r/thinkorswim•
jaql

Put options expired in paper trading account

Hello! Something happened in my paper trading account that I don't completely understand. I'm wondering if what happened is how it would have happened in a real account or if this is a paper trading account problem.

I bought 10 NVDA 7/23 $740 Put options @ 15.65 on 7/19 (before it split). The trade cost $15,650.

On 7/23 I attempted to sell the options, but TOS would throw an error saying the contract was invalid. I figured the paper trading account did not know how to handle the pricing adjustment, so I forgot about it.

When I logged in this morning (7/26), I had over $835k of buying power because TOS sold -1000 NVDA shares worth $740,000 due to assignment.

I was able to close the order by buying 1000 shares @ 193.14 leaving me with $642,418.25, a $546,860 profit.

Screenshot: https://imgur.com/ibeeh52

Did I make ~$546k of fake money or did I break TOS?

Posted Jul 26, 2021, 8:23 PM UTC

212
mastergunner99•

Pro Tip.

Paper Trade with an amount you'll actually trade with.

10
jaqlOP•

Indeed. I don’t think I would ever have spent 15k on this trade, but it seems like I found a fun bug in the paper trade account.

1
banana_splote•

If you want to make free money in TOS paper account, I found a few loopholes over time.

3
jaqlOP•

Yeah, seems like I found a free paper money cheat.

1
sainglend•

Right clicking does wonders. Apple users hate this one simple trick.

0
delectablehermit•

ToS probably broke on the split and exercised the contracts. If you had the $$$ for assignment. That would work.

2
jaqlOP•

Ah alright. I didn’t think I was going to get assigned since I was unable to sell them before they expired. I figured the split somehow borked the trade in the paper trading account. Seems like it assigned me at the pre-split price and credited me money instead of making me negative.

1
delectablehermit•

Yeah, When I was first messing with it, I was doing after hours LOs on TSLA, and forgot I placed it, I came back in with like an extra 150k a week later because it just exercised my calls on "margin." it was interesting to realize either way.

1
sainglend•

It credited you money because you had put options. Puts give the the right to SELL at the strike price. Your options were in the money and exercised, so you sold 1000 shares. That's why you received a credit.

Unfortunately, you didn't own 1000 shares so it was a short sell to open. Then the price went up and you bought to close for a loss.

1
destroyerodin•

The best thing is to call the trading desk and ask them to walk you through it. Looks like TOS is working perfectly based on what you shared.

But, I'll try since you were kind enough to share the screenshot of the transactions.

The transactions shows you bought a PUT option on 7/19. There is no sell transaction before close of market on 7/23. That means your options were automatically assigned.

It looks like you've discovered how automatic assignment works.

1
Mobius_ts•

Paper trading is all algorithms. It's meant to get an idea of trading procedure and to get someone familiar with the platform.

1
sainglend•

No, you would have lost a lot of money. The math here is wrong because of the split.

First, you sold short 1000 shares at 740 each. Then you bought back 1000 shares at 193.14. The split was 4 to 1, so if you sold 1000 shares, you'd have to buy back 4000 shares, not 1000 shares, after the split.

Since 740/4 = 185. So it is like you sold short 4000 shares at 185, then bought back at 193.14. You therefore lost 4000 x 8.14 = $32560.

Or, with the original numbers, sold 1000 at 740 = $740,000 collected. Then you would have to buy 4000 shares at 193.14 = $772,560.

+740000 - 772560 = -32560.

Edit: also you spent $15650 on the options, so the total loss was $48,210

1