r/oblivion•
Fastulv

Shield enchantments with a 2-handed weapon/H2H

Discussion

So there is this thing that has been bothering me for as long as I've been playing Oblivion. And it's the fact that since you can have a shield equipped along with a 2-handed weapon, you will benefit from a shield's enchantment even though the shield is neither contributing armor, used for blocking nor affecting magic effectivity.

It just makes no sense to me. It's clearly not actually "equipped". I feel like I'm cheating when I play a 2-hander and somehow still maintain that awesome shield enchantment that I shouldn't be entitled to by any sort of logic. And if the reason is that all characters should have access to the same number of enchantments, that's just poor design in my opinion. Would've made more sense to for example make 2-handers deal more damage instead, make sure some sort of a trade-off for an extra piece of equipment.

Why was the game designed this way? Can anyone else make sense of it? And it's anyone else bothered by it?

Posted Jul 28, 2021, 3:11 PM UTC

513
thebaconator136Expendable Follower #27•

I agree it is a little strange. I've thought about this too, I think it's mostly because equipping things is like putting it in contact with your body and not in your pack. If I'm holding a 2-handed weapon with a shield on my belt it's in contact with me. Just like how a pair of fire resist boots will resist a fireball aimed at your face. The items put their energy into the wearer, the item is just a power source.

This is my opinion on it, the devs might have a different explanation or it was just a bug they didn't care to fix. At least equipping a shield is optional so you aren't stuck with one if you like adding a little more challenge and better role-playing experience!

4
FastulvOP•

I used to motivate it that way too. But nowadays I think it's too far fetched since it doesn't affect encumbrance or magic effectivity.

1
Iris-on-Reddit•

oblivion has a lot of odd or just bad design choices like that

2
wyrmylon•

Yeah, this never made sense to me. The same is true for morrowind, but at least in that game you can't block with 2-handed or unarmed. This is one thing I think Skyrim did better (sacrilege, I know).

2
thebaconator136Expendable Follower #27•

I mean, historically longswords are all about attacking and defending. There is no reason why you couldn't block with a 2-handed weapon.

In Oblivion, you can block with fists. However blocking has no effect on the damage enemies using blade or blunt does. Hand to hand blocking will only absorb unarmed damage. .

One thing I find strange about Oblivion blocking is that you have to be an expert in block to gain a chance to shield bash. Anyone with a functional arm can push a shield forward. Skyrim got that right.

2
[deleted]•

Block with 2 hand weapon and unarmed is cool. I usually block so dont be those mountain lion oneshot.

1
SulliumBaurus•

And if the reason is that all characters should have access to the same number of enchantments, that's just poor design in my opinion. Would've made more sense to for example make 2-handers deal more damage instead, make sure some sort of a trade-off for an extra piece of equipment.

I think that trade-off would be too tricky to balance. An enchantment slot can be more than powerful enough to be worth trading a bit of damage for, but on the flip-side we don't get a full loadout of great enchantments until later in a playthrough. So you'd be encouraged to use two-handed at first and then switch to one-handed with shield as soon as you had good enough enchanted versions of everything.

An idea I had just now, though, was to make on-hit enchantments more powerful on two-handed weapons. This would make for an interesting choice between a heavily boosted offense effect or an extra constant effect from the shield.

2
thebaconator136Expendable Follower #27•

Stronger enchantments would probably also help the speed difference between one handed and two handed weapons. My main strategy for fighting a two-handed opponent is just backing up to dodge their attack and running forward after they swing.

1
FastulvOP•

That would definitely be a good option. And the same should go for robes that take up both the torso and the legs. Either a more powerful enchantment or the option to make two separate enchantments on the same piece

1
[deleted]•

I dont think that cheat! only one-hand deserve more slot enchant than us even though they do nearly same dps, run faster and has more defend. I use staff and equip shield and it not affect my spell affective, it make game easier to breathe because i wear robe so i lost another enchantment slot for pant

1
[deleted]•

You should use all elements you can get to beat the game and dont compared with other rpg. Skyrim is different because it have it own balance and different gameplay. Oblivion is different and if you not use maximum it advantage then cries because it too hard to unbeatable.

1
FastulvOP•

That's another way to look at it. That I don't agree doesn't mean it's not valid. Personally I value immersion and realism over min-maxing.

1
FastulvOP•

Yeah that's the imbalance I would've like to see fixed somehow. I only have very basic modding skills though, so I'm left with complaining about it hehe. Yeah the lost enchantment slot for wearing robes is also an issue.

1