Approved nomination in same S17 cell as another Pokestop, what now?

Question

I recently had a nomination approved which I later found out was in the same S17 cell as an existing Pokestop. As a result, the new nomination was not converted to a Pokestop.

I could have submitted the nomination about 5 feet over, and had it in a different cell (had I been aware of this detail - Niantic isn't terribly helpful here).

Are there any options to fix this? If I resubmit the same nomination, can it be approved again, just a few feet over? Or will it be rejected as a duplicate, despite the original nomination not being converted?

Posted Jul 23, 2021, 4:01 AM UTC

120
mattrogina•

I stead of trying to blame niantic, take it as a learning experience.

14
FlashesOfDarkonda•

Rejected as duplicate.

12
zoellsOP•

So the POI is effectively permanently dead, as far as Pokemon GO is concerned?

1
kawin240:ingress::pgo:•

It still is available to Ingress and Harry Potter, and to some extent it will influence spawns in Pokémon GO but it will never become a Pokéstop, unless you try to move it's location. To edit this, you'll need an Ingress Level 12 Account if the move is < 10 metres, if it exceeds it, you can use the wayfarer abuse form (it does say abuse but you can also report false locations > 10 metres there). Move edits sent in via form are directly reviewed by Niantic staff so if you only move it for cells instead of a more correct location, they won't do anything. Edits via Ingress go through Wayfarer but often they get denied as well for the same reasons like the ones via form.

6
zoellsOP•

Not the answer I wanted to hear, but helpful. Thanks!

3
AlfonsoMLA•

And there are people that will report you for abuse if you try to edit the location.

2†
RikNinja•

If you try to edit the location away from where the POI actually is, that is abuse

3
RikNinja•

It can still create new spawnpoints

3
baltimorecalling:ingress::pgo:•

Not really. Even if invisible in Go, portals in Ingress create XM on the map. XM is associated with Pokemon spawns, so it may up the spawn density.

If the other Wayspot ever gets removed IRL and in the game, the portal that you submitted will become a stop to take its place.

There's always an off-chance that Niantic may adjust how the Pokemon gameboard will be populated at some point, so your portal could make it into Go if they ever went that route.

Continuing to submit and get Wayspots approved will always be a benefit, even if they're not immediately usable in Pokemon Go.

1
[deleted]•

Depends, if it is a wayspot (but only visible in ingress) it will be marked as a duplicate because it is alreadu ingame... if it isn't a wayspot (because it also 'broke' the 20m rule for ingress) than you can just resub it without the duplicate thingy.

2
rozz_b•

If the POI also falls under the free cell you can try ask a level 12+ ingress player from your area to submit the location edit for you as it will still be active in Ingress and Wizards Unite (unless it was within 20m of another stop). You can check if it's active on the Intel Map as long as you have an Ingress account of any level. Resubmitting it will only get it marked as a duplicate as it does already exist in the Waypoint database..just doesn't meet the criteria to appear in Pokémon

1
ScottaHemi:pgo:•

I did something like this in my towns community center. i found out after submitting it that the post office was in the same S17 cell and the CS didn't show up.

I was able to move the post office poi north just a few feet to get it out of the S17 cell as well as placing the poi in a more accurate position directly over the building rather then right on the edge of the street.

though that only really works if the POI is on the edge of an S17 cell. and is being moved into a cell that isn't already occupied or yuo'll lose that poi in go. but your new one will probably show up. which isn't exactly what you wanted.

1