than them.