Characters Report Card: Black Widow
With the Black Widow movie out there's a whole slew of characters introduced. So here's my take on a report card for each major character, new and recurring, as to how the movie did in portraying them within the MCU:
Natasha Romanoff - B. The resolution of "Budapest" and the reconciliation with her family were strong points for the character as a whole. The context gives us a likely story for what she was doing during the Snap and gives the character a more rounded feel, even knowing her end. The abundance of fight scenes didn't play to her strengths nearly enough though, putting Natasha in situations that required far more direct confrontation than any self-respecting spy would allow. That said, Natasha as a character is better as a result of the movie. The pros outweigh the cons and at the end of it all we get a bit more of the characterization we should have gotten years ago. Better late than never.
Yelena Belova - A. Yelena is introduced as the complete foil to her sister. Light-hearted with a quick wit and fighting skills to match her sister, Yelena brings a sense of levity while providing a strong foundation for the character. As a whole, the movie feels like its as much about Natasha as it is about Yelena, and that's for the better. Unlike Natasha we don't know where Yelena is going, but we see how she became who she is today. She doesn't feel like a repeat of Natasha, who was introduced with no backstory, lots of brooding, standard femme fatale fare. Instead we know who she is, why she is how she is, and as an audience see how much potential she has as a character. While she will likely always draw comparisons to her sister, she brings a fresh take to the Black Widow role while staying true to the critical aspects of the character. I look forward to seeing what happens to Yelena in Hawkeye and throughout Phase 4 in the MCU.
Melina Vostokoff - B. A completely different take from [Melina in the comics](https://marvel.fandom.com/wiki/Melina_Vostokoff_(Earth-616\)), we instead get the mom assassin. She plays a vital role in supporting her fake daughters while showing them how an accomplished spy gets things done. As arguably the most spy-like spy in the whole movie, Melina uses her wits and her intelligence to think on the fly and resolve conflicts while doing the least amount of fighting amongst the main four characters. We see her intelligence and questionable morals as defining points for the character. She still feels a motherly instinct towards Natasha and Yelena though, and with little persuasion she is willing to take down Dreykov's entire operation. With her repeated indoctrination into the Red Room we know she is an extremely talented fighter and with one of her few fight scenes being against Taskmaster she traps her with the classic scissor-crotch-face throw, succeeding where Natasha had failed. So we know she's the real deal. She's smart, she's crafty, and she can fight. The only downside to the character is how she got into her situation to begin with. Despite being a major player in Dreykov's operation (designing multiple parts of his air city) its never made clear how long she has been free of his control. We're left assuming that she's been working with Dreykov reluctantly and been willing to turn on him for some time, although its not clear why she was never under his mind control like the other widows (or if it ever worked at all). That said, she brings a great blend of intelligence and craftiness, making for a strong addition to the team.
Alexei Shostakoff - C+. The movie sets up the Red Guardian as a great fighter and a hero of a past generation. Most of what we get is a comical super soldier has-been. We rarely see the hero that the Red Guardian used to be outside of beating up prison guards and Dreykov henchman. The moments with his family are easily the best for the character as they show his emotional clumsiness in an endearing way while showcasing his desire to return to the glory days. It's clear he was a man torn between family and country and had to live with his choices until his shot at redemption. The problem is that his redemption mostly involves getting his ass beat. He is a tranquilizer pin cushion and then a toy for Taskmaster. Even when the good guys are winning its rare that Alexei gets a win for himself. The bit about Captain America is a nice tie-in but never goes anywhere even when the potential was right there. If Taskmaster could talk (more on that in a bit) then she could mock Red Guardian, deliberately shift into Captain America's fighting style, and finally give Alexei the chance to "fight" Cap. With the original Captain America firmly out of the MCU this feels like it was Alexei's last shot at fulfilling his dream but it ended up squandered.
Taskmaster - D. If you didn't know who Taskmaster was, you probably don't care now. With only fight scenes to go off of, Taskmaster is left as an action-scene generator. Historically a character known to mouth off on the level of Deadpool, Marvel went the Fox route and shut up Taskmaster. This leaves us with a shell of the character, making her copycat abilities the only part of Taskmaster that we see. There's none of the intellect or the swagger that Taskmaster usually possesses. Instead we are left with a faceless machine who bulldozes through problems. While the movie explains this as Dreykov's daughter being under mind control, we end up with a tragic Taskmaster who's ultimately saved by Black Widow instead of an unscrupulous mercenary in command of any situation she's placed in. What's most disappointing is that it's a situation that could have been remedied. A voice modulator could have replaced a voiceless mimic while keeping the same reveal for the character. Then fans get to see how Taskmaster toys with an opponent's mind during a fight as well as provide a verbal explanation of the fighting styles she had taken. It leaves us with half a character, and it doesn't feel like a lot to move forward with. I'm left wondering if we will ever see Taskmaster again...or if Taskmaster is better off out of the MCU.
Dreykov - B. Dreykov has the confidence, manipulative nature, and sliminess you'd expect from a mind control villain. His team of relentless assassins are mere weapons to throw at Natasha and Yelena. His influence across the world is felt through the relentless pursuit of Natasha and Yelena no matter where they are, from remote Norway to bustling Budapest. And at last he captures his enemies and gloats as you'd expect any supervillain would do. Unfortunately he doesn't think about security, contingency plans, or nose plugs. Having entrusted Melina to build his prison cells he decides to place her within one unguarded. He places his entire facility up in the sky with no clear plan as to how to quickly evacuate in an emergency. Despite all his planning and seemingly foiling Natasha and Melina's switcheroo he never considers that Melina would have told Natasha about his pheromone gimmick despite it being the one and only thing keeping him from getting his ass beat at any moment. Having musk as your Pavlovian power is maybe not the weirdest ability we've seen but it does raise questions as to why he is so bold when he's thwarted by anosmia. Overconfidence being the downfall of a villain is a common trope but it felt like Dreykov could have done a bit better. At the end of the day though he was largely a vessel for evil. He did his job as the bad guy who needed undoing and any characterization of him that didn't make him seem like the trafficking piece of shit he was would have felt unnecessary. So for that he did things well enough.
Thanks for taking the time to read this, hope you enjoyed it.
Posted Jul 20, 2021, 7:01 PM UTC