[Criticism] Ghostbur suffering excessively might not be Wilbur's greatest writing decision.
I should clarify, first and foremost - I am your typical angst enjoyer.
I have written my fair share of soul-crushing angst, and have come to enjoy a lot of the DreamSMP's exploration into the genre (especially Wilbur's writing - I am a big fan of the first season above else, and usually will sing my praises for his character writing).
However, when a series begins to employ what I like to call "angst porn" (adding suffering for the sake of suffering), I think it starts to lose its impact a little. A few arcs have tipped into excessive hurt for no real narrative benefit, but I find the greatest perpetrator is Ghostbur's permanent limbo predicament - a plot point that I find to be poorly-thought-out for a few reasons:
- Angst for the sake of angst isn't fun, it's depressing. If there is no hope of any healing and recovery, or even a satisfying ending, what's the point of continuing to engage with a character emotionally?
- Ghostbur's suffering is detrimental to the narrative weight of the suffering of an active character. As a result, people are quick to use this plot point in order to act hypocritically towards Alivebur, even though he also experienced this great hurt.
- This doesn't seem to have an impact on the plot as a whole, and as a result, feels unnecessary. Unless the "Ghostbur isn't returning to the story" claim is yet another Reddit lore half-truth, for the most part, all this suffering doesn't have much of a reason for happening - like a plot point left hanging forever.
- If Ghostbur remains separate from Alivebur forever, does this mean that the character is doomed to always be splintered, no matter how much development he makes? It raises fears for a wholly unsatisfying conclusion, which in turn raises the first bulletpoint for Alivebur as well.
- This raises a story question - if Ghostbur is a separate consciousness, why exactly is Alivebur remembering Ghostbur's memories? Is that a plot hole of sorts?
Bear in mind, I am a die-hard Alivebur and Ghostbur enjoyer. I have spent the past eight or so months dedicatedly updating their Dream SMP Wiki character pages out of a deep-seated appreciation for these characters, and I will continue to do so. I just wonder if this particular story element is really the greatest narrative decision possible.
Kudos,
- Light
Posted Jul 20, 2021, 12:47 PM UTC
Honestly I think Wilbur just gets a kick out of making us suffer lol.