r/hockey•
nsbound

How can Fleury be traded to a team if he has a no trade clause?

I am a bit confused. Fleury apparently did not include Chicago on the list of teams he was willing to move to. How can he be forced to report there? Any clarity on this would be appreciated.

Posted Jul 28, 2021, 5:20 AM UTC

1231
Wayf4rer:NHL-TBL4: TBL - NHL•

Well, prior to the trade George Mcphee sat Fleury down for a meeting. In this meeting GM GM didn't say anything, and waited for Fleury to begin speaking, at which point he said ^"guywhogetstradedsayswhat" to which Fleury said what, and the rest was history.

175
TheAnalogKid18:NHL-DET6: DET - NHL•

Let the record show that this is indeed what happened.

22
Chronic_Messiah:NHL-SJS2: SJS - NHL•

I can confirm

2†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-3†
Gelidaer:NHL-MTL1: MTL - NHL•

He only has a 10 team no trade clause. I guess Chicago wasn't on his list

96
UnhealthyCheesecake:NHL-VGK1: VGK - NHL•

Chicago wasn’t on his no trade list he submitted last year. He could’ve submitted a new one tomorrow, and if what GMKM said is true that Fleury was notified of Chicago’s interest in the last few weeks then Fleury could’ve put Chicago on his new list

58
nsboundOP•

Okay, thanks. Your explanation clarified where I was confused.

7
MellowKevsto:NHL-NJD1: NJD - NHL•

Chicago wasn't on the list of teams he CAN'T be traded to. He has a Modified NTC, which means he has a short list of teams that he can refuse to be traded to. Chicago was not on that list.

33
nsboundOP•

Ah, thank you. I thought the list was for places he was willing to go to. I appreciate you clarifying this.

3
0DegreesCalvin:NHL-BOS7: BOS - NHL•

Man, I feel like if I was a player, I’d want a full NTC/NMC at all times. I can’t imagine not having autonomy over where you live/work.

3†
-RomeoZulu-•

Uproot your family and move to a new city on a moments notice sucks, thats why player’s agents push hard for them in UFA negotiations.

5
RikVanguard:NHL-CHI2: CHI - NHL•

To be fair, I think several players have said that even a 8 or 10 team NTC is effectively enough if your cap hit is reasonably high. Just pick the teams who aren't totally capped out and/or would have the right assets to want you and you're basically protected. Especially with the flat cap

2
0DegreesCalvin:NHL-BOS7: BOS - NHL•

How often can you change it? Annually?

1
kind-of-there:NHL-VAN3: VAN - NHL•

Yup.

2
Guj_Tugman•

I think you’re misinterpreting the reports of fleury not wanting to play elsewhere. He could only pick 10 teams to not get traded to. Just because Chicago didn’t make that list doesn’t mean he wants to play there

17
daveeb:NHL-PIT4: PIT - NHL•

Fleury had a 10-team NTC. Chicago was not on his list of 10 teams. This means Chicago was one of 21 eligible teams (after the Kraken are added) for Fleury to be traded to.

6
nsboundOP•

Thank you. I was looking at it backwards and now it makes way more sense.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
fracturedpersona:NHL-VGK2: VGK - NHL•

He has a 10 team no-trade clause. Obviously Chicago wasnt one of them.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
tgray106:NHL-BUF3: BUF - NHL•

Does anyone know how many teams he had on his no trade clause?

1†
PP_Horses:NHL-CHI3: CHI - NHL•

It was only a ten team NTC. Which meant Fleury had 10 teams he couldnt be traded to. The other 21 teams in the league are fair game.

If he had a full NTC or a no movement clause (NMC) then he would have to approve of every trade he is included in.

Of the 10 teams he cant be traded to, they were likely all 7 canadian teams and then who knows for the other 3

-2†
sopheroo:NHL-SEA1: SEA - NHL•

Being from Sorel (QC), Montreal might not have been on the NMC list.

Phoenix, Buffalo and the California teams are most likely to be on the list than one of his hometown teams, and the only one who's still around.

6
Psybio:IIHF-Canada: Canada - IIHF•

And Price being there is already a NTC.

1
Scratch_Simple:NHL-OTT2: OTT - NHL•

Buffalo…

2
Gnome_de_Plume:NHL-VAN4: VAN - NHL•

No, he just put Buffalo in 10 times.

6
PP_Horses:NHL-CHI3: CHI - NHL•

I didnt want to be mean

-1
spikymetal:NHL-NJD1: NJD - NHL•

NJ was one of them.

1
zogo13•

Why the assumption it would be the Canadian teams?

0†
PP_Horses:NHL-CHI3: CHI - NHL•

Higher taxes, stricter border regulations are the main reasons. All of canada is usually on player's trade clauses

3
zogo13•

I mean I could see that argument applying sometimes. But Fleury is from Quebec and still spends quite a bit of time around his hometown. It’s a little short sighted to think he would be in up in arms being traded to the Habs, if that were too happen. Taxes aren’t the only thing factored into where a player wants to go

Also, Canada has a some pretty legendary franchises. A lot of players in the NHL, almost half in fact, are Canadian. Many of them grew up cheering for a Canadian team or idolizing one of their players. A lot of guys would love to play for their favorite team growing up. Unless you can show me some stat that says players always have Canadian teams on their clauses, I think that last part of what you said just isn’t true

Just off the top of my head, Perry signed with the Habs in part because they were her favorite team growing up. Part of the reason Tavares signed with the leafs was also because he always wanted to play for them. There’s probably tons more examples

EDIT: Also remembered that Crosby also wanted to play with the Habs if he weren’t on the Pens, since he was a fan as a kid and his dad was drafted by them

1†
PP_Horses:NHL-CHI3: CHI - NHL•

Look up any players NTC list, almost all of them have canadian teams as where they would not accept a trade to even canadian players. Youre interpreting this as some shot at Canada when that is literally par the course for the majority of the leagues players. Most dont want the worse weather, taxes, and recently covid travel lockdowns that Canada has in comparison to the U.S. during the course of a season.

Naming 2 examples (one of which being a well past his prime Perry who at this rate is just content with staying in the league after being bought out) doesnt change that the majority of players with a NTC have the Canadian teams on them.

4