Stringing - Advice please?

Posted Jul 29, 2021, 9:01 AM UTC

Posted Jul 29, 2021, 9:01 AM UTC
what filament? brand?
What temp?
what are the retraction settings?
what is the condition of the filament used?
With the limited info you give, there is no way of helping you hence the questions ^^
while answering those questions maybe you'll find the solution by yourself otherwise, I'll try my best
Sorry, as I say I'm fairly new to FDM. Used to resin printing which it's a fair bit more simple lol
Filament is Black PLA, and I believe it was Creality branded.
Temps were whatever the defaults were. 200 Nozzle, 60 bed? (I have another print going now that's using those settings, so I assume it's the same since I changed nothing).
Retraction is.. whatever the default Cura 4.10.0 settings are. Speed is 50mm/s, Enable Retraction is on, Z Hop when retracted is off. Not sure where to see other settings related to this.
Filament seems ok. I've no idea how to measure whether it's good or bad. It has sat in my room for a couple of months without protection, but it's relatively dry, and sits away from any windows. It has snapped of its own accord once, which screwed up my first retraction test, but seemed fine since (3 hours into a print and it's not snapped again).
It certainly looks like wet filament. Working in the product design industry I'll say that stuff from China tends to be exposed to a lot of humidity before it even ships so I'd go out on a limb here and say that's probably all your issue is.
But first, those setting details you gave are good, but what are the settings on your retraction tower? If it's testing retraction way out of range then that could also be your problem. Most PLA retraction towers will test from 1-5mm (1mm per section) because that tends to be a good range for that type of filament. But without knowing that it's hard to help you out.
What brand of filament would you recommend then, just out of interest? I got Creality because, obviously, the printer is Creality - but what brands are better?
As for the retraction - I've got no idea. I didn't touch the settings because I've got no clue what most of them do, and googling things starts throwing out words that I'm sure I'll eventually know, but I don't entirely know which bit is which yet.
Well first where did you get that file from?
Same as shadow reaper just said:
The setting for pla seem fine so I would check to dry your filament or try a fresh roll of another brand like formfutura, protopasta or whatever is available in your region.
Can you also let us know if your fan is running while you're printing. The fa' that blows on your nozzle is the one we want to check here.
If after these checks the quality remains the same we'll start looking at the slicer as the model can't be the cause as you had the same results with a Benchy
Inland pla plus and esun pla plus are the best filaments I’ve never had a problem with either
Start with e-step calibration, then print up a temperature tower to find the ideal temp for that filament. After that (if you're still having issues) you can start experimenting with retraction settings.
(my default retraction for standard PLA is 6mm at 25 mm/s)
Thank you, I'll look this up.
I'm new to using my Ender 3 Pro. Had it sitting in my room for a number of months (never got around to using it, as it came with a fried motherboard, then I put a hole in the build plate, and I've been a bit scared to touch it since).
Yesterday, I finally decided it was the day to try it out! And so I did. I did a bed levelling test, and it was fine. I then did a Benchy test and it printed completely, but with fairly bad stringing - so that brings us to today, where I decided to do a stringing test. In the image, you can see how it came out. I used default settings, 100% infill, and my printer is not modified with the exception of a better lever where you put the filament in, and yellow springs.
Does anyone have advice on this? I know it's a fairly common problem, but I'm still unsure how to solve it.
I used the latest version of Cura to slice this, and printed it without changing much in the way of settings - and definitely didn't touch the GCode.
Any advice is appreciated!
Im not most intelligent ender user or 3d printer user by any means. But in most slicers I believe you can change the retraction settings and probably fiddle with the steps. I think your meant to reduce the steps? If you don't have it, I recommend a slicer called cura. Check the tension spring on your extruder and hopefully this will help.
Here is a video that may also help you. https://youtu.be/6LjbCIGCmd0
Absolutely string is based on temp, print speed, and retraction settings.
I'd start by putting in a new nozzle and making sure the nozzle is butting up against the heat break and bowden tube. That amount of stringing looks like a hardware issue.
No offense but looking at the layers, you got other things to figure out first.
Oh, I'm well aware it's not perfect. But given that the stringing was the most obvious problem, it was the thing I thought I'd tackle first.
Check out teaching tech’s printer calibration tools here: https://teachingtechyt.github.io/calibration.html
Particularly the temperature and retraction tuning ones. Also for PLA make sure your part cooling fan is on 100%
You’ll find with FDM you need to tune in each filament to get the best settings. Also if you can’t get it to print well even after tuning or if it sputters/bubbles as it comes out the nozzle then it’s likely soaked up water. You can either use a dehumidifier to dry it out or just get some fresh filament.
Hope that helps! Let me know if you struggle, happy to help you learn
Thanks for the advice, it's definitely something I'll look into. Out of interest, what brand of filament would you recommend? I use Creality at the moment, but I know it varies brand by brand (and even spool by spool).
It's less about which filament you use and more about tuning the printer to whatever you're using really. Also making sure your filament is kept in an airtight container to stop it absorbing moisture - there shouldn't be much variation between rolls of the same brand/colour but if you have an old roll that's sucked up heaps of water it will print badly.